News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by bhaak on Saturday January 05, 2019 @06:05PM (#18834919)
Both projects seem to put the blame on the other project. IMO, there are at least two other factions that can be blamed equally well.

First, nvidia for not providing OSS drivers and second, the user who runs an OS on hardware that can't be properly supported on this OS at the moment.

For years I have the rule that I prefer hardware that has proper Linux support. Even going a bit further that I try not to buy hardware that doesn't have OSS drivers unless there really is no other option (nowadays, that means mostly smartphones).

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by nickysielicki on Saturday January 05, 2019 @06:17PM (#18834996)
> nvidia for not providing OSS drivers

It's worse than this. Nvidia does not merely not provide open source drivers, they actively preclude work on Nouveau.

Phoronix link: https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=Nouveau-...

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by bhaak on Saturday January 05, 2019 @06:30PM (#18835085)
Ouch, that's mean. IMHO the only way to react to that is to close down shop. Ideally including Linux throwing out support for Nvidia cards.

I have a strong opinion on this as I was involved a few years ago in the Kindle homebrew community. After a while I decided that my time could be used better than on a product by a company that tries to prevent us from making his product better and more interesting to its users.

There is so much energy and time wasted when you have to fight against the manufacturing company and in the case of a graphics card, the result is that it just works as well as the other graphics card option that is fully supported OOTB. And then that's just for a piece of hardware that you can replace on average for a few hundred bucks.

Is that really worth the hassle?

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by zanny on Saturday January 05, 2019 @08:13PM (#18835629)
I've personally actively avoided buying anything with Nvidia hardware in it for 8 years now because of how awful their software business is. That has meant I've even skipped over tablets and phones using their chips and will never buy a Nintendo Switch because... well... firstly consoles are bullshit crippling perfectly good computers with proprietary OSes but secondly because it has an Nvidia chip in it.

I tell everyone I know not to buy Nvidia, I have built gaming computers both professionally and for family that I've actively advised against buying Nvidia parts for because of their business practices, and when I buy notebooks its a real PITA to get one without some Nvidia GPU in it but I do that too.

But Linux cannot "throw out" support for Nvidia. Nvidias driver is wholly independent of Linux, its why its such a PITA to work with. Its a DKMS blob driver and way too much other useful stuff depends on that interface to break it just to stop Nvidia. Fortunately nobody is going out of their way to support Nvidia either, such as their stupid attempt to fragment Wayland development with eglstreams nonsense.

The most valuable thing any of us can do is constantly decry Nvidia for being the reprehensible company they are and use what influence we have over those we know to distance them from buying their products the same way you should distance friends and family from buying Nestle or Exxon products or should avoid shopping at Walmart.

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by zhobbs on Sunday January 06, 2019 @01:47AM (#18836975)
If you do any machine learning you'll likely still need Nvidia for CUDA, it was the deal breaker for going AMD in my case.
Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by tntn on Saturday January 05, 2019 @11:56PM (#18836657)
Would you mind giving an overview of their reprehensible business practices for those of us who just buy GPUs without following the companies?
Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by SXX on Sunday January 06, 2019 @04:13AM (#18837410)
I'm nowhere as fanatical about it since when it's come to corporations there is no black and white, but there at least few cases I can recall:

* Even decade ago they did a lot of shady stuff when they initially separated GeForce and Quadro series. There was time when you can make little hardware mod on Geforce product that make driver think you have Quadro and magically a FP64 become twice faster and CAD application performance was doubled and tripled.

* Their OpenGL implementation was ever non-standard and allowed both code and shaders to work in situation where it's clearly should not. As result games and apps that was debugged on Nvidia hardware would never work on more conformant Intel / AMD drivers.

* In terms of Nouveau back in 2014 Nvidia started to require signed firmware files [0]. They promised shortly after to provide Nouveau with the files with clear licensing, but it took years. When files were finally released everything related to power management was missing and still not released until this day. So Nouveau can't implement recloking. On top of that they intentionally obfuscate the way firmware files stored within driver binary and also make GPU load firmware via DMA to make extraction much harder.

* Sabotaging of OpenCL in general by not implementing spec for years and keeping it generally much slower that it's supposed to be.

* Several years ago Nvidia twice added checks to their Windows drivers to stop consumer GPU drivers to work when passed into virtual machines. Both bypassed by hiding KVM identifier and changing HyperV hv_vendor_id, but it's was annoying [1].

* Nvidia forbidden to use consumer hardware drivers in datacenters [2]

* Nvidia tried to push some crazy anti competitive program to make exclusive deals with GPU vendors so they can't sell AMD GPUs in any kind of "gaming" product lines [3]

Again it's not like AMD is perfect, but that's a lot of shady stuff and I likely not even listed half of it.

[0] https://hardware.slashdot.org/story/14/09/27/1254219/nvidia-...

[1] http://vfio.blogspot.com/2014/08/vfiovga-faq.html

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16002068

[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16675557

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by zozbot123 on Sunday January 06, 2019 @05:10AM (#18837574)
> There was time when you can make little hardware mod on Geforce product that make driver think you have Quadro and magically a FP64 become twice faster and CAD application performance was doubled and tripled.

