News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by csmeder on Sunday February 03, 2019 @02:44PM (#19071742)
There are two separate issues:

A. 1,000 ft view: drugs are bad. Both chemical drugs and electronic entertainment that is engineered to be addictive. Light weight drugs in small doses are less bad: 90s vs now.

B. 50,000 ft view: the real problem. When rats are put in normal laboratory settings they choose drugs over food and water if given the choice. Most of our research on addiction is based on this. In a study where the rats were placed in a healthy environment they chose food and water over drugs.

We live and raise our children in the former. Humans evolved to be raised in an environment much closer to what is happening over in Germany with Forests kindergartens https://youtu.be/31eBV6ZTNDQ

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by clubm8 on Sunday February 03, 2019 @02:58PM (#19071827)
Personally I think the issue is, and I struggled for a long time to articulate this... escape.

I have always struggled with a cluster of issues... too much tv, too much internet, for a period in college binge drinking, overeating... the big "aha!" was that I was engaging in these behaviors to escape reality.

We live in a unique time where if you don't like the reality you're in, you can step into another. Society has rightfully developed stigmas against other harmful behaviors. But the issue is a level deeper.

For the first time in history, we can "escape" or "drop out" or whatever you wish to call it without chemicals. It's a powerful urge... after all, if you have a limited time on earth, and the world's information at your fingertips, it becomes extremely tempting to just tune out... everything.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by nitrogen on Sunday February 03, 2019 @03:11PM (#19071895)
Books were an escape vehicle before TV, movies, and games.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by lytedev on Sunday February 03, 2019 @03:18PM (#19071927)
Sure, but doesn't it work pretty differently? With books, you're just given words and your brain has to fill in the gaps and actually do some work. With video games and movies, your brain is directly stimulated; shown what to see and hear.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by leetcrew on Sunday February 03, 2019 @03:31PM (#19071985)
I know this is the common argument, but I'm not entirely convinced. when I was a kid, the graphics were quite primitive by today's standards, but playing the games at that age felt like stepping into a vivid other world. playing as an adult, I just see a bunch of geometry with shitty lighting while I run around clicking on HP sponges.

I wouldn't say that video games are quite as stimulating as reading a good book, but I think we underestimate how much our imagination works to "fill in the gaps" to make games feel real and rewarding.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by dkersten on Sunday February 03, 2019 @04:22PM (#19072300)
And how we used to think whatever the latest in graphics was, was oh so realistic and amazing!

I played MUD’s for a few years when I was younger and in hindsight it was amazing: while the writing wasn’t typically as good as a book, you still filled in the world and characters with your imagination and it was both interactive and social. I still have some vivid memories of it that are as clear as if it had been a modern game or movie, despite that in reality I was reading text.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by JauntyHatAngle on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:50PM (#19073855)
It's interesting, but I think games have taken a significant backstep over the past few years in terms of RPG's in many ways.

The issue for me nowadays is that AAA studios seem to demand certain things. One of which, is fully voiced dialogue.

This sounds good, people talking lines to me is great right? But the problem is, each of those lines costs time and money, and adds rigidity around what can be changed as you need to get voice actors in and pay money, take time to record the lines, sequence the lips, etc. etc.

Having a purely text based experience (see the character, but have the conversation be purely in text) allows for better variability, imagination on your behalf and way more dialogue because they aren't constrained by time and money as much.

I can't remember who said it, but It puts me in mind of the concept that sometimes the most creative things happen when given the least tools to work with - if you give an artist all the tools to work with in the world, they can often find it harder to focus. Give constraints and creativity is given bounds and scope to work with. It's a bit counter-intuitive but I really think it can be true.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by zimpenfish on Monday February 04, 2019 @06:43AM (#19075518)
> fully voiced dialogue

Yeah, I 99% hate this[1]. Doubly if it's from the person I'm supposed to be playing - let me have my own thoughts about what's going on!

