News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by dang on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @06:08AM (#19253375)
Would you please stop posting flamebait to HN? It's against the rules and we ban accounts that do it, regardless of which views they're battling for or against.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by mikekchar on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:28PM (#19250911)
Clearly this is a fluff piece of journalism. He said - she said. "5 sigma". Sounds great. What does it mean? 2 out of 3 satellites reported data that gave the 5 sigma conclusion by 2005, the third by 2016. Great. What does it mean? It doesn't really say, other than a 95 percent chance that global warming since 1950 is caused by humans. Somebody said they would like to notch that up to 99% chance. Another person wouldn't go so far. I think it's totally fair to criticise this virtually content free article.

I don't think it's fair to so glibly criticise the science. This article isn't the science. I think we, as members of a community that is generally educated to a higher level than other communities should be calling out this nonsense that gets printed because it gives real ammunition to people (among whom it is possible you are a member) who deride climate science on the basis of bad journalism. It's a massive shame because it's an issue with potentially dire consequences.

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by basurihn on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:38PM (#19250986)
I deride it based on bad journalism AND bad science.

Not all climate science is bad, of course.

The kind that takes an RCP of 8.5 with zero chance of happening and uses it as an input to policy recommendations is bad science.

Attributing current weather extremes (hint, occurrences are non Gaussian) is bad science.

Releasing doom and gloom predictions to the media before peer review that are then ripped apart (but not covered by media) is bad science.

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by mikekchar on Monday February 25, 2019 @08:16PM (#19251205)
To be fair, the linked article contains no science ;-) It certainly contains none of the science that you are describing. It's an appeal to authority. 4 out of 5 dentists recommend chewing gum after dinner. You're taking a particularly bad article and using it as a launching pad for describing your own issues which are only related by topic.

I'm writing this not to slap your hand, but in hopes that you can get to a point where all your posts aren't down voted ;-). Your message is not cohesive enough to follow. If you pick and choose which thing to talk about more carefully, I think you will find that you will get a much more responsive audience.

For example, in this case, the original article was absolutely rubbish. The only apparent reason one can see for it being on the front page is because it had the "right" headline. Nobody needs that kind of thing. People like me who feel that the science shows that we need to change our lifestyles for our future prosperity don't need this. People like you who (seemingly) feel that the science shows that we don't need to change our lifestyles don't need it. We're on the same side. Don't waste that opportunity!

A rant against the world is very satisfying, but it's not very effective. You will possibly pick up other disenfranchised people, but I don't think it will go much further. Instead, I recommend trying to respond with laser precision and discuss individual problems without bringing in all the other baggage. This time would be a good time to talk about how they are quoting scientists who are talking about conclusions with virtually nothing to explain what those conclusions are about. Perhaps you can say that we shouldn't be using such terrible journalism as input into important political dialog. Such an insight will be valuable for everybody. Another time, if real science is described, you can discuss problems with statistical techniques, etc, etc. Again, it will benefit everyone. Ideally, I would suggest that you attempt to downplay your own political agenda (everyone has one!). You have your own preferred outcome, but if you don't stress it, you have a much better chance that people with the opposite viewpoint will feel welcome enough to read what you have to write. From there, they may start to think that they should revisit their own position.

Anyway, I hope that proves helpful to you. I was reading your posts and really felt bad for your situation, which is why I decided to reply. Maybe the advice won't be good for you, but I hope it's worth thinking about.

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by saagarjha on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:44PM (#19251030)
> Attributing current weather extremes (hint, occurrences are non Gaussian) is bad science.

I'm pretty sure the general conclusion is that, on average, the climate is warming, which makes weather extremes worse.

> Releasing doom and gloom predictions to the media before peer review that are then ripped apart (but not covered by media)

What are these predictions, and where are they being ripped apart?

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by deogeo on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:08PM (#19250771)
What makes you think it's 'advocacy' science? How would climate science have to change to convince you otherwise?
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by austincheney on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:49PM (#19251064)
The science isn’t the problem. The evidence and research are solid. It’s the communication.

