News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by jdblair on Monday February 25, 2019 @12:18PM (#19247293)
When I joined a particular startup 4 years ago I was surprised that they owned their own servers mounted in racks in a rented colo. I was all, how retro! But then the head of IT showed me the cost savings over AWS and how he orchestrated it all using VMWare images, and I saw he had a point. He saved more than enough money to pay for his full time salary to keep it all going, even dealing with hardware maintenance. What was unique was that the company had a predictable load that didn't change much. If we had needed to change capacity level drastically over a regular cycle then AWS would have started to make sense.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by Tistel on Monday February 25, 2019 @12:53PM (#19247647)
I have worked at a startup that was paying > 20k per month for AWS. I am certain the whole system could run on one dedicated blade. There was just this culture (made easy with docker containers) of "spin up another box" for every silly little tool. I have met self taught dev ops people who did not understand that you could create more than one user on a aws ubuntu machine. I was like: "if cost is a big issue, then lets spin up one beefy machine and create users for each dev", because thats what everyone using unix did back in the day (it works fine). The reply was "thats not possible" so every dev got their own dedicated instance that was 99% idle. We are paying >3k per month to aws and the business team is complaining about waste. sigh. old guy rant over.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by thruhiker on Monday February 25, 2019 @01:25PM (#19248002)
Did you weigh these costs against the value of the developers not stepping on eachother's toes using the same instance?Separate users with sudo privileges provides zero isolation.

I'm unsure what use case was, but if it was a testing or staging environment dedicated to each developer, having a separate right-sized instance for each is quite sane and reasonable.

EC2 instances such as the T2/T3 series are cheap enough that there's normally not a need to be so miserly in my experience.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by CharlesColeman on Monday February 25, 2019 @01:30PM (#19248050)
>> I am certain the whole system could run on one dedicated blade. There was just this culture (made easy with docker containers) of "spin up another box" for every silly little tool.

> Did you weigh these costs against the value of the developers not stepping on each other's toes using the same instance? Separate users with sudo privileges provides zero isolation.

Each developer's machine is a separate instance. If the whole system could run on "one dedicated blade," then the developers could easily run a local instance on their own machines (either directly or in a VM) without stepping on anyone's toes.

Using AWS for local development seems wasteful and over-complicated to me. The only good reason I can see for doing it is if you're really vendor-locked into AWS-proprietary services, and it's impractical to run your code anywhere except on AWS (but that's arguably a mistake in itself).

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by deathanatos on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:12PM (#19248430)
> Each developer's machine is a separate instance. If the whole system could run on "one dedicated blade," then the developers could easily run a local instance on their own machines (either directly or in a VM) without stepping on anyone's toes.

What the parent you're responding to likely meant was that, by running everything on one system ("one dedicated blade") you are causing all of the things on that system to share certain things. The set of system-installed packages; if nginx needs to be installed and running, is its configuration now shared between all of the services on that machine; and even the very OS itself (e.g., if it needs to go down for updates, or it needs to do, say a dist-upgrade, which means that all of the associates services on that instance need to dist-upgrade together, and one laggard can thus hold everyone back.)

Even in the case of developers using an instance on AWS, the same applies, really: a dev, legitimately developing some component, could have cross-talk to others, in all of the same ways listed above. I do agree that giving devs dedicated instances might not be appropriate in many instances, and it perhaps wasn't appropriate in yours. But there's two points here: whether the devs needed those instances, or could develop on local laptops, and whether putting all instances or users on a single instance works well.

Even for development, given that most corps seem to love giving devs that code primarily for Linux servers OS X laptops, there might be advantages to allowing them to develop on the actual target hardware.

> There was just this culture (made easy with docker containers) of "spin up another box" for every silly little tool.

Docker here should make it rather trivial to combine everything onto a single instance, since that's what isolation gets you: a well defined unit that doesn't have endless unknown dependencies on the host system.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by h1d on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:07PM (#19250758)
Sounds cheaper to just give them VMware fusion and a dev OS image which is mostly identical to the target architecture.

I really don't see why many run their environment on macOS through Homebrew etc which is surely going to require modifications here and there when deploying to Linux servers.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by miranda_rights on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @01:44AM (#19252456)
An old job had that setup, with about 15 devs per instance. It worked surprisingly well, where each developer had sudo access but was asked to 'use it with care'. It helped that there was a mix in the type of work, so not everyone was doing resource-intensive work, etc.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by h1d on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:03PM (#19250729)
Can you not run a docker container for each dev who would log into it, so they're isolated to begin with?

