1) An actually error corrected qubit
2) A quantum factorization of the number 15
You can set yourself artificial goalposts of "hey my entanglement lasted a little longer on architecture X this year, therefore Moore's law means it is inevitable" -but you still can't factor the number 15. Please factor the number 15. No "pre compilation" where you leave out the number of gates needed to get the answer -just factor the number. Show me this, and then I will proceed to make fun of the idea that you can factor, say, a 3 digit decimal number. This is the only demonstrated interesting use case for QC, and the only reason anyone is funding the topic.
Yes, yes, "modeling quantum systems" -OK, go model an interesting quantum system for me.
https://arxiv.org/abs/1411.7403
2. http://science.sciencemag.org/content/351/6277/1068 seems like it might satisfy your requirements. It doesn't seem to use the answer in its calculation, but I'm not sure.
You're at Yale and presumably going to Berkeley later: maybe you should try to do this. Sounds to me like you could build a whole career on meeting the challenges involved in factoring the number 15.
Edit add: since you continue to add material, I will continue to add comments; half the text of the Blatt paper is verbiage making excuses for the fact they dropped the operations they knew were not needed to factor 15, just like the NMR quantum computers in the 90s did. In fact, this one is worse than 90s results.