News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by cr1895 on Monday January 14, 2019 @06:17AM (#18902198)
I'm struggling to understand how you've connected "health care is a basic right" to the state imposing something on a person by threat of violence.
Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by mcv on Monday January 14, 2019 @06:56AM (#18902370)
Forcing people under threat of violence is a popular strawman with people who oppose a civil society. Maybe it's the only way they can think of to get things done?
Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by assblaster on Monday January 14, 2019 @07:00AM (#18902384)
It's not a straw man, it's a practical question. If healthcare was a human right, you should be able to describe how you enforce that right, especially when someone infringes upon that right, such as a physician who refuses to provide services requested by a patient.
Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by mcv on Monday January 14, 2019 @07:10AM (#18902430)
Physicians may very well refuse services requested by a patient if the physician doesn't think those services are good for the patient. Health care is not a self-serve buffet. This has nothing to do with health care being a basic right.

And if a physician denies a patient necessary treatment, there are already ways to deal with that. Physicians are (usually?) subject to disciplinary committees that deal with malpractice and other bad behaviour by physicians. Furthermore, a physician who refuses to do their job can be fired just like anyone else who refuses their job. This also has nothing to do with health care being a basic right.

So what exactly is your practical question is it's neither a straw man nor one of these two issues?

[dead]
Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by mcv on Monday January 14, 2019 @08:21AM (#18902714)
I think you are a couple of steps behind in the discussion. When people say that health care is a basic human right, they don't mean that physicians don't deserve to get paid for their work, they mean that everybody should have affordable (possibly government provided) health insurance. That insurance pays the physician. In some cases, the government simply pays for all care whether or not the patient is a citizen.

But yes, if an unlicensed physician tries to practice without a license, that's generally considered illegal in most countries, and for good reason. Charlatans pretending to be able to cure patients have cost lives. There's a good reason why physicians need to meet certain standards before they're allowed to call themselves physician.

Physicians can absolutely be and often are self-employed, even in countries where health care is considered a right. They too need to meet those standards. No, they can't be fired, but they can lose their license if they violate those standards. I'm not sure to what extent they're free to refuse to accept patients, but if they do accept a patient, that does come with a certain responsibility towards that patient.

[dead]
Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by cr1895 on Monday January 14, 2019 @10:50AM (#18903860)
I'm not sure why you're latching on to this notion of appropriating the work of others.

In the Netherlands (what I'm familiar with), healthcare functions through compulsory private insurance. Healthcare is paid for both by insurance contributions (on the order of 120eur per month, with a deductible of about 385eur) and by taxes. If one can't afford to pay the premiums, it is subsidized by the government. It's free if you're under 18. The system functions with a sort of gatekeeping by general practicioners, where GP visits cost nothing in addition to the health insurance premiums and if there is some issue beyond which the GP can handle you are referred to a specialist.

>Health insurance is supposed to pay for catastrophic losses, similar to auto and home insurance.

In the Netherlands it pays for routine, preventative care as well as catastrophic losses. That's why it's compulsory for everyone.

> Is health insurance a human right?

Yes, in the NL.

>What does "affordable" mean? What happens when hospitals and physicians reject your insurance? What co-pays and coinsurance are considered affordable?

Government policy, which also dictates who is eligible for subsidy. Insurance rejection isn't a thing.

>Does the right to health insurance extend to people who willingly destroy themselves for pleasure? Do they pay the same amount as people who take care of themselves?

Yes, though I'm not sure what medical discretion there is if for example an elderly life-long smoker needs a transplant. Suffice to say everyone has the right to health insurance.

>Can "healthcare is a human right" extend to Americans who travel to Europe for the purpose of obtaining free elective medical care at the expense of European taxpayers

An American cannot travel to the NL for free healthcare.

Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by mcv on Monday January 14, 2019 @02:18PM (#18905555)
> Insurance rejection isn't a thing.

The opposite is a thing, though: that your insurance refuses to cover some treatment. It's not a free-for-all buffet, after all. That's where the GP comes in: for many treatments, the GP first has to refer you to a specialist for the treatment by that specialist to be covered. For some more experimental treatments, a physician from the insurance company has to approve coverage.

And some things aren't covered at all. There's some variation in what various insurers cover, although they all cover the serious hospital stuff (because that will bankrupt you if they don't).

> Yes, though I'm not sure what medical discretion there is if for example an elderly life-long smoker needs a transplant. Suffice to say everyone has the right to health insurance.

I believe there was talk a couple of years ago about whether smokers should pay a higher premium. Then it was discovered that smokers actually used less health care due to dying younger, and everybody shut up about it.

