> Moussouris, who created the bug bounty at Microsoft, warned that if badly implemented such programmes could see talent leaving organisations in favour of pursuing bug bounties, and thus damage the talent pipeline.
I've seen her argue this on Twitter before - the argument IIRC is that bug bounties should always pay less than getting a job helping the blue team / writing secure code in the first place, otherwise the incentives are all wrong. It's great that you know about bugs, but it would be better not to have them. And, also, there's a bit of a prisoner's dilemma involved in that you don't want to let the rest of the industry drive up the expected payouts of bug bounties beyond the expected salaries of secure developers, but you also don't want to lose out on vulnerability reports either.
Step two: Introduce subtle vulnerabilities
Step three: Claim bug bounty under a pseudonym (or just get someone else to claim it)
Google, for example, pays out bug bounties regularly, but their main security expense is wages/etc of security professionals, and that is probably in the neighborhood of a billion dollars a year.
Also, a bug bounty usually limits the scope a lot more than a typical pentest does, i.e. no testing of infrastructure security, internal networks etc..
Lastly, if your bug bounty is high enough to make highly skilled people spent time to find your bugs its probably cheaper to just higher some security folks yourself and prevent excessive payouts (by preventing bugs).
Of course all of this does not stop some C-levels from using a bug bounty as replacement, but the issue is not as clear cut and especially the last point should even make sense to non-technical people.
Outsourcing bug finding is only a retroactive solution, not a proactive one
Then again, I can imagine some teams would get utterly spammed with inane, wrong or non-bounty-able reports, which could be an issue.
From a purely fiscal point of view, why hire expensive full time staff to go digging when you can just throw a few sheckles at stuff as it comes up?