[1] There are some games which have excellent voiced dialogue as part of the world building, e.g. Albino Lullaby

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by tpxl on Monday February 04, 2019 @09:52AM (#19076758)
There is a school of though that the character you're playing should not be voiced (or not even respond textually), precisely because the player cannot then imprint their own thoughts on the character, because the voice/actions/emotions/whatever don't match with that of the human player.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by dkersten on Monday February 04, 2019 @07:45AM (#19075849)
I love fully voiced dialogue in some games, if it’s done well it can really help with telling a story, but in more freeform roleplaying games it definitely detracts from the fantasy that’s playing out in my imagination as it means I can’t imprint my own feelings of what characters are feeling. MUDs were definitely the pinnacle of that for me, especially when you played with people who took their fictitious roles seriously and added freeform scenarios that weren’t hard coded into the game, through a shared acknowledgement that what other players invented became a real part of the fiction even though it wasn’t recognised by the software simulation.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by leetcrew on Monday February 04, 2019 @11:57AM (#19077933)
imo, the Witcher 3 is an example of very well done fully voiced dialogue. I almost never wanted to skip through it. I think it fits in this game because you are playing as an already fleshed out character, Geralt. like you said though, sometimes the player character is meant to be more of a blank slate that you fill in yourself. in KOTOR, the player character is essentially a blank slate, as you literally have no memory of who you are and an important part of the story is that you decide who you will be (villain or savior). in this game, the unvoiced player dialogue was the right design choice.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by dkersten on Tuesday February 05, 2019 @08:09PM (#19091774)
I agree. Like you are saying, I find voices dialogue similar to preset player characters. If the game is telling a story about a specific character (and, super importantly, spends a great deal of effort on deep and meaningful character building), then having a voiced or preset player character can really make the experience great. Geralt is such a character, he has a lot of depth and a lot of history and it’s a great experience to get to explore that.

If, on the other hand, the game has little or weak character building around the player character then please let me create my own character (let me choose gender, looks and name) and don’t have the character voiced at all — let me play the character I like to imagine they are instead.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by westmeal on Monday February 04, 2019 @10:36AM (#19077124)
You can make it work, but it's crammed into absolutely everything now just because you CAN.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by bitexploder on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:39PM (#19072705)
Some MUDs back in the day had combat and skill systems as complex as any modern MMOs. They were the precursor to MMORPG.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by taborj on Sunday February 03, 2019 @08:39PM (#19073359)
We're off topic here, but there are still plenty of MUDs around, and they're still as good or better.

Check out https://www.mudconnect.com/index.html

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by dkersten on Sunday February 03, 2019 @07:13PM (#19073050)
Absolutely. They were mechanically quite advanced in some cases and the roleplay heavy ones had some of the most immersive experiences I’ve had in any game.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by agumonkey on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:23PM (#19073745)
Games used to need your mind to fill in gaps too. Crude limited capabilities of pre 16 bit era made it somehow impressionist and symbolic. Today it's all faux-reality. Amazing technically really.. but not so on the other side of the paddle.

Also the pacing. There are games that weren't action based, and required contemplation (shadow of colossus for instance, there were a few others). There were also sim city like games, or flight simulators that required some focus.

Even games like Resident Evil, they did capture your mind like a book a bit. That said a book requires a lot more than a game.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by celticninja on Sunday February 03, 2019 @06:13PM (#19072843)
A book makes you use your own imagination. Video games take the bulk of that work away from you so it's easier initially but imagination can easily outdo the games in the medium to long term (if you persevere)
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by pizza234 on Sunday February 03, 2019 @04:09PM (#19072219)
This reminds me of the very typical discussion about the value of mathematics and the "descendants": physics, chemistry etc. :-)

If the ultimate purpose is to "do some work", movies and videogames definitely do:

- movies require (in theory) around 90 minutes of undivided attention, which is definitely "work" (how many people can watch an entire movie without peeking at the phone?); additionally, they can be intellectually and/or emotionally stimulating - videogames are essentially, in general, structured challenges, which is "work" again: analytical, creative, reactive...

I'd say that quality of an escape, if we want to set this concept, could be better defined by the human experience added by it.

Alcohol doesn't really add any valuable experience (assuming one even remembers it).

Books, in average, may give the most valuable experience because they may be the most selective medium (due to the attention required).

