News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by jacques_chester on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @06:37PM (#19031030)
I've been on both sides of this sort of divide, as both insider and outsider.

It's easy to see it as politics. I do, pretty much all the time, but that's because I have a background in politics. I'm primed to assume the worst.

I think the explanation is simpler. If you are a Googler, you mostly talk to Googlers, you mostly come to quick consensus that way, and it all makes sense to you and the Googlers you had casual whiteboarding sessions with. So you just go ahead with the to-you-obviously-best decision and get surprised when non-Googlers are mad at being presented with a fait accompli.

There is no ill-will and no conspiracy required. Some of the personnel allocations are driven by corporate strategy, but folks engineering on the line are all reasonable human beings. It's just simple personal dynamics. You talk mostly to the people closest to you unless sustained effort is made to keep stuff in the open.

Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by justicezyx on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @07:06PM (#19031238)
You missed the key part.

This is why it was open sourced, as a balance between control leverage and adoption.

Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by gouggoug on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @08:34PM (#19031762)
> This is why it was open sourced, as a balance between control leverage and adoption.

I feel like I read this kind of statement all the time and I don't understand the reasoning behind it.

Google came up with k8s. They could have kept it for themselves, or, open source it. They open-sourced it. It definitely benefits them, but, it also benefits us a lot.

Saying they "open sourced, as a balance between control leverage and adoption" is so cynical. So I'd like to ask, what's the alternative? Not open-sourcing? Who would that benefit?

What would be the non-ill-intentioned alternative that Google supposedly could have chosen?

Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by mfer on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @09:39PM (#19032150)
Why did Google create Kubernetes and open source it? Why did the people who created Kubernetes all leave Google? What was the business strategy behind it all?

After all, the created omega but it never did replace borg. Kubernetes wasn't meant to replace borg, was it?

Google didn't create and release Kubernetes out of the goodness of their hearts. Have you ever pondered the strategy behind it all? Maybe they couldn't have kept it to themselves because that would have defeated the underlying purpose in the first place?

Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by thockingoog on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @10:02PM (#19032260)
> Why did the people who created Kubernetes all leave Google?

Umm, we didn't?

> created omega but it never did replace borg

It did have material impact on Borg.

Sometimes the strategy is simply "we know how to do this, and we'd prefer not to see you go through all the same pain to figure it out".

Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by aberoham on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @10:29PM (#19032381)
Timmy!! When will knative and istio be handed over to a foundation? Does LF/CNCF have enough carrots in Jim Zemlin's bag of tricks??

'tis fascinating to dig in to open source serverless on Kubernetes options only to realize that there's probably 100+ engineers working on istio+knative, ~10x more than any prior alternative.

When is KnativeCon coming?

Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by jacques_chester on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @10:39PM (#19032437)
I don't think he's involved very closely.

Since folks get so worked up about allocations unofficially shaping decisions, I suggest[^] that Knative be homed with the Cloud Foundry Foundation, where the rules are written to give votes based on how many fulltime contributors you assign. That way it's all out in the open.

Disclosure: I work for Pivotal, which is in both the CFF and CNCF. I was aware of Knative relatively early.

[^] in a ha-ha-only-serious way

Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by mfer on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @10:09PM (#19032295)
Tim, I should not have used "all" there.
Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by gouggoug on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @10:21PM (#19032344)
> Why did the people who created Kubernetes all leave Google?

Brendan Burns went to Microsoft to work on Kubernetes on Azure. He'd been working at Google for 8 years already. Microsoft probably paid a lot to acquire him and it wouldn't be surprising if he saw it as an exciting opportunity to keep working on his creation while leading an exciting new project.

Joe Beda and Craig McLuckie left together to found a company whose product _is_ Kubernetes (Heptio).

So I could guess they just realized that their resume opened them to exciting new opportunities.

> Have you ever pondered the strategy behind it all?

Yes, and I can't see what it could be, so I'd love to be enlightened.

So far all I see is that I'm using an amazing software that has considerably simplified my life when dealing with my infrastructure. I so happen to be using GKE (and maybe _that_ was the grand evil plan all along!), but I know that I could use AWS or Azure or even go back to bare metal if I wanted to.

Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by shaklee3 on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @01:24AM (#19033124)
Aaand they sold that company to IBM for a huge amount, so it was likely a smart move.
Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by mohaba on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @04:53AM (#19033853)
VMWare
Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by shaklee3 on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:54AM (#19035002)
Thanks. Got all those acquisitions that happened around the same time mixed up.
Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by pgeorgi on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @08:20AM (#19034771)
> Why did Google create Kubernetes and open source it?

I think it's misleading to conflate questions whether Google's k8s engineers can use shortcuts through the organizational fabric around k8s with the project's source licensing.

k8s being open source merely means that the code is open and for everybody to use under clear and rather generous (even if potentially reciprocal) terms that are OSD compatible.

In particular "open source" doesn't mean that everybody gets to have a say on anything or everything: those with commit rights always reign supreme.

As for the part about procedural rules and their (ab)use like the ability to take shortcuts because everybody outside the cabal happens to be absent for whatever reason: that could have happened just as well in any body under pay-to-play rules that covers "software standards" (or anything, really), eg. OSF, X/OPEN, UEFI Forum, ... You don't don't get to hear about the drama.

Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by shaklee3 on Wednesday January 30, 2019 @01:22AM (#19033116)
To be fair, two of the cofounders went to different companies to focus on k8s. So while they left Google, it clearly wasn't because they wanted to get away from kubernetes. Rather they're got a great opportunity and took it.
Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by wmf on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @08:53PM (#19031878)
In theory I guess Google could have open sourced k8s and then walked away, refusing to contribute anything more. According to "community is everything" thinkers this would have led to even greater/faster adoption than k8s already has (if such a thing is possible). Of course it sounds ridiculous when you state it explicitly which I guess is why they never do.
Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by justicezyx on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @10:30PM (#19032384)
A for profit company doing something with balanced objectives, how is hat ill intentioned?
Re:The Kubernetes Kustomize KEP Kerfuffle by jacques_chester on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @10:35PM (#19032411)
I've argued something similar but not identical, which is that Google wanted to commoditise container platforms to stop AWS from moving further ahead. Scorch the earth, basically. That's what I meant by strategy guiding allocations. Google put their shoulder to the wheel with people, funding and sustained PR.

But that's still different from the day-to-day goings-on being discussed here. The fate of Kustomize is not the stuff grand strategy. My argument is addressed to that level.