News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by Phemist on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:49AM (#19224851)
This has already gone meta-meta, in that there is a thread in every comment section on a post by Stephen Wolfram that complains about his self-obsession, and also one that complains about the complaints.

Basically, there is an HN gentlemen's agreement to collectively ignore Wolfram's self-praise, so that discussions about the worthwhile nuggets of insight in his blog posts are not drowned out.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by jjoonathan on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:32AM (#19225087)
That strikes me as a bad idea.

Silence = implicit approval. Don't implicitly approve Wolfram's narcissism. Just don't.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by dang on Friday February 22, 2019 @01:27PM (#19227736)
It's not about Wolfram, it's about HN threads not repeating themselves over and over again. When they do, they're off topic. And boy do they do that about this one.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19222812

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by throwawaymath on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:13AM (#19225442)
I'm going to have to vehemently push back on this. I don't think you can declare what does and does not constitute "implicit approval" for other people. You can't just impose a crusade on other people.

Am I approving of Wolfram'a narcissism if I read an article of his but don't make a comment discussing his narcissism? What if I upvote an article but don't comment about it? What if I comment, but not about his narcissism? Where's the line?

Where does my obligation begin and end? If I choose to abstain from commenting on someone's narcissism, does that mean I have to boycott their work? Do I have to boycott talking about their work with other people?

If you don't respond to this comment of mine, am I to read your silence as implicit agreement? If not, why is that idea any less flippant than yours?

I'm not going to conspicuously trot out a meme about Wolfram's narcissism every time he comes up. It doesn't add any new information to the discussion, whereas he frequently writes interesting things. It also won't make Wolfram any less narcissistic, it will just be obsessive and futile. He's not harming anyone.

To give an example, what you're suggesting is the reason why (for the most part) the only people who find Stallman bearable are people who share his ideology. If you have a pet crusade you launch whenever a topic comes up, you'll quickly find your comments marginalized by everyone who frankly doesn't care about it as much as you. It's just not a productive use of time and doesn't effect the change you think it will. It's a poor hill to die on.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by jjoonathan on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:45AM (#19225715)
Whether silence should mean tacit approval and whether it does mean tacit approval are two entirely different questions. I'd argue that it shouldn't but it does.

Mentioning and disapproving of Wolfram's narcissism is hardly akin to dying on a hill, and nobody is even asking you to do it, but Phemist is asking people to not actively disapprove of Wolfram's narcissism and I find that odd.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by afiori on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:13AM (#19225971)
> Whether silence should mean tacit approval and whether it does mean tacit approval are two entirely different questions. I'd argue that it shouldn't but it does.

Silence can also mean dismissal. Wolfram is hardly at a level of cultural influence where he is rallying up support for a narcissistic lifestyle.

In the course many years we moved from an honour culture where tolerance was a weakness and misbehaviour was something to strongly react to toward a dignity culture where we try to lead by example and where (in polite conversation) criticism needs to be more nuanced.

Moreover by that logic I am silently approving of many things all the time, when talking about Obama and medicare I often omit drone bombing as a topic.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by zazen on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:59AM (#19225852)
>nobody is even asking you to do it

It may not have been your conscious intent, but your previous comment was in fact in the imperative:

>Don't implicitly approve Wolfram's narcissism. Just don't.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by comboy on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:54AM (#19225253)
Well if you don't like him just ignore him, that's the biggest weapon in today's world.

There are so many more interesting things to discuss than the author's personal traits.

As Eric Weinstein put it, we are standing on shoulders of jerks[1] (I wouldn't put Stephen in this particular category). We do need people like Wolfram and we need them to be themselves.

1. https://youtu.be/TKeMIWVOnbo?t=553

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by jjoonathan on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:56AM (#19225822)
If Wolfram didn't drag a self-aggrandizing anecdote into every third sentence it might be easier to focus on his ideas.
Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by theli0nheart on Friday February 22, 2019 @08:56AM (#19225273)
What’s your goal with that? Character smearing is tiring, repetitive, and doesn’t belong here. Let’s move on and focus on the ideas he’s sharing.
Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by jjoonathan on Friday February 22, 2019 @09:53AM (#19225786)
Wolfram's narcissism is tiring, repetitive, and doesn't belong anywhere. Let's keep that message clear and not go for "it's OK to be a jerk if you're smart."
Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by theli0nheart on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:03AM (#19225894)
Um, no.