Of course ports can't be shared for each app servers but you can get around that anyhow.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by thruhiker on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @02:10AM (#19252536)
If the development environment is comprised of multiple container images that would likely justify dedicated small EC2 instances.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by eftpotrm on Monday February 25, 2019 @01:35PM (#19248090)
Knew a place that turned off the developers' test environment because it was costing 10x that per month. Which was as popular and successful as you can imagine. I'm.... skeptical about the benefits of the cloud architecture they actually had, given those costs.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by twh270 on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:07PM (#19250761)
Our org just implemented this. A script turns off all services in lower environments (dev, qa) at night; another one turns 'em on in the morning. Of course if you need to, you can run your own script to turn on your services "if you need to".

This is being sold as a "step in the right direction", where "right direction" is anything that reduces cloud costs. (Payroll costs are apparently invisible, so the time people waste dealing with this baloney doesn't count. Not to mention the annoyance.)

I'm tempted to point out that they could save a lot more money by merging microservices into macroservices....

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by sigfubar on Monday February 25, 2019 @01:04PM (#19247780)
I've worked for a certain IoT startup that at one point paid $850k/month (eight hundred and fifty thousand USD per month) for AWS usage. After about a year of full time work by a team of SREs and programmers, the bill was made to go down by half.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by h1d on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:09PM (#19250777)
Any breakdowns on cost?
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by UncleMeat on Monday February 25, 2019 @05:32PM (#19250120)
That's like half of one engineer. Less if you include all of the overhead of having an employee. That can easily be the right choice.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by mancerayder on Monday February 25, 2019 @01:16PM (#19247910)
I have met self taught dev ops people who did not understand that you could create more than one user on a aws ubuntu machine.

Wait, you're saying there's a Bachelor of Science DevOps degree?

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by Tistel on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:33PM (#19248622)
They are very young, nice kids, who have started from a pure aws standpoint. They started with AWS tutorials. These tutorials did not teach the full unix environment. The gaps in their knowledge is like the grande canyon. If they just read the O'reilly book on linux: http://shop.oreilly.com/product/9780596154493.do. they would be miles ahead. But, their only interest is docker/kubernetes. Those technologies are great, but, they simply have massive gaps in their knowledge of the fundementals. They don't seem to like reading technical books from cover to cover. So they just read tutorials far enough to get the system started. Then they cut/paste from stackoverflow when problems arise. If that does not work, they blame the tools ("couched is too slow!"). Again, its not their fault, just the new dev culture. I freely admit I am an old fogey.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by mancerayder on Monday February 25, 2019 @04:31PM (#19249641)
We agree.

I interviewed at (a fast growing real estate startup) and as an old guy, I highlighted my vast enterprise Linux engineering experience. The response from management was, oh, that's nice but doesn't matter here. I can teach people the command line in one day. This is a big AWS and exclusively Linux shop.

What do you say to that?

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by heydonovan on Monday February 25, 2019 @04:40PM (#19249709)
From my experience, the hardcore Unix folks should stick to jobs that highlights that type of knowledge. If you join an AWS shop, you're never going to dig into low level things like the proc filesystem, and the arcane knowledge of knowing every single tool just isn't used. I've gone from remoting into machines on the daily, to not using SSH for almost a year now. Just depends on the job I suppose. Went from having knowledge of all the different signals, and getting really good at tcpdump/gdb, to just writing Terraform/CloudFormation scripts, and nuking an instance from orbit if there were any issues with it. Such a different workflow.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by mancerayder on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:27PM (#19250902)
Yes, BUT:

Grey-haired Linux folks who've hammered on complex, changing, sometimes esoteric systems in different companies with unique challenges COMBINED with having to have learned a programming language, to view these people as obsolete is an ultimate folly of youth here in IT.

To suggest that it's all different now, your Shell/Perl/Webserver/database/caching/networking experience somehow has nothing on Python/Terraform/AWS/Docker really shows inexperience of hiring managers.

I learned both, and I can tell you AWS+someyaml+Python are MUCH easier than any of the stuff I listed above. Yet, there's a new generation of hiring managers that believes otherwise.

