News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by skh on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:43PM (#19193673)
Western civilization is in crisis because of these social experimental policies undermining its original meritocratic competitive default mode. So, the real question is, where/when at some point does this madness stop?

We have a significant segment of the population that has been historically oppressed and suppressed. After desegregation whites fled the cities. Go look at the population of the top 50 cities in the U.S. in 1960 and compare with their populations in 1970, 1980, 1990, and 2000. That white flight had a very bad effect on the school systems in those cities since school funding is largely a product of the tax base. So while from a legal standpoint there is equality (and this is generous given how bail, policing, etc. are done in the U.S.) there is indeed a state of inequality. Western civilization is not in a state of crisis because of attempts to remedy this state of affairs.

I submit the real question is when will people understand the social context in which a significant segment of the population exists and seek ways to remedy the problems. Be part of the solution.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by ryanmonroe on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:54PM (#19193773)
> Have different standards for awarding doctorates based on race?

This is not at all what the article is saying. The article argues the low percentage is partially due to a "leaky pipeline" where black students don't have access to the same educational resources, and partially due to an unwelcoming atmosphere. The "So what?", if there is one given, is that we should address those issues, and the only example they give of how to do this is voluntarily setting up and participating in organizations for minorities. Implying the article as asking for lowered standards for black people is a mischaracterization.

I wouldn't even look at the article as an argument for any particular educational policy though. To me it seems like the article is light on the "So?", because its main aim is just to convey what's in the title: "What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician". If the content of the article just boils down to "it's kinda shitty", it would still be worthwhile and convey valuable information we should care about, even if the implications are left to the reader.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by mLuby on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:39PM (#19193627)
I mean, doesn't the madness stop once the identity breakdown in a given field roughly matches the identity in the general population?

If X% of people are Black, I would expect given no structural impediments that roughly X% of Mathematicians would also be Black.

The how to get there in the quickest and fairest way is a political question.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by towaway1138 on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:05PM (#19193895)
As a statistician or economist, I would actually be quite shocked if the proportion was often close. This rarely or never happens in other fields, even ones where there is essentially no possibility of such supposed impediments. Randomness happens.

Instead of stealing someone's thunder by putting them on easy mode, give them the opportunity to kill it.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by ericdykstra on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:04PM (#19193881)
This is baseless, unscientific blank-slateism, and isn't true anywhere in the world among any demographic segment in any measure.

If 10% of Singaporean men are gay would you expect 10% of male plumbers in Singapore to be gay? If women are 30% of the workforce in Canada, would you expect Canadian dental assistants to be 70% male?

Disparate outcomes doesn't imply unfair treatment.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by whyisthewhat on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:09PM (#19193927)
What specifically do you think is the reason black people should not be expected to achieve demographic parity in academic math? And how does that relate to “blank slate-ism”? You seem to be implying that there is some inherent characteristic of black people that prevents them from attaining equal representation in math academia. Is this what you intended to convey? Please be explicit.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by ericdykstra on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:18PM (#19194011)
> What specifically do you think is the reason black people should not be expected to achieve demographic parity in academic math?

I don't expect demographic parity in anything.

> And how does that relate to “blank slate-ism”?

You only expect demographic parity in everything if you think genetics doesn't play a role in what type of careers people choose.

> You seem to be implying that there is some inherent characteristic of black people that prevents them from attaining equal representation in math academia.

Well, for one, it looks like Black students choose Math as a major significantly less often than Asian students do. Blacks having some genetic predisposition to prefer other subjects seems like a pretty decent hypothesis.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by rapture-bepure on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:29PM (#19194111)
Well, if you'd care to let us measure the bumps on your head, I'm pretty sure we could now come up with an equally moronic theory about related misshapen heads with a predisposition for making irrational, racist comments on the web.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by tptacek on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:05PM (#19193890)
No, that's true. They just suggest it.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by ericdykstra on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:12PM (#19193950)
No, again, this is blank-slateism. People are born with genetic predispositions that influence things such as height, eye color, mathematical ability, and career preference. You would only expect population-proportionate outcomes if genetics played no role. Even if they only play a 10% role, you get vastly different outcomes.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by tptacek on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:20PM (#19194025)
No, you're falsely projecting your own concerns about your interlocutors onto me. It doesn't follow from "sharply disparate outcomes suggest unfairness" that I must be a "blank-slate" purist. And, in fact, your response suggests you're the one with the extremist take: that disparate outcomes are most likely the result of fair processes running on unequal inputs. Approximately nobody on HN believes processes in general to be fair (see: any thread about which companies VCs choose to fund, or about the impact of lobbying on government decisions).

