News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Time Travel (2006) by tbabb on Friday February 15, 2019 @02:11PM (#19173773)
It is already implied by relativity that time doesn't flow. You cannot choose a definition of "now" that some other observer who is moving relatively to you would agree with. Under relativity, observers will disagree about which events are happening simultaneously. So if there are two observers in the universe, the notion of a "global now" is incompatible with relativity.

If some particular observer's definition of "now" could be determined to be the "right" one by some experiment, that would reject the equivalence principle, which is the foundation of relativity. In other words, not likely to happen.

Using this principle one can build a conceptual "chain of simultaneity" between observers that extends arbitrarily far into the future or past.

It is no surprise, then, that physics doesn't have a concept of "now". In all physical equations, time is a free parameter, which we can set to any value, and those equations will tell us what we should expect to observe at that time. Physical equations do not reify any particular "t".

The fact that time seems to "flow" subjectively for us is an artifact of the fact that information can't (that we know of) flow from the future to the past, therefore at any given slice of time for a given observer, the past appears "set" (the observer has information/measurements about it that confine its possible states), but the future appears undetermined (there are no available direct measurements of it).

Why information can't flow from the future to the past is an extremely interesting question that is not terribly well answered, especially given that the laws of the universe are time-symmetrical. I think most physicists would posit that it has something to do with the perplexingly low entropy of the big bang, statistically mandating that later states must have higher entropy, thus birthing the second law of thermodynamics and giving rise to the "arrow of time".

Why specifically the Second Law would prevent the flow of even a single bit of information travelling into the past is not clear to me. As the article points out, Deutsch 1991 showed us that grandfather paradoxes don't exist once you factor in quantum mechanics. This is a question that has captivated me for many years.

Re:Time Travel (2006) by darepublic on Friday February 15, 2019 @02:49PM (#19174107)
I thought that time was essentially an illusion? Isn't time just things changing from one state into the next. So time travel isn't really logical, it would entail changing the entire state of the universe at once from its current state to one it had in the past
Re:Time Travel (2006) by lisper on Friday February 15, 2019 @04:43PM (#19174999)
> Why information can't flow from the future to the past is an extremely interesting question that is not terribly well answered.

I took a whack at it a while back:

http://blog.rongarret.info/2014/10/parallel-universes-and-ar...

Re:Time Travel (2006) by tbabb on Friday February 15, 2019 @09:36PM (#19176656)
Great article, thanks for sharing! I actually found your Google talk some years ago and found it fascinating.

I agree with basically all of your article. It certainly explains the dichotomy of physical laws allowing a spacetime to be "played backwards", while our experience must always be that of it being "played forwards"-- the time reversal of learning something is forgetting it, and this would invert the topological sort of knowledge dependency that places slices of our experience in the "future" or the "past". As such an observer in an isolated part of the universe which was being "played backwards" would label our future as their past.

If we buy into the Second Law, it makes sense to me that there would be some direction where there are more messy entanglements between all the parts of the universe, and in the other direction there would be fewer, and we would name the first direction "the future" and the second direction "the past", since there would be information embedded in all those mutual entanglements that would over-constrain states in the past and under-constrain states in the future.

What I don't get is what prevents me from setting up a circumstance where a measurement I make in the present is correlated with the result of (say) a coin flip in the future. That is easy to do if the coin flip is in the past, but impossible the other way around. I agree that by your logic if I were getting more information on the whole from the future, then I would almost definition label that "the past". But why not even one bit from the future? I can make a meaningful mark on a particle at time t0 and read it at t1, but not if t0 > t1. How come?

Re:Time Travel (2006) by lisper on Saturday February 16, 2019 @01:18AM (#19177373)
Thanks for the kind words.

> there would be some direction where there are more messy entanglements between all the parts of the universe

Yes, that's exactly right, except for the word "messy". It's not "more messy", it's just "more".

> what prevents me from setting up a circumstance where a measurement I make in the present is correlated with the result of (say) a coin flip in the future

Nothing. If you flip a coin with enough precision you can make it come up reliably on one side or the other. ("But that's cheating!" you say. "I want the flip to be random." Well, you can't have it both ways: if the flip is random, then by definition it's not going to be correlated with anything in the past!)

> why not even one bit from the future

Because then it wouldn't be the future.

Think about this: how would you distinguish "receiving a bit from the future", which is apparently not possible, and "making a reliable prediction about the future", which is possible in many cases?

> I can make a meaningful mark on a particle at time t0 and read it at t1, but not if t0 > t1. How come?

You can't actually "make a mark" on a particle the way you can on a classical object. You can prepare a particle in a particular quantum state, but that's not the same as putting a mark on it.

Re:Time Travel (2006) by tbabb on Saturday February 16, 2019 @02:07AM (#19177496)
> You can't actually "make a mark" on a particle

Yes, of course. That was loose wording for "affect a particle a way that is meaningful", i.e. prepare it. :)

> "But that's cheating!" you say. "I want the flip to be random."

Actually, no, I'd rather the bit be useful!

> If you flip a coin with enough precision you can make it come up reliably on one side or the other.

Sure, if I know enough about the universe at some moment in time, by unitarity, I know its state at all other times. Having enough information to run the laws of physics forward to compute the outcome of the 2020 super bowl coin flip isn't much different, then, than running them backward to get the 2019 flip (and just as impractical). But what is interesting is that I could correlate (say) the spin of an electron with the result of the flip and read it later to tell what the flip was, but not earlier to tell what the flip will be.

(Obviously information about the past coin flip is available in many more places than just in my prepared particle, but I don't need anything more than that one qubit to precisely know the result. That's a big difference from needing to know everything in the coin's past light cone! )

If we peel away the human-imposed notions of time and causality (as you do in your article), and see spacetime as a "block" with microscopic time symmetry, or perhaps even further dismantled into only basis states of Hilbert space, it's still obscure to me why particles-- even individual ones-- seem to "carry" information only from the past and not from the future.

On an intuitive level it seems perfectly natural. On the level of (time-symmetrical) fundamental physics, I can't pin down why it would be.

Re:Time Travel (2006) by lisper on Saturday February 16, 2019 @11:11AM (#19179237)
> That was loose wording for "affect a particle a way that is meaningful", i.e. prepare it. :)

Yes, but these details matter. Preparing a particle in a quantum state is fundamentally different from making an identifying mark on a classical object.

> > If you flip a coin with enough precision you can make it come up reliably on one side or the other.

> Sure, if I know enough about the universe at some moment in time, by unitarity, I know its state at all other times.

That's not what I meant. I'm not talking about trying to measure the state of the coin and the flipping apparatus in order to predict the outcome, I'm talking about building a precision flipping apparatus that allows you to control the outcome.

> I could correlate (say) the spin of an electron with the result of the flip and read it later to tell what the flip was, but not earlier to tell what the flip will be.

Actually, you can do both, and the procedures are essentially identical: to do the former, you look at the coin and manipulate the electron state to match. To do the latter you look at the electron and manipulate the state of the coin to match. Easy-peasy.

Is that not what you wanted? If not, why? (Remember that when I suggested you would want the coin flip to be random, you denied it.)

Re:Time Travel (2006) by kiliancs on Friday February 15, 2019 @03:05PM (#19174224)
I enjoyed this PBS Space Time video explaining this and more with examples: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HUMGc8hEkpc
Re:Time Travel (2006) by chr1 on Friday February 15, 2019 @05:20PM (#19175263)
It is worth to note that systems with preferred system of coordinates and "flowing" time can have Lorentz symmetry (for instance see https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/887/relativistic...) so relativity doesn't tell us about time travel as much as we might hope