News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by ForHackernews on Friday February 15, 2019 @07:22AM (#19170261)
There's a big difference between a jerry-rigged bomb strapped to a quadcopter and a purpose-built killbot produced by a nation state. Strong international sanctions against warbots are a good idea, even if it won't prevent every terrorist from making their own low-rent version.
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by Recurecur on Friday February 15, 2019 @07:32AM (#19170314)
"There's a big difference between a jerry-rigged bomb strapped to a quadcopter and a purpose-built killbot produced by a nation state. Strong international sanctions against warbots are a good idea, even if it won't prevent every terrorist from making their own low-rent version."

Killbots built by nation-states (essentially) are already available for purchase. How does an autonomous helicopter drone armed with an AK-47 sound? ;-)

>The Blowfish A2 “autonomously performs complex combat missions, including fixed-point timing detection and fixed-range reconnaissance, and targeted precision strikes.”

>Depending on customer preferences, Chinese military drone manufacturer Ziyan offers to equip Blowfish A2 with either missiles or machine guns.

>Mr Allen wrote: “Though many current generation drones are primarily remotely operated, Chinese officials generally expect drones and military robotics to feature ever more extensive AI and autonomous capabilities in the future.

>“Chinese weapons manufacturers already are selling armed drones with significant amounts of combat autonomy.”

>China is also interested in using AI for military command decision-making.

https://www.technocracy.news/china-releases-fully-autonomous...

China and Russia will ignore any treaties on this, just as Russia has already ignored many including the INF Treaty. As in many other cases, the West will essentially tie its own hands while allowing others to literally get away with murder.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by Recurecur on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:07AM (#19170556)
So I see this was downvoted without any effort to rebut the story...

Anyone care to explain?

It should also be mentioned that the drone I linked to above was being shown at an arms show, and is essentially being offered for sale to all comers. I'm sure there'll be healthy sales to some of the more autocratic/aggressive nations out there...

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by iliketosleep on Friday February 15, 2019 @09:09AM (#19170996)
I totally agree with your point and have raised this issue before (but not here). Most people prefer to bury their heads in the sand rather than confront these uncomfortable and complicated dilemmas.

I believe the scientists in question would not be calling for this kind of ban if their sons and daughters were sent into battle against nations equipped with such weapons - in fact, they would be cooperating to develop this very technology if it meant protecting their loved ones.

It's easy to be an idealist, until you've truly got something to lose. I think a lot of people need to be reminded of this.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by pbhjpbhj on Friday February 15, 2019 @09:14AM (#19171033)
So, I had to reread your middle para because I honestly thought you were heading an entirely different direction.

Do you think it should be legal for citizens to carry RPGs, machine guns, grenades, ..., so they never have to go in to a room in which someone else might have more firepower?

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by michaelt on Friday February 15, 2019 @10:28AM (#19171624)
Pretty sure iliketosleep means "if their sons and daughters were in the military during a war, and were sent into battle" - after all, it'd be unusual to be sent into battle in any other circumstances.

And yes, I think most people agree it should be legal for soldiers to carry machine guns and grenades when in warzones during wars.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by pbhjpbhj on Friday February 15, 2019 @10:54AM (#19171864)
You misunderstood me. I was asking the question I wished the parent to answer.

The point the GP made was seemingly that we shouldn't let potential enemies have better weapons (autonomous drones), denying them for ourselves.

Yes, I assumed they were considering the context of state sanctioned aggression.

I wondered if they only found that reasoning appropriate for states, or in general.

One could ask "should we always seek for the most terrible weapons to be legal in any context in order to ensure no enemy can outmatch us due to restraints of law?".

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by iliketosleep on Friday February 15, 2019 @06:32PM (#19175778)
To address the point that I think you're getting at, the difference between a military and civilian context is that is that the former is a potentially "no rules, everything at stake" situation. There is no international enforcement agency that can force all nations to abide by an agreed set of rules in any meaningful way. Thus, in a practical sense, there's no restriction on the type of weapons the enemy may develop and a nation must be on the cutting edge of military tech at all times "just in case".

In the civilian context, enforcement agencies in most first-world countries are able to restrict weapons and violence reasonably well - most people won't see the need to arm themselves and will prefer to be law abiding. But in countries rife with violence where law enforcement is weak or corrupt, I imagine people would try to arm themselves with what they can regardless legal constraints.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by Konnstann on Friday February 15, 2019 @12:28PM (#19172802)
I think that reasoning is valid for state-sanctioned aggression, or war to be precise. Personally I think that as long as collateral damage is minimal, we should strive to develop the most deadly, most efficient weapons we can, specifically for the purposes of deterring unchecked aggression.