Today at work I had to explain absolutely basic DNS to someone. I dunno, call me skeptical about this new paradigm business. The paradigms look awfully familiar.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by anongraddebt on Monday February 25, 2019 @05:53PM (#19250276)
I'm on the business side, and am relatively young. Have dabbled with computer stuff since middle school (built desktops with my Dad, internet privileges revoked for a year in middle school for hacking the Oracle system, have run linux on my non-work laptop for the past ~5 years, etc.), but never pursued serious study whether solo or in a formal setting.

Both with tech and non-tech related learning, my autodidact process (largely determined by growing up through the late 90's and early aughts) was the following:

(1) Google search or Amazon search

(2) Blitz-read some website I thought might be relevant from the Google search results or Blitz-read for author and subject matter info. I thought might be relevant from the Amazon search results

(3) Stop at (2) because I had pieced together a solution or had gleaned a sufficient amount of information; or repeat (1) and (2) until piecing together a solution or gleaning...

This rather clunky but speedy (notice I did not say efficient) process likely accounts for far more of my knowledge and skill base then I'd care to admit to friends and colleagues.

All this to say: management's response to you is representative of a default mode of thinking determined (to a non-trivial degree) by the environment in which they grew up.

This default mode of thinking has a number of short-term benefits, but often results in many long-term headaches. Indeed, you really can teach someone the command line in a day. However, this someone will end up doing stuff I do with the command line, such as using ls 100x more than is necessary or almost always changing directories one at a time.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by xfitm3 on Monday February 25, 2019 @07:22PM (#19250862)
“Thanks for your time. Have a nice day.”
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by toomuchtodo on Monday February 25, 2019 @01:19PM (#19247930)
Documentation is no replacement for experience.

EDIT: I agree that OPs choice of words makes the idea expressed ambiguous.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by mancerayder on Monday February 25, 2019 @01:26PM (#19248020)
I just don't understand what a "self-taught" DevOps person is -- as opposed to a someone-taught? Self-taught usually means "not educated formally."

All DevOps / SysAdmins / etc. are "self-taught." So it's unclear what the OP meant.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by nunez on Monday February 25, 2019 @11:45PM (#19252037)
it can but if that blade or the enclosure dies, the system is sol...also, procurement can be a pain
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by drieddust on Monday February 25, 2019 @01:11PM (#19247846)
I agree completely.

I consult with multiple customers and they all want cloud. It's "Cloud First" and any discussion to the contrary results in lost business. If you do that you are considered a Dinosaur.

On the issue of predictable load, most businesses not only have predictable load but a lot of capacity is just allocated and never used. VMware serves such scenarios even better by going for heavy over allocation. Everyone will demand 10 servers with 8vCPU, 64 GB of RAM without actually using even 10% of the allocated capacity.

But hey Cloud is cool so I have to be on it.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by ses1984 on Monday February 25, 2019 @01:22PM (#19247968)
You can be cloud first and still not squander money on idle resources...
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by drieddust on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @01:06AM (#19252311)
That requires culture change and it's hard for big boys with checkbooks.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by scarface74 on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @08:23AM (#19254028)
If all you’re doing with AWS is a bunch of EC2 instances - the equivalent of a bunch of VMs - yes you will spend more and not get any operational experiences.

That’s like the old school Netops people who got one AWS certificate, did a lift and shift of a bunch of VMs and then proclaimed their client has “moved to the cloud”. The client still has the same amount of staff, same processes, etc. Of course it isn’t going to save any money.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by drieddust on Wednesday February 27, 2019 @12:49AM (#19261171)
That's the reality of it. Any proper move requires longer term planning (> 2 years) and currently CIO themselves don't usually last 2 years. Any project however complex needs to be executed in a quarter which means "Lift and Shift".

Sad reality.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by lykr0n on Monday February 25, 2019 @12:20PM (#19247312)
This. If you can predict your workload with some accuracy, and have someone who knows how to design systems- you can save a lot of money. AWS' value is that "we can do everything except write your code for you" which you end up paying a lot for.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by weinzierl on Monday February 25, 2019 @12:51PM (#19247634)
If you have someone who knows how to design systems and your workload is constant most of the time with occasioal spikes you could run your base load on your own machines and offload the spikes to AWS.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by lykr0n on Monday February 25, 2019 @01:17PM (#19247918)
Yep. There is a 99.99% chance one of the following will happen:

- Your Colo has direct connect to AWS, so you can deploy EC2 under times of load

- Your Colo offers some sort of virtualized infrastructure that you could wire into your network and offload under times of load

- Your Colo has a virtual server provider running that you can offload to in times of load.

