News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by threeseed on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @05:28PM (#19040273)
For me the next couple of years are going to make or break Tesla.

You have pretty much every car manufacturer releasing flagship electric cars in 2019/2020. And most of them are either cheaper than Tesla or offer far more value i.e. premium branding and better interiors. And whilst they have their Supercharger network I suspect that pretty soon we will governments intervening to regulate standards and build out infrastructure.

So they better get ready quickly before the onslaught comes and like you said be profitable if margins drop.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by rconti on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @05:58PM (#19040517)
Electrify America has an order of magnitude more money to spend on charging than Tesla used to build their supercharger network. That said, they seem to be using it to buy charging networks but so far the experience isn't improving. Conventional EV roadtrip charging is years behind Tesla.

I'm not sure "premium branding" for the competition matters vs Tesla, as I don't think the latter has a downmarket reputation. Interior/existing brand relationships I can see helping the conventional players. Range doesn't seem to be there even on the models supposedly coming out this year. It seems like we keep hearing the Tesla killer is coming Real Soon Like Now.

Still, I ultimately agree they need to sustain through the onslaught, it just seems like it's taking longer than expected.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by Reedx on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @06:34PM (#19040785)
> For me the next couple of years are going to make or break Tesla.

Maybe, but haven't people been saying that about Tesla for 15 years now?

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by taneq on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:06PM (#19041005)
That's what happens when you aggressively scale a business. They could have throttled back and been a profitable niche manufacturer with the Roadster, and again (albeit a bigger niche) with the Model S, and again now with the Model 3. But that's not their goal, so they're continuing to expand as fast as possible, and that carries risks.
Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by threeseed on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @10:29PM (#19042058)
Sure. But they never really had serious competition until now.

Companies like Mercedes, Audi, Jaguar own the mainstream, premium car market and they've only just joined the game.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by btilly on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @06:31PM (#19040744)
As I most recently pointed out in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18712442, there is good reason to believe that all the other car manufacturers are going to learn the hard way that their interests do not align with their dealers. Which means that consumers will learn that they shouldn't go to existing car companies to buy electric cars. Which does not bode well for the future of existing car companies.

(This is a prediction that I've been aware of for around 20 years now. And the form of the problem - that existing tech manufacturer's wind up hamstrung by their existing supply and sales networks, is a common one for companies that get destroyed by disruptive innovation.)

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by reitzensteinm on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:05PM (#19040999)
This is a bizarre argument to me, and I remember thinking that the last time you "pointed it out".

You're essentially saying that tens of thousands of dealers and hundreds of billions of dollars worth of car companies are going to go out of business because they can't find a mutually beneficial incentive structure.

It's not going to be all roses, but Tesla shunning dealers hasn't exactly been either, from a service quality and cost structure perspective.

Porsche doesn't seem to have any trouble shifting Taycans, doubling their production from an initial 20k to 40k units a year (simultaneous to Tesla cutting their X/S production from 100k to maybe 80k).

Here's my prediction: legacy auto manufacturers will continue to be years behind Tesla, but if and when the space matures that'll stop mattering. At that point, Tesla better stop acting like a startup and have their shit figured out, lest they become the Myspace of EVs.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by btilly on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:34PM (#19041157)
You're essentially saying that tens of thousands of dealers and hundreds of billions of dollars worth of car companies are going to go out of business because they can't find a mutually beneficial incentive structure.

It would be far from the first time. One of the biggest problems is for a company whose internal incentives and business model are based around one set of market assumptions to rethink it all and do something else instead.

Both The Innovator's Dilemma and The Innovator's Solution touch on this. The latter one in particular walks through how internal structures and incentives have caused company after company to fail to figure out how to sell products that they know consumers are buying.

The two most common problems being that it is very hard to cut your own margins to match a low margin competitor, and it is even harder to convince a third party sales distributor to cut their margins.

Anyways this is something that I've been aware of for close to 20 years. In another 10 years you'll be able to decide whether I was wrong.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by reitzensteinm on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:08PM (#19041321)
Yeah, I've read them too. But you're not saying that it's a challenge the industry will face, you're saying the death is a fait accompli, and the entire traditional auto industry is not real competition to Tesla (your words from your linked post).

