News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by sneakernets on Friday January 04, 2019 @12:34PM (#18825863)
Is anyone surprised that assigning numbers to people to identify them seems to backfire every time it's tried?
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by test6554 on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:31PM (#18826425)
The government should issue a public/private key to every citizen/resident and provide a verification service that companies can use to verify a citizen's identity without the citizen having to hand over any secret information.

They could even optionally store one or more profiles that you could use for streamlining your interactions with various private industries: financial services, health care, employment, shopping, and travel could all have separate datasets about you stored for convenience.

Then when you want to do business with a company, you grant them access to the appropriate profile. When you conclude your business, you revoke access.

The same would be great for phone and email networks. Basically instead of giving someone your contact info, you give them a voucher to contact you. They call or email to the service and include the voucher (all automated) and the service either forwards it along or ignores it based on whether the voucher is valid. And you can invalidate any voucher at any time for any reason.

For people that like things simple, they could use a single voucher for everything, but for people who want more control they could do separate vouchers for everyone, or some easier middle-ground like family, friends, professional, commercial, and misc.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by sbarre on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:52PM (#18826588)
Yeah until the government database gets compromised and all the private keys get leaked.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by pariahHN on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:19PM (#18826854)
This isn't how asymmetric encryption works - government would store public keys, users would manage their own private keys +/- passphrases. If there was a breach at central storage, the only thing that could possibly be taken would be the public keys which by definition are useless for anything other than verifying a signed message or encrypting a message to the holder of the private key.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by sbarre on Saturday January 05, 2019 @09:45AM (#18831867)
You're right, my mistake!
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by user5994461 on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:02PM (#18826696)
They couldn't be leaked, they would be in the hands of the people. The government only needs a public key.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by colejohnson66 on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:06PM (#18826730)
Then when the user inevitable loses their private key? Not everyone is tech savvy enough.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by BenjiWiebe on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:10PM (#18826769)
Then use an annoying lengthy in person procedure to issue a new one.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by bashinator on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:25PM (#18826908)
Make issuance and re-issuing of the key contingent on DNA verification.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by andrewla on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:03PM (#18827166)
... so the government has a copy of your DNA on file? What about when that database gets compromised?
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by sneakernets on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:49PM (#18827479)
That would be some pretty impressive skills to fake DNA.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by andrewla on Friday January 04, 2019 @04:33PM (#18827839)
I was referring more to the privacy implications of having the government have your DNA on file.

Faking DNA; well for that it would depend on how the test was administered. A cheek swab would be reasonably easy to fool, a blood draw less so if administered carefully. This is all assuming no corruption or anything; DNA tests contain no cryptographically attestable proof of match.

Any who knows, with DNA based therapies you might find yourself unable to pass a DNA test for yourself in the future.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by fivefive55 on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:19PM (#18826856)
That doesn't sound any worse than losing your social security number.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by acdha on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:24PM (#18826901)
SSNs are identifiers and not intended to be private. The only reason anyone cares about SSNs is that some private businesses were negligent in their authentication procedures and have tried to shift the blame to the victims.

In contrast, if you have public-key encryption people are going to build systems on the assumption that your private key is only available to you despite several decades of history showing that's not a safe assumption.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by colejohnson66 on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:21PM (#18826877)
Your SSN you can memorize. A 2048 bit+ private key is gonna be a lot harder
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by gammateam on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:50PM (#18827090)
You go in person and give a new public key and cryptographically sign the governments message with it

In person the government will have their own redundant and convoluted process to verify you before giving you a message to sign, just like today to reissue a SSN

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by alkonaut on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:07PM (#18826742)
That’s not a problem so long as the number is a non-secret identity rather than a secret used to verify identity. A social security number (or any such personal identification number in any country) is only an identifier and not secret. It’s like an email address, not like a password.

A leak of lots of non-secret data (eg email addresses) is an integrity problem not a security problem. A leak of passwords or other secret data is s security issue.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by briffle on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:07PM (#18826736)
There is no problem with assigning people a number. the problem is that people start using that number as Verification, not as an identifier.

