You're making an argument that since the word is consistent, everything is fine and dandy, but the meaning of the word hardly changes the situation here. Not everything is about outrage, there are legit disturbing points this article makes.
They've normalized calling people whales (and dolphins and krakens and...). They've dehumanized their clients; made it easier to not feel concerned that people are dropping hundreds or thousands of dollars on intentionally addictive video games.
The fact that the word "children" part of the discussion is a side-note. They're high-dollar spenders (whales).
I don't understand the outrage about the term "whale" here.
I do understand outrage about the targeting of underage gamers though.
And that makes it OK to refer to people (often those with addiction problems) spending money they don't have on videogames as whales? To target them explicitly with psychological tactics to get them to spend even more money?
I disagree. It's dehumanization. It's morally wrong. Am I in a bubble for thinking such actions are wrong, or are others justifying their own immoral behavior in thinking "well, it's their fault for playing the games and spending the money"?
Facebook, by nature, is a dehumanizing company. They have over 1 billion user accounts...
As someone who works for a software company, I have never considered it my responsibility to check whether a user is "spending money they don't have" on my product. How is that tenable?
I've also never targeted underage users - before you throw me under that bus for no reason, as well..
While whale does not carry a very offensive undertone when you're characterizing a group falling victim to some scheme, it is certainly insulting and dehumanizing when they are your targets, especially when calling individuals as such.
My reasoning is fine. I don't like Facebook, and I don't recommend it, because it is dehumanizing, by nature.
Assume less. It makes for better conversation..
Or in other words, calling a child a "whale" implies they think it is perfectly fine that children are high stakes gamblers, because this is the value judgement that comes with the term "whale".
If they are knowingly _targeting_ underage users, I do not condone that at all, and it should be addressed. Stop with the "outrage" about the term "whale". It doesn't add to the conversation
All of us are rational actors who should dicuss EULAs with their lawyers and fully understand and evaluate the consequences of tracking and surveillance.
You live in a weird and not particularly healthy bubble. In every industry I've ever worked in that has lots of clients but derives most revenue from the big fish, "whale" is the common and standard term. It's not demeaning and the whales are generally proud of their status.
If you need some pop culture orientation, watch just about any TV show set in Las Vegas.
All video games are addicting. To a kid's perspective, they're just playing a regular game.
You've stretched the word "addicting" pretty far when you use it to put an equality between both "Spec Ops: the line" and "Candy crush saga".
OR
It might have been a quick reaction to the exorbitant expenditure and it was the first word that occurred to the employee because it's a common term and they've dealt with 50 other cases that day.
[HN user proceeds to post his outrage at outrage culture]
That’s awesome, reminds me of the movie PCU, where the students protest protesting.
> Facebook wouldn't refund large purchases made by underage gamers. (Regardless of if they are 1 years old)
Need more be said?
My interpretation of all these stories coming out on the news this past year is the creation of a narrative (you could also say exposing) of the reality of Facebook's corporate culture. One that lacks empathy towards its users and society overall, and instead is focused solely on the ends of user engagement, data collection, and revenue generation plowed with a blind following of the word of "Zuck". This all regardless of the means to get there.
Given the prominence of FB's products in so many people's lives, I don't think the outrage is misplaced.
Legally the parents consented to the charges, but it’s clear from the leaked documents Facebook knew parents thought it was a one time charge not something their kid could spend without limits.
But the complaint here is that the headline implies that it means something that they used the term whale. It doesn't.
Whales are just a segment of customer. And incidentally, there are real, legit whales. There are a lot of rich people in the world who willingly throw money at luxury items like exotic cars, expensive vacations, lavish parties, etc. And some of those people like to play video games too and are totally content spending $500 or $5,000 on coins and junk for a game.
Basically there are two ways to interpret this story. One of them has Facebook salivating while asking themselves, "Is this kid a whale?" The other interpretation has Facebook asking themselves with some degree of concern, "Is this whale a kid?"
Sure thing. COPPA.
https://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/rules/rulemaking-regulatory-...
If they knew these patrons were as young as five and didn't have informed consent from their parents, they're in deep.
Have at it, askafriend.
Kids under 2 aren't supposed to be getting any screen time, except possibly to talk with their parents or grandparents on Skype/Hangouts/Facetime. If people are outraged about 1-year-olds racking up enormous gambling debts, then they're not nearly outraged enough since for every 1 kid who does that there needs to be thousands or tens of thousands using the app in the first place.
https://jakeseliger.com/2018/11/14/is-there-an-actual-facebo...
So sick of seeing this junk on HN every day.
I do think the outrage culture as found in Reddit, etc and most of main stream media are slowly creeping in to HN.
Now my automatic reaction to articles like this, any side that resorts to appeals to emotion in an argument, is trying to be manipulative.
If that were certain, then it's irrational for facebook to refuse the refund.
The entire piece starts with a faulty, provocative implication that has no basis in reality.
The solution would be for Facebook employees to stop doing this kind of thing on an almost daily basis.
If Facebook the corporation can't or won't control its behaviour because its first loyalty is to maximise shareholder value then it's up to various governments to get together and sort out some kind of regulation.
Businesses will always try to profit maximize. Not stating what Facebook is doing is right or wrong because that's subjective depending from which perspective you look at it but the root of the problem is not Facebook itself; it's people using Facebook.
Getting mad at Facebook for allowing kids to perform in-app purchases is like getting mad at McDonalds for allowing kids to purchase junk food. Unless you of course think that McDonalds is "exploiting children" as well when parents take them in the restaurant, then we don't have much to debate here.
Yeah, you hit that libertarian sauce way too hard. Stop worshiping money and relearn how to respect humans.
Feel free to keep blaming corporations for bad parenting and lack of responsibility for their own children.
Would recommend that you start worshipping money yourself so you can buy yourself a better education. Maybe then you'll stop telling people how to live their lives in a way that tailors to ignorance.
Cheers.
Anyone who's worked in gaming knows that "Whale" is a term to refer to high spenders that are several deviations from the norm.
A 1-year old racked up $10k in bills on a game where people normally spend $30? Whale. Period.
That's not unreasonable at all because the 1-yr old is in-fact a high spender several deviations from the norm.
Does any of this mean the game was explicitly marketed to 1-year olds? No.
Is it possible that the parent racked up the $10k in bills and blamed it on their kid? Entirely.
Have at it HN.