Google generates revenue in Poland. They have operations in Poland and all (so they use all the public goods like employees, infrastructure, safety etc.). They should pay taxes in tens of millions of Euros for this. But instead, they generate fake expense in Ireland, send an invoice to the Polish office, call it "branding" or something else, the invoice is big enough to generate a loss. They do not need to pay taxes in Poland since they are at "loss".
That's the issue. Not that Ireland has a different tax system. The issue is that companies are allowed to avoid taxes by generating fake expenses and the EU prohibits other countries from doing anything with it really.
IMO 1,5% fixed tax is very attractive rate.
If that is correct, then it makes perfect sense to shift profits - after all, it's not like Google Poland just came up with their new foobuz algorithm that is providing value. They're just selling it there.
> They're just selling it there.
This is literally the money generating part, the rest are cost centers.
Companies aren't allowed to vote for a reason.
> I hope you understand how deeply hypocritical it is to tout paying taxes as a moral obligation while at the same time refusing to be held accountable for how that money is being spent or denying companies a voice.
There's nothing hypocritical about not wanting corporations to have even more power than they already have.
Taxes are ways to keep the money in the country, reinvest it so it ripples back to the civilians.
Tech companies are avoiding this.
Ps. I hope your being sarcastic
You break the rules = fine
A political protection against something from other countries ( eg. Dumping and killing the internal market) = tariff
Taxes = helping the country/nation, based in money you earned from civilians/local businesses there
These are very different things.
I think it's very concerning that European countries are so focused on taxing access to their market rather than asking themselves the question of what they can offer to businesses and individual to make them more interesting as places to settle down or establish a company.