News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:JMAP: Like IMAP but Not Really by efdee on Friday January 25, 2019 @04:37AM (#18996726)
If paying to send email is your suggested solution, I can see why you don't like the meme in question. But the suggestion is rife with problems. How exactly are you going to get everyone to start paying for email, which is free today? If it's a parallel system, how are you going to get people to switch? Who are they going to pay?
Re:JMAP: Like IMAP but Not Really by tonyedgecombe on Friday January 25, 2019 @05:25AM (#18996907)
If people received credit for incoming mail then the majority wouldn't get a bill as most people receive more than they send.
Re:JMAP: Like IMAP but Not Really by thekyle on Friday January 25, 2019 @08:37AM (#18997734)
As an alternative but similar idea, Proof of Work was originally developed to solve the email spam problem. The idea was that you would hash the email body + timestamp + nonce producing a hash with some number of leading zeros. It would be fast for individual devices to compute and fast for email servers to verify en mass but expensive if you needed to send lots of emails.

The obvious downside is that since the system is fundamentally just cryptography it doesn't discriminate between spam and legitimate bulk mail (password resets, newsletters, mailing lists, etc.)

Re:JMAP: Like IMAP but Not Really by bjoli on Friday January 25, 2019 @05:32AM (#18996939)
Most bigger services are probably going to send and receive about the same amount of mail so it will be an almost zero-sum game. Most services today have a cap on how mail you can send, and this could be made more explicit and have cases where the end user actually pay.

I don't really see the payment as a big problem. This has been discussed previously, mostly initiated by the big email services

Re:JMAP: Like IMAP but Not Really by mathnmusic on Friday January 25, 2019 @05:26AM (#18996913)
> Who are they going to pay?

The sender pays the reader. If the reader is the one deriving the value from this communication, they would pay the sender out of band as compensation.

Re:JMAP: Like IMAP but Not Really by detaro on Friday January 25, 2019 @05:28AM (#18996919)
So what does a reliable, not centralized payment system that is viable for this volume of tiny transactions that everyone can use look like? That's IMHO the big problem with all these suggestions.