News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by geofft on Saturday January 26, 2019 @01:00AM (#19005031)
Here's a simpler proposal: anyone from anywhere can come here and take any job. If you leave your job, voluntarily or not, you have 90 days (up from the current grace period of 60 and strict rule of 0) to find another job. If you've been here for a few years you can apply for citizenship, independent of your employer.

The primary objection to this is crowding out the labor market, to which I'd say: protectionism doesn't work. If there are people in another country willing to do the same job for cheaper, the invisible hand will figure out how to move the jobs there, perhaps through competition. Fighting the free market isn't going to work: figure out how to work within it. (For instance, offer a UBI for citizens only.)

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Saturday January 26, 2019 @01:13AM (#19005081)
The primary objection to that idea is the complete destruction of your country's culture.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by geofft on Saturday January 26, 2019 @01:39AM (#19005162)
Again, protectionism. If a billion people in India and a billion people in China are competing in global markets, my country's culture isn't going to survive anyway. How is Ottoman culture doing these days? Honestly, how is the British culture of even a century ago doing these days? How long did the Japanese culture so carefully preserved survive Matthew Perry's arrival?

(Also as it happens I'm an American-born child of Indian immigrants, so I am actually a carrier of American culture and not Indian, so I have reason to question the implicit assumption that immigrants will destroy culture.)

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Saturday January 26, 2019 @02:56AM (#19005381)
You're a carrier of American culture (at least in some superficial way) because you grew up surrounded by Americans. If 500 million people moved here, they would not grow up surrounded by Americans.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by geofft on Sunday January 27, 2019 @06:58PM (#19014538)
Well, okay, but there are multiple times 500 million people living in other countries growing up extremely not surrounding by Americans, and they are preparing to quash America's culture entirely in 100-200 years through economic dominance. Do you prefer that outcome?
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by fiblye on Saturday January 26, 2019 @02:50AM (#19005365)
If you dig in, a lot of cultures have roots going back centuries. People might be wearing tshirts and jeans everywhere you go, but the way they handle family matters and daily routines is very different.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by comesee on Saturday January 26, 2019 @05:34AM (#19005731)
You're a superficial carrier of American culture. Sure you speak English and consume American media, but you have socialist values which are not American. This is the land of the free, not the land of government-enforced equity and insanely high marginal taxes for the rich. Let me guess, you're anti 2nd amendment? If there were more people who thought like you in America, the country would indeed collapse in on itself.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by geofft on Saturday January 26, 2019 @03:05PM (#19008131)
No, I'm pro-Second Amendment. Probably more strongly than you: I believe the original purpose of the Second Amendment was to maintain a continuous threat of violent revolution against the government, not to let people hunt deer or whatever, and as a result I believe that the people have a right to own weapons sufficient to win a war against their own government—either by letting the people have a nuclear deterrent, or by disarming the government to the point of having no weapons the people can't have.

Not sure what that has to do with anything, though.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by danmaz74 on Saturday January 26, 2019 @11:24AM (#19006912)
The op talked about the free market always winning, and you accuse him of being a socialist?
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by CalRobert on Saturday January 26, 2019 @02:16AM (#19005273)
Bummer, isn't it? I left the US because of its work culture (always working all the time, or trying to look like it) and now it's infecting Europe, or parts of it at least.

But that was without throngs of Americans moving here

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by fzeroracer on Saturday January 26, 2019 @02:36PM (#19007968)
To be fair, American culture is the destruction of other cultures if you take a critical eye at American history. It's quite funny to see people so protective of it.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Saturday January 26, 2019 @03:54PM (#19008429)
Well, I'm not talking about American culture, I'm talking about any country taking in immigrants, and general reasons to object to it. It certainly isn't economics-only. (America has already undergone this process in many waves, e.g. when non-Quakers took over Pennsylvania, or when Californians move to Idaho.)
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by fzeroracer on Saturday January 26, 2019 @05:50PM (#19009071)
This is a thread and topic about America and immigration in America. To suddenly shift and say that you're somehow not talking about American culture seems rather incredibly disingenuous.

And that said, a culture does not deserve to live by virtue of existing. It's protectionism and xenophobia, founded purely because of fears that immigrants will somehow replace your culture with something you view as being lesser. This is a two-way street because I have seen people use it as an argument against letting in people that would destroy woman's rights or what now here in America...and I've heard it used in fears of immigrants fighting for minority rights or woman's rights in countries like Japan.