I conceded something about the point you made --- that disparate outcomes are not dispositive of structural unfairness --- and you responded to that concession by trying to caricature me. In this exchange, you have not come across as someone trying to discuss a complicated issue in good faith. Try again.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by whyisthewhat on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:17PM (#19193998)
So your belief is that black people as a group have inherently less mathematical ability than whites people? Am I misinterpreting you?
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by 0815test on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:26PM (#19194076)
A mathematics PhD is going to be in the far right tail of aptitude for a lot of relevant skills. This is the admittedly very rare case where altogether tiny differences in "inherent" ability will get amplified to the point where they actually start to matter - whatever "inherent" might mean, in the first place! Yup, crucially, even differences that are generally understood as "not inherent" can be so hard to address that they might as well be, for all we can do about them. If you ate too many lead paint flakes as a kid, the probability that you're going to be a successful math PhD drops quite a bit. And, short of tearing down and rebuilding a lot of homes that happen to have lead paint, lead pipes, etc. in them, we're unfortunately not going to be able to address this "inherent" unbalance for the foreseeable future.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by tptacek on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:30PM (#19194117)
You understand that the perception that you're looking at someone's skin color or facial features, making a prediction as to whether they ingested lead paint as a child, and then acting accordingly is going to be problematic, right?
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by 0815test on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:35PM (#19194168)
But of course no one sane is doing anything of the sort. The issue is how to explain the difference between "% of people with visible feature X in the general population" and "% of folks with feature X who happen to be math PhD's". Well, if feature X correlates with issues like eating lead paint as a kid, even to a small, otherwise undetectable extent, you're going to find that sort of difference.
[dead]
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by dang on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:40PM (#19194229)
Personal attacks aren't ok here. We've banned this account. Please do not create accounts to break the site guidelines with, and please don't take HN threads further into flamewar hell.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by helen___keller on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:33PM (#19194149)
"given no structural impediments" is the keyword - without any structural impediments, all your examples should be true.

Structural impediments aren't inherently unfair - for example, if gay men simply prefer not to be a plumber for some unknown reason, that is enough to say that there is a structural impediment for gay Singoporean plumbers, and there doesn't have to be anything unfair about that.

On the other hand, sometimes structural impediments are immoral and should be rectified. If a whole bunch of gay singoporean men wanted to be plumbers, but weren't allowed to enter the profession as a result of laws against their sexual orientation, that would be an unfair treatment and action should be taken to fix the unfair treatment.

With this in mind, we KNOW that minority populations have been very negatively affected for MANY generations from legal discrimination, which directly caused poverty. It is also widely accepted that family wealth is strongly correlated with success academically, and it is widely accepted that success academically is strongly correlated with socio-economic mobility.

Thus, the basis for affirmative action is that there is a moral burden to rectify structural impediments that are a legacy of legal racism, and that helping oppressed minorities get an education in spite of their circumstances helps propagate the socio-economic mobility that education enables.

You can disagree with many parts of this chain of logic. Perhaps higher education doesn't really help socio-economic mobility. Perhaps the moral burden should not be on universities to rectify past mistreatments. Perhaps you believe there is no moral burden to take action to rectify the legacy of last generations' (and all previous generations') racism & sexism. Maybe you even believe that the absurd underrepresentation of minorities and women in certain fields that were historically limited to white men is not at all tied to said historical oppression but simply due to preference or other factors considered acceptable.

However, examining underrepresentation is not baseless or unscientific, whether or not you agree with the conclusions.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by mLuby on Monday February 18, 2019 @04:03PM (#19194422)
An impediment by its very nature is unfair, even when it's something clearly genetic, because it impedes one group from doing the same as another group. However, to my knowledge there's no evidence of predispositions to fields of study based on (sex or race) genetics despite lots of effort to find scientific basis for such claims.

I can't imagine a good reason why young gay singoporeans wouldn't dream of being plumbers any more than the next kid.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by helen___keller on Monday February 18, 2019 @04:30PM (#19194641)
Just to clarify, when I write "unfair" I mean specifically that it is something that public policy should potentially address as a public concern.

