Phone app can use a custom TLS CA to make sure the stick was produced by Google and is not a rogue neighbor phishing for your WiFi password..
Yes, it is; Chromecast activation has always used the Chromecast itself as the WiFi host; you have to do that to even set it up to use another network.
> you got a code on the screen you could use to activate the device with google from any browser - much like many many many TV apps use (visit foo.com/activate and enter code NNNN).
TV apps can do that because the TV device is already configured to connect to a network. And both the app and your browser can connect to the same remote server. Chromecast activation can't work that way, since it occurs as a necessary prerequisite to connecting the Chromecast to a network.
This matches my understanding as well.
05's answer about security and rogue devices is a good one. It makes a lot of sense. For my (and I expect most people's) threat model, google's prying eyes are a more credible concern than my neighbor's, and I wish they hadn't changed it, but it's nonetheless a defensible reason for making the change.
Phishing by a random bad actor taking advantage of lack of TLS verification is far more likely than Google putting a sandbox escape in a phone app they distribute to steal information from you. I really hope most people's threat model doesn't match yours in this respect.
But then again, I de-Googled myself ages ago, so mostly not a problem.
Now, they require that it be managed with the google Home app, and have discontinued the method that allowed chromecast use without installing additional google software on your phone.
This made for a really disheartening christmas experience, when I first assured my mother that no, we could skip this stuff with your phone, only to find out that no, she would indeed have to make that sacrifice.
Especially frustrating is that my same devices, validated with the old method, continue to function just fine.
Does anyone with more knowledge than I have know of a reason for this that isn't data-greedy or consumer-hostile? From my perspective, "Don't be evil" has been dead long enough that the bones are sunbleached.