TV, in average, may give the least, for the opposite reason.

Movies are definitely an infinite human capital. There's lots of garbage, of course.

I find hard to make any generalization about video games, as it's a very diverse medium. Farmville and co. "fare" in the ranks of trash TV, however, games like "Papers, Please" make a very significant experience.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by shrimp_emoji on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:10PM (#19072553)
Where do games like Screeps, Dwarf Fortress, RimWorld, Factorio, or Minecraft feature? Leveraging (or demanding) the user's creativity and construction to meaningfully drive gameplay (though how meaningfully varies) is like opening an extra dimension compared to games where you're only meant to respond to stimuli relatively simply, like Papers, Please.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by voidpointercast on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:43PM (#19072719)
Dwarf Fortress is a helluva thing, good reference. I'd argue that's just as demanding as any IRL project and it requires planning, forethought, and myriad other detail and macro oriented skills.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by pizza234 on Wednesday February 06, 2019 @09:08AM (#19095126)
"Papers, Please" has a significant intellectual (/moral) meaning; it's extremely reductive to characterize it as a game "where you're only meant to respond to stimuli relatively simply".
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by jdmichal on Sunday February 03, 2019 @06:30PM (#19072898)
I pretty much my ability to easily navigate arbitrary rule sets to games of all types played as a child. And it's a very nice skill to have. After all, code and APIs are just some arbitrary rules...
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by hrktb on Monday February 04, 2019 @04:03AM (#19074910)
I think it’s more a question of in which direction you do the work.

Reading a book is a bottom up process. A movie/comic is top bottom: from visual/sound info you parse what’s happening, characters motives, what direction everything is going.

People argue the top-> down approach is “lazier”, but hearig from viewers who couldn’t understand the point of even simple movies, I don’t think it’s true, it’s just that people who don’t “get it” are left on their own as there is a forced timeline.

In that sense, video games bring two major mechanics to the table:

- interactivity: you need to understand what’s going on and take action to move forward. Also you can assume your choices.

- retryability: you can redo any part you didn’t get, the mechanic is baked into the game where for a movie it’s a PITA. I see my kid playing RPG and asking again and again NPC for info, because he didn’t get it the first time. It’s a very powerful mechanism.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by FPGAhacker on Sunday February 03, 2019 @04:04PM (#19072187)
This is true, it takes effort to visualize, but it becomes automatic over time. You don't think about everyday language. You just use it. Same with books.

Take the time to develop this skill when you aren't in need of escapism and you can reap the benefit when you are in dire need.

There are other benefits as well. Developing your visualization skill is one that benefits pretty much everything in life. Visualization greatly aids learning and understanding.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by slipperymate on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:21PM (#19072615)
With video games you at least develop hand-held coordination, and in some, tactical skills. As for movies I'm not so sure, but for people who critique or study them it's at least beneficial.

hand-eye

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by nine_k on Sunday February 03, 2019 @11:32PM (#19074017)
Crucially, books are non-interactive, they don't give you feedback.

Books are in the same class as movies and TV. Games are a different class.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by ohaideredevs on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:05PM (#19073677)
I agree with you entirely - books are escapism. But there are levels of escapism - you would agree that a book is better than heroin, right? If so, you agree that there is a hierarchy. Reading teaches a lot of useful skills, such as, you know, reading.

Then there is the fact that both video games and books can teach, but there are diminishing returns. When I first read Snow Crash and Neuromancer, they taught me a lot of things. Now there is virtually nothing I can draw from most sci-fi.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by HNLurker2 on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:21AM (#19074754)
Rationally, fictional evidence is useless.

Imaginatively, fiction and imagination are the only things that stimulate to push the boundaries in science and tech.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by nybble41 on Monday February 04, 2019 @12:34PM (#19078441)
Fiction isn't evidence (except, perhaps, of basic plausibility, which is a pretty low standard). It does, however, contribute to hypothesis generation; the hypotheses thus inspired by fictional sources can then be tested out in the real world.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by agumonkey on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:19PM (#19073729)
Books are so low on addiction and very high on interesting stimuli.

for some reason, solid matter full of glyphs in our hands captivate the mind differently than other medium / formats.