Science comes in two flavors: research and experiments. Other things, even if attempting to sound scientific, are probably not science. One example is consensus, which itself isn’t science unless we are talking about behavioral sciences. The average person is not a scientist, certainly not a climatologist, but is generally decent at perceiving the basics of interpersonal communication and can discern if something is science or not regardless of their agreement or bias.

That is problematic, how do you talk to those people? They won’t understand the science, but alternate means of communication results in potential for arguments that are manipulative or far out of scope.

The idea is that climate change is a big deal. It is disruptive and that disruption will be very expensive and damaging, possibly catastrophic. Bad stuff. So, you want to convince people it is bad in order to change policy. Here is where the challenge begins, because policy discussions are generally political and not scientific even if all the supporting evidence is science and that evidence is overwhelming. The goal of science is advancing knowledge according to the scientific model, which is different than the goal of a policy conversation. Knowing nothing about climate or research a person can still detect that shift in conversation from science to policy/persuasion. Accounting for that without losing your message is delicate.

You can be good at science and less good at communication. If the conversation is purely fact and research based it isn’t emotionally compelling, but if it isn’t emotionally compelling there is no drive for policy change. At the same time if it is emotionally compelling it is open to falsification by irrational and illogical means. That is a hard problem to solve.

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by basurihn on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:54PM (#19251095)
RCP 8.5 is, even according to the IPCC, highly highly unlikely. One could say the evidence for that scenario is... not overwhelming, or even whelming.

Evidence for "just what" is overwhelming... you find out the "just what" is nothing much, really.

There's a correlation between CO2 rise and a very small temperature increase, tht may or may not be a big deal. We don't know.

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by cazum on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:33PM (#19250949)
All science is 'advocacy science' when you deny the conclusions.
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by basurihn on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:41PM (#19251014)
I deny creation science. I am a denier.
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by cazum on Monday February 25, 2019 @08:05PM (#19251144)
You can't deny creation science, as creation science hasn't yet formed a coherent hypothesis capable of being denied.

Climate science has testable hypotheses that continue to give reliable, observable and consistent results. Claiming that its conclusions are wrong requires denial, as no one has yet been able to demonstrate that that they are wrong.

Creation science hasn't even yet been able to form a framework that can be tested, let alone denied. I'd argue it doesn't even qualify as a science.

Yes I'm being pedantic. Yes I will die on this hill.

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by wtvanhest on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:19PM (#19250838)
Personally, I'd like to see a financial market develop that allows people to predict future global temperatures in short, mid and long term time frames. (let's say 5 years, 10 years, 30 years).

That market would reveal humanities unbiased view of climate change predictions. It would give us a great tool to put things in perspective.

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by lazyjones on Monday February 25, 2019 @08:06PM (#19251145)
Good suggestion, but first you'd need consensus on methods for measuring and calculating global temperatures. Currently, several different methods are used by established institutions and the results come with a relatively large confidence range.

Personally, I'd rather bet on temperatures at single stations than what these observatories calculate.

Here are some details: https://www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/monitoring/climate/sur... (scroll to "What do other groups do differently?")

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by wtvanhest on Monday February 25, 2019 @09:45PM (#19251605)
That is a feature of having a financial system. People with really good incentives would attempt to find an agreeable way to measure earth's temps.
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by jessedhillon on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:40PM (#19251000)
Rates of retirement savings participation vs doomsday hoarding, controlled for age cohort, should get you a rough cut at it.
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by jhanschoo on Monday February 25, 2019 @08:23PM (#19251236)
Will that truly be undistorted? At the levels of scale in the energy sector, there might be a profitable incentive to distort the market. Use FUD against the issuers so that most would not care to invest, then manipulate whatever is left.
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by NeedMoreTea on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:20PM (#19250847)
Attempting to debunk legitimate science without evidence or citation is garbage.

How typical that it's the first comment on the story.