I don't need to wait ten years to decide that you're wrong; even if your prediction turns out to be correct (which it might), assigning a 100% probability to this outcome is absurd, and if you could reliably do this you'd be a trillionaire.

Since we're reading the tea leaves via business school curriculum, what about a little Prisoner's Dilemma?

Let's assume that consumer demand exists for EVs (which Tesla has basically created single handedly), and EVs aren't profitable when slotted in to the cost structure of a traditional dealership due to the lack of maintenance. Dealers try every trick in the book to steer customers away from EVs.

Why wouldn't a percentage of dealerships defect, rebrand and focus exclusively on EVs? They'll enjoy abnormally high sales, and be profitable on the margins from new car sales alone. Dealerships that insist on only selling ICE vehicles will stick around for a while, but nobody will start one, and the number will be reduced by attrition. The total number of dealerships fall and the EV transition is completed over a few decades.

So to be clear: you assign a zero percent probability to this happening?

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by btilly on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:52PM (#19041558)
The probability is not 100%, but I believe it to be very high.

As for your hypothetical, the reason is that the dealers that try to do that won't make a sufficient profit to their business model unless they sell EVs at a very significant premium to published list price. And it will be very hard to sell consumers on letting them do that.

Even if you could get consumers to accept those prices, the industry would then face the problem that the margins on EVs from traditional car manufacturers have much higher margins than the EVs from startups like Tesla. Which will make them uncompetitive in the marketplace. This gets us back to the classic problem that it is hard to get organizations to significantly cut their margins. And even harder to convince your business partners to do so for your benefit.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by reitzensteinm on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @09:27PM (#19041764)
You are assuming that Tesla and future competition can operate their own dealerships more efficiently.

They don't get their physical presence for free, and the cost is baked in to the sales price just the same way.

Maybe Tesla can pull that off but there's no reason to expect other EV manufacturers will until they hit massive scale.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by kjksf on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @10:23PM (#19042033)
Let's say there are 2 grocery shops. All their costs and expenses are the same but one grocery shop sells twice as many products per square foot / unit of time.

As someone interested in more profit, which store would you rather own?

The argument you're responding to wasn't "Tesla's stores are dramatically more efficient".

The argument is that Tesla stores sell Tesla's EV cars effectively (because that's the only thing they sell) and traditional dealership anti-sell EV cars because they make more money on selling ICE cars.

This is not a conjecture. In addition to plenty of anecdotal evidence, there were qualitative studies both in US and Europe where researches sent "mystery shoppers" pretending to be interested in buying EV cars.

The results were dismal. Many dealerships didn't know much about EVs themselves and in the worst case, they would literally lie about how bad EVs are.

That will be a problem for GM, Ford, and others when they finally have good EV cars to sell.

And there's no obvious solution to that. Car makers and dealerships are frenemies so it's not like GM can dictate terms to their dealers or that they can force dealers to do a good job selling EVs.

The obvious solution (heavily subsidize dealers with bigger discounts) is bad for profit margins. Investors like profit margins and it'll look doubly bad because when they finally have EV cars to sell, they'll go through the same "loss due to low volume / production ramp" that Tesla went through in first half of 2018 and will be competing with Tesla's 2021 heavily cost optimized production.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by reitzensteinm on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @10:39PM (#19042108)
In fact parent was making claims about the extra markup required for a traditional dealership to make a profit on EVs. This expense doesn't magically disappear on a Tesla, unless their dealerships are more efficient.

Feel free to argue with my prisoner's dilemma point earlier in the thread if you want, which is in my view how this will play out. I've already agreed that what you're describing is an issue (and am at a loss why you took the time to write it out), I'm merely asserting that it's not going to spell the end of a quarter trillion dollars worth of wealth.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by btilly on Thursday January 31, 2019 @12:01PM (#19046293)
This expense doesn't magically disappear on a Tesla, unless their dealerships are more efficient.

Walk into a regular dealership and then Tesla's version and you tell me which is more efficient.

For just one example of the differences, consider the typical haggling over price where multiple sales people and managers interact with you for an extended period of time to try to get you to spend top dollar. Compare with the Tesla version where you're pointed at a computer open to their website where you can order and configure the car that you want.

I've already agreed that what you're describing is an issue (and am at a loss why you took the time to write it out), I'm merely asserting that it's not going to spell the end of a quarter trillion dollars worth of wealth.