There are impediments that should not be addressed by public policy - for example , if young gay singoporeans are less likely to become plumbers because gay culture looks poorly upon plumbers, that's unfortunate but shouldn't be a matter of public policy.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by bluthru on Monday February 18, 2019 @06:25PM (#19195421)
>If X% of people are Black, I would expect given no structural impediments that roughly X% of Mathematicians would also be Black.

What makes you assume that? Do you feel the same about the NBA?

[dead]
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by dang on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:42PM (#19194250)
We've banned this account for using HN primarily for ideological battle.

If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email [email protected] and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future.

[dead]
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by moorhosj on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:12PM (#19193952)
It's odd to compare two private industries (NBA and music) to education which is predominantly funded by the public.
[dead]
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by tptacek on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:04PM (#19193886)
The guidelines ask you to write more carefully as topics get divisive, but you're doing the opposite: talking about the "madness" of affirmative action is emotional language that does nothing but polarize the thread. Plenty of HN people respectfully and carefully disagree with affirmative action; if you can't be one of them, step aside and let them do it instead.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by eruci on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:14PM (#19193972)
Agreed! Should have used the word "irrational" instead.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by tptacek on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:25PM (#19194062)
You understand that there are many coherent rational arguments in favor of affirmative action, and that what you're really having is a disagreement over some pretty complicated premises that are unlikely to be disposed of in short, pithy comments, right? I try hard to listen to conservatives despite being a liberal and have learned to dial my hackles down in conversations about race-based affirmative action because, while I disagree with conservatives on that point, I'm not going to get anywhere by claiming that the fairness and practicality of affirmative action is a received truth. You're going to have to do the same thing with your opposition to affirmative action.
[dead]
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by tptacek on Tuesday February 19, 2019 @12:19PM (#19200686)
I sense BS. As is the case here, a mediocre mathematician using the race card to score some political points.

Wow, you sure took that to a great place. Can't imagine why you'd have a hard time having this kind of conversation with people.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by eruci on Tuesday February 19, 2019 @02:11PM (#19201825)
I mean, real professionals focus on their work, not the color of their skin.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by tptacek on Tuesday February 19, 2019 @02:37PM (#19202020)
All you know about this professional is that he was willing to talk to the NYT about how hard it is to be a black mathematician. That made you uncomfortable, and so you've constructed a whole mathematics code of conduct to forbid it that exists only in your head, which you further projected from to slander them about their competence.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by unclebucknasty on Tuesday February 19, 2019 @12:19PM (#19200690)
>I do not think any race is inferior/superior to any other and as such people of all races should be treated equally in all fields of professional achievement

>Conservatives and Liberals should openly talk about these issues for the common good

What's difficult to process here is that you lay out a cogent argument--or at least a coherent rationale--for why you oppose affirmative action. Essentially, you believe no race is superior to others. That's great.

But, of course, people can plainly see that you are excluding the actual reason that affirmative action exists--having nothing to do with the inherent features of any race, and everything to do with historical racial inequities. And, it is very difficult to believe that you are unaware of these inequities (or their bases for affirmative action, for that matter).

Now, you can make the argument that you don't believe affirmative action is the appropriate remedy for past racial injustices. But, that's not the argument you're making. Instead, you ignore this salient factor and instead posit some saccharine, red-herring rationale for eliminating it. And, this must be purposeful. I mean, surely you don't earnestly believe that affirmative action is intended to mitigate inherent racial inferiorities (or do you?).

So, given this, it appears that you are not earnestly interested in "talking about these issues for the common good", to say the least.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by eruci on Tuesday February 19, 2019 @02:22PM (#19201907)
"surely you don't earnestly believe that affirmative action is intended to mitigate inherent racial inferiorities (or do you?)."

Of course, I don't. That's not what I've been saying at all! No matter what it appears to your point of view.

The common good is optimized when the best people, regardless of their skin color, occupy the positions they deserve in all fields of professional activity.

The common good is also optimized by openly and fairly having these discussions, in a way that pushes people to see each other's point of view, hence pushing all sides towards the middle.

It is a way to prevent the election of extremists in high positions of power who then polarize us even further apart.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by unclebucknasty on Tuesday February 19, 2019 @04:22PM (#19202944)
>Of course, I don't. That's not what I've been saying at all!

