News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by wgjordan on Sunday March 10, 2019 @02:08PM (#19353261)
The post shares several pain points with Debian's slow, aging change-process and integration-infrastructure.

Open question: If Debian contributors feel the need to drop out and move on due to these pain points, are there less-painful Linux-distribution projects out there that are getting more of these pain points right they can flock to? Is this a sign that Debian needs to reform, or that other, newer distributions are outpacing it?

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by nextos on Sunday March 10, 2019 @02:16PM (#19353316)
I like Debian, but I agree it's become too slow and bureaucratic.

Sadly, like most big organizations, it is hard to implement changes from inside.

In my opinion, most Debian's issues stem from a centralized imperative package manager where all packages need to be carefully kept in sync for things to work. Moving to something like Nix would greatly simplify development.

This is far from a new idea. In fact, it was quite thoroughly discussed in debian-devel mailing list back in 2008, 2013 and several other times [1].

[1] https://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/2008/12/msg01007.html

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by asveikau on Sunday March 10, 2019 @03:29PM (#19353845)
> it's become too slow and bureaucratic.

When I first used Debian in the 90s it had a reputation for being slow and bureaucratic.

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by josteink on Sunday March 10, 2019 @05:38PM (#19354716)
And unlike most distros which were around back then, Debian is still here today, so it must be good for something.

That said, I agree anything Debian (and thus Ubuntu too) and FSF feels awkwardly baroque to work with these days.

Old email-based systems, bickering over politics and minor issues rather than the subject at hand, for weeks or months... and no standard CI?!?

With all that I too find myself spending my time contributing elsewhere.

It’s a shame as these 2 organizations acts as a fundament for sooo many things I rely on daily, but I just can’t bother.

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by noir_lord on Sunday March 10, 2019 @06:37PM (#19355130)
> Debian is still here today, so it must be good for something.

It’s stable and I know they’ll still be around 5 years from now.

They also very rarely break anything on updates.

There are only three Linux distress I’d run in production, RHEL, Debian or Ubuntu (depending.

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by sanxiyn on Sunday March 10, 2019 @11:59PM (#19356560)
What is the problem with old email-based systems? This is an honest question.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by josteink on Monday March 11, 2019 @04:13AM (#19357412)
For FSF and Emacs all bugs, discussions and contribution are handled through email.

Sending patch-files by email and then having to discuss/defend your patch for weeks, only to have to create and send a new one, leaving receivers to diff patch-files to see what is different...

Let’s just say in 2019 you expect something a little more sophisticated to be available to make your contribution easier.

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by rleigh on Monday March 11, 2019 @04:18PM (#19362389)
There's no problem with systems which allow interaction by email. It can be handy, and if you like that, then the Debian BTS is convenient for responding to bugs as a maintainer. However, email-only systems which don't offer any other methods of interaction can be problematic.

email-only interaction can be massively inefficient. For larger changes, I might need to change the severities, tags, and follow up to dozens of bugs. For every metadata change I make, I need to check the reply to make sure the change took place. That means manually tying together sent emails with BTS replies and repeating any which failed.

I used to track all this on large pieces of paper! I shouldn't need a manual system to manage my interaction with an issue tracking system. When I press submit in any other system, the effect is immediate. This is hugely costly in terms of time and effort to do really trivial and mundane things. It's one thing to do it once, but what happens when you make 30 changes and have to wait 20 minutes for each request to round-trip? It's a logistical nightmare which can take several hours to complete.

If I was to highlight a single problem with the Debian BTS, it's that there was a failure to acknowledge its inefficiencies and look at other systems. The criticisms raised in this thread aren't new; they were known 15+ years back. There's a reason why the others are not using email as their primary mode of interaction, and it's a shame the BTS didn't get a decent web frontend to make it more efficient as well as more accessible.

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by JohnFen on Monday March 11, 2019 @12:09PM (#19360021)
The thing that I think Debian does best (which is the same thing that has kept me using Debian since about 1996) is stability. I don't think any other Linux distro (that isn't Debian-based, anyway) even comes close.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by hanru on Sunday March 10, 2019 @10:16PM (#19356196)
> In my opinion, most Debian's issues stem from a centralized imperative package manager where all packages need to be carefully kept in sync for things to work.