I tried a lot of things, every time I get a book I feel different and most importantly better. Coming from a not avid reader.

#2cents

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by Apocryphon on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:42PM (#19073826)
Do reading books on e-readers, tablets, and phones have the same effect? How about static websites with long-form text?
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by agumonkey on Monday February 04, 2019 @12:29PM (#19078379)
That's what I cryptically meant by 'lots of things'. As an ex-abstractophile-nerd I used to think that information is information, whether it's on paper, lcd or e-ink.... I read GNU manuals in emacs or in terminal so I'm not craving for aesthetics or high res.

Turns out all mediums have subtle contexts that change the experience (at least personally [thus anecdotally]).

LCD: fatigue, luminosity, potential for distraction because you're using a machine, battery, other apps

Tablet: similar to above although maybe less so (bought a kindle 7, sadly the sub-HD resolution was another flaw)

e-ink: never tried, I wish I could but never did so far. I expect it to be a bit better than the rest

A book is dead. It requires nothing beside a bit of light. Maybe the physicality of pages make my brain focus differently, maybe touching, maybe the fact that it's dead and it won't move weirdly, change. The very high resolution helps.

All of this is super fluffy, but I value my opinion (I was surprised by it too) just enough to say it out loud. It doesn't imply you can't enjoy and learn efficiently with a digital machine but I'm sure it won't be the same as reading a book.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by PascLeRasc on Monday February 04, 2019 @10:33AM (#19077094)
I'm not the parent, but I agree with him completely and for me books on a screen and web articles don't have the same effect, even if it's great writing. For me nothing can beat a paperback.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by celticninja on Sunday February 03, 2019 @06:11PM (#19072831)
Yup and I frequently used them as such. Of course these days that seems tame, but there was a time when the printed word probably spelled the downfall of society for some group too.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by magpi3 on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:45PM (#19073837)
As was poetry. All storytelling can be viewed as an escape. But it can also be viewed as a powerful way to reimagine the world.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by toasterlovin on Monday February 04, 2019 @12:25PM (#19078328)
It is the dose, not the substance, that makes the poison.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by AstralStorm on Monday February 04, 2019 @01:34PM (#19079165)
It's actually both. And also whether intake is repeated.

The platitude is completely wrong.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by toasterlovin on Monday February 04, 2019 @02:14PM (#19079626)
Fine. But we're both saying the person I was responding to is wrong. Which was the actual point.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by sixo on Sunday February 03, 2019 @03:48PM (#19072094)
This is my exact feeling. The problem is upstream: the world that needs escaping.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by agumonkey on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:25PM (#19073756)
Society has been slowly but surely working at decoupling everything. Every problem gets a ~solution. You don't need to depend on people directly, it's easier than having to deal with them. You don't have to deal with physics, put VR goggles and enjoy unlimited retries at shooting preys.

I think it's a bit sad.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by matthewwiese on Sunday February 03, 2019 @03:23PM (#19071949)
Very well put, and I agree with your general analysis.

The question is: how exactly is this a "bad thing"?

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by kordlessagain on Sunday February 03, 2019 @03:31PM (#19071993)
Specifically, the philosophical belief of dependent origination indicates practicing one thing here may lead to "things" happening there: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prat%C4%ABtyasamutp%C4%81da

The argument goes that "dropping out" may be linked to a causal effect of which of which we are not yet aware.

For example: https://www.politico.com/magazine/story/2018/02/08/why-young...

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by matthewwiese on Sunday February 03, 2019 @03:59PM (#19072161)
Thank you for the link to the Wikipedia page. Makes for good Sunday reading :)

If am tracking everything right, then an (albeit simple) description of dependent origination is that we can't necessarily predict the unknown-unknowns of our actions. If so, I don't see how dropping out (in the Timothy Leary sense) is any different from other phenomena that cause unforeseen consequences?

Using your example as my example, that Politico piece presupposes that increased sex ala the sexual revolution is itself an altogether "good" thing, and that the effects of Netflix et al is impacting that previously held ideal in a negative manner. At the risk of sounding contemptuous, I quite frankly don't see what the big deal is, and it reads more akin to vacuous hand-wringing.