On what principles will it not do so? Merely because it seems absurd? Or is there some logic that applies?

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by marvin on Thursday January 31, 2019 @12:55PM (#19046934)
I've greatly enjoyed this thread, thanks to you and parents for taking the time to write it out. Just wanted to add, putting the "250 billion dollars of wealth destroyed" into perspective, that is more or less what Apple's loss of market cap during the last 6 months represents.

Granted, that's to a large degree a speculative reduction in wealth. A similar re-valuation of the global car industry's future prospects would cause more mayhem due to well-established investments in supporting industries. It's fascinating how 250 billion dollars in reduced marked cap means "meh, it was overvalued" in Apple's case, whereas it would be a nasty surprise of historic proportions if it happened to the car industry.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by wpdev_63 on Friday February 01, 2019 @08:50PM (#19060479)
The tentative release for many of these new electric cars are in 2019/2010. There's probably going to be a good chance that they are delayed with the technical difficulty of manufacturing electric cars at scale.

Also I wouldn't count out Tesla's major advantage in sourcing the best batteries at wholesale prices.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by RobLach on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @06:02PM (#19040553)
I have a feeling Tesla didn’t capitalize enough on their first mover advantage and now it’s going to be tough as proper competitors move into the market.

Audi is matching the Model X with the E-Tron, but without Tesla build quality: https://www.audiusa.com/models/audi-e-tron

Volvo Drive-E, Jaguar I-Pace, new Nissan Leaf; similar stories.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by tomp on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:13PM (#19041043)
> offer far more value i.e. premium branding and better interiors

This can't happen soon enough. Ever since driving a Tesla, I'm completely disappointed by the interior/control panels of most (all?) other cars. Buttons, seriously? A 9-inch screen?!

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by paganel on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:35PM (#19041168)
> Buttons, seriously?

Buttons allow a driver to not take his/her eyes off the road while changing the radio station or adjusting the AC. Totally eliminating dashboard buttons is dumb, but fortunately some car-makers have started realizing this and have started to re-introduce some of those buttons.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by bronco21016 on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:22PM (#19041389)
Additionally, buttons and knobs allow critical systems like HVAC to be operational and affordably serviced when the infotainment system inevitably dies. This was the primary reason I got rid of my 2015 Ford Fusion. The SYNC system in it became a generation behind and even when it was the latest generation it was nearly impossible to get it serviced at the dealer for software updated.
Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by tomp on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:20PM (#19041376)
Yeah, I'm not opposed to a few buttons - like +- temperature, all blinkers, etc. But in most cars, the number of buttons is just overwhelming, so you probably need to take your eyes off the road just to find the button you're looking for!
Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by Ntrails on Thursday January 31, 2019 @11:36AM (#19046045)
I could type on my old Nokias etc without ever looking at the message. It was flawless. If one wanted to do it whilst driving (not that anyone ever would, of course) it could be done without ever looking away from the road. That's the power of actual physical feedback.

I'm sure there's someone somewhere who can prove me wrong and touch-type flawlessly on their touch screen phone. But in most cases you're relying heavily on auto-correct to make a parseable sentence. Which means you'll need to look at the screen a lot.

The radio/Cassette player in my car is all buttons. I can change stations, volume, switch to tape etc without looking much at all. Some buttons I might no remember their place - but here's the crucial thing. I don't have to keep looking until I make contact. I glance, see where the button is, and then feel for it.

A touch screen simply doesn't give you that, you either need to see yourself making contact or wait for the software to do something you may (or may not) have wanted. If it's wrong, you're now trying to fix that and try again.

I do not believe that touch screens reduce risk in interacting with car functionality, indeed I'm pretty sure they increase it.

Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by marvin on Thursday January 31, 2019 @12:58PM (#19046977)
Siri works well enough for me that I can perfectly dictate a text message without taking my eyes off the road. That's just one data point and I know others have diverging experiences, but it seems likely that voice control with improve enough that this could soon be a feasible way of controlling a car's secondary systems too.
Re:Tesla Q4 2018 Earnings Letter by erobbins on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @07:32PM (#19041150)
Seriously? Tesla interiors have a high tech feel, but they are pretty spartan and lack luxury I expect in a $100k car. You can get into a 3 series BMW and it's got a higher quality interior than any Tesla.