Hmm, in my opinion, this is good thing, not an issue needs to be solved.

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by rmk2 on Sunday March 10, 2019 @06:26PM (#19355048)
openSUSE uses the Open Build Service[0] to build, well, openSUSE. OBS also supports other distributions etc., but it makes it fairly easy to put up a package.[1]

For RPM-based distros (e.g. openSUSE), you write a .spec-file, check it in via OBS's version control alongside your sources, and off you go. OBS builds the package (and pulls in dependencies as needed etc.) and publishes the result as a repository with GPG keys and all the jazz, which you can just add to your own distro, and which is openly visible, so everybody else can use your package(s), too.

OBS also supports forking existing packages, and you can merge them back together, which means you can fix something in an existing package (whether a distro-package or something somebody else put up) and if they accept the changes, congratulations, you just fixed something in the distribution.

This means a lot of building, compilation, versioning etc. is out in the open, and you always have the sources available on top of it.

As an aside: I doubt people will "flock" to openSUSE, since many people sneer at them for no good reason (YaST, still?!), but they do a lot of good work, are good upstream contributors (like RedHat and unlike Ubuntu) and some of the tooling is absolutely amazing, except that nobody really knows about it.

[0]: https://en.opensuse.org/Portal:Build_Service

[1]: https://fosdem.org/2019/schedule/event/distribution_build_de...

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by moosingin3space on Monday March 11, 2019 @01:45AM (#19356941)
OBS is so good, Fedora (my distro of choice) has a clone of it called Copr: https://copr.fedorainfracloud.org/
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by sverige on Sunday March 10, 2019 @08:28PM (#19355751)
I'm a BSD guy but needed a Linux distro last year for a specific project. OpenSUSE was remarkably good, stable, easy to use and update, and apparently free of the political crap that seems to come with many other distros.

I have recommended it to others who need a stable Linux distro with lots of well-maintained packages. Some of them looked at me like I was crazy. Preconceived notions are hard to overcome sometimes. Oh well.

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by h1d on Sunday March 10, 2019 @10:02PM (#19356144)
Do you feel any concern when the owner keeps changing? I think that's part of the reason people keeping a distance.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by vertex-four on Sunday March 10, 2019 @02:32PM (#19353447)
NixOS/nixpkgs is exceptionally friendly and open to new developers, and even just a one-off patch is simple to do.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by danieldk on Sunday March 10, 2019 @02:52PM (#19353609)
Indeed. I started using NixOS and Nix a bit more than six months ago and I was contributing patches within no-time. One can just submit a pull request on GitHub (with the proper format) and a lot of aspects are automated: e.g. the impact of the change (in terms of packages that are effected) is automatically determined and someone with the right privileges can request a build. Some PRs linger around for a longer time, but most of my PRs were merged within the day. Also, I received useful feedback if a PR needed more polish.

What helped me a lot with Nix is that you can easily make your own local derivations. Derivations are usually short [1] and bear little risk with sandboxed builds enabled. Basically, you do a nix-shell -p mypackage, you get dropped in a shell with your derivation, but it does not affect the rest of your system.

[1] Example of a C++ library: https://github.com/danieldk/nix-home/blob/master/overlays/30...

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by mongol on Sunday March 10, 2019 @02:39PM (#19353497)
I am surprised OpenSuse does not get more attention. I feel its infrastructure, with the open build service etc, should be aťtractive to many?
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by rmk2 on Sunday March 10, 2019 @06:28PM (#19355061)
Ugh, just saw your comment now. I wrote a bit more in a sibling comment about openSUSE. For some reason, people seem to either sneer at openSUSE (probably people who go way back?) or are simply unaware of anything it does and/or its existence. I briefly asked the people at the openSUSE stand at FOSDEM 2019 why they don't advertise things such as OBS more, and the answer suggested that some people basically don't see a point in it? It's a pity.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by JohnFen on Monday March 11, 2019 @12:11PM (#19360052)
The last time I tried OpenSUSE, it gave me nothing but problems. Admittedly, this was many years ago and things may have changed -- but I have no real reason to give it another try to find out.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by nik736 on Sunday March 10, 2019 @02:12PM (#19353296)
I switched all my servers to Ubuntu years ago when people were telling me "Ubuntu is no server distribution". I honestly never looked back.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by Twirrim on Sunday March 10, 2019 @02:41PM (#19353511)
Ubuntu is... interesting.

