To which I replied, "What about the weeding out and approval process required for candidates?"
To which he replied, "Well, you can't have a sheep herder run for President and win."
On that basis, I believe America has proven the supremacy of its democracy, for better or worse.
Bill Clinton came from poverty, had no father, was a nobody governor for Arkansas with a mixed record of success in politics. He defeated a very powerful patriarch of the Bush dynasty - former CIA head, former Vice President, WW2 hero, former member of Congress - who was backed by Ronald Reagan (an extraordinarily popular President). He also defeated one of the richest and most famous people in the country at the time in Ross Perot (of course some would say Perot actually defeated Bush, which is interesting as well as Perot was a political outsider).
Barack Obama had no father in a similar manner as Bill Clinton. Grew up in a still difficult time to be half white and half black, raised by a white family. He didn't come from a dynasty or impressive wealth. He admitted doing drugs, admitted being interested in alternative culture and Marxist ideas in his youth. He got soundly elected by knocking the more conservative Clinton dynasty out of the way, despite the enormity of the money and support behind Hillary Clinton.
Donald Trump, a billionaire, was opposed by nearly every layer of power in the US, including nearly all of the media, nearly all celebrities, nearly all journalists, and including nearly the entire Republican Party and most of its big money backers. He's the first political outsider to win the Presidency in more than a century and is still openly opposed at every step by the same forces that opposed his candidacy.
Bernie Sanders - openly a Socialist in a nation that has historically aggressively rejected most variations of Socialism - came one step away from competing with Trump for the Presidency. He had to be thwarted by his own party, sabotaged in numerous ways, to prevent that outcome. That is a case where the more powerful group prevailed using under-handed tactics. However it's non-the-less impressive how far Sanders got, when most of the system clearly opposed him and his policies.
It's blatantly clear the US system isn't only different by appearances. It still enables outcomes that would be impossible if it were truly only an oligarchy style pre-selected system (this is where I acknowledge that the US does have aspects of pre-selection and some oligarchy-like power structures, it's obvious). All the power structures in the US opposed Trump and still do, including essentially all of its wealthiest persons; he flat-out was not supposed to win. Hillary Clinton, as the more powerful dynastic insider candidate, would have won against either Obama or Trump if the US primarily operated by pre-selection (Trump would have never gotten beyond Jeb Bush in that case).
https://www.ranker.com/list/the-twelve-worst-us-presidents-b...
Or a progressive Democrat like Bernie Sanders.
>> Well, you can't have a sheep herder run for President and win.
> Or a progressive Democrat like Bernie Sanders.
No one was stopping Sanders from running as an independent.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-google-hacking-idUSTRE750...
This seems reasonably accurate. The gov has complete access to Wechat's data and can create, edit, or destroy any content they choose. They regularly run ML algorithms across the whole network to identify whatever they want. They can't do this with Facebook or WhatsApp.
The domestic Chinese social networks are fully staffed with censors [1] and likely police surveillance, so it would obviously be more difficult and dangerous for Chinese people to organize on them. The great firewall blocks the foreign that aren't willing to fully participate in that censorship and surveillance regime and that are large enough to be a threat, and the Communist Party likely judges the foreign operators to be less reliable partners in any case.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/02/business/china-internet-c...
Another factor that makes domestic Chinese websites a poor choice for political organizing and activism is the PRC government's efforts to make all web activity traceable to a national ID number. Why do you think it's now difficult to impossible to buy a activated SIM card at a corner shop, and why WIFI access points and most websites require an access code be sent by text message before you can get online or create an account?
> Finally, almost non of my Chinese friends who live in the west use FB even though they have the liberty to do so.
I don't use FB even though I have the liberty to do so.
> Again, somebody has to be quite ignorant not to see FB as a national security treat.
There are some very important distinctions that you're missing. The free exchange of ideas among citizens is not a national security threat unless you're a regime that is opposed to human rights [2] [3]. The issue with Facebook is really one of state-sponsored impersonation.
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Document_Number_Nine
[3] https://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/20/world/asia/chinas-new-lea...
No. The great firewall is mainly there to prevent the Chinese people from organizing and disseminating information in ways that challenge the government [1]. They want to prevent something like the Arab Spring or the color revolutions [2].
Since you bring up Russian election interference: some Chinese government actions on the internet actually resemble Russian troll armies more than anything else [3].
[1] https://gking.harvard.edu/publications/how-censorship-china-...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_Spring
[3] https://gking.harvard.edu/50c
> Yes, China has elections.
So have the Soviet Union and all kinds of dictatorships [4]. There's a big difference between having party-controlled "elections" and free and fair elections. The PRC most certainly does not have the latter.
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Election#Sham_election