News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by jbob2000 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:29PM (#18876490)
> A DVR and a set of "old school" network cameras in an internal network have none of those problems

Ring is a $300 purchase and takes an hour to install. This would take me a few weekends and would cost thousands of dollars. Cloud centralization makes things easier and cheaper, by orders of magnitude.

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by e1ven on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:39PM (#18876578)
Why would it be so difficult to connect to locally?

A company could drop a camera and a small NAS box, and have it all work over the local WiFi.

I haven't looked into it, but I suspect there are several vendors who already do this.

It would get more complicated to support accessing it while away from home, admittedly. I don't know if that's an important feature for this application.

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by Mister_Snuggles on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:55PM (#18876760)
> It would get more complicated to support accessing it while away from home, admittedly. I don't know if that's an important feature for this application.

This is a huge feature which I've solved using an IPSec VPN. This is not something that's easy for regular people to do though, so it's not a universal solution.

If someone made a router that could easily provision VPN access for a device (e.g., generate a sensible OpenVPN config or something) it would make this setup a LOT easier.

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by ASalazarMX on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:43PM (#18876619)
> It would get more complicated to support accessing it while away from home, admittedly. I don't know if that's an important feature for this application.

That's the killer feature. What good is a home surveillance system if you have to be there to use it?

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by mulmen on Thursday January 10, 2019 @04:30PM (#18878400)
This feels like one of the huge benefits to true widespread adoption of IPv6. A firewall is still required but without NAS it becomes much easier to connect to individual devices on arbitrary networks from anywhere.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by mulmen on Thursday January 10, 2019 @09:34PM (#18880571)
NAS? NAT.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by cordonbleu on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:40PM (#18877886)
i can drop a link right now that will let you look around at my driveway, if i get to know you better i could give you a login so you can see it works.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by jbob2000 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:50PM (#18876696)
> A company could drop a camera and a small NAS box, and have it all work over the local WiFi.

If you setup a company to do this, you will quickly find you are a customer service and call center company, NOT a security tech company.

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by bradknowles on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:09PM (#18876938)
Synology has IP camera support out of the box. For one camera. If you want more, you have to buy more licenses, which are only available from them. In hard copy form. And they take a week or more to arrive.

Been there, done that.

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by Lammy on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:54PM (#18876754)
I know this is going to sound a lot like “Why would anyone use dropbox when they could roll their own with an rsync shell script” but it’s not that bad. Please don’t spread FUD about the difficulty of freeing yourself from cloud surveillance. A copy of Blue Iris is $60, and you seem to be able to get 1080p indoor WiFi cameras for about another $60 each. Anyone who can connect a device to their wireless network, run a program, and forward a port can get equivalent functionality, and from my experience even a lot of non-tech-focused people are familiar with doing that for e.g. Xbox Live
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by mavrc on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:29PM (#18877166)
> Anyone who can connect a device to their wireless network, run a program, and forward a port can get equivalent functionality

I am very capable of all of those things and I don't agree.

To install a camera on my porch somewhere, I'd need first to run power to it, which is a difficult proposition that would probably mean I need to hire an electrician to do it right, as I'm not confident at all in my ability to properly do electrical wiring in places where it needs to be properly weatherproofed. And adding electrical to a near-as-makes-no-difference 80 year old house would look pretty hideous. Then, need to set up a server with redundant spinny storage and offsite backup, which, while not being terribly expensive these days, isn't particularly cheap either. And I don't even know how to begin approaching the mobile app notification issue. Doable, I'm sure, but does Blue Iris have notifications and remote access for viewing built in?

Or, alternatively, I paid $160 for a Ring doorbell and installed it in place of my existing doorbell in an hour or so.

I wish I had more control over it, and I _really_ wish they had an open public API. But at the same time, from a time/money investment point of view, getting the Ring was an obvious move.

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by chaostheory on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:44PM (#18877313)
Yes, wiring is the most complicated part of any outdoor video security setup. Since you can't avoid wires, even with wireless cams (unless you opt for battery operated cams like Arlo), it's just easier to use PoE so you won't need an electrician.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by dhimes on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:49PM (#18877988)
For anybody else like me out there, PoE means Power over Ethernet.

http://www.veracityglobal.com/resources/articles-and-white-p...

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by Mister_Snuggles on Thursday January 10, 2019 @05:12PM (#18878791)
I kind of cheated for my cameras. I simply put them in the window next to the front door and hid the power cable in the adjacent closet.

Because they're behind glass, using the built-in IR illumination is out of the question. Instead I use an LED bulb outside to provide light for the camera to see even in day mode.

It's not ideal by any measure, but it works OK enough.

If it were an option, I'd run PoE to proper outdoor cameras.

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by chaostheory on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:41PM (#18877293)
It is not FUD. Even for a techie there's a decent amount of setup involved, not to mention the pain and cost of having to maintain an entirely separate computer dedicated to video surveillance. I have my own poe setup and maintenance is just annoying in order to maintain feature parity with a major service. For a non-techie, it's not even an option. Also indoor cameras are not equivalent to outdoor cameras, especially in terms of cost. It is going to cost a few thousand dollars for a decent non-cloud setup.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by StudentStuff on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:02PM (#18876853)
To pile on, I picked up a few Wyze Cameras for $25ea, reflashed them with Dafang Hacks, and they work perfectly well for catching porch pirates and people coming down my block pulling every car door handle.

No cloud dependence, subscription needed or extra internet bandwidth use.