Watch out for what packages you rely on, and what repository those packages come from. If they're in universe, expect your bug reports on Launchpad to go unanswered or unresolved. The only way to get fixes in them is to go upstream to Debian. But note that not every bug in a universe package is actually fixable or broken in a Debian world, because the bug might be down to interactions between a decision made by Canonical with packages in the main repository, and those for the universe package.

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by danieldk on Sunday March 10, 2019 @02:58PM (#19353636)
Yes. For some reason people, even those running Ubuntu servers, are surprised to learn that universe has no guarantee to get updates for known vulnerabilities.

Ubuntu is currently divided into four components: main, restricted, universe and multiverse. All binary packages in main and restricted are supported by the Ubuntu Security team for the life of an Ubuntu release, while binary packages in universe and multiverse are supported by the Ubuntu community.

https://wiki.ubuntu.com/SecurityTeam/FAQ

If you care about security, disable universe and multiverse on servers, or use Debian Stable if you want a Debian-based distribution.

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by bubblethink on Sunday March 10, 2019 @03:16PM (#19353763)
I think ubuntu has done a decent job with universe by and large. I find it in much better shape overall than epel. A good way to judge the health of these auxiliary repos is to look at the age of chromium. Ubuntu is generally good with patching at least security issues in universe. epel is still running behind by a month or two despite the security disclosures. So RH ought to take a page from Canonical's book when it comes to epel and make it a more official thing than the entirely community driven thing it is right now.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by h1d on Sunday March 10, 2019 @09:59PM (#19356120)
I don't mind RH being slower as I take it that's what makes RH what it is. Old packages but most stable.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by bubblethink on Monday March 11, 2019 @02:56AM (#19357179)
It's not about RH packages directly. They are fine. As it is with universe on ubuntu, you quite likely need epel on rhel for doing quite a lot of basic stuff. If you are able to get by with just the proper supported packages in each distro, this doesn't affect you. And that's where the two diverge. universe is in better shape since it is semi-official, v/s epel which is completely unofficial/community-based.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by Conan_Kudo on Monday March 11, 2019 @09:36AM (#19358826)
Actually, since EPEL is often backports from Fedora, many people elect to keep them up to date with what's shipped in Fedora, so it tends to do better than other counterparts.

The closest counterpart is SUSE's PackageHub, which is often seeded by stuff going into openSUSE Leap that isn't part of SLE itself.

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by bubblethink on Monday March 11, 2019 @03:39PM (#19362088)
Just saw your other comment about Fedora. Thanks for Fedora and EPEL. I was just pointing out that EPEL would benefit from some recognition as a semi-official but ultimately unsupported repo from RH. Technically RH already has 'optional' channels which are already in that category, but EPEL should really be that. Some communication channel between RH and EPEL and QA so that stuff doesn't break on RHEL point releases and maybe some resources for security updates would go a long way in making RHEL more usable.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by mattdm on Monday March 11, 2019 @07:50PM (#19364060)
Are you a RHEL customer? If so, telling your salespeople this would not hurt. Just sayin' :)
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by Conan_Kudo on Monday March 11, 2019 @05:59PM (#19363269)
We'd all love that. It's funny, because Red Hat does regularly source content from EPEL to pull into RHEL for various products, which is where these issues come from.

I would love it if Red Hat were to give it proper recognition. I honestly don't know why they haven't yet...

Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by apetresc on Sunday March 10, 2019 @02:18PM (#19353336)
I think Ubuntu suffers equally from every single pain point that Michael describes in his post.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by astazangasta on Sunday March 10, 2019 @02:22PM (#19353369)
Given that ubuntu depends heavily on debian maintainers and governance, what exactly does this improve?
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by SteveNuts on Sunday March 10, 2019 @02:18PM (#19353335)
Ubuntu LTS distributions have been the perfect mix of new-ish packages and stability for us.
Re:Winding down my Debian involvement by h1d on Sunday March 10, 2019 @09:56PM (#19356109)
Are they who blindly use CentOS/RedHat?

Ubuntu specifically has a "server" version. I've been using it since 10.04 (almost 9 years) and never had to use anything else.