[dead]
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by saagarjha on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:26PM (#19250889)
Inflammatory comments with no supporting evidence are usually downvoted, irrespective of the opinion they espouse.
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by basurihn on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:33PM (#19250942)
Except the followup inflammatory comments, of course.
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by saagarjha on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:38PM (#19250987)
I'll admit that I couldn't resist replying; such comments are usually discouraged. However, I felt that you deserved to know the reason why Hacker News downvotes comments for the off chance that you didn't know already.
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by basurihn on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:31PM (#19250930)
I used to evaluate scientific contracts for the federal government. I was lied to on a monthly basis.

Scientific fraud is not a thing of the past. It's not even rare.

Karl Popper is turning over in his grave.

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by saagarjha on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:40PM (#19251001)
> Scientific fraud is not a thing of the past. It's not even rare.

Sure, but even accusations of scientific fraud require evidence to back them up. Can you provide some credible evidence to show that the majority of the scientific community is engaging in fraud?

[dead]
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by dang on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @06:08AM (#19253378)
If you continue to do flamewar like this on HN we will ban you. That goes double for your comments that crossed into personal attack.

If you know more than other people, the thing to do here is neutrally provide correct information, so people can learn. If you can't or don't want to do that, please don't post.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by jhanschoo on Monday February 25, 2019 @08:31PM (#19251277)
> Who defines credible?

If you want to convince others, you can provide a direct argument with data/popularly cited paper that a significant proportion the science in the field is bad. There are always reasonable people, not necessarily the ones you are replying to, that you may yet convince.

Alternatively, you can also provide an example for illustration and good reasons why it should generalize.

> If I mocked someone for using a linear regression on cyclical data, do you know why that's bad?

It's not necessarily bad to use linear regression on periodic data. If you wish to capture a trend independent of the periodic change, all the data in the periods are uniformly sampled/weighted, and the period is so short v. the timeframe of the data/the data for the regression is a whole integer.

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by midwest1 on Monday February 25, 2019 @09:04PM (#19251412)
jhan -

If you calculate a linear trend from subsets and get largely different results, a linear trend though the entire data set is only meaningful if you have several cycles of data. I would argue we do not have several cycles of data.

Allow me to point you to a climate scientist (who does not deny global warming). Her site is quite comprehensive. Avoid the comments section.

www.judithcurry.com

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by jhanschoo on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @02:24AM (#19252587)
Thanks for the link! That looks like a good read.

What kind of cycles are we talking about? I'm under the notion that typically the only effect that should not be captured should be seasonal change with yearly periods.

Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by api on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:17PM (#19250831)
Creation science is a purely religious viewpoint with basically zero physical evidence.

Climate science has a clear physical mechanism (CO2 traps more solar energy than N2, O2, etc.) and quite a bit of observation confirming the effect. It's simple to do an experiment showing that increasing CO2 increases a primary mechanism of the greenhouse effect. It's really pretty simple. The only debate is just how significant the effect will be, how rapid, and whether it's linear or there are thresholds.

The only reason this is a politicized issue is that the fossil fuel industry is wealthy and powerful and aligned with numerous interests including major nation states where petroleum makes up a huge percentage of export revenue. If it were not such an economically significant issue there wouldn't be any debate.

[dead]
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by arcticbull on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:27PM (#19250901)
"Wrong" isn't an argument.
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by SamReidHughes on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @11:18AM (#19255532)
It's not just the fossil fuel industry -- it's every industry that buys energy, and consumers that buy it -- it's politicized because the prosperity and growth of the economy as a whole is at stake.
Re:Evidence for man-made global warming hits 'gold standard' by api on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @02:45PM (#19257662)
I don't think that argument works. According to caiso.org (California) about 30% of my electric power right now is solar and over 50% are non-fossil-fuel sources including solar, wind, hydro, and nuclear power. In Texas wind sometimes provides over 50% of power for some regions. 20 years ago that would have been under 10% in both cases.

If fossil power is phased out it will just increase demand for other sources of energy. These will at first be more expensive, but high demand causes investments in scaling which reduces unit cost as in virtually every industrial process. Look at the cost curves for solar and wind for the past 20 years. It's almost like Moore's Law.