News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by tyingq on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:35PM (#19290131)
They did get a nice short-term windfall by changing the JDK license. Which will fall away in a couple of years as everyone shifts to OpenJDK or something other than Java.

I'm also seeing big stodgy companies getting more comfortable with things like Postgres. It will take a while, but barring some big change, Oracle is headed down long term.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by uli00 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:49PM (#19290184)
Oracle is not a tech driven firm. It is sales driven, meaning their sales teams are world class at ingratiating themselves with decision makers at "big stodgy companies". How do you explain why they survived all this time. Very very few of the top Tech firms use any Oracle software for atleast the last 10-12 years now. Some even have internal procurement bans!
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by brianwawok on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:57PM (#19290221)
They USED to have world class software. Compare Oracle DB to the competitors 10 years ago. They were at least GOOD. Lots of good features for giant companies.

Competitors have gotten a lot better over the last 10 years. Oracle has mostly just raised pricing. It works for a while, but at the current path I don't see Oracle the company existing in 20 years.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by ksec on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:31PM (#19290419)
I would say arguably they ARE still world class. It is just most people don't need or cant justify their price tag when competition has caught on with clear Roadmap and sustainability.

So basically they have a shrinking value proposition and they are rising prices. ( Why does that sound so much like Apple, Now I am worried )

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by pmart123 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:52PM (#19290521)
I love my earpods and I think it shows they still are at the top when it comes to innovating on consumer devices.

Using Apple Pay also makes so much sense for the consumer as it limits your CC data being at every retailer since Apple Pay tokenizes the sensitive information.

If you want to see where Apple is going, checkout the Apple Healthkit API:

https://developer.apple.com/documentation/healthkit/samples/...

While it is too soon to say that Apple will own the market, Apple is the only big tech company that has positioned itself for privacy and trust, giving it the best chance to own this market of the big four.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by amluto on Saturday March 02, 2019 @03:00PM (#19290866)
“Good” depends on the use case. I used Oracle once, about ten years ago. The client library was so big and bloated that just loading it took the majority of the total running time of my not-terribly-long-running program.

Not to mention that figuring out the connection strings is so miserably complicated that you basically need a trained expert to figure it out. The docs were worthless.

I think I can spin up an entire blank MySQL instance faster than I could connect to an existing Oracle database back then.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by brianwawok on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:35PM (#19291296)
Well if you don’t need the features then clearly you are not the target. The oracle DB is going to support many different things compared to your MySQL cluster.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by amluto on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:36PM (#19291801)
I was most definitely not the target. But having such a miserable experience just accomplishing the basics did not make me at all inclined to consider Oracle for future projects.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by pmart123 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:46PM (#19290488)
>>> Very very few of the top Tech firms use any Oracle software for atleast the last 10-12 years now.

I think you missed the word "new" in there. Amazon finally is cutting ties with its Oracle DB this year. While I won't be surprised if AWS starts offering "migrate off Oracle" as a consulting service, Oracle was still the standard through the 2000s. I think they have built up so much negative goodwill though that no startup would ever consider using Oracle even if they gave the first five years away for free.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by solatic on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:06PM (#19290588)
> While I won't be surprised if AWS starts offering "migrate off Oracle" as a consulting service

If AWS can offer a database that satisfies the Mongo API (DocumentDB), then why couldn't Amazon offer a database that satisfies the Oracle DB API, complete with automatic migration?

The day that happens is the day Oracle stock goes straight in the toilet.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by tyingq on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:08PM (#19290598)
I suspect that would resurrect something like the Oracle vs Google lawsuit, where an API signature is somehow a thing you can copyright.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by jerven on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:39PM (#19291317)
The "API" is doable. Being binary compatible is not at all. Oracle DB is complex because of historical choices (the patch picking, compatibility flags) etc... inbuilt JVM and PL/SQL.

Those things that make working on OracleDB today difficult is what made it so dependable for people with money in the last 20 years.

It also runs on a lot of architectures that today's software is not really running on anymore.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by godzillabrennus on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:32PM (#19290717)
Mongo was open source. They copied the api under that license.

