News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is there hope for IPv6? by wongarsu on Saturday January 05, 2019 @12:09PM (#18832745)
There are great apps "requiring" end-to-end connectivity. Cryptocurrency clients, various videochat solutions, many multiplayer games, bittorrent clients, etc. They either force you to set up port forwarding (unless they can do it themselves using UPnP), or they use STUN/ICE or any of the other NAT traversal techniques. As a last resort it's often sufficient if enough of your users are reachable from the outside and the rest can connect to them.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NAT_traversal#Techniques

Re:Is there hope for IPv6? by paulddraper on Saturday January 05, 2019 @12:46PM (#18832988)
Exactly. We already have "the killer app". Or several killers apps. But we also have a NAT punching.

And that works. Does it take blood and tears to make it work? Certainly. But not so many to make it infeasible.

Re:Is there hope for IPv6? by Canada on Sunday January 06, 2019 @09:32AM (#18838484)
Where it would be really great is mobile. It would make voice and video apps so much better if users who trust each other could directly connect without the latency adding rendezvous host. It would also need some sort of authenticated uPnP like protocol for telling the carrier when to allow traffic through their firewall though. I wouldn’t want random hosts to be able to waste my precious battery and bandwidth by sending unwanted traffic for my phone to process and discard.
Re:Is there hope for IPv6? by Gibbon1 on Saturday January 05, 2019 @01:51PM (#18833440)
Consumer IOT devices really should be peer to peer so it just works without the manufacturer having to deal with security issues on the server side. And because there are two types of IOT providers, those that don't want your data nor the security headaches that entails;those whose business model is about spying on people.
Re:Is there hope for IPv6? by wongarsu on Saturday January 05, 2019 @01:58PM (#18833492)
If your IOT device doesn't connect to the internet, then there isn't an issue to begin with (peer to peer on IPV4 works great within your own WIFI, and other non-IP protocols on a different frequency are usually a better choice anyways).

If it does connect to the internet, I would rather have the device phone to one server only, and that server handling public access. It's much easier to keep one server secure than millions of devices that are in the hands of customers.

Of course my prefered option are IOT devices talking to one hub I control in my network, and me deciding how I want to expose that hub. But in that case, peer-to-peer communication is a non-issue just like in the first case.