- Is close enough to one of the big 3 that a Site to Site will work fine

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by ekovarski on Monday February 25, 2019 @12:51PM (#19247632)
... isn't that the hardest part, predicting workload, for many companies. Scaling up within a colo can be troublesome due to procuring hw, having remote hands rack it, setup, etc.

If you can predict workload then you could also reduce your cloud bills, in theory, by moving spinning up/down instances.

Many are going the cloud route because the cost of entry is much easier to start developing but eventually, yes, the cost skyrockets and you do end up paying for putting little forethought into the real workload requirements.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by toomuchtodo on Monday February 25, 2019 @12:57PM (#19247695)
> Scaling up within a colo can be troublesome due to procuring hw, having remote hands rack it, setup, etc.

One senior sysadmin/infrastructure engineer with on-prem experience is enough to scale up your colo presence. You can either assemble your own servers or custom order and have them shipped directly to the colo. Remote console and power management (PDUs) is a solved problem. Out of band management, also solved. Virtualization, solved. Push your VM snapshots, content, artifacts, and database backups into your object store of choice for offsite backups. Ideally, your colo facility is within driving distance of your office if you absolutely need physical access. Otherwise, you pay someone at the colo a few hundred bucks a month for remote hands services.

EDIT: k8s arguably makes this easier than in the past. You want to run on your own cluster? You can. You need to burst your containers to spot instances in someone else's cloud? You can.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by user5994461 on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:08PM (#19248395)
All the problems you consider solved are only solved if you have the tooling from AWS/Google or half solved if you have VMWare.

With physical hardware, the sysadmin will spend a lot of his time fighting the hardware supplier and the colo to get hardware in place and running, then reinvent the tooling. Any trip to the facility is half a day lost.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by toomuchtodo on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:23PM (#19248536)
Many organizations run their own hardware successfully without the tooling I mention. There are problems, just different problems from cloud with significant cost savings realized. Why would you be fighting your hardware supplier or your colo? I have never had a hardware vendor "fight me", and only once had challenging negotiations with a colo provider.

Have you never lost half a day of getting work done because Amazon's EC2 API was failing to launch new instances? I have! [1]

To simply hand wave away hosting your own hardware as infeasible and more costly (especially when it's been proven to be more costly) is unproductive at best.

[1] https://hn.algolia.com/?query=AWS%20outage&sort=byPopularity... (HN search of "AWS Outage")

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by user5994461 on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:34PM (#19248629)
The cost savings have never been proven. If anything, they're proven to be miscalculated every time someones gives his numbers.

Self hosting is doable up to 2 or 3 servers with a very few services. Beyond that it's really suffering from the lack of tooling, the lack of isolation and the lead time of weeks to get anything more in place.

DELL wants to re verify by phone 3 times before they bill or ship anything. Don't ask me why, I don't know, I keep begging them to stop doing that.

I've had the API down about 4 times in a year, always for specific types of instance, if I remember the count well. Never more than a few hours. It's nothing in comparison to the weeks it takes to ship and setup physical hardware.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by nasalgoat on Monday February 25, 2019 @04:58PM (#19249867)
Funny, I managed to run a globally-dispersed on-prem system with over 300 individual physical machines (well, blades in racks) with one other guy no problem for many years. I was dealing with four different hosting providers doing remote hands and never had any issues whatsoever.

About the most complicated tooling we had was Anaconda.

I think I lost three hard drives in that time and all three were hotswapped with zero downtime under warranty. No other failures. And that's not an outlier - I've been doing this 25+ years and the hardware failure rate has been pretty consistently low.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by eastern on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:21AM (#19269620)
Similar experience here roughly, albeit mine is at a smaller scale.

The key phrase in your post is 'doing this 25+ years'.

What you're providing is the /confidence/ that you can do it. Most outfits nowadays probably have no one who has that.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by speedplane on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:33AM (#19269661)
I think there's a sliding scale with cloud services.

At the ultra-small scale (1 person company), it's arguably cheaper to run from a single server you bought.

Mid-sized companies (~2-1000 people) probably benefit the most from cloud computing because they need fewer dedicated salaried employees to manage them.

Beyond ~1000 employees however, you're going to need that expertise regardless of whether you use cloud or on-prem. And the markup of those thousands of cloud machines will start to become significant. You'll need to do a cost/benefit analysis and I can see it going in either direction.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by speedplane on Thursday February 28, 2019 @02:28AM (#19269645)
The cloud's cost savings are not in your 300 individual machines. In fact, I'd bet that your 300 machines are much cheaper than the equivalent on AWS.