Do you think that overclocking a CPU clock is "magic", too? You were just running the hardware out of spec! Yes, FP64 and CAD were a lot faster, whatever; are you going to trust these faster-reached results to be always correct? Or that the card isn't going to break down in the midst of some important workload? The whole point of labeling something "Quadro" is to say "these cards are good for that sort of critical stuff - they've been extensively tested for reliability".

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by throwaway2021 on Sunday January 06, 2019 @07:41AM (#18838048)
What's bad about Nestle? I know their products are very expensive, but aside from that? Care to elaborate?
Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by purerandomness on Sunday January 06, 2019 @08:59AM (#18838322)
Among the most recent ones, lobbying for water privatization: https://www.google.com/search?client=opera&q=nestle+water+pr...

And the usual reliance on Palm Tree Oil, as another example

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by quietbritishjim on Sunday January 06, 2019 @08:59AM (#18838319)
This is a reference to the baby milk scandal [1]. Nestlé would market their powdered baby milk in developing countries as being better than breast milk, even though it's not. Worse than that, they would give away samples to new mothers for free or a substantially reduced price, who would then lose the ability to lactate because they're because they're not actively doing it. After that they would be forced to buy the powder, and not all of them could afford it.

This was at its worse in the late 1970s, but it seems the practice hasn't entirely stopped even today

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nestlé_boycott

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by xvilka on Sunday January 06, 2019 @03:36AM (#18837308)
If everyone from FOSS world will show them the middle finger like Linus did, maybe, just maybe they will become friendlier a bit. But our only true hope if this company will go bankrupt and out of the market.
Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by zozbot123 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @06:30PM (#18835084)
Well, not quite. The charitable way to put it is that they are requiring signed firmware in hardware, in order to help stem fraud by 3rd party resellers (where some card model X is sold to naïve buyers as a more desirable model Y, with a hacked firmware to match) and project noveau is obviously impacted.
Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by SXX on Sunday January 06, 2019 @04:23AM (#18837429)
Problem is that Nvidia did much more than just signing firmware:

* Separated firmware that needed for basic and fully functional driver and given Nouveau only bits they wanted.

* Obfuscated and hidden firmware files within the driver binaries so they harder to extract.

* Changed loading process so GPU read it via DMA to make reverse engineering of firmware loading harder.

It's pretty clear that all of that was exclusively done to harm Nouveau.

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by wolfgke on Saturday January 05, 2019 @09:16PM (#18835978)
> It's worse than this. Nvidia does not merely not provide open source drivers, they actively preclude work on Nouveau.

If the noveau developers had true hacker spirit, they would move nouveau development into the darknet.

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by izacus on Saturday January 05, 2019 @07:02PM (#18835270)
> First, nvidia for not providing OSS drivers and second, the user who runs an OS on hardware that can't be properly supported on this OS at the moment.

nVidia does provide perfectly working closed source drivers on Linux though - how is it their fault that some 3rd party implementation of the drivers doesn't work in a stable manner?

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by bhaak on Saturday January 05, 2019 @08:42PM (#18835786)
Define "perfectly working". If I download the Linux sources, compile the kernel and install it, there is no official Nvidia driver to be seen.

I didn't say that Nvidia is at fault for the state of the nouveau driver. I said they are at fault for not providing OSS drivers. Nvidia doesn't want to play by the rules of Linux development but they still want to be on Linux. That's legally possible but why should the user or distro manager give Nvidia a pass here when other companies play by the rules?

Think about it. Which components would you be willing to download drivers for if they weren't OSS? Your monitor? Your sound card? Your harddisk? Your network card (oops)? Your mouse or keyboard?

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by gmueckl on Saturday January 05, 2019 @09:38PM (#18836129)
If you download the current Windows ISO image and install that offline, you won't get a proper driver for your nVidia card either. Yet, this is accepted as normal.

Some Linux distributions that do not hamper themselves artificially on philosophical grounds offer nvidia binary drivers in their package repositories like they do with every other driver they contain. Your focus on the kernel sources is too narrow.

There absolutely was a time when you had to download all these drivers you mention separately - for Windows. And people put up with it. I think even today the Windows installer is forced to offer an option to install 3rd party RAID controller drivers into the installation environment...

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by pard68 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @11:51PM (#18836641)
Parent is referring to the fact the Linux drivers are meant to be baked into the kernel and Nvidia doesn't wish to play ball.

You can't compare Linux and Windows when it comes to drivers, they have different methods of providing those drivers.

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Sunday January 06, 2019 @01:52AM (#18836986)
Yeah, and Linux's insistence on not having a stable ABI for drivers is problematic for Nvidia, just as Nvidia's insistence on not open sourcing their drivers is problematic for Linux.
Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by gmueckl on Sunday January 06, 2019 @02:27AM (#18837093)
I can fully compare those, your wish to the contrary nonwithstanding:

- both are viable desktop operating systems

- nVidia successfully and consistently releases high quality video drivers for both

Re:Chromium blacklists Nouveau by TheChaplain on Sunday January 06, 2019 @04:35AM (#18837459)
I installed Ubuntu last month, I didn't do anything special and the nVidia drivers are running on my system providing excellent gaming experience.

So to me it seems to work just fine.