News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by cimmanom on Friday March 01, 2019 @04:06PM (#19285266)
Where is the line drawn between a declension and a phrase? Even though they're a single word, a lot of those Finnish variants appear to serve the purpose that a multi-word phrase would in most languages.
Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by chousuke on Friday March 01, 2019 @04:25PM (#19285404)
Finn here. Most of the technically valid declensions of "dog" would never see any actual use, so it's not quite as bad as it seems, but I think you still need to count them as individual words because they can't form a valid sentence by themselves.

These noun declensions are not where it ends, though. There are many ways to derive adjectives from nouns and nouns from verbs and verbs from adjectives, so you can generate technically valid new words for quite a long time given just one root.

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by klipt on Friday March 01, 2019 @04:45PM (#19285588)
> These noun declensions are not where it ends, though. There are many ways to derive adjectives from nouns and nouns from verbs and verbs from adjectives, so you can generate technically valid new words for quite a long time given just one root.

You have verbs like "dogged" and adverbs "doggedly" in English too.

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by thaumasiotes on Friday March 01, 2019 @04:59PM (#19285730)
Generating adverbs ("doggedly") from adjectives ("doggéd", two syllables) is, as far as I know, absolutely universal among inflectional languages. Adverbs and adjectives are very closely related things.

Generating verbs ("dogged", one syllable) from nouns ("dog") is absolutely universal among ALL languages, inflected or no, but is a much less regular process than the adjective-to-adverb derivation, as the relationship between an arbitrary noun and an arbitrary related verb is much less regular than that between an adverb and its matching adjective. English is pretty free in deriving verbs. Latin very obviously has methods of deriving verbs and adjectives from other parts of speech, but those are generally not given any formal grammatical treatment when you study the language -- it's expected that you'll just pick them up by feel.

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by Someone on Friday March 01, 2019 @05:56PM (#19286124)
”English is pretty free in deriving verbs”

Or, as Calvin said: “Verbing weirds language”

(https://www.gocomics.com/calvinandhobbes/1993/01/25)

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by brian_cloutier on Friday March 01, 2019 @11:21PM (#19287549)
Huh, I don't think Turkish lets you verb nouns. They've got plenty of ways to turn verbs into nouns but every time I try to make the other way work it just sounds weird.

Any chance you know the term in linguistics for verbing things? I want to look it up because you're right that this feels like a natural thing to do, it's surprising that Turkish doesn't allow it.

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by thaumasiotes on Saturday March 02, 2019 @01:52AM (#19287969)
Derivation is the term for generating one word from another word. I don't think there's a term for specifically deriving verbs.

I did find a paper on Google Scholar purporting to list "derivations producing verbs from nouns" in Turkish, "An Outline of Turkish Morphology" by Oflazer, Göçmen, and Bozşahin.

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by est31 on Friday March 01, 2019 @04:57PM (#19285706)
English also has diminuitives. piglet, doggy, etc.
Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by ajuc on Friday March 01, 2019 @05:31PM (#19285975)
English diminutives are very rudimentary and irregular compared to inflected languages.

In some language you can form several levels of diminutives from any noun. Even stuff that makes no sense, like "cute taxes", "cute death", "cute abstraction", "cute declension".

And you can form the opposite - take a noun and create less cute/uglier/larger version of it.

And these additional forms still obey the other rules, including declension. So there's a combinatorial explosion of versions of each word.

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by Udik on Friday March 01, 2019 @07:10PM (#19286542)
> Even stuff that makes no sense, like "cute taxes", "cute death", "cute abstraction"

A cute abstraction would definitely be my thing. As we would say in Italian, an astrazioncella, or astrazionuccia, or astrazioncelluccia, or astrazioncinuccia, or astrazioncinelluccia. :)

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by r-bryan on Friday March 01, 2019 @10:46PM (#19287412)
When learning some Italian I was both dismayed and fascinated to discover that it was necessary to avoid every diminutive ("cute") and augmentative I could think of, because they all carry sexual innuendo.
Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by Udik on Saturday March 02, 2019 @04:14AM (#19288404)
> they all carry sexual innuendo

They don't. Your teacher was a pervert. :)

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by ajuc on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:26AM (#19288076)
Abstrakcja, abstrakcyjka, abstrakcyjeczka, abstrakcyjunia, abstrakcyjeczunia, ... :)
Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by valiant-comma on Friday March 01, 2019 @09:13PM (#19287057)
The Russian word vodka is a diminutive form of voda (water) — in essence, vodka is “cute water”.
Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by ajuc on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:20AM (#19288057)
yep, same in Polish.