Rather, the cost savings come from the salaries of you and the "one other guy" you mentioned. If cloud hardware can bring your staff of 2 down to 1, then the cost savings are huge. More-so if they can bring it down to 0 and have devs manage the hosted infrastructure. Each of your salaries is likely near or higher than the cost of running all those machines.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by nasalgoat on Thursday February 28, 2019 @10:33AM (#19271999)
In my experience with cloud - pushing 8 years now - it's a total fallacy that you can just run without admins. Every time I've come in to clean up a giant mess left by "devops" who were actually just devs who knew nothing about administration of servers I've found massive amounts of waste, duplication, zero optimizations and poorly operating systems that even a intermediate admin would have helped to mitigate. One place, just doing a bit of tuning and moving a few services on-prem resulted in a $200K/year savings.

Developers and Administrators have different priorities and I can count on one hand the number of true "DevOps" people I know - the rest are either decent admins and poor devs or decent devs but poor admins. The idea is nice but the reality isn't quite what its made out to be.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by user5994461 on Thursday February 28, 2019 @06:15PM (#19276347)
It's a fallacy to save money on personnel. The time saved by not managing low level hardware will be assigned to other tasks. The savings are actually done on instance costs and flexibility.

Physical instances have too much over provisioning and zero flexibility. You can easily be paying for an order of magnitude above the actually used capacity. (This can be helped with VmWare virtualization instead of bare metal but the amount of new companies using VmWare is shrinking and licenses are expensive.)

Whereas with the cloud, you can half any instance CPU/memory to save half the money. There is even build in monitoring to analyze usage. There is little waste.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by speedplane on Saturday March 02, 2019 @02:42AM (#19288118)
> Physical instances have too much over provisioning and zero flexibility. You can easily be paying for an order of magnitude above the actually used capacity.

The cost of the hardware is not the issue.

Paying for 600 machines when you actually need 300 probably "wastes" $50-80k/year in over-provisioned hardware. Hiring a skilled admin to figure out what's going on, optimize the network, and reduce those 600 machines down to 300 probably costs at least $150k/yr in their salary+benefits. The cloud does not decrease the cost of the hardware (it's actually more expensive), but it allows you to reduce the number of admins managing it. That's the cost savings.

Given the above example, what would any reasonable general manager do: hire someone to make things more efficient, or just pay for the over-provisioning?

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by user5994461 on Saturday March 02, 2019 @10:07AM (#19289514)
You're hopefully kidding when you say that the costs of the hardware is not an issue. Server grade hardware costs an arm.

600 servers at $10k each, that's $6M upfront. Then another $6M within 3-5 years to renew them.

Of course in that example you'd pay someone, even multiple people in fact, to make things more efficient.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by user5994461 on Monday February 25, 2019 @05:32PM (#19250122)
Well, you're either incredibly lucky or you have zero monitoring and failures have no impact.

I couldn't imagine having to manage 300 physical servers in a team of two. The hardware, OS and networking alone are more than a full time job with 24/7 oncall expectations. In fact that's why I don't do this anymore.

Pretty sure my current company had more failed hard drives this month than you all these years. I remember a shipment of servers once with more dead motherboards than that.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by nasalgoat on Monday February 25, 2019 @05:51PM (#19250259)
I bought all brand-new Dell blade servers so that's probably the main reason it was fine. IP-based kickstart boot, anaconda provisioning, it only took one person to monitor a server's setup.

The point is that managing on-prem equipment is the easiest its ever been. When I started the ratio of admin to box was 1:50, now it's easily 1:300.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by pmoriarty on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:50PM (#19248759)
"Self hosting is doable up to 2 or 3 servers with a very few services. Beyond that it's really suffering from the lack of tooling, the lack of isolation and the lead time of weeks to get anything more in place."

There are plenty of companies with their own datacenters of hundreds or even thousands of machines. Yes, these companies usually have deep pockets and their own dedicated staff to take care of these servers. This is how it was done before AWS existed, and is likely to continue long after AWS ceases to exist.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by scarface74 on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @08:28AM (#19254074)
And that’s just the point. AWS lets you not only cut down on “dedicated” staff. You can also share a lot of the staff you do need by using a Managed Service Provider.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by snark42 on Monday February 25, 2019 @03:00PM (#19248866)
> DELL wants to re verify by phone 3 times before they bill or ship anything. Don't ask me why, I don't know, I keep begging them to stop doing that.