Right. So, the point is that if you know the purpose of affirmative action is not to mitigate racial inferiorities, yet you make the argument that affirmative action isn't needed because there aren't racial inferiorities, then your argument is obviously disingenuous.

That is, there's something else motivating your distate for affirmative action; something you'd clearly prefer to conceal. But, the rest of your comment offers a clue.

In any case, if you find people unwilling to engage in a discussion with you "for the common good", it's because they see through your transparent attempts at misdirection.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by tptacek on Tuesday February 19, 2019 @02:39PM (#19202038)
The only point of view you're willing to entertain is your own, the one that says that "skin color" has no bearing on how people are treated professionally. When a credentialed professional tells the NYT that that hasn't been their experience, you take offense, and from your offense construct a claim that they must not be professional or even competent.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by eruci on Tuesday February 19, 2019 @02:54PM (#19202174)
Btw, to ascertain the competence for a given individual in a given field it is easy to check. Go to Google Scholar and look at the number of citations.

For Edray Goins it is a relatively low number, that's why I used the word "mediocre."

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by burkaman on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:35PM (#19193581)
> what do we do?

Good question. It's a very hard problem, and requires a lot of thought and self-reflection to even begin to solve. Simple university admission policies will not solve such a broad social issue, as you've noted.

> original meritocratic competitive default mode

Can you explain this? When/where did this meritocratic system exist?

[dead]
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by DanBC on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:03PM (#19193868)
> how the British civil service worked

Literally an old boys network where people had to go to the right schools. The civil service is currently working hard to correct years of racist (and sexist, and ableist) hiring practices.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/black-and-asi...

"The study, commissioned by the Cabinet Secretary Jeremy Heywood and the Cabinet Office minister Francis Maude, found that ethnic minority staff got lower marks in performance reviews, do not always have equal access to promotion, and don’t feel they work for an organisation that is “open, fair and inclusive”. Even black and Asian officials who make it to the senior ranks felt it was largely because “their face did fit” the mould in other ways – like attending Oxbridge or having middle-class parents."

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by tptacek on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:28PM (#19194096)
Just want to add that historical British society has a pretty amazing, filigreed culture of bigotry that has clearly been perfected through centuries of refinement. I didn't know this until I had a product management job where I had to work directly with a decent-sized direct sales team, and we had an upper-class and a lower-class person on that account team. The British take things beyond skin color, or even the old 1900s notion of whether the Italians are "truly" white --- they've got their hierarchy of parentage calibrated down to the county.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by tptacek on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:48PM (#19193726)
The historical British civil service is your prime example of a superior meritocracy?
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by coldtea on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:54PM (#19193781)
>Meritocracy was the default for institutions so long as someone could enter the competition. The aberrations were for nepotism/ cronyism but those appear to be relatively limited.

Limited? Weren't universities merely the place were nobility and rich heirs went to study to get back and lead their inherited empires?

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by _bxg1 on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:47PM (#19193713)
There's something to be said for representation. If you're a bright high-schooler with some interest in mathematics, but don't have a single mathematician to point to who shares your cultural background, it's much harder to visualize and manifest your goal. There's at least a partial self-sustaining mechanism to this sort of thing, which I think is the best argument for affirmative action.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by iguy on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:00PM (#19193839)
But "shares your cultural background" is in large measure something we choose. Not necessarily as individuals, but as a society, in what we emphasise.

Why can't "American" be the right cultural background, or better yet for math nerd kids, "mathematicians who are also musicians" (common), or "mathematicians who like drawing pictures" / "hate drawing pictures" (most depts have both)?

Instead we choose always to emphasise fault lines, and they are proliferating. How many years until it's important to hire enough openly gay (or muslim, or trans, or atheist!) mathematicians, for exactly the same reasoning? The kids likely to become mathematicians may be the people on the planet least interested in these divisions, but they are really really interested in symbols on paper.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by _bxg1 on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:10PM (#19193937)
> Why can't "American" be the right cultural background, or better yet for math nerd kids, "mathematicians who are also musicians" (common), or "mathematicians who like drawing pictures" / "hate drawing pictures" (most depts have both)?

Because America consists of multiple strongly-cohesive subcultures that aren't as simple as "American", but go much deeper than hobbies. Of course there are no hard lines, but if we're being reasonable, we can see this to be generally true. It's human nature to compare yourself to those who are strongly similar to you, especially when those similarities take the form of life challenges having been faced.

