Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit
by gaze on Monday January 21, 2019 @11:54AM
(#18961595)
https://imgur.com/a/HCJ7hLq
Again, exponential progress in coherence time.
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit
by scottlocklin on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:02PM
(#18961660)
Well, for one thing, consultants who can see through baloney like that are extremely valuable to people in business.
You ever look at Haroche's 1996 argument against QC? You should go have a look.
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit
by gaze on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:16PM
(#18962217)
Read it. Pretty stale take, which it would be for being 23 years old.
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit
by scottlocklin on Monday January 21, 2019 @01:57PM
(#18962571)
Have any of his concerns been addressed? Do you, for example, have a pithy rejoinder to the idea that manipulating an exponential number of states to any degree of precision is kind of impossible?
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit
by happytoexplain on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:01PM
(#18961658)
>Talk to me in 10 years when you're not bringing me a steak for a living.
This comes off as an incredibly hostile sentence, though I suspect you may have not meant it as just an attack.
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit
by scottlocklin on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:04PM
(#18961683)
Dude, some guy with a Ph.D. in quantum computing from MIT brought me a steak for a $10 tip; does that not concern you?
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit
by toufiqbarhamov on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:33PM
(#18961906)
Dude, some guy with a Ph.D. in quantum computing from MIT brought me a steak for a $10 tip; does that not concern you?
Dude, your n=1 anecdote isn’t as amusing or compelling as you seem to think. Your entire argument seems more like a thinly veiled excuse to rant than it resembles an intellectual exercise. That’s hardly an inspiring argument from a self-styled empiricist.
Re:Quantum computing as a field is obvious bullshit
by scottlocklin on Monday January 21, 2019 @12:50PM
(#18962032)
I thought it was hilarious, personally, as we were discussing at the dinner table why quantum computing is probably nonsense. My interlocutor (who was more or less going along with the conventional opinion that QC is about to "change everything") thought I bribed the waiter to say this.
Talk to me in 10 years when you're not bringing me a steak for a living.
FWIIW I went to a Gordon conference on this in the 90s, and literally, the capabilities of quantum computers have not changed since then. Zero. None. There has been no "Moore's law like progress." There hasn't been any! That's the point! There's been more progress in interstellar space flight than quantum computing (I dunno, White-Juday is at least a good try), but at least warp drive creators aren't trying to convince people like you to ruin your lives.