News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by gaze on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:20AM (#18961336)
Disclaimer: I'm near the end of a PhD in experimental quantum computing.

I'm not sure what he means very little progress... we're entangling over long distances, we're doing practical error correction, we're reaching really long coherence times. More importantly, we've seen exponential progress in coherence times over time. Moore's law-like progress. Quantum computing has also had the side benefit of generating obviously practical results like ultra wide bandwidth, high dynamic range quantum limited amplifiers, and debatably practical but stunning fundamental results like reversing a quantum jump in real time by feedback. This is all recent. Quantum computing research has exploded in the last 10 years. The blog post just sounds like some dude that doesn't really understand physics, didn't do a thorough literature search, didn't really even look at recent news articles, who pats himself on the back for being a real practical business guy instead of a Quantum Physics PhD, because some Quantum Physics PhD served him food or something and thus they must all be floundering. He then goes on to poorly explain why quantum computing is really really hard and therefore we shouldn't be spending money on it. Poorly I say because he can't even seem to explain properly one of MANY proposed implementations of a quantum computer. One that isn't even particularly popular anymore. I really think he just woke up angry and wrote this.

Nearly having finished a PhD in quantum computing, I wouldn't say the skills I'm most proud of I picked up are my understanding of quantum mechanics... I'm now an expert in low noise microwave electronics, high speed feedback control, cryogenics. Some of which are practically useful skills, some of which are highly applicable towards better understanding of the natural world in ways that I think the author would even agree are worthwhile. So no, my life hasn't been wasted and my career hasn't been ruined.

Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by bassman9000 on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:06PM (#18961693)
He then goes on to poorly explain why quantum computing is really really hard and therefore we shouldn't be spending money on it

I think it read more like

We're still ages away from the ancilliary technologies that will allow us to tackle quantum computing

The whole XVIII century vs SR-71 example was pretty clear

Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by gaze on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:34PM (#18961910)
But what technologies are needed to make quantum computing work with say superconducting qubits? High speed room temperature processors? FPGAs and fast DACs/ADCs will do it. Low loss cables? Got that. Low noise amplifiers? Got it. Idk what people want. It’s a good time to start throwing money at it to iron out the problems that nobody wants to do a thesis on. It’s not riskfree but it’s a reasonable bet.
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by bassman9000 on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:56PM (#18962074)
Indeed, you gotta risk to win. But at which threshold you stop, and reconsider, given the lack of results? 1B? 10B? 1T?

I'm not an expert on the matter, but I understand "cut your losses".

Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by gaze on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:18PM (#18962235)
What “lack of results?”
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by scottlocklin on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:30PM (#18962330)
I very clearly pointed out that no QC researcher has created, for example:

1) An actually error corrected qubit

2) A quantum factorization of the number 15

You can set yourself artificial goalposts of "hey my entanglement lasted a little longer on architecture X this year, therefore Moore's law means it is inevitable" -but you still can't factor the number 15. Please factor the number 15. No "pre compilation" where you leave out the number of gates needed to get the answer -just factor the number. Show me this, and then I will proceed to make fun of the idea that you can factor, say, a 3 digit decimal number. This is the only demonstrated interesting use case for QC, and the only reason anyone is funding the topic.

Yes, yes, "modeling quantum systems" -OK, go model an interesting quantum system for me.

Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by gaze on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:42PM (#18962428)
1) https://www.nature.com/articles/nature18949

https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.7403

2. http://science.sciencemag.org/content/351/6277/1068 seems like it might satisfy your requirements. It doesn't seem to use the answer in its calculation, but I'm not sure.

Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by scottlocklin on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:53PM (#18962529)
If the abstracts were actually true and someone implemented an actually error corrected qubit with lifetime 320ms, I guess it should be trivial to apply a few thousand operations to a mere 4 qubits and factor the number 15.

You're at Yale and presumably going to Berkeley later: maybe you should try to do this. Sounds to me like you could build a whole career on meeting the challenges involved in factoring the number 15.

Edit add: since you continue to add material, I will continue to add comments; half the text of the Blatt paper is verbiage making excuses for the fact they dropped the operations they knew were not needed to factor 15, just like the NMR quantum computers in the 90s did. In fact, this one is worse than 90s results.

Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by scottlocklin on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:47AM (#18961542)
"my life hasn't been wasted and my career hasn't been ruined"

Talk to me in 10 years when you're not bringing me a steak for a living.

FWIIW I went to a Gordon conference on this in the 90s, and literally, the capabilities of quantum computers have not changed since then. Zero. None. There has been no "Moore's law like progress." There hasn't been any! That's the point! There's been more progress in interstellar space flight than quantum computing (I dunno, White-Juday is at least a good try), but at least warp drive creators aren't trying to convince people like you to ruin your lives.

Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by gaze on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:54AM (#18961595)
https://imgur.com/a/HCJ7hLq

Again, exponential progress in coherence time.

Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by scottlocklin on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:02PM (#18961660)
Well, for one thing, consultants who can see through baloney like that are extremely valuable to people in business.

You ever look at Haroche's 1996 argument against QC? You should go have a look.

Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by gaze on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:16PM (#18962217)
Read it. Pretty stale take, which it would be for being 23 years old.
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by scottlocklin on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:57PM (#18962571)
Have any of his concerns been addressed? Do you, for example, have a pithy rejoinder to the idea that manipulating an exponential number of states to any degree of precision is kind of impossible?
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by happytoexplain on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:01PM (#18961658)
>Talk to me in 10 years when you're not bringing me a steak for a living.

This comes off as an incredibly hostile sentence, though I suspect you may have not meant it as just an attack.

Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by scottlocklin on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:04PM (#18961683)
Dude, some guy with a Ph.D. in quantum computing from MIT brought me a steak for a $10 tip; does that not concern you?
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by toufiqbarhamov on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:33PM (#18961906)
Dude, some guy with a Ph.D. in quantum computing from MIT brought me a steak for a $10 tip; does that not concern you?

Dude, your n=1 anecdote isn’t as amusing or compelling as you seem to think. Your entire argument seems more like a thinly veiled excuse to rant than it resembles an intellectual exercise. That’s hardly an inspiring argument from a self-styled empiricist.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18961731

Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by scottlocklin on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:50PM (#18962032)
I thought it was hilarious, personally, as we were discussing at the dinner table why quantum computing is probably nonsense. My interlocutor (who was more or less going along with the conventional opinion that QC is about to "change everything") thought I bribed the waiter to say this.
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit by z3t4 on Tuesday January 22, 2019 @01:31AM (#18966409)
If you only sleep 4 hours you can have two jobs and still work on quantum computing. Then when you make a break-though someone steals your idea. Science is only for the privileged.