News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by WalterSear on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @02:58PM (#18868223)
I've been vegan 20 years. Big, socially-censured changes can seem daunting, but anyone who says you can't eat well, and easily, is fooling themselves.

You either live your values, or come to terms with being part of what you don't like about the world.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by agumonkey on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @03:14PM (#18868354)
Not what I was saying. Eating meat is natural, it's been for cosmic ages, and to an extent I have no issue with that. The mass globalized consumption does bother me. I reduce my consumption. I might try vegan but I'll surely miss all the meat based products. Maybe I'll find a middle point by breeding, killing producing it myself so at least I did it on my own, think what you want, there's a form of respect in that. I don't think I will enjoy 100% vegan. Another option is synthetic meat, we'll see.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by fnovd on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @04:22PM (#18869032)
>Eating meat is natural

Relieving yourself outdoors is natural, and we've been doing it for ages. Killing intraspecies rivals/competitors is natural, and we've been doing it for ages. Dying of a preventable disease is natural, and we've been doing it for ages. I don't think we should base our behavior off naturalistic fallacies.

Is eating meat better for your health than abstaining? Usually not. Is eating meat better for the environment? Usually not. It's very easy to just eat meat and dismiss veganism as impractical because that's the socially dominant position to have.

It's easier than ever to transition to a more vegan diet. There are hundreds of replacement products to ease your transition if it's something you care about. There are ethical, environmental, and health-conscious reasons to reduce or eliminate meat consumption. Conversely, many arguments for eating meat are just appeals to tradition or appeals to nature. The industrial production of meat, which is universally detested, actually supplies the vast majority of meat consumed in the US.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by manmal on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:15AM (#18871705)
That’s the most careful vegan pitch I‘ve ever seen, cudos.

I‘m all for reducing meat consumption. We don’t need meat every day, and maybe not even every week. Everybody except meat processing companies would be better off.

My personal view is that complete meat avoidance will lead to long term health challenges, 5-10y down the road. There‘s too much valid-sounding criticism of the china study to just believe its conclusions. Some low-mercury seafood every now and then does loads for your health.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by hi41 on Thursday January 10, 2019 @04:30PM (#18878407)
I have thought about going vegan too. Do you think it would work in all geographical areas? What about people living in very cold regions of earth. They can’t grow crops throughout the year. They have to subsist by hunting fish and other animals. What do you think?
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by mensetmanusman on Thursday January 10, 2019 @07:13AM (#18873298)
Our political and cultural system is largely based on the naturalistic fallicy, one can't blame people too much for following it.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by perfmode on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:23PM (#18875736)
Your comment is an appeal to tradition meant to justify a different appeal to tradition. How interesting.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by omeid2 on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @09:35PM (#18871053)
What is a naturalistic fallacy?
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by fnovd on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @10:04PM (#18871181)
Apparently the concept I was referring to is called appeal to nature, not a naturalistic fallacy.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by spurgu on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @03:36PM (#18868583)
Agreed. I'm vegan but I would definitely not turn down eating animals caught in the wild, especially if I was part of the hunt. But I would also never hunt just for the sport. It's the mass production of intelligent beings* in horrible conditions that bothers me the most.

Fishing is another dilemma. Technically as per above definition eating fish (unless bred) would be fine, but then again we've destroyed so much of the fish population already. If I were out at sea then sure, but just for pleasure right now while being land based? No thanks.

*) this first part of the sentence alone is enough for me to not want to have any part of it

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by quantum_magpie on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @11:33PM (#18871542)
Personally, I'm on completely opposite side.

Nothing detests me more than killing a free creature. I absolutely loathe hunting and fishing, and I wish it was either made completely illegal, or the hunting of the hunters legalized (I heard comments that they do it for the thrill, so having another hunter on your back should be even more exciting!).

I do eat pieces of farmed meat from time to time, though.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by spurgu on Thursday January 10, 2019 @06:49AM (#18873192)
Can't argue against how you feel and yeah I agree it's sad to see a poor animal being hunted down and killed by another animal, or a human, but wild and free animals are constantly getting preyed upon and generally don't die of old age so you're not really adding to their suffering in any way by hunting/killing them.

That said I wouldn't have anything against making hunting hunters legal. :D At least if they're above a certain income level and thus don't have a practical need to hunt.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by LyndsySimon on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:11PM (#18875591)
> That said I wouldn't have anything against making hunting hunters legal. :D At least if they're above a certain income level and thus don't have a practical need to hunt.