Do you have another example of what you are trying to describe? Perhaps I missed the forest for the trees in your above link and haven't approached the topic in good faith.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by kordlessagain on Thursday February 07, 2019 @02:19PM (#19107638)
Sorry for the delay.

It's sorta like "equal and opposite reaction". Push and pull. Up and down. Without "up", there is no "down".

When we do new things, we aren't really sure what the effects or the reach of the correlated/opposite/related effects will be. Going "up" and elevator has simple ramifications. You will need to go "down" again. This is a type of "karma", when your decision making process gets involved. I think of karma as more "work you do" than "shit you've brought upon yourself". It can be good or bad.

With something more complicated, many things may occur all at once and not necessarily be obvious in their origins. Polar vortexes, for example, may be caused by the Earth heating up and disrupting the magnetic field which keeps the cold contained. At least that's what Faraday thought.

You are right about pointing to challenges in predicting unknown-unknowns. In science, we typically avoid those discussions. In other philosophical approaches, we identify them with something beyond our conscious awareness.

Buddhism, Jainism and Hinduism have been dealing with these concepts for a long time. It's interesting to see how technology and those thoughts are converging.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by Fosyon on Sunday February 03, 2019 @09:22PM (#19073514)
Did you fix that behaviour? I'm in the same boat currently.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by el_nahual on Sunday February 03, 2019 @07:19PM (#19073069)
A bit of a nitpick here but I think "Light weight drugs in small doses are less bad: 90s vs now." has a [citation needed]. In my (anecdotal, personal) experience, a heavy weight, sporadically used drug is much more effective than a light weight ones, especially for mental issues.

My heuristic for this is the following:

1. All psychic drugs have a main effect + side effect.

2. The benefit comes from changing your baseline mental "loops". This can happen slowly, or quickly, but requires something to be different. [citation needed]

3. Main effects can be, when taken to excess, if not necessarily _fun_, then certainly _different_, or new.

4. The industry is averse to their drugs being fun, because it leads to "abuse". So they only sell drugs where the main effect is small.

5. This means that most psychic drugs provoke a small change to baseline mental state, and (proportionally) large changes to everything else. So you feel a _little_ better, maybe, and very constipated/sleepless/irritated/whatever.

6. The ideal treatment would actually be super powerful drugs, like psilocybin, ketamine, MDMA, or LSD, taken very sporadically and in controlled (but not clinical) settings. Of course, this will never happen because of point (4).

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by crooked-v on Sunday February 03, 2019 @02:57PM (#19071819)
> When rats are put in normal laboratory settings they choose drugs over food and water if given the choice. Most of our research on addiction is based on this. In a study where the rats were placed in a healthy environment they chose food and water over drugs.

I'm reminded of the mouse "utopia" experiment, and how people somehow find it surprising or insightful that animals left stuck in an overcrowded cage indefinitely with no entertainment and nothing to do gradually go insane.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by AstralStorm on Monday February 04, 2019 @01:37PM (#19079197)
Mostly overcrowded and unstructured, breaking nursing socialization behavior of mice via massive interruption of strangers walking through nests and huge noise.

(See later experiment with "rooms" for mice.) The strain of mice used was relatively aggressive too.

Of course, not quite applicable to humans or even apes.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by kakarot on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:27PM (#19073768)
> When rats are put in normal laboratory settings they choose drugs over food and water if given the choice.

We've shown that cocaine addiction can be mitigated or altogether avoided by enough positive social interaction.

When the benefits that cocaine would provide to the dopamine system are already present from other external sources, the rat is much less likely to self-administrate cocaine to "self-medicate", and this is likely further modulated by if medicating inhibits the rat's ability to continue getting dopamine from other sources.

It's clear that psychosocial health is a huge factor in avoiding addiction.