> An American cannot travel to the NL for free healthcare.

But if an American travels to the UK and gets ill or an accident there, they are mostly covered, because of the socialised nature of the NHS. In Netherland with its privatised system, you still need to have actual insurance. Most tourists do, although that's not going to cover pre-existing conditions, obviously. (Well, that sounds American.)

Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by mcv on Monday January 14, 2019 @10:18AM (#18903561)
> How are the phrases "healthcare is a human right" and "everybody should have affordable health insurance" even remotely connected?

The latter is to ensure the former.

I suppose it would be better to have a system like the NHS, because it saves on paperwork and ensures everybody has access to health care with the fewest hurdles possible, but that's not the only way to do it. It can be done through a system of private health insurance as long as it's very well regulated.

But however you do it, a system where people are denied health care or go bankrupt trying to pay for health care, is not good enough.

Look, you're clearly putting a lot of effort into trying not to understand this, and I guess I can't stop you. If you were honestly interested in these questions, you could just look around you at how various countries handle this, instead of grasping at straw men.

Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by ceejayoz on Monday January 14, 2019 @12:45PM (#18904741)
> If healthcare was a human right, you should be able to describe how you enforce that right, especially when someone infringes upon that right, such as a physician who refuses to provide services requested by a patient.

Why is this a problem for healthcare, but not, say, voting (which requires people to staff the polling places etc.), or the right to a jury trial (which requires judges, baliffs, etc. as well as the jurors)?

Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by assblaster on Monday January 14, 2019 @06:51AM (#18902343)
How do you compel physicians to treat someone who comes to them asking for services?

If a physician refuses to perform a knee replacement, for instance, because a patient does not want to pay for it, does the government step in and force the physician to do it?

In the United States, physicians have autonomy to decide how they practice. Do physicians in Europe have autonomy?

Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by detaro on Monday January 14, 2019 @10:56AM (#18903901)
The vast majority of emergency departments in the US is not allowed to turn someone away if they need emergency care. Somehow, that works even there. (even though due to lack of universal healthcare payment is not secured)

Many jurisdictions, including some US states, legally require everyone to provide emergency aid if possible, not just doctors.

The entire talking point about the individual doctor is a tired straw man, societies manage people having rights guaranteed by the system of society all the time, they do not break down if an individual person steps out of line.

Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by dbbk on Monday January 14, 2019 @06:20AM (#18902211)
What are you on about? Having the right to it doesn't mean you're forced to have it.
Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by assblaster on Monday January 14, 2019 @06:56AM (#18902372)
No, I'm asking about how you go about forcing physicians to provide services against the physician's wishes.

Maybe frame it in a different field: if programming services was declared a human right, how would you go about ensuring that every programmer provides services to everyone who asks for services regardless of payment? How do you ensure quality as well?

Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by mcv on Monday January 14, 2019 @08:32AM (#18902779)
Standards, regulation and ensuring people get paid. If programming services was decided to be a human right, and I was in the business of providing those services, I'd expect there to be a system in place to ensure my services meet the standard, and to ensure that I get paid for my work.

Consider legal representation: that is also a right. Sadly it's often very expensive, but for people who cannot afford a lawyer, one is generally provided by the government. And while there's certainly a lot that can be improved about the lawyering business, lawyers aren't exactly starving.

I am aware that for most examples I can come up with, the US tends to do a poorer job than most countries. I guess it's no surprise that health insurance is in such a sorry state in the US, and that many people have such weird misconceptions about things like this.

Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by assblaster on Monday January 14, 2019 @09:55AM (#18903383)
>If programming services was decided to be a human right, and I was in the business of providing those services, I'd expect there to be a system in place to ensure my services meet the standard, and to ensure that I get paid for my work.

What if you get paid 25% of what you get paid right now because those in charge of regulating programming have determined that you have been getting paid too much?

What if those regulators have determined that your current documentation is insufficient to be paid for, and that you are now required to spend 25% more of your day on additional documentation requirements that do not actually improve the quality of your actual program?

Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by mcv on Monday January 14, 2019 @10:10AM (#18903492)
If I didn't like the job for whatever reason, I'd get a different job of course.

But if health care and lawyers are any indication, there's little risk of that happening. Well, neither are immune to paperwork, but they're very well compensated for it.

Re:Hospitals Must Now Post Prices. But It May Take a Brain S... by DanBC on Monday January 14, 2019 @11:03AM (#18903973)
Doctoring is a job. If you wish to have absolute control over which patients you take you work in private practice.

If you want a bit less control over which patients you take you work for the hospital.

No guns needed.