I know it's in jest, but I hunt (very occasionally) mostly to remind myself of the reality that the meat I eat comes from the taking of a life. It has nothing to do with physical need.

I think it's much more wrong to eat meat and hide how it is obtained from one's self than it is to stay at least tentatively connected to the reality.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by spurgu on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:21PM (#18875702)
I think that's very good reasoning.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by agumonkey on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @03:42PM (#18868641)
Even gun hunting feels too sadistic to me. I'd use a bow or a rope and that's it. When I'll be too old to jump .. I'll hope I made enough kids to fulfill that role :)
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by mikestew on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @04:16PM (#18868979)
Even gun hunting feels too sadistic to me.

If you think it's sadistic to hunt with the stopping power (and typically quicker death) of a rifle, you're not going to like bow hunting much.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by agumonkey on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @04:49PM (#18869291)
No it's the overwhelming ease of killing a gun offers.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by hoorayimhelping on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @06:18PM (#18870033)
Right. I think the point is, it's much better than the alternative. Which is realizing you missed your shot and the deer you were trying to kill humanely (ya know, to show respect and commune with nature) will now take eight hours to die in slow agony with an arrow sticking out of her cause you can't find where she ran off to.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by agumonkey on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:46AM (#18872454)
I got it, but if you're hunting to feed, you don't harm and let it there.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by agurk on Thursday January 10, 2019 @06:27AM (#18873109)
A well aimed, correctly placed shot of the right type can be exceedingly fatal but it doesn't follow that waving any gun in the general direction of something and carelessly pulling the trigger will achieve that.

Firstly one has to get in the right position to get a good shot. Of course bad hunters could take carefree pot shots, but they would be widely condemned by their peers. The right position means you have to be:

- close enough. Many forms of hunting will take all day to carefully track an animal and if you're lucky at the end of the day take one careful shot

- from the right direction. You wouldn't take a shot from behind the animal

- able to fire safely. You wouldn't fire at an deer on top of a hill as you have to think about where the bullet will go afterwards

Some forms of hunting, like a driven bird shoot can involve just standing and waiting for birds to come in your direction then take careful shots at them. With this type of shooting I can see more resonance with your objection but hitting a moving target is easier said than done and etiquette on these considers a well execute hard shot much better than going for easy ones.

For many other forms of hunting the actual shot is a very small part of the whole activity and whatever weapon is being used makes much less difference.

Then one also has to remember that there are many different types of gun. Take for example using a large caliber rifle and distances over 1km vs hunting with a handgun. Both require huge amounts of skill in handling the weapon on top of the other general hunting skills.

Some countries require a permit to go hunting, which follows a lot of study and then an exam. This material goes into a lot of depth, and actually discharging the weapon is a surprisingly small amount of this material.

Technology-wise a gun is an improvement on exhaustion hunting, or using more primitive projectile weapons, but is far from making the whole process overwhelmingly easy.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by int_19h on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:29AM (#18871961)
What of it? If hunting is actually utilitarian (i.e. for food), there's no ethical issue here. How difficult it is only matters if hunting is a sport, but that's exactly the ethically dubious part of it.

So even in that sense, using a bow is more "sadistic", since it amounts to causing suffering to a living being for the sake of more challenging entertainment for oneself.

(And, of course, a bow would be a lot more painful to the animal, even in the best case of a non-botched shot.)

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by agumonkey on Thursday January 10, 2019 @03:48AM (#18872463)
it's not entertainment, it's about not overpowering, I used bow as an example, maybe it's still too strong (you can kill from afar) but compared to a gun, at least it requires skills to actually kill. Anybody can pull a trigger.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by int_19h on Thursday January 10, 2019 @07:07PM (#18879808)
Again, why does it matter that "at least it requires skill", if it's not for entertainment? And why is "overpowering" a problem? An overly powerful weapon just means that there's more chance of a one-shot kill on the animal, that minimizes suffering (especially from when wounded animals escape, and then slowly die).

If you mean the ability to take more game with a gun than with a bow, that is controlled by hunting licensing and game tags. Without tags and quotas, bow hunters would decimate animal populations just as well, through sheer numbers.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by agumonkey on Friday January 11, 2019 @10:36AM (#18884189)
Suffering is not a problem to me, every creature suffers, I don't pursue it, and it's not for sport; it's for fairness. I can remove a life to feed me if I didn't abuse an unfair position. Everything has to avoid death, it's how nature balances itself, it's almost thermodynamical.. I need the others, I was built for taking and avoiding being taken. ~class struggle in a way.