> Instead we choose always to emphasise fault lines, and they are proliferating. How many years until it's important to hire enough openly gay (or muslim, or trans, or atheist!) mathematicians, for exactly the same reasoning?

Presumably this kind of "emphasis" will settle once things have balanced out - i.e., once diversity in a given field roughly matches diversity in the general population. In the meantime we skew our meritocracy a bit, but it should be a temporary situation.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by iguy on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:24PM (#19194054)
These aren't hobbies. Number theorists and topologists have minds that work in profoundly different ways. Talented 12-year-olds will like some kinds of problems much more than others. I think a great outreach goal would be to get them rooting for one team or the other -- to give them an identity within mathematics, in other words.

I'm not suggesting we can eliminate all other subcultures at the stoke of a pen. But do think they can grow or die in strength as a result of our actions.

I have more sympathy for the seeing-someone-like-yourself argument when talking about aspiring pop stars (or politicians) who need to imagine themselves being on TV. But I'm dubious for mathematicians, most of whom apply to grad school because they still like solving problems, not because they imagine themselves in a job.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by _bxg1 on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:38PM (#19194204)
> But do think they can grow or die in strength as a result of our actions.

Are you suggesting it's desirable for them to die off? America is built on its diversity of subcultures. Just because there's some tension between them right now doesn't mean they're bad. These are growing pains.

> I have more sympathy for the seeing-someone-like-yourself argument when talking about aspiring pop stars (or politicians) who need to imagine themselves being on TV. But I'm dubious for mathematicians, most of whom apply to grad school because they still like solving problems, not because they imagine themselves in a job.

Based on what I've heard from friends in academia, it has more in common with being an aspiring pop star than many would like to think

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by iguy on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:55PM (#19194357)
Die down, not die off. The melting pot is a great idea, but Balkanization is a terrible one. I worry that the drift is toward the latter.

And, I'd support policies to actively discourage aspiring pop stars, of all flavors! But I do mean particularly mathematics here, who are several sigma off the middle of academia.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by dayvid on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:46PM (#19193701)
I've travelled a bit and I think most people have the same potential to be good at different fields across races. The main difference is how much value is placed on a skillset in a society.

There's more of an emphasis in Math (and Science?) in Asia. When I was in India, I was a part of a group scavenger hunt and all the girls decided they would work together to solve calculus problems. That blew my mind. In USA, people are able to brush aside math by saying it's hard or math isn't for girls, etc.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by joppy on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:10PM (#19193930)
I think “meritocratic competitive default mode” is not looking deep enough. Putting aside any instances of, for example, rich idiots getting admitted to universities just because they’re rich, there is still a massive problem with admitting people to universities based “on merit”. People growing up in lower socioeconomic backgrounds are going to have had a lower quality of education prior to applying for entrance to university, and most processes I’ve read about don’t really take this into account. As a result, comparing everyone equally across the same (for example) entrance exam means that you end up selecting for people from higher socio-economic backgrounds.

I don’t know a good solution to this, but I think it’s something that needs to not be forgotten when discussing “meritocracies”.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by Zenst on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:41PM (#19193646)
"So, the real question is, where/when at some point does this madness stop?"

Maybe when all race and gender fall under a single label such as human, in all forms of life. But then, that's meritocracy as we know it.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by avip on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:56PM (#19193797)
Factually speaking there are, for example, women secured positions in Universities. So "...Have different standards for awarding doctorates based on race"? Maybe not for Ph.d, but for tenure the answer is factual yes.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by gefh on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:37PM (#19193605)
After we've corrected the historical discrimination? i.e. not yet.
Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by pstuart on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:38PM (#19193606)
> Have different standards for awarding doctorates based on race?

Things need to be fixed systematically, including education from the pre-school level on. Every kid is a potential scientist, it's the ones we nurture that make it there.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by devnonymous on Monday February 18, 2019 @03:07PM (#19193909)
> Have different standards for awarding doctorates based on race?

The point of the article, if you think about it, is this is exactly what is happening currently and needs to be stopped / reversed.

Re:What It's Like to Be a Black Mathematician by Retra on Monday February 18, 2019 @02:37PM (#19193603)
What crisis are you referring to? Why do you call it a crisis, rather than simply an ongoing problem?