News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by russley on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @12:56PM (#18857670)
Ironic that a site about GDPR compliance has 6 potential trackers according to Privacy Badger.
Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by lmkg on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @01:36PM (#18858092)
Which might be fine, depending on their privacy policy. Let's take a look...

Their privacy policy indicates they are claiming Legitimate Interest as the legal basis for using Google Analytics. My network tab also sees hits form ShareThis and Facebook, which are not mentioned in the Privacy Policy. There's a section on Embedded Content, but I don't see any content embedded in the privacy policy itself.

https://gdpr.eu/privacy-policy/

I will say this does a good job of being straightforward and readable, and covering what a privacy policy needs to cover. But it's still incomplete with regards to what data is being sent where.

Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by bad_user on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @05:36AM (#18863735)
Except Google Analytics cannot be a "legitimate interest".

A legitimate interest is one that prevents the service from operating. E.g. if you're a pizza delivery service, you need to use the customer's address, since it's implicit in what the service does and the customer expects you to use their address for the purpose of home delivery.

If you block Google Analytics however, in what way will the service be impacted from the perspective of the user experience? There is no impact, even if this costs the business optimization opportunities or money. You can argue that the inability to use Google Analytics can have a long term impact on user experience, but that's not how legitimate interests work.

In general, "making more money" or "becoming more popular" are invalid reasons for stating a legitimate interest.

Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by fixermark on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @01:37PM (#18858104)
GDPR compliance doesn't imply that tracking is disallowed, right? The GDPR specifies the allowed, legal protocols for tracking users and consumer behavior on sites.
Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by richardwhiuk on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @02:45PM (#18858910)
Which includes a firm opt-in, which none of these does.
Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by lmkg on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @03:21PM (#18859274)
IF the legal basis for processing is Consent, then that consent needs to be opt-in and freely given.

If. If if if if IF IF IF.

Consent is not the only legal basis for processing. This website in particular claims Legitimate Interest as their legal basis for Google Analytics. If you can support a claim of Legitimate Interest, then none of the restrictions specific to Consent apply. Starting with opt-in vs out-out.

Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by robin_reala on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @12:37AM (#18862556)
You’re not allowed to store personal data in GA by their own terms of service, so the argument is moot: neither consent nor legitimate interest is needed.
Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by xg15 on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @05:30PM (#18860399)
True - however wouldn't "legitimate interest" be subject to precedents and also depend on what exactly you're tracking?

As a layman I'd assume that if one site gets to claim Google Analytics as "legitimate interest", this would imply GA being fair game for any site, provided they don't do anything special with it.

Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by zorga on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @08:13PM (#18861439)
Which is fair; I shouldn't have to ask for consent from the user to have analytics on my site. Having analytics is a necessary part of running a web app successfully.
Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by chopin on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @04:38AM (#18863530)
This doesn't imply GA, sending data to a third party (and one of the worst offenders with respect to privacy at that). The same can be achieved solely by first party means. It's just not that convenient.
Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by richardwhiuk on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @12:21PM (#18866581)
I don't think the EU would agree with that, but IANAL.
Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by zorga on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @12:28PM (#18866659)
I don't care what the EU agrees to, there's this thing called national sovereignty; I'm not subject to the laws of every country that simply asserts I am. The world cannot function if we're subject to every law every country decides to claim we're subject to.
Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by scaryclam on Tuesday January 08, 2019 @03:23PM (#18859288)
IIF they are processing personally identifying information.
Re:Complete guide to GDPR compliance by M2Ys4U on Wednesday January 09, 2019 @06:20AM (#18863912)
Personal data, not personally identifying information.

The former is a lot broader then the latter (and the latter is a US legal term and means precisely nothing in the EU).