Woda, wódka, wódeczka, wódzia, wódziunia.

and then if you don't like drinking you can go the other way:

wódka, wóda, wódzicha.

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by mcguire on Friday March 01, 2019 @04:35PM (#19285488)
Wikipedia:

"Finnish is a member of the Finnic language family and is typologically between fusional and agglutinative languages. It modifies and inflects nouns, adjectives, pronouns, numerals and verbs, depending on their roles in the sentence."

"Fusional languages or inflected languages are a type of synthetic language, distinguished from agglutinative languages by their tendency to use a single inflectional morpheme to denote multiple grammatical, syntactic, or semantic features."

"An agglutinative language is a type of synthetic language with morphology that primarily uses agglutination. Words may contain different morphemes to determine their meanings, but all of these morphemes (including stems and affixes) remain, in every aspect, unchanged after their unions."

"A synthetic language uses inflection or agglutination to express syntactic relationships within a sentence. Inflection is the addition of morphemes to a root word that assigns grammatical property to that word, while agglutination is the combination of two or more morphemes into one word."

In a hardcore synthetic language, the difference between a word and a phrase is just about meaningless. The "words" can get full on crazy-pants, too.

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by tuukkah on Friday March 01, 2019 @04:49PM (#19285629)
How to know where one word ends and the next begins: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Word#Word_boundaries

Examples of how the system works in Finnish and in other languages on the continuum: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agglutination

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by rando444 on Friday March 01, 2019 @05:02PM (#19285761)
I think the distinction you are looking for is the articles.

In english you have dog and dogs, but can add articles and say 'these dogs' 'those dogs' 'the dogs' and so on. In languages like finnish, the articles are included in the word, thus more variations when you take case and word genders into consideration.

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by eMSF on Friday March 01, 2019 @07:07PM (#19286522)
No word genders in Finnish, sorry! :-)

Also, pronouns like "these" and "those" can't be included in the word in Finnish -- however, those that indicate ownership can (i.e. my dog/s, or the genetive case* ). There's no direct equivalent of "the dog" in Finnish either, the closest being "these/those dogs" where applicable.

* For language nerds: considering the subject (that emphasizes the many declensions in Finnish), it is somewhat ironic that both "my dog" and "my dogs" is the same single word in formal Finnish. Unlike many other cases, plain genetive doesn't allow distinction between singular and plural.

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by NoNameHaveI on Saturday March 02, 2019 @11:09PM (#19292661)
"No word genders in Finnish, sorry!"

No direct word for "please" either, unless you want to count kiitos, which I understand as thank you.

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by amaccuish on Saturday March 02, 2019 @06:00AM (#19288688)
> but can add articles and say 'these dogs'

FYI those aren't articles, but demonstrative adjectives, which are part of the language class of determiners, to which articles also belong.

Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by pw6hv on Friday March 01, 2019 @04:14PM (#19285317)
That's right, I would say that it is a bit misleading. Anyway 15 cases are already surprising, and if we count the plural form then we have 30 forms for a noun. I tried to learn Finnish when I was living there, I think it is a really enjoyable and logical language. Certainly one of the most special languages that we have in Europe.
Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by depressedpanda on Friday March 01, 2019 @04:27PM (#19285421)
Well, yes, it's quite special; it's a Finnish-Ugric language, one of the few languages in Europe that isn't Indo-European.
Re:English, Swedish, German and Finnish Decline “Dog” (2013) by est31 on Friday March 01, 2019 @04:28PM (#19285436)
The line is drawn around having single words for what other languages have phrases for. koirankaan is a single word just as houses is not a phrase (house es) but the plural of house.

Languages use different concepts to express the same ideas. The study of languages isn't built around the ideas but around the structure of the language itself.