However, I believe we found that Apple would alter the binary prior to release so we couldn't even guarantee the binary Apple was producing was ours. So it was not possible to allow users a way to validate even from the time of our closed-source build.
Alternatively, they can make it paid, shared source to allow inspections while simultaneously making money. If aiming for contributions to paid source (eg bug fixes or feature improvements), they can make the licenses irrevocable per version with the OS interfacing parts permissive, open source with allowance to swap them out as desired. So, the old version could be updated legally for new platforms giving potentially, perpetual ROI. People wanting upgrades or security fixes have to buy the new version or maintain a subscription.
I mean, nothing would stop people from just doing that themselves with the source shared. I just figure lots of paying customers will stay paying customers switching for reasons having nothing to do with source license. They move for all kinds of non-security, non-philosophical reasons.
https://reproducible-builds.org/docs/sharing-certifications/
and this is a good explanation about Mozilla's plan for logging Binary Transparency results:
Of course, not being FOSS is a pity, a trade-off. But I believe their 'solid business' would be made impossible then. (Unless someone invests $50 million or so - but frankly I prefer the status quo).
Uhm... Would one be able to verify that? Threema is a swiss company, and Switzerland is known for their high standards in terms of privacy. Would it be possible to see who owns the shares of Threema the company?
In contrast, the silicon valley idea of a startup is "get as much investor money as you can get, grow your team quickly, become a unicorn, sell your company and cash out, rinse and repeat".
Both have their advantages and disadvantages, but especially for privacy focused products I prefer to get those from companies that finance themselves, and that don't have big VC investors which will want to see big ROI sooner or later. If the startup behind a free product I use is sold, then my user data is sold with the company. And usually financial interests stand above privacy considerations. (Obviously, otherwise the investors wouldn't invest.)
Money is power. Ideally your money comes from your users.
Are there any IMs that actually have these?
[1] https://f-droid.org/en/2018/08/16/twif-17-the-reproducible-b...
https://threema.ch/en/faq/source_code
Yes, they sent some source code for security review in 2015, but there is no guarantee that the binary you download is related to that source code at all.
Nowadays I'd expect a secure messaging app to not just be open source, but also have reproducible builds (checked by third parties). It would be nice to have Binary Transparency too, so that people can check that they are being offered the same binary as other users are getting.