The skill side is a way to deserve it.

Fishing with a rod in a river versus a large boat with a big net. It's just too easy to wipe fishes without them standing a chance. A gun is similar to me.

I understand that you don't want to inflict pain and I don't want either, but as long as it's ~balanced, it's fair game.

Also, note that these animals have acute senses, hearing, smell.. it's not there for no reason. They also run fast to chase or run away. It's just how it is. I find balance in having to work for it, so I know deeply and appreciate few.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by int_19h on Saturday January 12, 2019 @01:51AM (#18890080)
Like I said, the proper way to ensure we don't wipe anything out is licensing and tag system, which is implemented in pretty much every country, and is enforced meticulously in any developed one.

And that all is completely orthogonal to tools used. I guarantee you that if you only allowed hunting with e.g. a wooden spear, but removed any other restrictions, deer would be wiped out very quickly in US. There's just too many people, and in such a large population a subset that is both skilled and interested is "large enough".

But in any case, your original comment accused people who hunt with guns of sadism. Which very different than fairness.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by agurk on Thursday January 10, 2019 @09:23AM (#18873998)
I spoke to an older hunter in New Zealand once who said he initially started with a view like yours. He was into rifle marksmanship, and didn't see the point in shooting at a live target.

He had a friend who said it was harder than he thought, and invited him to come along sometime and see if he found it easy. Of course he went out, and even when lead in the direction of the deer couldn't manage to get one.

After that he was hooked. He had a similar story about eating the offal from the deer, and now thinks it's among the best bits.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by exclusiv on Friday January 11, 2019 @01:23PM (#18885574)
I've seen it surprisingly easy. I went on a deer hunt in Texas and the ranch owner had all these automatic feeders that ring a bell when they drop the feed. So the deer just show up on cue and they had blinds all over the property.

More like target practice than hunting in my opinion. They did get a ton of game management tags and they were really targeting the non-typical deer (ones with messed up racks).

So it was a sad kind of "hunting" but did seem to serve a purpose.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by agumonkey on Thursday January 10, 2019 @01:04PM (#18876244)
It might not be trivial but it's infinitely easier. The speed and energy, the range ..
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @03:26PM (#18868477)
> Eating meat is natural, it's been for cosmic ages, and to an extent I have no issue with that.

That's true, but I think a similar argument can be made that any situation where the more powerful control the less powerful is natural, e.g. slavery, patriarchy, etc.

That said, I think the first step for everyone is to realize the cognitive dissonance that modern society tries to keep in place when it comes to eating meat (i.e. meat is just a nice, tasty hunk of protein that comes wrapped in plastic and styrofoam from the grocery storeand is in no way related to that adorable cow video I saw on Instagram). If that were more common I think many people would try to at least consume animal products more humanely as you have suggested.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by agumonkey on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @03:31PM (#18868529)
I was thinking about pre settlers hunting, where humans were only slightly above other animals (and in some land, probably on par or below).

I agree that last 50 years made us completely oblivious to reality. Which is probably the first reason for waste and over consumption.

our grandparents still lived in an era where they were a lot close to nature (vegies or animal) they used to do that with their own hands. To me that's the least you can do. And it has a lot of individual and social benefits too. You know more what is around, you enjoy more what you have, it creates group rituals.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by pathseeker on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @04:52PM (#18869316)
>meat is just a nice, tasty hunk of protein that comes wrapped in plastic and styrofoam from the grocery storeand is in no way related to that adorable cow video I saw on Instagram

Honest question. Are people this ignorant? I grew up around ranches so the source of meat is blindingly obvious to me. Are people really seeing beef in the grocery store as magic that comes from nowhere?

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by the_gastropod on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @05:23PM (#18869594)
I don't think people are necessarily that ignorant. But the dirty business of slaughtering animals has been hidden away from public eye extremely well. There's a certain "out of sight out of mind" aspect to it.

If, to eat meat, people had to kill the animal themselves, what proportion of meat eaters do you think would continue the practice? I obviously don't know the answer, but I suspect it would be far less than 100%.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by icebraining on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @06:24PM (#18870068)
If the urban dwellers like me suddenly had to kill their own prey, I agree we'd see a surge of vegans. But on the other hand, I think that's also because that disconnect allows people to think about cows as "cute". The people I know who grew up raising and killing their own animals have a much more utilitarian view of the matter.