People treat your SSN as a password, when really, it just uniquely identifies you. Its basically an Email Address, not a password.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by saool on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:10PM (#18826775)
> it just uniquely identifies you

not even. you need other data points, like DOB, to build enough uniqueness, and there are still many stories of collisions.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by reaperducer on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:25PM (#18827307)
it just uniquely identifies you

Try working face-to-face in communities of recent, poor immigrants where five, six, even ten people using the same (likely purchased) SSN is not unusual. I've seen entire families using the same SSN.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by alkonaut on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:08PM (#18826755)
Don’t use any service that considers SSN a verification.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by lotsofpulp on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:11PM (#18827227)
Functionally useless advice if you ever have to deal with mobile networks, internet service providers, financial institutions, utilities' providers, any government, schools, universities, and the list goes on.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by alkonaut on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:20PM (#18827268)
Those services take the SSN as proof of identity and not just identity?

Wouldn’t most people’s SSN’s be leaked already so using SSN rather than proper ID isn’t much better than nothing?

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by lotsofpulp on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:43PM (#18827417)
Yes, when you call customer service you’re usually asked to provide your SSN to verify you are who you are.

Some are finally requiring a PIN or passcode, but very few in my experience.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by alkonaut on Friday January 04, 2019 @06:12PM (#18828641)
Providing you SSN identifies you no better than your email address or postal address. It’s not a secret number. There may be a provider that has a 2FA. It should be a cheap way for them to get more business.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by Wohlf on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:11PM (#18826223)
There is no other way to establish identity beyond a limited social circle besides a unique address or number.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by Balgair on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:32PM (#18826439)
That's ... incredibly interesting. I can't figure out a counterpoint to this. You are correct, 'identity' is not all that easy to verify outside of a small group. I think there are larger implications about human nature here than just trying to o-auth a user.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by ngneer on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:37PM (#18826478)
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by Balgair on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:00PM (#18827147)
Thanks!
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by ngneer on Friday January 04, 2019 @12:45PM (#18825977)
Numbers have to be assigned in order to break the symmetry. Otherwise how would you tell humans apart?
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by cal5k on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:10PM (#18826214)
Right, but it's like using a private key as an identifier. As soon as it's compromised you need to get a whole new ID.

I'd rather see something like Bitcoin's HD wallets used for identification - your private keys are on a hardware device, but you can generate new "personal identifiers" for use with public services that, if compromised, could be burned through a central registry without requiring a replacement of the private keys.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by njarboe on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:31PM (#18826433)
The only real problem with most of these "identity theft" problems are that lenders are not punished/fined when they lie to credit bureaus and say you borrowed some money instead of someone who has impersonated you. Prevent the banks/loan makers from libeling you and this information leaking is not that much of a big deal. Banks might not like it, but the populous would definitely support it.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by drewmol on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:57PM (#18826631)
To further your suggestion, start referring to "identity theft" as fraud. Banks/loan makers don't just libel you, they further the initial crime and commit fraud every time they transfer/sell/bundle the fraudulent debt.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by njarboe on Friday January 04, 2019 @09:40PM (#18829556)
There needs to be a specific phrase to replace the phrase "identity theft". I think the phrase "bank libel" could work as it is not a phrase currently used very often. Unfortunately "bank fraud" is a common occurrence, so not a great name for this specific type of bank fraud.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by cal5k on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:53AM (#18846131)
Well, the above solution would actually allow you to connect the stolen number to the specific organization you supplied it to. That would help with accountability quite a bit!
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by Kalium on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:46PM (#18826542)
This is a great idea! It solves a lot of problems up front - it allows for multiple, verifiable, identity slices and separate revocations of each.

That said, you may also want to consider that a system design may want to have the ability to re-issue private keys. It's wise to assume that hardware dongles may, in the fullness of time, prove attackable. Certainly many Bitcoin wallets have.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by cal5k on Monday January 07, 2019 @10:55AM (#18846153)
It might be necessary to issue new dongles every once in a while, but it wouldn't be unreasonable to have a user fee for doing so. Certainly people have to pay to renew driver's licenses and such already.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by Kalium on Monday January 07, 2019 @08:47PM (#18852310)
You may wish to consider stepping carefully with this one. It's reasonable to charge for driver's licenses and passports because those are privileges.

It would be unreasonable to charge people a fee for a basic requirement of being enabled to be verifiable by their government. Especially if the system you're imagining is to be used for things like identification to establish voter eligibility.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by cal5k on Thursday January 10, 2019 @12:20PM (#18875687)
Why is it unreasonable? You could exempt anyone below a certain income level from paying the fee - it's no different than any other kind of tax.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by Kalium on Monday January 14, 2019 @10:49AM (#18903840)
It's a de facto poll tax. You may wish to research the history of such, it's both fascinating and horrifying.