It's an argument born out of irrational fears and one I find not compelling at all.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Saturday January 26, 2019 @06:11PM (#19009173)
Well I certainly object to the destruction of America’s culture too, but the construction of geofft’s argument is that categorically he could only think of one possible objection to immigration.

And it’s not an irrational fear. It’s a very obvious fact that America with wide open borders would be a worse place for existing Americans to live, just look at the average country and ask if Americans would like to live there, and why not.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by fzeroracer on Saturday January 26, 2019 @06:15PM (#19009195)
I don't believe it's a very obvious fact at all, considering America has had very lax borders in the past and I would not describe it as being a far worse place to live. If you're going to describe something as an obvious fact, how about you back up your obvious fact with citations or data? Otherwise then yes, it would be an irrational fear.

And I would imagine the converse is true: If you asked anyone in another first world country if they would like to live in America, I would bet you'd see the results end up rather negative. Especially after the past few years of nonsense we've exhibited to the rest of the world.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Saturday January 26, 2019 @06:27PM (#19009246)
Simply by increasing population, traffic, and pollution it would make the country worse off.

You don’t need studies and citations to figure this out, you need to hold in your head a model of reality. You need above average people, who give more than they take, in order to drive the quality of the country upward.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by fzeroracer on Saturday January 26, 2019 @06:58PM (#19009394)
Let's take your argument to the extreme then: If increasing population -> more traffic -> more pollution, then the obvious thing should be to reduce the birth rate in America which is a far more pressing issue than immigration if we're talking pure population growth.

Not only that but by your own argument since we need 'above average people' who 'give more than they take', the end result should be forcing people out of rural areas (the dense metropolitan areas tend to be more economically powerful) while also ensuring they can't procreate. What I'm getting at is essentially using population growth as an excuse for restricting immigration is itself an excuse, because there are many ways in which the issues of population growth are stymied and more effective at doing so.

And yes, I do want studies and citations. You're essentially begging the question in lieu of actually providing evidence for your own claims. I want you to give me explicit citations for your claims and your 'model of reality', because you're assuming that your model of reality is correct without any factual basis.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Saturday January 26, 2019 @07:21PM (#19009498)
Sorry, pal, you don't get to dictate the terms of this conversation.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by fzeroracer on Saturday January 26, 2019 @07:28PM (#19009535)
Then you're admitting that you're not here to actually debate in any sort of rational manner. If you make a claim and can't substantiate your claim when called out on it, then your claim has no rational or factual basis. At which point your entire argument falls apart, especially when you call something a 'very obvious fact'.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Saturday January 26, 2019 @07:42PM (#19009594)
You're welcome to post a citation showing that increased immigration would reduce traffic and pollution. Otherwise I'm not gonna bother.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by fzeroracer on Saturday January 26, 2019 @07:57PM (#19009668)
It's obvious now that you're not actually willing to properly argue on your side of the debate. The argumentative burden of proof is on the person making the claims, not the one disputing it. The fact that you're being so flippant about your claims does not do your argument justice.

Not only that, but now you're attempting to twist the argument into something that it wasn't in the first place. Even if we did decrease immigration, that wouldn't fix the issues of traffic and pollution in America because those are born out of poor city planning combined with lax industrial standards. Unless you want to somehow argue that immigrants contribute more to pollution than corporations doing things like say, flaring in West Texas.

If you can't support your claims with evidence when called out on it, then you shouldn't make such bold claims period.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Sunday January 27, 2019 @08:43PM (#19014904)
More people = more traffic is not a bold claim. That's traffic engineering 101.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by geofft on Sunday January 27, 2019 @06:57PM (#19014529)
> Simply by increasing population, traffic, and pollution it would make the country worse off.

This doesn't at all seem obviously true to me. It rather seems obviously false: I find big cities more pleasant to live in than small towns, even though they have more of all three. More population seems like an inherent virtue to me. More traffic gets turned into more efficient traffic via public transit, or building denser and more walkable cities, or whatever, which I find more enjoyable than cars. More pollution is a side effect but a solvable one.

If your argument is the model of reality in your head, then you need to admit that the model of reality in lots of other peoples' heads is very different, and there's no reason that your model should win (unless you're claiming that your political opinions matter more than others'?).