My understanding, and I’m not a lawyer so don’t consider this legal advice, is that you can’t copy a commercial api or it’s infringing on their intellectual property.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by Itaxpica on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:47PM (#19290796)
The copyrightability of APIs (specifically Oracle’s APIs, even!) is at the heart of a lengthy and still-ongoing legal battle, with several decisions in both directions.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by tyingq on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:47PM (#19290794)
The mongo example is a bit odd since the open source license was AGPL. Sounds like you can copy an AGPL API signature without releasing your own source?
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by alexis_fr on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:03PM (#19291150)
I thought the copyright law had an exemption for compatibility?
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by tyingq on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:19PM (#19291227)
See https://www.eff.org/cases/oracle-v-google

Oracle won the last round, Google asked the Supreme court to look at it in January. Guess we'll know some time soon.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by pmart123 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:09PM (#19291438)
It would probably turn into the ultimate cigar butt stock though as long as they didn't keep spending money on crazy acquisitions and the stock fell 40% on the news.

I would have to think so many organizations have random scripts, etc. that the risk vs. reward still won still be high er than you think, especially when say the CTO of JPMorgan's job depends on "knowing Oracle."

Personally, I think IBM will likely crash and burn way before Oracle does.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by tyingq on Saturday March 02, 2019 @12:53PM (#19290208)
Sure, not disputing how they got where they are. I'm speculating that none of that helps them from here. Big stodgy companies, their bread and butter, are now tired of Oracle's shit. And, they now have lots of credible options.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by Spooky23 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:10PM (#19290303)
How are they doing their financials?
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by microdrum on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:42PM (#19291335)
The entire Amazon retail business is on Oracle DB.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by grumpydba on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:55PM (#19291385)
It was migrated away to aurora
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by bradleyjg on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:53PM (#19290527)
I don't understand their java strategy at all. By making the switch that they did they forced into existence Amazon Corretto. There's are lots of companies that, rightly or wrongly, want a big corporate name behind a piece of technology they are relying on. IBM and Red Hat were already there, but no CTO is going to have any objections to relying on Amazon over Oracle.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by tyingq on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:28PM (#19290702)
It also may be the last kicker needed for some to start moving to Node, Rust, Go, etc.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by bradleyjg on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:44PM (#19290773)
Maybe, but I doubt it.

Java is in a rather secure place right now. Everyone that chases the new shiny is long gone but it’s not yet at the point where it is difficult to hire for (e.g. COBOL).

So young buck comes to the CTO and says 'let's do a rewrite in Go' and the CTO says 'why in the world would I want to do that?' Then young buck says 'okay, what about just coding the new frobinator in Go?' CTO still says no, because then he’d have to hire Go programmers and Java programmers or at least waste time cross training. Young buck's less honest compadres have probably gone ahead and put Go into production here or there without permission, but I don’t think that’s a danger to Java.

What really changes this dynamic is when schools stop teaching Java.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by ronnier on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:36PM (#19291304)
Go is legit and a huge threat to java and other languages. My entire career has mostly been java based for the backend. The last few months all I’ve been writing is go. I’m finding libraries in Go that I can’t find in Java. I’m seeing lots of new tech all written in go. Go has all the momentum at this point.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by JulianMorrison on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:19PM (#19292147)
My feeling is that they'll exist alongside each other in not very overlapping niches.

Java is what you write in, if what you're selling isn't the code but some service that the code provides, and you aren't a startup, and you can afford a support team and want a lot of devs.

Go is what you write in when you're selling the thing you made directly, like say it's a DB engine, or you're a startup and want low effort support and only want a few devs.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by chii on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:49PM (#19292592)
I imagine java is what a company would choose if they have a massive budget, but is unwilling to hire cowboy coders.

Java makes maintaining a feature easy, and the programmers hired can be average and still be able to make something of acceptable quality, in an acceptable timeframe.