Your idea of using income levels is an interesting and intriguing one. Thank you for bringing it forth for discussion! However, have you considered that it may pose some complications, such as how one can document and prove income without a way to prove identity in a system where every such document is tied to identity? Might it not be easier to skip that administrative overhead entirely?

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by solarkraft on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:18PM (#18826282)
This is good, but it'll take a while to catch on.

I can well imagine everyone receiving a hardware key generator for personal identification purposes. Some id cards already have something similar and it shouldn't be all too expensive.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by ngneer on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:35PM (#18826462)
Assuming a fair bidding process...
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by politician on Friday January 04, 2019 @12:49PM (#18826022)
Coarsely, the reason for the need to tell humans apart is to assign debts.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by mulmen on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:00PM (#18826112)
Huh? What about my Safeway card that tracks my shopping habits? Or my phone number that allows anyone in the world to contact me? Or my address that identifies a physical location to send me things. Or membership numbers in clubs? Or the example from TFA: passports.

How would any of those be feasible with coarse mapping of ID to human?

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by Spooky23 on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:09PM (#18826201)
Why do you need an externally defined unique ID?

If I tell you that i am Spooky23, 123 Main St, anytown, AK, [email protected], what more uniqueness do you need?

Hoarding passport numbers, drivers licenses, ssn, etc usually doesn’t serve a legitimate purpose. When it is required to meet compliance or other requirements (say an payroll processor who needs an SSN to withhold taxes), it needs to be protected and have access controls.

Marriott does not have any need to authoritatively know who I am beyond payment arrangements. I'm not borrowing money from Marriott, so they don't need my SSN. They may need my passport when I check into an international hotel to meet compliance requirements, but they don't need to store it in a reservation system, and don't need to store it beyond the international jurisdiction where I checked in.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by cr0sh on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:39PM (#18826496)
Marriott probably keeps the passport numbers to identify people in their hotel chain management systems, because they are an international company with hotels (and other similar properties) worldwide.

Name, address, and email probably isn't fine-grained enough, as multiple people can all share the same information - and name isn't enough because some people name all their kids the same, sometimes the same as the parents (yes, it is crazy insane, perhaps narcissistic - but people). Then there are those who do similar things for fraudulent reasons.

In theory (I'm sure there are ways around it) no two people should have the same passport and passport ID number. Now, not everyone has a passport, but if they do, and they are travelling internationally, Marriott likely would rather have that information, so they can track you as you use their services in multiple places around the world (and offer you various amenities, upgrades, advertising, etc of course)...

That would be my guess.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by maccard on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:13PM (#18826797)
Presumably a combination of name and email address is enough for "marketing" purposes for Marriott.

Less nefariously*, I did a bit of digging and in the UK, hotels are required to record an ID for aliens (ironically, there is no central ID system in the UK, which I assume is why it's for aliens only). If the liability is on the hotel in case of incorrect information, it makes sense they would require the most common form of internationally recognized ID (a passport).Italy has a similar system introduced in the 30's by the fascist govt at the time for keeping track of who was where when. If I were an international business,it would make sense to me to comply with the regulations everywhere rather than try selectively enforce it.

(Nefarious-ness of Marriott. Not necessarily a comment on trusting the people who came up with the law in the first place)

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by ngneer on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:27PM (#18826394)
Spooky23 seems to be implicitly relying on uniqueness that is leveraged by the underlying message routing system. With the case of "123 Main St, anytown, AK" there is an implicit assumption that no one else lives at that address. With the case of "[email protected]" there is an implicit assumption that the mailbox is not shared.

Hoarding numbers serves the very purpose of ensuring a unique assignment. For instance, if "the" department of transportation did not have a "global" database, then it would risk minting the same number twice. That having been said, it is true that knowledge of a "master" identity is not a requirement for making payment arrangements.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by Spooky23 on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:06PM (#18826733)
What’s the anticipated trust level?

For most commerce, I need to be able to tell that you are the same “Spooky23” who was here last time.

If you need to positively and authoritatively identify me, collecting numbers is not sufficient. End of the day, these companies are either overcollecting for convenience or doing a poor job of collecting information for compliance purposes.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by maccard on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:15PM (#18826815)
> End of the day, these companies are either overcollecting for convenience or doing a poor job of collecting information for compliance purposes.