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Sunday January 27, 2019 @08:41PM (#19014893)
I think waiting in traffic and being forced to use alternate means of transportation is a net negative. There are already Big Cities in this country for anybody that enjoys the city-slicker lifestyle, and increasing total population won't make the world better for those people.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by geofft on Sunday January 27, 2019 @06:47PM (#19014482)
> the construction of geofft’s argument is that categorically he could only think of one possible objection to immigration.

This is untrue. I said the primary objection. Of course there will be a lot of other objections.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Sunday January 27, 2019 @07:57PM (#19014743)
Okay, that's correct. And I disagree(d) with what the primary objection is and would be. Maybe not your objection, but most people's, in every country.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by geofft on Saturday January 26, 2019 @04:42PM (#19008691)
I was gonna ask - are you also in favor of putting restrictions on Californians moving to Idaho?
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Saturday January 26, 2019 @05:16PM (#19008885)
I haven’t actually told you my immigration policy, and it’s clear you’ve incorrectly decided you know what it is.

My immigration policy would be to let in the set and sequence of immigrants that makes this country as nice a place to live as possible. Approximated with a greedy algorithm, that means picking the individual that makes this country the most nicer place, letting them in, and then repeating the calculation until we’ve run out of people that make the country a better place for us to live. Culturally, that means cultural optimization, not preservation.

I’d happily stop 99.999% of noncitizens from moving here and working here while allowing Californians to move to Idaho. (I’d also remove the financial penalties California places on people that moved from Idaho to California.)

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by geofft on Sunday January 27, 2019 @06:54PM (#19014520)
That's not a coherent policy - that basically describes everyone's policy. That describes the current US policy. That describes my policy. It's just that you've shifted it to a discussion of what makes the country a "nice place to live," which obviously lots of people disagree on. In particular you haven't answered what to do when there are conflicting arguments over whether bringing in a particular person would make the country a nicer place to live or not, or for whom it's nicer.

Specifically, I think that this country would be a nicer place to live for myself if I can hire whomever I want for my team regardless of citizenship and without big government second-guessing my decision, and if they can feel confident about their long-term future once they move, therefore making them a) more likely to accept and b) happier and more productive when they're here.

I also think that the number of people who have moved into the SFBA (myself included, I'll be honest—feeling uncomfortable with that is part of why I left) have made it a worse place to live. I think there are ways to solve that other than internal migration restrictions, and I have other philosophical objections to internal migration restrictions, but I do see their appeal. You, for some reason that I don't totally follow, either don't think that SFBA has become a worse place to live or that this isn't an important criterion in deciding internal policy; I'm curious which it is (or whether I've misinterpreted).

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Sunday January 27, 2019 @08:30PM (#19014841)
That doesn't describe current US policy, which prevents people from coming that would make the country a nicer place to live, and lets many people in that wouldn't. By design, it even brings in random people.

I'm not describing a policy, I'm describing an ideal. (A simple concrete policy proposal is below.)

You said:

> Here's a simpler proposal: anyone from anywhere can come here and take any job.

So that doesn't describe your policy proposal either. Plenty of people can hold down a job and make the country a worse place for others, or a subset of others, simply by competing for resources, driving down wages in the sector they work in, by being a criminal, or by voting immorally.

I want to let everybody you'd let in, except for people whose immigration would make the country a worse place. Define that ideal as you will.

As a pretty good approximation, we could limit immigrants to those that could qualify for military service.

> myself included, I'll be honest—feeling uncomfortable with that is part of why I left

That's also a reason why I left. My policy as a national policy, is to make the country a nice place for all of its citizens (except criminals and slovenly degenerates) to live in. So that includes people that might like to move from Arizona to California. They're making their own lives better, which counts for something.

> I think that this country would be a nicer place to live for myself if I can hire whomever I want for my team regardless of citizenship and without big government second-guessing my decision

If you're like most employers, that means you're happier if you get to drive down working class wages, while you get to reap greater profits from your pre-established position in the market. That's good for you, but not good for the average American.

To make my goals a little more nuanced: Economically, I want only the smartest immigrants, which do advanced stuff like start companies, work for them, or work in healthcare, which drive up the demand for working-class labor, letting average Americans negotiate a better piece of the pie, while driving down the cost of their healthcare. Culturally, I want supply limited so that immigrants assimilate, and I want all the immigrants and their children to be crime-free pro-life Republican voters. :-)

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by mars4rp on Saturday January 26, 2019 @02:21AM (#19005281)
I bet native Americans of couple centuries ago agree with you.
[dead]
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Saturday January 26, 2019 @03:10AM (#19005414)
What.