You need to get a Dell sales rep you deal with everytime you order. You'll get better pricing too.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by ahartmetz on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:37PM (#19248656)
Computing power on AWS costs 3x+ as much as the naively calculated cost of buying and running servers. Of course there are situations where running your own servers actually is cheaper. You are arguing the impossibility of something people are doing right now, so...?!
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by scarface74 on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @08:26AM (#19254052)
There is a lot more that AWS does for you than host a bunch of VMs...
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by toomuchtodo on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @11:56AM (#19256018)
Many use cases doesn't require what AWS provides besides storage and compute primitives. If your use case must use Amazon, use Amazon. If not, consider more efficient alternatives.

I don't mention AWS in my comment, not sure why you thought I was comparing the two.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by scarface74 on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @01:01PM (#19256704)
Even then if you can just get rid of one support person you can save enough to buy a lot of from AWS just taking into account the management you don’t have to do - if you automate.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by pmoriarty on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:42PM (#19248692)
"Ideally, your colo facility is within driving distance of your office if you absolutely need physical access. Otherwise, you pay someone at the colo a few hundred bucks a month for remote hands services."

That remote hands service is usually very limited. Datacenter staff usually don't have the time or the skills to do detailed troubleshooting, setup, or maintenance. Maybe they'll swap out a disk for you, power cycle a server, or turn a knob on a KVM switch. If you want more, you'll have probably have to buy in to managed service, which they'll do on their own hardware and with their own setup, where you'll be paying closer to AWS prices.

Now if you want the kind of availability and redundancy that AWS offers you, you'll have to have a presence in multiple datacenters around the world, where these sorts of issues and others will multiply.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by toomuchtodo on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:48PM (#19248747)
> Now if you want the kind of availability and redundancy that AWS offers you, you'll have to have a presence in multiple datacenters around the world, where these sorts of issues and others will multiply.

Wikimedia is serving Wikipedia (ranked #5 for Internet traffic) with ~550 servers out of Dallas, TX and Ashburn, VA for about $4 million/year in tech costs. OpenStreetMap infra is ~$120k-$150k/year (albeit with volunteers and some donated hosting capacity). Do you need Amazon to do better?

I am not trying to be a "stick in the mud". I am trying to save you money.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by sgwae on Wednesday February 27, 2019 @07:22AM (#19262767)
aws is only a few cents an hour, i dont get why wikipedia doesnt switch over unless they are pocketing the differece.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by toomuchtodo on Friday March 01, 2019 @01:57AM (#19278505)
Because Wikipedia doesn’t want to waste money.

“A few cents an hour”. It’s a 30% markup over physical hardware, not to mention extortionate bandwidth pricing.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by alchemism on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:52PM (#19248785)
You might be surprised at what offering them (the “hands”) a packet of well-written runbooks and a bottle of scotch for the holidays will get you.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by lykr0n on Monday February 25, 2019 @03:14PM (#19248991)
I work at a company that runs out of 11 datacenters around the world. We don't have issues with availability and redundancy
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by drieddust on Tuesday February 26, 2019 @01:21AM (#19252363)
Servers are cheap enough so buying a few and keeping on standby is no brainer and they are good for 5 years generally.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by chomp on Monday February 25, 2019 @12:48PM (#19247608)
Even if you can't predict the workload too well, you can go hybrid cloud - colo for the baseline and then AWS for the unpredictable stuff. ManageIQ is great for this.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by dba7dba on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:14PM (#19248449)
I think VMware has expensive licensing. At least for me when I was just trying to set up home linux lab environment. And than I discovered Xen Project.

I played around with that, and than AWS/DO came along.

Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by fosco on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:26PM (#19248566)
I've been tinkering with bhyve lately at home. there are definitely a few kinks to work out but I am _very_ happy with it and hope the community around it grows.
Re:As AWS Use Soars, Companies Surprised by Cloud Bills by user5994461 on Monday February 25, 2019 @02:03PM (#19248349)
You were lucky to have a guy with VMWare experience. Most startups who avoid the cloud go bare metal and that's completely unmanageable. Basically a pair of high memory servers running every services with no isolation whatsoever.

By the way, Vmware is not exactly cheap either. I recall when I was selling VMWare licenses 10 years ago, it was starting around $5000 per server.