Another huge factor more relevant to today's era is post-capitalist existentialism, which we can't really test with lab rats but I'll be damned if it doesn't make me want to erode away inside a warm fuzzy ball of artificial pleasure sometimes.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41593-018-0246-6

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by ssivark on Sunday February 03, 2019 @03:41PM (#19072051)
Forest Kindergartens remind me of a movie I quite liked, which others might find interesting: Captain Fantastic (2016) https://www.imdb.com/title/tt3553976/
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by jungler on Sunday February 03, 2019 @04:57PM (#19072490)
The more I think about the "boredom is good" concept, the more I suspect it's flawed. Bored kids get into trouble, especially as they get older. By 18, a very bored kid left to chance will have found an unhealthy outlet like drinking or property theft.

We have a lot of screens now. But it's what one sees and does with the screen that matters. There is an element of media as pollution in this, but it's contrasted against our notion of "the classics". We always end up with a youth that is a mixture of the misspent and the classics.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by NeedMoreTea on Sunday February 03, 2019 @06:11PM (#19072830)
Bored kids who are always bored and have no outlets to stem that boredom often get into trouble. I think that's pretty well known and correlated. It's a picture that's been seen in countless deprived areas. Some will make their own outlets that might include drink or crime. Others will make their own constructive outlets.

I doubt that degree of chance is what anyone is advocating. Instead a little dead time, or space to be bored every day or two is often the spark for something creative. Make a Lego model, draw a picture, go out on bikes for an hour, kick a football round the back garden, etc etc.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by mmmmpancakes on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:39PM (#19072708)
“By 18, a very bored kid left to chance will have found an unhealthy outlet like drinking or property theft.”

Do you have some statistics to back up this claim, along with a comparison against teens who are not bored?

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by marcell on Sunday February 03, 2019 @05:55PM (#19072771)
You’re trying to analyze raising children scientifically, and I think that’s impossible.

You can never measure bored teens against non-bored teens in any meaningful way. No parent will want to, or be able to participate in a scientific study to tests the effects of boredom on their teens. What would that even look like? Randomize parents in two groups, and have them change their parenting in prescribed ways? No parent would agree to that.

Even if you did that study, and parents didn’t fail to follow the instructions, the results wouldn’t be applicable. Humans are different. What works for one teen may be counterproductive for another. You could get an average impact of 0, but that doesn’t mean there isn’t impact on a per-teen basis.

And of course, you don’t even know what outcome you want to optimize for. Is it grades? Number of friends? Salary at age 35?

Raising kids is (for better or worse) completely unscientific. Discussions are based in anecdotes and personal experience, not statistics.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by mmmmpancakes on Sunday February 03, 2019 @06:14PM (#19072848)
“You’re trying to analyze raising children scientifically, and I think that’s impossible.”

You lost me already. You are flippantly dismissing everyone in developmental psychology and related fields with no justification.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by Nasrudith on Sunday February 03, 2019 @07:04PM (#19073024)
The point is that they are individuals and one size fits all is doomed to failure. Any findings will be coarse and easy to confuse cause and effect. Just because children active in sports and music programs may be healthier and happier doesn't mean forcing the kid into both will improve things - by all means expose the kids to it, encourage them and let them pursue it but forcing a square peg into a round hole is good for no one.

There were worries that powerlines were harming children because children with homes near power lines had worse performance in schools. Analysis found that the mechanism for the "harm" was lowered property values - parents who lived near powerlines considered unsightly had fewer resources and it reflected in their children's academic performance.

A pure statistical approach on an individual level is like trying to have a full term baby in one month. Trying to actually raise children involves small N numbers with divergent starting states and control is impossible. You won't raise your second child in the same environment as the first - the year is different, you are different and there is the addition of an older sibling.

You can figure out great harms and benefits but anything else is shrouded in enough noise that attempting it at that level is practically superstition.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by mmmmpancakes on Sunday February 03, 2019 @07:21PM (#19073082)
I am not advocating for a pure statistical approach.