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by bradknowles on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:06PM (#18876907)
You're still dependent on binary Chinese firmware blobs that these tools are based on. Not something I consider trustworthy.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by userbinator on Thursday January 10, 2019 @04:31PM (#18878416)
The fact that they don't require a cloud/internet connection should relieve much of the worry already... and it's not as if the original firmware wasn't Chinese either.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by throwguooey on Thursday January 10, 2019 @11:49PM (#18881087)
Pretty sure most of the other blobs also come from China.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by chaostheory on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:45PM (#18877339)
> No cloud dependence,

I own a few. I'm pretty sure you need to talk to centralized servers in order to hit your cameras, especially remotely - the time it matters most. Did I miss something?

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by trashcan on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:29PM (#18877758)
The Dafang firmware he flashed allows RTSP so they can be used as generic VOIP cameras. That functionality isn't present in the original firmware.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by StudentStuff on Friday January 11, 2019 @05:48AM (#18882482)
Umm, these cameras offer RTSP streams, not SIP. Wish they offered SIP for use of the mic and speaker though...
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by trashcan on Saturday January 12, 2019 @01:47PM (#18892622)
Haha, sorry. I meant IP cameras, not VOIP.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by cordonbleu on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:39PM (#18877281)
i live in alaska, and there are a lot of undereducated people that do just fine setting up home networked cameras. it isnt difficult to do, and people here really hate "the man" so ring and any other cloud based security is not an option. thats the knee jerk part of it. there is also frequent power interruptions brownouts blackouts. so a lot of people straddle off n on grid. a local surveilance system is the only working option here if you need it to be continuous LAN service. I really do hope a bunch of "snow billies" [self included] are not smarter than HN users.

this just in. Ring is also a "ceiling cat". https://9to5google.com/2019/01/10/ring-camera-live-feed-acce...

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by jbob2000 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:01PM (#18876829)
IKEA can't get people to assemble a fucking box, and you're here telling me that it's totally possible for people to set up their own networked camera system?

Yes, it's possible. No, it's not easy. I've been working as a software dev for like 10 years now and I would happily purchase Ring instead of pulling my hair out for a whole weekend trying to yak-shave[1] my way to a hacked together security camera system.

[1] https://seths.blog/2005/03/dont_shave_that/

Edit: Everyone, just read the replies to my original comment and you will see why Ring is better. There's a million different ways to setup a home camera system, each with their own intricacies and challenges. THIS is why Ring is better. It's the ONE solution that ties together all this technical bullshit that nobody really wants to deal with (unless you're passionate about networking. Which is probably a lot of the users on this board. Which is why I'm probably getting crushed with downvotes).

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by mimixco on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:49PM (#18877989)
The problem is that the original intent of buying such a device has now been subsumed under a tech company and government agenda, the surveillance state. When you see Ring on the shelf everywhere, it isn't advertised as a way to surveil you and your family, to scan your face and report your video and audio to cops.

This reminds me of 23 and Me which acts like it's helping you but, by signing up, you agree to help Big Pharma and cops keep track of you.

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by austhrow743 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @04:45PM (#18878567)
That's a reason to be opposed to Ring. Hell, it's a reason to be opposed to surveillance cameras in general. What it is not, is an argument about the ease of installing your own DVR set up.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by mimixco on Thursday January 10, 2019 @06:26PM (#18879527)
This is true. However, it seemed relevant to the thread.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by Mister_Snuggles on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:52PM (#18876726)
> > A DVR and a set of "old school" network cameras in an internal network have none of those problems

> Ring is a $300 purchase and takes an hour to install. This would take me a few weekends and would cost thousands of dollars. Cloud centralization makes things easier and cheaper, by orders of magnitude.

I have a number of "old school" network cameras and an on-site DVR, it doesn't take "a few weekends" to set everything up.

Adding a camera is simply a matter of following the instructions to connect it to the network. This would be the same process for a Ring or an "old school" camera. Adding a camera to Blue Iris is a 5-15 minute job, depending on how much tweaking you want to do to the motion detection settings.

In terms of implementing from scratch, I picked up a refurbished Windows 10 Pro machine, set up and updated Windows, installed Blue Iris, and added my cameras, in an evening.

Cost-wise, my setup is more expensive than a single Ring camera. However, my incremental costs are a lot cheaper since I can buy sub-$100 cameras instead of $300 ones. There's also no monthly fee, which is nice.

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by bradknowles on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:08PM (#18876924)
Properly installing and maintaining Windows is a full-time job in and of itself, forget everything else.

Not something I want to waste my time on.

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by Mister_Snuggles on Thursday January 10, 2019 @04:00PM (#18878109)
I thought this too, but Windows 10 has needed surprisingly little babysitting in my experience.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by Rebelgecko on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:44PM (#18877323)
Do you have any sort of off-site backup? I think one of the big advantage of the "cloud" cameras vs a home setup is that it's easy to view footage anywhere (I haven't used Blue Iris so maybe they make that easy), and if someone breaks in and steals your computer you'll still have the video somewhere else.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by Mister_Snuggles on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:58PM (#18878083)
I don't. I've thought of building such a thing, but it's not something that I really have a need for.

It's a good consideration though and a definite advantage for the cloud services.

Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by syphilis2 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @02:07PM (#18876916)
There's no monthly fee, but you do have the cost of running that Windows 10 machine. What does that amount to? At 100W and $0.14/kWh I calculate about $10, which is competitive with something like Nest Aware.
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by illumin8 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @05:10PM (#18878776)
Not to mention if you get robbed they're going to take the PC that has your recordings on it, so good luck giving the police footage of your robbers...
Re:For Owners of Ring Security Cameras, Strangers May Have B... by Mister_Snuggles on Thursday January 10, 2019 @04:03PM (#18878143)
This really depends on the machine and how you deploy it. I picked up a refurbished SFF business desktop type of machine and the power draw is only 40-60W (with Blue Iris running and recording from all of my cameras).

This is definitely a consideration though. More cameras and/or higher resolution cameras will result in more power consumption or require a beefier machine.