In the US we have institutions for the mentally ill and he would be better off there, but it's becoming increasingly more only for the wealthy to use.
Is this really true? This seems to be a popular assessment but every now and then I see first-hand accounts of people who went to jail/prison and my main takeaway from them is that it's simply boring and nothing really happens, and that the average joe is just going to go in, be bored, and get out.
There are definitely big stories/issues that come out every so often but they seem to be the exception rather than the rule.
I was arrested on a minor misdemeanor and thanks to the magic of corruption, got thrown in jail for 35-days when my plea deal was 0.
I was in jail with convicted murderers, people on murder trial etc. I was handcuffed to a man that was savgely beaten by gang members for a minor offense involving a newspaper.
The process to goto court was insane — including dry runs where you basically sit in a small cold holding room with up to 50 people from 6am to 5pm but are never called to court. In that room, inmates had been murdered and yes they’re cameras now but people cover them up for a fight.
This was my 1st arrest, for a dubious crime. I even called the police for help, was unjustly arrested than put in jail with violent criminals and violent deputies whose behavior has improved since the FBI installed video cameras.
Also, in the US, 75 percent of people in jail are back within 3 years. It's not necessarily because people can't "get better." It's also because US society is setup to continually attack people who have gone to jail and send them back. It's the entire reason why the majority of people in jail being minorities is so egregious.
So either the misdemeanor was not minor, or this guy has something else going on?
Like maybe he's black?
Maybe he's dating the arresting cop's ex? But if this kind of thing were the case, you'd normally see more charges. (And no plea bargains.)
I'd say maybe it was a political thing, but it's not an election year.
Who knows? But 35 days is way outside the mean. The average person would not get that much for a 1st offense on a minor misdemeanor.
https://www.ussc.gov/sites/default/files/pdf/research-and-pu...
Torture: > the act of inflicting excruciating pain, as punishment or revenge, as a means of getting a confession or information, or for sheer cruelty.
https://www.dictionary.com/browse/torture
Please stop with the hyperbole and misapplication of defined words. You degrade the actual meaning of the word when used improperly in this context. Also, you state that it's a voluntary action, entirely controlled by the prisoners behavior.
> If the prisoner doesn't behave just right
So - behave if in prison. Seems reasonable.
Contrast what you claim is torture, with actual torture that does go on: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/jan/23/lawyer-torture...
I'd take your version of torture any day of the week, because it's actually pretty tame compared to real torture.
It's far from hyperbole and far from voluntary, especially when you start considering the needs of the mentally ill with regards to prisons and how they're supposed to behave.
And solitary confinement is one small part in the overall torture scheme perpetrated by US prisons. It's not hyperbole, it's the facts.
Not in the least, unless you are saying "what about using the actual definition of the word" is a bad thing for people to do.
One point is that should we forcibly imprison someone who has not committed any real crime?
Or even put them in a mental hospital?
In the US at least jails and mental hospitals have a long history of twisted sadistic abuse by extremely well meaning individuals who were convinced they knew what was best for these people.
During the Bush II administration he appointed a Homeless Tsar (who didn't like Bush) who advocated for a program where the hopelessly homeless were put into a decent 1 bedroom apartment, signed up for health care, and given a small monthly stipend. This cost less than these men were costing society showing up at the emergency rooms with frostbite and side effects of diabetes, etc. One controversial aspect was that there were no restrictions on what they spent the money on. They could for example purchase vodka instead of food if that was their desire. Unlike with most homeless shelters, they were left alone and allowed to live their lives as they chose if they wanted that.
This program was very successful and greatly decreased the cost of managing long term homeless persons.
I agree, that $1k per day per patient for that is a way too much, and I see this as the problem. But while reading this article I've formed a suspicion that article points to moral unacceptability of imprisonment of mentally ill. It is unacceptable because it is amoral and to hell with all the attempts to reason rationally. Is my suspicion is a right one?