A startup rather wants to move fast. Java is harder to move fast at - but Go probably has that in spades. I do believe Go will not succeed in a large, beaurocratic place. And as a start up grow out to become more and more beaurocratic, the tech transitions with it.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by erik_seaberg on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:44PM (#19291347)
You could edit JVM bytecode by hand, but nobody wants to, we have tools for that. I'm sorely tempted to make a language that transpiles to/from all the Go boilerplate that shouldn't concern human beings.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by JulianMorrison on Saturday March 02, 2019 @08:06PM (#19292115)
Some of the boilerplate is likely to go away in new versions. (See new "check" syntax.) But the hidden advantage of Go has always been the ability to look at a function and just see what it does. That comes at the expense of boilerplate, but is worth it.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by erik_seaberg on Sunday March 03, 2019 @05:25PM (#19297330)
Whenever I look at some Go, it seems the "what it does" is buried in a big pile of mechanics that could have been generated. You're more likely to see half a dozen error-prone lines copying between slices than an obvious HOF named "filter".
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by ronnier on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:02PM (#19291416)
Can you give me examples of what you mean? I agree some of it is low level, verbose even, but on the other hand, I'm able to figure things out on new projects rather easy, there's just fewer layers and magic things happening.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by Apocryphon on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:18PM (#19291495)
Wouldn't Kotlin or Dart be a better replacement for Java?
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by JulianMorrison on Saturday March 02, 2019 @07:58PM (#19292096)
Go isn't just a replacement for Java, it's a step off the entire JVM and out of the ecosystem of heavyweight "enterprise" frameworks.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by repolfx on Wednesday March 06, 2019 @04:15PM (#19322867)
Go is heavyweight: its runtime doubles your memory usage and gives you an incredibly slow garbage collector, it also gets fast compile times partly by not optimising much. Source-wise it has a boilerplate problem practically as bad as Java's just in different ways.

Meanwhile there are lots of frameworks in the JVM world, some of them "heavy" with features, but if you want frameworks that are much smaller, github is overflowing with them.

Kotlin eliminates most of the boilerplate, leaving you with a slimline language, a powerful runtime and a wide choice of libraries. Go doesn't have much to compete with that.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by tomrod on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:47PM (#19291355)
Don't they teach Python now?
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by bradleyjg on Sunday March 03, 2019 @07:32AM (#19294154)
Based on my a limited view, if a new grad majored in something other than computer science+ but took some programming classes he or she is overwhelmingly likely to be most comfortable in python. However new grads with a cs degree+ are likely to have at least some and often quite a bit of exposure to java.

+ or software engineering, etc.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by geofft on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:55PM (#19290537)
What is the practical difference between Oracle Java SE and OpenJDK? That is, why would you pay for it instead of immediately switching to OpenJDK?
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by tyingq on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:00PM (#19290561)
They (mostly) didn't used to charge for their JDK. Up until recently, there were code differences. As of v11, there's supposedly no difference.

So, basically, companies need to move from Oracle JDK 8 to OpenJDK 11. And pay Oracle until they are done. It's a fair amount of testing and verification for some big companies. Now that it's costing them license money, they'll do it.

Edit: And, of course, many will also be incented to move off Java altogether.

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by bradleyjg on Saturday March 02, 2019 @03:54PM (#19291117)
There are a few odds and ends—IIRC some fonts, some gpu accelerated widget implementations for swing, and some obscure crypto options.

But the OpenJDK is the reference implementation and almost certainly has everything you need. The only reason to use OracleJDK is if you want to buy a support contract from oracle (NB there are companies, including very big ones, that will sell you a support contract for OpenJDK.)

Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by vbezhenar on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:45PM (#19291589)
There are almost no visible differences between Oracle and Open JDK now. Here's list of differences: https://jaxenter.com/oracle-jdk-builds-openjdk-builds-differ... basically it's some legacy support and their commercial offerings.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by vbezhenar on Saturday March 02, 2019 @05:42PM (#19291581)
You would pay for it if you need support from the very creators of that software. Otherwise you would use free version. It did not change conceptually. All they did is made their offering more visible (and probably they will blackmail those who download stuff without thinking and reading licenses). You could buy support and use proprietary software before that change.
Re:Warren Buffett sells his Oracle shares, retains $44B inve... by monocasa on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:04PM (#19290574)
Support contract in order to have a lightning rod for blame if/when shit hits the fan.