The parent of my first comment was making broad claims about the effects of boredom without justification. I dont think the assertion has any value without some good evidence. I was therefore providing the parent comment an opportunity to Contribute something more substantive than armchair speculation.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by marcell on Monday February 04, 2019 @12:12AM (#19074133)
I don't think I was being flippant. That's the thesis of my comment, and the rest of it is supporting points.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by Nasrudith on Sunday February 03, 2019 @06:45PM (#19072952)
It also isn't new at all - the puritans had similar ideas that took them from ruling England after ousting the king to what may be snarkily summarized "We prefer nobility over these self-rightious fundamentalists wankers."

It is a toxic "your misery is good for you because it flatters my ego" attitude mixed in with nostalgia for a past that never was.

Being able to deal with boredom productively is useful but that doesn't make boredom a virtue or a good way to promote it any more than being able to stay sane in maximum security with only a library makes isolation a virtue and solitary confinement a good way to promote sanity and literacy.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by hopler on Sunday February 03, 2019 @06:44PM (#19072950)
The rat park study found that a good environment did make opioids less attractive, but also found (and downplayed, dishonest science) that rats in the good environment still did prefer opiods to water when the opioids didn't have a bitter taste.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rat_Park

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by sizzle on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:18PM (#19073725)
Mindfulness and mediation are great for disengaging from vices and building resilience to addictive triggers and compulsive thinking.

I wish someone taught me mediation to rebalance my thoughts as early as high school so I could be more introspective and have more control over my insecurities/tendency to think compulsively.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by nicoburns on Sunday February 03, 2019 @10:23PM (#19073748)
IMO, meditation should be taught even to really young kids (say, 4 years old upwards). I imagine they would benefit just as much.

Interestingly, some alternative education systems seem to have such an approach. In the waldorf/steiner system (at least this is what I was told), the early years are supposed to be about learning personal discipline and how to work with others. With reading/writing not taught until later (age 7). The idea being that the kids will learn much quicker if they can concentrate and focus on their work. Makes a lot of sense to me.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by HNLurker2 on Monday February 04, 2019 @03:25AM (#19074763)
IMO, we should all become monks (if you live in Theravada country its tradiion) at age 20 and then give up. Why? You have great experience, and no one obligees you to stay. You can stay for a few months (Like countries Vietnam, Cambodia etc)
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by brightball on Sunday February 03, 2019 @03:00PM (#19071841)
Some friends of mine and their girls moved to Germany for 2 years and talk non-stop about these schools. They say it’s the thing they miss the most.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by sarcasmOrTears on Sunday February 03, 2019 @07:49PM (#19073180)
That forest kindergarden looks awesome. Too bad it's a liability hell in basically all western countries. Freedom-oriented laws would solve a lot of problems.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by prawn on Sunday February 03, 2019 @08:11PM (#19073245)
I'm in Australia. My 6yo son attends the same primary school I did 30+ years ago. They now have a "nature play" area with softball-sized rocks and 6' long baseball-diameter logs that the kids use in breaks to build forts, help climb things, etc. They use the rocks to crush things up or build structures in a dry creek. The hover-parent in me can see a million ways it will end in disaster, but aside from a bloodied fingernail and some scrapes, I haven't heard of anything too bad in the 12ish months he's been there. It's a definite trend here in designing play spaces for children.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by AstralStorm on Monday February 04, 2019 @01:44PM (#19079294)
Yes, you could be liable for harm if you do not supervise the kids well. Other than that, the activities are not especially dangerous.

Realistically, an unattended playground is vastly more dangerous. Or giving scissors to kids. (Including allegedly kid safe models.)

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by dagw on Monday February 04, 2019 @10:38AM (#19077136)
"liability hell" in the sense you mean is pretty much a US concept.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by ThomPete on Sunday February 03, 2019 @07:50PM (#19073186)
Its actually not. Only in the US.
Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by dragonwriter on Monday February 04, 2019 @04:01PM (#19080588)
> When rats are put in normal laboratory settings they choose drugs over food and water if given the choice. Most of our research on addiction is based on this.

No, it's not.

A lot of popular discussion of addiction is, but that's a very different story.

Re:Let Children Get Bored Again by AstralStorm on Monday February 04, 2019 @01:32PM (#19079148)
B: Please bring these studies. If you do misquote the so called "mouse paradise" experiment, please read the original in detail and also further work of the author.