News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by platz on Monday January 28, 2019 @08:55AM (#19017404)
So Freedom only got a slap on the wrist, basically
Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by SuperGent on Monday January 28, 2019 @09:21AM (#19017565)
When asked about the Freedom fine, [Patel] responded, "I decided to take it as a cost of doing business."

This is the problem, why should you not take dubiously legal or moral action, if there isn't a significant deterrent?

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by krageon on Monday January 28, 2019 @10:21AM (#19018075)
Because you shouldn't be an asshole. People aren't animals unless they have some sword of Damocles hanging over them keeping them in line, it is a conscious choice to do the wrong thing.
Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by Buttons840 on Monday January 28, 2019 @11:11AM (#19018565)
Sure, many good people follow the law because they're not assholes, but they were out advertised and out grown by one asshole who broke the law and was never punished.

On a micro scale, not wanting to be an asshole will cause people to follow the laws. On a macro scale, the only way to make people follow the law is to make breaking the law costly.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by rebuilder on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @01:42AM (#19024315)
Social pressure doesn't seem to work in societies as big as we now have. There's not much meaningful feedback from victims to wealthy criminals, because these hardly ever even meet. Financial incentives override social responsibility in such a situation, and I don't see how to address wrongdoings except by changing the incentives.
Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by magduf on Monday January 28, 2019 @10:39AM (#19018248)
You can't expect this of people. When you do expect this, as you seem to, you end up setting up a society where sociopaths like that guy are able to rise to the top and profit handsomely because the people who made the rules just can't seem to conceive of someone who doesn't mind being an asshole as long as it gets him ahead.
Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by krageon on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @02:33AM (#19024509)
This is about the US. I don't live there, I do think that and while it is super bad everywhere on earth I think we can agree the US is pulling the cart in terms of terrible. Frankly you I think the argument that "this is just how it'll be" is not one that is terribly convincing on it's own.

Yes, it'll go wrong. It'll also go right. I don't think we need to structure our society like a prison just because it has the capacity to be worse than we like it to be.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by Aeolun on Monday January 28, 2019 @10:36AM (#19018207)
Of course it is, but you’re not in it for anything but the money.
Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by readhn on Monday January 28, 2019 @09:23AM (#19017578)
pretty typical. look at Snowden. The guy ruined his own life and nobody still gives a damn. Was it worth it? i dont think so. He definitely should have kept quiet even if it was against his own personal beliefs. It sucks but it is what it is.

HSBC got slapped on the wrist for laundering cartel money.

"If you’re suspected of drug involvement, America takes your house; HSBC admits to laundering cartel billions, loses five weeks’ income and execs have to partially defer bonuses"

https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/outrageo...

happens all the time with corporations.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by whatshisface on Monday January 28, 2019 @09:57AM (#19017848)
>He definitely should have kept quiet even if it was against his own personal beliefs.

That argument for moral complacency is largely self-fulfilling, because if nobody thinks that one person defecting will change anything, you'll never get more than one defector at once, and nothing will ever change. In that way everyone will march in lockstep to hell and deserve every bit of the torture that's waiting for them.

The foremost thing that Snowden achieved was that he quit doing the bad thing. There is some value in not being an active contributor to the suffering in the world. Sure, if you quit littering that won't clean up the parks, but at least you won't be a litterer anymore. The first thing Snowden did to improve the state of the world was reducing the number of NSA employees by one; and he improved himself by switching from NSA employee to unemployed. Too many people overlook this, thinking that all that matters is whether or not the world is good on average, while ignoring whether or not they themselves are good.

Secondly, Snowden hasn't been forgotten. It might take a few more to follow in his footsteps before the lesson sinks in to the public, but the things he revealed are still out there.

