Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by rhacker on Thursday January 17, 2019 @06:33PM
(#18935683)
It's like if they said "Fuck" on the radio and then decided to arrest anyone that possibly heard the transmission.
Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by t413 on Thursday January 17, 2019 @07:18PM
(#18935930)
It's a great example of the breakdown in understanding of a system. People envision WiFi as a wireless pipe or cable whereas in reality you're broadcasting in every direction out to infinity.
When reality doesn't match peoples' expectations they legislate a 'fix' (making listening illegal) rather than fixing the fundamental technical issue (with encryption, randomized IDs, etc).
Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by mehrdadn on Thursday January 17, 2019 @04:38PM
(#18934888)
Even collecting water falling on your roof is illegal in some places...
Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by asdff on Thursday January 17, 2019 @05:19PM
(#18935214)
I think that's argued a little differently. Rain you collect from your roof is water removed from a watershed which has an impact on everything living in that environment. You aren't allowed to burn your trash in your yard and pollute the 'public' air either, for example.
Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by abraae on Thursday January 17, 2019 @08:10PM
(#18936190)
Thank you for that explanation. Living on rain water, I have always thought those situations were barking mad, now I get it.
Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by maxerickson on Thursday January 17, 2019 @09:45PM
(#18936641)
In the US it's because the water rights aren't attached to the property, not so much because of the environmental impact.
That is, it's a rancher that is gonna get up in your business if you put in a rain barrel, not a cactus.
Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by droithomme on Thursday January 17, 2019 @10:06PM
(#18936723)
> It may be illegal to monitor networks for MAC addresses
I use promiscuous mode to monitor and send alerts about everybody with a wifi active phone that comes onto my property. I also have cameras and motion sensors. It's not illegal and if it's made illegal I'll keep doing it because I have an intrinsic fundamental human right to protect my property.
Re:Count the people around you by monitoring wifi signals
by abtinf on Thursday January 17, 2019 @11:23PM
(#18937014)
This is interesting. Can you describe your setup in more detail?
Isn't it odd that you can't read electromagnetic signals penetrating your walls without your consent?