I don't think GP was making an argument that I should carry an AK-47 on me so that any muggers i come across are less likely to out-arm me.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by pbhjpbhj on Friday February 15, 2019 @01:29PM (#19173403)
Thanks. Per your 2nd para, why not, what's different in you legally allowing the availability of the most deadly means in the two contexts?
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by Konnstann on Friday February 15, 2019 @04:09PM (#19174740)
Nation-states cannot, in my mind, be compared to individuals when it comes to propensity for aggression. The vast majority of individuals, in, say the U.S. are not armed, whereas the majority of nation-states have a military. Furthermore, the countries that are in proximity to "aggressive" states either have a strong military e.g. Israel, or have military presence from other countries with strong militaries e.g. South Korea.

Also, the distances between different countries vs the spread of information is also vastly different. It is harder to commit an international act of violence with no witnesses than it is an interpersonal one, and the threat of retaliation keeps violence at bay, for the most part at least.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by chrisseaton on Friday February 15, 2019 @07:52AM (#19170443)
> produced by a nation state

Why do people always say ‘nation state’ in these situations? It’s not a fancy word for ‘major country’ - it means something specific. For example the UK is definitely not a nation state. The US is arguably not a nation state either, due to its cultural and lingual heterogeneity and tribal sovereignty.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by ForHackernews on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:43AM (#19170822)
Fine, substitute "state actor" or whatever pedantic term you prefer.

Jargon nitpicking is my second-least-favourite kind of HN nitpicking, coming in close ahead of "Boy there was an advert on that article!/Why U no adblock?" nitpicking.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by United857 on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:18AM (#19170632)
Especially in American English, the term nation state is often used to disambugiate from a 'state' at the sub national level -- eg one of the 50 US ones.
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by SCHiM on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:20AM (#19170651)
The uk and us are definitely referred to as nation states in cyber Warfare lingo. I think the meaning is close to: group with lots of resources and strategic goal directed in that context.
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by chrisseaton on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:24AM (#19170683)
That's the same mistaken meaning that the original commenter is using.

A nation state is a nation that is also a state. The UK clearly is a union of four nations into one kingdom. I mean - the clue's in the name.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by az123zaz on Friday February 15, 2019 @09:14AM (#19171029)
As many have noted in American English this distinguishes from a state (as in the United States).

Additionally "nation" can refer to the collective people rather than a centralized government in action.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by pbhjpbhj on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:34AM (#19170754)
It's 3 kingdoms, they are "united".
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by chrisseaton on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:37AM (#19170783)
They're nations. Why do you think Wales has a 'national' assembly if it isn't a nation? Why do you think they have their own 'national' bodies for things such as sports? Why do you think they compete separately in competitions like the 'six nations'?
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by pbhjpbhj on Friday February 15, 2019 @10:19AM (#19171545)
Wales is a curious one, I've tried to establish when it became a "nation" best I can do is some time in the last 100 years or so.

Unless you're going to separate out historic county kingdoms (Wessex, Sussex, Kent, Gwent, etc.) then England annexed the counties that compromise the region we now call Wales as lands of the English Crown.

The UK was initially formed by the Union of two kingdoms, England and Scotland at which time all the parts of Great Britain were under the same Monarch.

Your contention doesn't necessarily disagree with this historical fact.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by jstanley on Friday February 15, 2019 @09:18AM (#19171051)
It is 1 kingdom, which is united.

It's "the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland", not the "United Kingdoms of Great Britain, Northern Ireland, and whatever 3rd one you have in mind"

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by pbhjpbhj on Friday February 15, 2019 @11:01AM (#19171931)
Two then Great Britain and Ulster. Though Lord Steel appeared to imply it should be 3 on calling her Queen of Scots when the Scottish Parliament opened.

I was under the seemingly false impression that the Queen was separately Queen of England and Scotland still/again. But it does appear she is Queen "of Great Britain, Ireland and the British Dominions beyond the Seas" making her Queen of 2 kingdoms (Great Britain, Ulster) within the UK?

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by kkarakk on Friday February 15, 2019 @07:59AM (#19170506)
"nation state"

Dictionary result for nation state noun a sovereign state of which most of the citizens or subjects are united also by factors which define a nation, such as language or common descent.

so you can call anything a nation state as long as that thing issues a passport i guess?

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by chrisseaton on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:06AM (#19170548)
> so you can call anything a nation state as long as that thing issues a passport i guess?