Finally, there actually have been some changes because of his actions (I saved the most concrete point for last). Nobody on HN discounts the reality of malicious state attackers anymore - it used to be that nobody expected to be on the receiving end of a state level attack (and we never secured appropriately), but now it's common knowledge that Public Enemy Number One is actually the public itself. Snowden definitely helped push forward HTTPS rollouts, for example.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by Simon_says on Monday January 28, 2019 @12:43PM (#19019375)
Snowden's escape was a near-run thing. He intended to go to Ecuador and got trapped in Russia. He's only living free now because Putin likes showing the rest of the world that the USA is just as bad as Russia. It very easily could have gone another way with Snowden never seeing the light of day again and getting tortured for the rest of his life.

That's a lot to ask of anyone, and why I think Snowden will go down as among the bravest people in history.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by Aeolun on Monday January 28, 2019 @10:37AM (#19018227)
You can stop littering without being fucked over by it very easily.
Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by whatshisface on Monday January 28, 2019 @10:58AM (#19018439)
If you stop littering you'll have to carry trash around for longer, which is a personal cost. Littering is a miniature analogy, with and smaller table stakes. The hedonistic difference between making a good salary selling out your countrymen and hiding from your government in Russia is pretty big, a lot bigger than carrying a chip bag around, but the moral difference scales in proportion.

A common fallacy is thinking that you only have to be a good person for matters less than $100. I can't explain it or present an argument in its favor but it is a very common sentiment.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by Aeolun on Monday January 28, 2019 @07:12PM (#19022476)
I don’t think that’s a fallacy so much as survival instinct. Doing the ‘right’ thing becomes disproportionally harder when the matter goes over $100.

Good is relative to average, and is a concept that society determines the baseline of.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by whatshisface on Monday January 28, 2019 @09:41PM (#19023259)
The problem with recourse to the survival instinct is that survival actually turns around and becomes bad past a certain point. For example, consider the survival of a brutal regime: they might say "we have to be brutal or else the people would stop us." A lighter analogy would be a vampire that drinks blood to say alive: yes, he has to do it to stay alive, but the thing that's being kept alive is a vampire. More realistically, someone might say, "I am embezzling from my company because if I didn't I would default on my house." Of course, that is a silly objection, because the person they're keeping housed is an embezzler.

So, Snowden's choice was between giving a traitor the easy life and facing hardship and uncertainty as a good person. Granted, he had to suffer a lot, but the alternative to suffering was providing comforts to a criminal that happened to be him.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by arminiusreturns on Monday January 28, 2019 @09:50AM (#19017780)
First off I don't think you can make that determination, (was it worth it), only Snowden himself can. Second, while the toll was high for him, those of us who have sworn an oath to the Constitution take that oath very seriously and I applaud him for being one of the rare ones with enough conviction to act on his beliefs instead of just spouting them. Third I am eternally grateful to Snowden because without him all my rants about the coming surveillance dystopia would still be met with incompetent or malicious accusations of being "crackpot conspiracy theory" and generally ridiculed (like many other things the public still hasn't caught up on).
Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by smush on Monday January 28, 2019 @11:47AM (#19018904)
Any other things the public hasn't caught up on that you care to share?
Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by arminiusreturns on Monday January 28, 2019 @03:47PM (#19020919)
I will try to respond when my work day is over.
Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by Retra on Monday January 28, 2019 @10:06AM (#19017941)
>look at Snowden. The guy ruined his own life and nobody still gives a damn. Was it worth it? i dont think so.

If it wasn't worth it, you wouldn't know his name, and you wouldn't be talking about it today. Does that count for nothing to you?

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by magduf on Monday January 28, 2019 @10:45AM (#19018302)
Whether it's "worth it" is completely subjective, and differs from person to person based on their values.

You seem to value having your name remembered; i.e., you value fame, and you're projecting that onto Snowden. I don't know what Snowden values, but assuming he values fame as you do (or that the person you're responding to does) makes no sense.

If the person you responded to values only financial security and a peaceful life, then he's absolutely right to say he doesn't think Snowden's actions were worth it, because to him, Snowden sacrificed all that and got nothing in return but exile in Russia. (I guess it could be worse... there's worse places to live on the planet, but Russia is a pretty lousy place to live in my book.)