One consequence of unlimited immigration to America would be a major setback in women's rights and practical freedom in many pockets of the country.

[dead]
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by SamReidHughes on Saturday January 26, 2019 @02:58AM (#19005386)
> Leave him alone, he just wanta to secure the existence of his people...

Wow, you need to learn how to distinguish between stuff your brain tells you and reality.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by diogenescynic on Saturday January 26, 2019 @01:18AM (#19005100)
This is the dumbest idea I’ve ever seen. Why bother being a country at that point? You’d have 2 billion people moving here tomorrow and living in the streets. Bad idea.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by geofft on Saturday January 26, 2019 @01:41AM (#19005170)
Not sure what you mean by "being a country," but, no, you wouldn't. If they didn't have jobs they couldn't stay. If they did they'd find housing - perhaps some would even build housing for the rest. To imagine that two billion people could move to the US, find employment, and all be homeless is to imagine an interesting form of market failure that I don't yet understand.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by Hallucinaut on Saturday January 26, 2019 @08:21AM (#19006160)
So they would definitely get back on planes rather than just going rogue and trying to stay in the country and working illegally? And existing citizens would not lose out through massive oversupply problems in the labour market?

I can't say I agree at all this would be of benefit to any nation willing to do this.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by geofft on Saturday January 26, 2019 @09:16AM (#19006362)
Like I've been saying in this thread, existing citizens are going to lose out anyway. The labor market is global. There is no way to have the government interfere in the free market to preserve jobs for certain people of certain backgrounds, and not have it backfire. It is already backfiring, in many industries.

So if you care about not making existing citizens lose out—which I do!—find a solution other than protectionism. Find a solution that works. A UBI, so that not finding a job doesn't ruin your life, is a good one. Fund it with income taxes on immigrants who come here and do well. (And on a UBI you can spend as much time as you want training in an advanced skill or learning a complicated profession so that you can compete in another segment of the labor market.)

No country is going to do this because no country wants to admit to their citizens that the "country" and "citizen" abstractions are powerless against the reality of the global free market. It's too politically incorrect; people would rather believe that protectionism works. But it's the right thing to do.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by gedy on Saturday January 26, 2019 @10:20AM (#19006615)
> The labor market is global.

Not for all countries! Definitely an imbalance there, and US is already pretty generous with immigration numbers. We've also seen that cheap labor does not reduce cost of living in developed countries, so importing foreign cheap labor is a loss for not-rich folks.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by geofft on Saturday January 26, 2019 @11:47AM (#19007034)
That's not what I mean—what I mean is that labor is in the service of products and services, and the market for products and services is overwhelmingly global. You can get software from anywhere. You can get PCBs from anywhere. You can get oil from anywhere. You can get clothes from anywhere. You can get cars from anywhere. You can get produce from almost anywhere. (Prepared food is hard, as are a few other things like haircuts, but my argument is those are the minority.) Soon you'll be able to get truck drivers from anywhere with remote oversight of self-driving cars.

So if you're in any of these fields, you're competing with people around the world. You're not competing directly—the playing field is still quite bumpy—but it's becoming more level.

So if the actual goal you have is "I want citizens to not starve and be homeless," which is certainly my goal, protectionism is a temporary patch holding back a storm. One day it will stop working. Better to prepare for that day instead of denying it.

(Unless you plan on dying before then and don't care about your kids' future, but I assume all the people in this thread saying "culture" care about that....)

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by gedy on Saturday January 26, 2019 @06:34PM (#19009280)
> You can get clothes from anywhere. You can get cars from anywhere. You can get produce from almost anywhere...

But not everyone in any country can "get X from anywhere" is part of my point.

Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by thatcat on Saturday January 26, 2019 @03:20AM (#19005434)
Plenty of jobs pay less than a living wage.
Re:H-1B: Oracle favored hiring foreign graduates of US colle... by geofft on Saturday January 26, 2019 @09:21AM (#19006377)
OK, I am fine with amending my proposal to "any job that pays at least a living wage in the area where you live."

A bonus of that amendment is that if you want to bring family, you must all in sum earn a living wage for your family, but you can split that however you want, so e.g. you can legally bring children who aren't going to work or legally take more than 90 days to raise a child.

(Also it might embarrass the government into raising the minimum wage for citizens to a living wage.)