It could be that the alienation brought by modern slaughter is the keystone in bringing about a substantial reduction in the number of eaters of animals; now that would be ironic!

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by feintruled on Thursday January 10, 2019 @07:42AM (#18873408)
Fascinating thought. Echoes Seamus Heaney's poem The Early Purges about farm life, especially the line "living displaces false sentiments" and "'Prevention of cruelty' talk cuts ice in town/Where they consider death unnatural" https://www.poemhunter.com/poem/the-early-purges/
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by yesenadam on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @05:09PM (#18869477)
I haven't eaten meat in nearly 30 years, and literally haven't missed it once, ever. Have never craved it at all. I guess I wouldn't have expected that!

It feels strange writing 'have never craved it'...ghoulish or something. Vegetarianism/veganism just becomes a habit, and once you're outside the, er, 'meat world', you can see the brainwashing, it's not pretty. All those heart-warming tv ads for eating lamb etc. (Kill and eat cute little sheep!??) The word 'meat' sounds...well, something akin to how 'long pig' sounds - somewhat disturbing. (I did a cartoon once of a cow saying "Hi! I'm a meat animal.") I hate how the fish in the oceans are referred to as 'fish stock', as if they only exist as food for humans. It bugs me more that humans are eating them all, and polluting the oceans with nets in doing it!

Personally, I'm a lazy vegan - I do vegan shopping, but don't refuse everything offered with some dairy in it. That would be a pain. Cheesy dishes just don't taste good to me now, they seem...smelly (e.g. it's getting harder to find pesto without cheese added..blech) But I infrequently think about what I eat or don't. Apart from these few times on HN, I haven't thought about it in years. I was more of a vegan activist when young...but I don't think I changed anyone's mind. It seems almost impossible for someone to see that something nearly everyone does is totally unethical. I can't remember what flipped the switch in my head. I think it just dawned on me one day.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by goldenkey on Thursday January 10, 2019 @08:12AM (#18873540)
If an act is selfless, and the opposite is socially accepted, you won't find many takers.. The ethics matter and I'm sure huge swathes of people are in denial and subscribed to the fallacies listed above in this thread - but ultimately it comes down to doing what is right when no one is checking you except for a few high level thinkers and the universe itself.

It also takes commitment. I've been vegan before and I'm trying it again - usually stomach problems force me to at least retain cheese. I think with Elmhurst's new peanut protein shakes, Ill be able to stick to it. Give the vanilla one a try - they are amazing and so much better than soy.

https://elmhurst1925.com/shop/protein-shakes.html

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by leaf_house on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @08:55PM (#18870888)
Why not set yourself the challenge of only eating ethically farmed animal products? I think you’d find this ends up leading to a mostly vegan lifestyle unless you’re willing to devote considerable time and money.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by agumonkey on Thursday January 10, 2019 @04:42AM (#18872655)
I almost considered moving to start a farming thing with a relative.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by majani on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @05:20PM (#18869582)
Even in the growing and harvesting of plants, large amounts of animals get killed in the process. The moles underground, the rabbits and hares that eat the plants, the rats and snakes that shelter in the piles of harvest etc, they all have to be killed en masse to ensure a good harvest. Given this fact, veganism appears to me like a refusal to accept the reality that this world is a harsh one full of chaos. I prefer to focus on sustainable consumption as the reasonable balance between the two extremes of veganism and American fast food.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by fnovd on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @05:28PM (#18869651)
The largest consumer of crops grown in the United States are our farmed animals. Eating soybeans directly instead of sending them to factory farms reduces the amount of animals killed, both in the factories and on the fields. There is no trade-off in terms of animal death when switching to a plant-based diet. You are always killing fewer animals.
Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by goldenkey on Thursday January 10, 2019 @08:18AM (#18873583)
Torture is the main ethical reason to not eat meat. You are right about death - we all die, nothing new there. But doing the right thing is never about purity - its about choosing the actions that cause the least bad will.

Torture and Death should not be chosen over Incidental Death if one wants to be honest about acting with pragmatic good will.

Re:Penguin travels every year to visit man who rescued him (... by leaf_house on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @08:58PM (#18870896)
This is a common logical fallacy used to justify your current lifestyle. Veganism is not about moral purity, its about the tangible impact of your actions.