News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by coldtea on Sunday January 06, 2019 @08:49AM (#18838277)
>Anyone can probably reach the top 5% in most non-athletic areas given enough time.

At any given time, only the 5% of the population can reach the top 5% in any area.

If anybody could do it and e.g. just 10% did it, then there would be a new 5% (the top 50% of that 10%), and the rest 50% wouldn't be in.

>Thus, I'm a big fan of Peter Theils advice to work on things that satisfy the property that: "if you weren't working on it, this problem would not get solved".

Which is a self-aggrandising way for Theils to say that he helped solve some problems that wouldn't have been solved otherwise.

Unless you have tons of means to contribute (e.g. billions) to some cause, the idea starting out as some e.g. college student that "this problem wont be solved without my help" is 99.9999% BS.

Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by notsofastbuddy on Sunday January 06, 2019 @08:59AM (#18838323)
There aren't very many axes along which >5% of the population actively try to improve themselves. This makes it easy to reach the top 5% if one is trying.
Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by jcoffland on Sunday January 06, 2019 @10:58AM (#18838916)
>> Anyone can probably reach the top 5% in most non-athletic areas given enough time.

> At any given time, only the 5% of the population can reach the top 5% in any area.

I believe the GP is saying you can be in the top 5% of a chosen field, if you try, because other people are pursuing other things. So 100% of the population could be in the top 5% of something.

Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by achillesheels on Sunday January 06, 2019 @05:32PM (#18841169)
I strongly agree with this. So much antagonism in society, however, arises when people aim for the wrong 5%, e.g. a 5’6 basketball player aiming to make the NBA. Now, such a baller is more directly confronted with his low outcome, but most of the world is not so apparent with people’s preconceived objectives which are often ego-emergent.

This is where I find deep meaning in the Cervantes quote, “The road is always better than the inn.” Accepting the outcome of the admixture of own’s controllable action and the infinitely greater uncontrollable action of the world as positive can go a long way to a kind of stoic peace and ultimately happiness with one’s worldly produce.

Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by southerndrift on Sunday January 06, 2019 @09:58AM (#18838607)
The ratio between goals and people is not 1:1.

With enough specialization, everybody can become the best in one specific topic. That's the game most phd students play.

Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by late2part on Sunday January 06, 2019 @01:15PM (#18839651)
That’s reasonable. Also, solved goals entice new goals to be created for others.
Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by coldtea on Monday January 07, 2019 @02:55AM (#18843546)
>With enough specialization, everybody can become the best in one specific topic. That's the game most phd students play.

Given the rapid devaluation of Phds (never mind the big debts), it doesn't serve them very well in most areas of science...

Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by tw1010 on Sunday January 06, 2019 @09:02AM (#18838330)
Just because something is social signaling (which it undoubtedly is in Theils case), doesn't mean it isn't true, and that you shouldn't follow the advice.
Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by coldtea on Monday January 07, 2019 @06:15AM (#18844338)
Just because a "virtue signaling" statement can also be true, doesn't in any way infer that his advice is good.

If anything, it gives him a motive to say it (virtue signal) which is not "to tell the truth".

So, the advice might very well be true and we should very well follow it. But thus far we have absolutely no arguments as to if that's the case.

Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by tw1010 on Monday January 07, 2019 @09:47AM (#18845502)
You're prematurely moving the debate one abstraction layer up, making the issue about the whether a general virtue signal can ever contain truth. (That's an interesting discussion and I agree with you that it's definitely likely that virtue signaling statements are less truthful in general than "honest" statements.) Had you looked down on the concrete statement we're discussing, clearly no argument would be needed. Clearly it's good advice to "do things which wouldn't be done if you wouldn't be there to solve it", what's there even to argue about.
Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by drieddust on Sunday January 06, 2019 @09:53AM (#18838589)
> Which is a self-aggrandising way for Theils to say that he helped solve some problems that wouldn't have been solved otherwise.

Exactly, I started reading his book Zero to One and quickly dropped it into trash-bin after scanning randomly. I am not sure why it got rated so high. In my view entire advise boils down to create businesses in uncharted territories and create a monopolies around them.

Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by opan on Sunday January 06, 2019 @09:04PM (#18842183)
I don't think it's about money. One example I immediately think of is the various free software projects that are short on people who care and have time to work on it. Often I find something that seems interesting to me but hasn't been worked on in months. I can't yet program, but I always think "if I had the skills, I could just work on this myself right now". It's not that I'm special in this, except that I care and not everyone does.
Re:Ask HN: How did you decide what problems to solve in your... by Aeolun on Sunday January 06, 2019 @09:56AM (#18838600)
I don’t think it matters much whether or not it’s actually true. What matters is that you believe it.

Also, there’s a ton of fairly specific problems that haven’t been solved yet, so chances of someone working on it are small.