It’s never OK to be a jerk.

But that doesn’t mean jerks have nothing of value to add to the world. No human being is perfect. If we disregarded the successes and breakthroughs of anyone who did anything bad in their lives we’d still be living in the Stone Age.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by FatalLogic on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:23AM (#19226064)
Picasso was a jerk, Mozart was a jerk etc

I'm not saying Wolfram is in their league, but I think the same principle applies. You salute the ideas, not the man.

If you want to criticize the person, then keep that separate.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by zazen on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:45AM (#19226255)
I would agree if discussion of Wolfram's narcissism were being dragged into a discussion of Mathematica that didn't otherwise feature Wolfram personally; but that's not the case here. The link is to a text written by Wolfram, in substantial part about Wolfram, in which Wolfram's narcissism is on display. We can't separate the person here.
Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by golemotron on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:33AM (#19226648)
I do. You could.
Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by zazen on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:59AM (#19226868)
I've tried to suggest that there are difficulties with separating the person from a personal biographical essay in a way that there aren't in separating the author from an abstract art work.

I don't suppose you feel like engaging with my suggestion with something more than this blunt, unsupported rejection?

If you merely mean that when discussing such a piece we can remain generally calm and give room in the discussion for things other than the author's arrogance, then I agree.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by golemotron on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:16PM (#19227025)
Good. We agree. I think that separating and author from their work is a skill that can and should be cultivated.

I was serious that I can separate the person, so that's an existence proof.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by zazen on Friday February 22, 2019 @12:32PM (#19227176)
>I was serious that I can separate the person, so that's an existence proof.

Those of us who are mere mortals can't reliably predict ourselves to achieve perfection on complex, subjective tasks like this.

You find your own self-confidence to be highly convincing to the point of mathematical proof. Please have another think about that. And about making "clever" four-word dismissals of other people's comments.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by theli0nheart on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:32PM (#19230187)
>> I was serious that I can separate the person, so that's an existence proof.

> Those of us who are mere mortals can't reliably predict ourselves to achieve perfection on complex, subjective tasks like this.

I was able to separate the two as well without much of a problem, so...I guess I must be some sort of god too. :)

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by zazen on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:53PM (#19230333)
Congratulations on being too clever for humility. I remember how simple life looked to me too, before I learned to start thinking.
Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by golemotron on Friday February 22, 2019 @06:45PM (#19230275)
Pleased to meet you. Welcome to the club.
Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by viscanti on Friday February 22, 2019 @11:29AM (#19226613)
> Don't implicitly approve Wolfram's narcissism. Just don't.

That's fair, but I'm not sure that a comment thread on HN is going to change him. He might be stuck in his ways at this point and may not even care about what some of the posts here say about his narcissism. I'm also not sure that we need to convince anyone here that he is a narcissist, as that part doesn't seem contentious. So maybe focusing on the other areas is better.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by golemotron on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:13AM (#19225966)
Narcissism is a psychological disorder. Is it okay to attack and shame people for something they can't control? That doesn't seem right.
Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by nmstoker on Friday February 22, 2019 @01:17PM (#19227635)
This is not meant argumentatively, but is it intrinsically part of the definition of a psychological disorder that it cannot be controlled at all by the person? And presumably people here aren't actually diagnosing him with the condition, merely saying be acts like that (as many smug, full of themselves people also act that way without it being clear they've got a disorder)

Irrespective of that, I'd say that shaming someone isn't great whatever, but there's no denying that this kind of thing is disruptive - people persevere with his writing because he's often got valuable points to communicate, but you'd have to be thick skinned to say it wasn't intensely annoying.

Even if Stephen can't control it, it seems like he's functional enough that he would be aware of the way he comes across and simply ask someone to edit out the OTT aspects brefore he posts. Knowing his eagerness for efficiency, perhaps he could even automate the text processing with the Wolfram Language.

Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by rongenre on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:59AM (#19226364)
I'm reasonably sure that the self-aggrandizement that he does is probably why Mathematica is pretty much a niche product, even compared to Matlab, and certainly numpy/pandas.
Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by nsxwolf on Friday February 22, 2019 @10:21AM (#19226039)
I just roll my eyes at his self-praise when I see it. I don't think it's really all that harmful or necessarily narcissism.
Re:There Was a Time before Mathematica (2013) by lqet on Friday February 22, 2019 @07:52AM (#19224860)
I was not aware of that, but am now. Thanks!