What? No - you just gave the argument against that!

> are united also by factors which define a nation, such as language or common descent

This means the UK isn't a nation state - we have four nations in the UK, with different cultures, descents, and in some areas even languages.

It also means that the US is not a nation state - the people there have very distinct descents. Today Americans literally still say they're 'Italian' rather than 'American'. Many Americans don't speak English. The US literally describes tribal lands as 'dependent nations', so it isn't one nation even by their own federal definition.

Examples of nation states are places like Iceland and Portugal. These are the major military players that the original comment was trying to refer to.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by dannypgh on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:17AM (#19170630)
It's possible for a person to be a member of multiple nations. In the eyes of many Americans (USian), American most certainly is a nation.

MAGA-style nationalism is quite popular and powerful at the moment...

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by chrisseaton on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:23AM (#19170674)
Yes establishing your own nation as a state is a goal for many nationalists. And you can see some nationalists pointing at Japan (a nation-state) and saying that they'd prefer their state to be more homogenous like Japan.
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by Symmetry on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:11AM (#19170586)
Korea is one nation divided into two different states. And the Soviet Union was one state comprised of several nations which later split apart.
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by ljcn on Friday February 15, 2019 @07:58AM (#19170498)
It sounds fancier than "state"? Which is what was meant I think.
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by swarnie_ on Friday February 15, 2019 @07:27AM (#19170287)
> There's a big difference between a jerry-rigged bomb strapped to a quadcopter and a purpose-built killbot produced by a nation state

Aren't we already there thought? Don't the US already have semi-autonomous flying kill-driods? The ones that occasional crash Pakistani weddings unannounced.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by epochwolf on Friday February 15, 2019 @07:35AM (#19170333)
If you count ICBMs, we’ve had them at least since the 1960s.

For more targeted strikes with conventional explosives, we started using Tomahawk Cruise Missiles in 1991 during the Gulf War.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by Recurecur on Friday February 15, 2019 @07:59AM (#19170511)
Those aren't autonomous weapons in the sense meant here.

Both of what you mention attack a predetermined target - a target selected by humans.

This technology is about "smart weapons" going out and searching for targets. For instance, the Chinese helicopter drone I mentioned in another post could easily be fitted with an IR sensor, and could probably hit targets out to ~200 meters with the AK.

One challenge is IFF (Identification Friend or Foe), but if you just want the drone(s) to kill all "enemies" within a certain boundary that'd be easy. AK ammo is even cheap, unlike the $500K missiles we often use to blow up individual jihadis...

And of course, at any time a human could potentially take control or at least monitor activity.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by adrianN on Friday February 15, 2019 @07:48AM (#19170422)
Those are lethal but non-autonomous weapons afaik. A human pulls the trigger.
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by dvfjsdhgfv on Friday February 15, 2019 @07:32AM (#19170311)
> Strong international sanctions against warbots are a good idea, even if it won't prevent every terrorist from making their own low-rent version.

Assuming that all nations follow. Otherwise one rogue player can have a huge advantage, and that's the general problem with trying to ban military technologies.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by adrianN on Friday February 15, 2019 @07:49AM (#19170428)
The same is true for chemical or biological weapons. Banning them has worked reasonably well during WW2.
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by scotty79 on Friday February 15, 2019 @07:55AM (#19170474)
However scary they are they are not particularly effective agains enemy combatants. That's the main reason the ban sort of works.
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by tomatotomato37 on Friday February 15, 2019 @09:50AM (#19171305)
That's mostly because nukes are a better value once their manufacturing infrastructure is up. They're essentially a bioweapon with a really big boom included (purchase now and get an EMP pulse for free!)
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by Mirioron on Friday February 15, 2019 @09:47AM (#19171292)
>Strong international sanctions against warbots are a good idea, even if it won't prevent every terrorist from making their own low-rent version.

Why? I read the article, but I'm not buying the "would increase conflict" angle. Some countries are in constant conflict anyway. It's not like the reason they're not fighting more is because they have a lack of men. A lack of equipment is much more likely to be the limiting factor.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by codyb on Friday February 15, 2019 @08:37AM (#19170775)
Certainly, but when it's ten or twenty jerry rigged drone bombs I'm not so sure it make a ton of difference.

Swarm warfare is going to be cheap and interesting.

That's why the US can spend a quarter million on IUD proof humvees, and the insurgence can just put pointed caps on them to pierce the armor.

It's a lot cheaper to fuck shit up than it is to defend against it.