News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by michaelt on Friday February 15, 2019 @10:28AM (#19171624)
Pretty sure iliketosleep means "if their sons and daughters were in the military during a war, and were sent into battle" - after all, it'd be unusual to be sent into battle in any other circumstances.

And yes, I think most people agree it should be legal for soldiers to carry machine guns and grenades when in warzones during wars.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by pbhjpbhj on Friday February 15, 2019 @10:54AM (#19171864)
You misunderstood me. I was asking the question I wished the parent to answer.

The point the GP made was seemingly that we shouldn't let potential enemies have better weapons (autonomous drones), denying them for ourselves.

Yes, I assumed they were considering the context of state sanctioned aggression.

I wondered if they only found that reasoning appropriate for states, or in general.

One could ask "should we always seek for the most terrible weapons to be legal in any context in order to ensure no enemy can outmatch us due to restraints of law?".

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by iliketosleep on Friday February 15, 2019 @06:32PM (#19175778)
To address the point that I think you're getting at, the difference between a military and civilian context is that is that the former is a potentially "no rules, everything at stake" situation. There is no international enforcement agency that can force all nations to abide by an agreed set of rules in any meaningful way. Thus, in a practical sense, there's no restriction on the type of weapons the enemy may develop and a nation must be on the cutting edge of military tech at all times "just in case".

In the civilian context, enforcement agencies in most first-world countries are able to restrict weapons and violence reasonably well - most people won't see the need to arm themselves and will prefer to be law abiding. But in countries rife with violence where law enforcement is weak or corrupt, I imagine people would try to arm themselves with what they can regardless legal constraints.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by Konnstann on Friday February 15, 2019 @12:28PM (#19172802)
I think that reasoning is valid for state-sanctioned aggression, or war to be precise. Personally I think that as long as collateral damage is minimal, we should strive to develop the most deadly, most efficient weapons we can, specifically for the purposes of deterring unchecked aggression.

I don't think GP was making an argument that I should carry an AK-47 on me so that any muggers i come across are less likely to out-arm me.

Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by pbhjpbhj on Friday February 15, 2019 @01:29PM (#19173403)
Thanks. Per your 2nd para, why not, what's different in you legally allowing the availability of the most deadly means in the two contexts?
Re:Scientists call for ban on lethal, autonomous robots by Konnstann on Friday February 15, 2019 @04:09PM (#19174740)
Nation-states cannot, in my mind, be compared to individuals when it comes to propensity for aggression. The vast majority of individuals, in, say the U.S. are not armed, whereas the majority of nation-states have a military. Furthermore, the countries that are in proximity to "aggressive" states either have a strong military e.g. Israel, or have military presence from other countries with strong militaries e.g. South Korea.

Also, the distances between different countries vs the spread of information is also vastly different. It is harder to commit an international act of violence with no witnesses than it is an interpersonal one, and the threat of retaliation keeps violence at bay, for the most part at least.