Or both. Overxollecting makes sense at a global level (all systems the same everywhere), but even if they only collect what they need they're clearly not treating it correctly

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by mulmen on Friday January 04, 2019 @03:37PM (#18827385)
My response was to the idea that unique identifiers are only useful for debt collection.

In response to your moved goalposts: how is storing the passport ID different from storing the address or email? Are all three not "externally defined unique IDs"?

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by nly on Friday January 04, 2019 @04:01PM (#18827565)
I'd rather hotels had my passport number than most home address.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by elliekelly on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:53PM (#18827110)
Many countries legally require hotels to record guest passports.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by politician on Friday January 04, 2019 @07:04PM (#18828952)
These examples say more about the sad state of the world we live in than the feasibility of the use cases.

I didn't say these things were impossible, just that they are about collecting debts, so I've tried to respond below by showing how they allow parties to collect debts.

- Personalized tracking for marketing and advertising use cases is about changing subject behaviors, so that they spend their time and energy on things that other people want them to spend it on. Grocery store "loyalty" cards are one of many examples of how we cede agency -- in this case, allowing a corporation to assign a debt in the form of coupons that predispose us to buy a particular item. Does the 49 cents off the chocolate treats make the 30g of sugar more healthy? This is textbook predatory behavior.

- Phone numbers are a thing because we rely on centralized communications where the phone number is associated with an account billed monthly for collecting a usage debt. However, with technologies like torrents and WebRTC this is changing. In the future, maybe you provide each of your friends and family with a unique signature that allows them to look you up on the net?

If I could give up my phone number, it would certainly cut down on all of the robocalls and spam I get every day. This isn't novel or weird: many people already hand out email addresses of the form [email protected] to bucket spam.

- A physical address is a weird example because it identifies a physical location, not a person. I am not my home address; I just sleep there sometimes. Sometimes, I'm sleeping somewhere else.

- Club membership? That's easy - if you're paying for membership, then they need an account id to collect the debt for your membership. If you're not paying for membership, they don't need an ID. There are lots of clubs or meetups that don't require IDs -- the evening tech meetups/bar crawls around Seattle, for example.

- Passports, Customs, and Borders exist as a mechanism for the state to collect taxes on goods crossing international borders. Not the only mechanism, just one of them. Governments are currently struggling with goods and services crossing international borders digitally bypassing these checkpoints. I'm not sure, though, why you think passports are a humane thing -- we put tags on livestock.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by pkaye on Friday January 04, 2019 @12:58PM (#18826093)
Would you be fine having your medical history mixed with someone else with the same name?
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by drewmol on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:07PM (#18826740)
Yes, I would even be willing to pay a small fee for this.

(not the op)

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by politician on Friday January 04, 2019 @06:29PM (#18828757)
(op here) The premise of the grandparent is an illusion that depends on the idea that somehow a medical provider (which one?) is a better caretaker for your medical history than you are. In the cases where that is actually true, power of attorney is the real solution -- not EMR records hosted offsite by 3rd party vendors in 3rd world countries on behalf of one or more hospitals. How absurd.

My medical history is mine; it's ultimately not yours. If you need my medical history, allow me to give you limited access to it.

Now, if your billing is opaque and you're playing shenanigans with the insurance companies about who owes what, then sure, you need my Passport, SSN, DNA, Real ID, and biometrics -- and you should probably hold my medical history hostage too -- to make sure that you can collect on the debt.

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by ngneer on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:02PM (#18826131)
Capitalism is involved for sure, but "debt" seems harsh. How about "resource allocation"?
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by lawlorino on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:04PM (#18826711)
What alternative would you propose?
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by NedIsakoff on Friday January 04, 2019 @12:53PM (#18826060)
The Chinese 居民身份证 works well for its intended purposes and has not back fired.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by castis on Friday January 04, 2019 @01:01PM (#18826119)
thats 'Resident Identity Card' for anyone who doesn't want to google it.
Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by seppin on Friday January 04, 2019 @09:00PM (#18829402)
> has not back fired

Unless they ended the program, you forgot the word "yet"

Re:Marriott Concedes 5M Passport Numbers Lost to Hackers Wer... by davengh on Friday January 04, 2019 @02:13PM (#18826799)
Yet. That we know of.