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by Retra on Monday January 28, 2019 @10:49AM (#19018341)
>You seem to value having your name remembered; i.e., you value fame, and you're projecting that onto Snowden.

Total bullshit. Nothing I said implies any of this.

What I value is that we can have a discussion premised on facts. Snowden is a real person who exists, and we can discuss what he did and what the consequences are. The alternative is that we discuss a hypothetical whistleblower and have all our reasoning dismissed as fear-mongering or paranoia. That is what I value.

>Whether it's "worth it" is completely subjective, and differs from person to person based on their values.

To be clear, it is worth it to me to have Snowden be a whistleblower because I had to pay nothing for the privilege. There are not many people who would say it is not worth it for someone else to be a whistleblower unless they think whistleblowing is inherently objectionable.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by daveFNbuck on Monday January 28, 2019 @10:50AM (#19018346)
Would you ruin your life if it guaranteed I'd know your name and mention you 6 years later as an example of someone who ruined their life without achieving anything?
Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by Retra on Monday January 28, 2019 @11:16AM (#19018607)
You're not the only one talking about him, and that very much contradicts 'not achieving anything'. In any case, your individual perspective being contrary to my claim isn't anything meaningful here, because there isn't an impactful person on this planet who hasn't had their accomplishments trivialized by somebody.
Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by daveFNbuck on Monday January 28, 2019 @05:35PM (#19021725)
I'm not trivializing his accomplishments. You're the one who's implying he hasn't accomplished anything beyond being an example people bring up in HN comments.

Would that be worth ruining your life? I'm asking for your perspective.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by Retra on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @02:40PM (#19029207)
WTF are you reading? I said that the fact that Snowden can be used as an example is evidence of him accomplishing something. Explicitely to argue against the position that he hasn't accomplished anything. I am in no way arguing that he didn't accomplish anything more.

>Would that be worth ruining your life? I'm asking for your perspective.

Would what be worth ruining my life for? Obviously one doesn't make such personal sacrifices solely for personal gain, so if I'm going to ruin my life, it will be because I feel that it could very well lead to the betterment of many other lives. There's no 'perspective' there to glean. The fact that you would personally not value my sacrifice doesn't really impact that, because frankly, I don't give a shit what you think. You're just some rando with an opinion.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by daveFNbuck on Tuesday January 29, 2019 @09:04PM (#19031956)
> I said that the fact that Snowden can be used as an example is evidence of him accomplishing something.

How is it evidence of anything more than his fame? It's very counter-intuitive that being brought up as an example of an unaccomplished person is evidence of accomplishment. I don't see how that works.

If you want to argue in favor of Snowden having accomplished something important, point out his accomplishments. Your argument is bad and makes it seem like he has none.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by Retra on Thursday January 31, 2019 @03:00PM (#19048198)
What he accomplished was to spark a dialog. That was basically what he set out to do, and his fame is evidence of it, because it can be used to track that dialog.

Your argument is predicated on a category error.

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by daveFNbuck on Saturday February 02, 2019 @10:07AM (#19063321)
We're currently discussing him in the context of how whistleblowing is ineffective. If that was the conversation he wanted to spark, this is evidence of his success. I believe he wanted to spark a different conversation.

Being famous doesn't really indicate on its own that you've sparked any particular conversation, so I don't see how it's evidence of that.

What argument do you think I'm making and how is it predicated on a category error?

Re:The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing by Retra on Friday February 08, 2019 @03:09PM (#19118174)
He did spark a different conversation. So many of them, in fact, that you know his name as a consequence of people having those very conversations.

>Being famous doesn't really indicate on its own that you've sparked any particular conversation, so I don't see how it's evidence of that.

That's funny. Edward Snowden's name doesn't seem to be brought up in random-ass conversations. He seems to always come up when people are talking about security and surveillance. I wonder if that's a spurious correlation, or if it is evidence of something? Perhaps some kind of impact that he's had on conversations about those very subjects?

Perhaps you have a better explanation of this correlation?