This is pretty similar to how people reacted when cars showed up about a hundred years ago, and for good reason - drivers now kill half a million people a year, 30,000-40,000 of those in the US, disproportionately affecting people walking and cycling. We have evidence that self-driving cars are safer than human-driven cars, but we _also_ have evidence of "Tesla drivers pretending their half-assed version of self-driving is safe" and "self-driving car kills pedestrian" and no driver to face the consequence for this. More than a few of the touted designs for cities that self-driving cars enable are an utter hellscape for people who like walking, cycling, or motorcycling, and cars already destroyed our cities once.
Personally, I'd rather live in a place with no cars of any sort. Barring that, I'd actually prefer self-driving cars (they do seem safer) with massive restrictions on speed, noise, etc. But I can understand these people's concerns and just calling them Luddites doesn't really help.
I don't follow. How are cities designed for self-driving cars hellscape? You admit that self-driving cars would likely lead to an objectively safer conditions for others, so what's the downside? They would also likely lead to higher utilization, more fuel efficiency and less traffic since much of traffic is due to human error. Protocols are also much easier to program and enforce than with human driven cars (e.g. people parking in bike lanes, double parking, stopping in unsafe zones to allow passengers to exit).
You're not going to get rid of cars. It's nice to say you prefer walking and biking and such, but the fact is that that's mostly a luxury of being wealthy and having the ability to live in a location where you can access your place of work and other facilities easily. If you're living in a rural area or a less expensive suburb of a large city, you rely on other forms of transportation such as a car or public mode of transportation (e.g. bus or subway). There are also those that have mobility issues that would be greatly inconvenienced by your insistence of a car free world.
Additionally, the idea of living directly in a city to be a luxury really destroys the justification of a "city" in the first place, in my opinion. The whole idea of suburbs throughout human history was the luxury of not being in a city, but thanks to that mentality + the Baby Boom, modern cities are now glorified business parks.
Sounds like a perfect being the enemy of the good issue. Whether or not cities are designed for cars is separate from 'should the cars be self-driving'. That sort of hairshirt anti-harm reduction has a poor track record.
> The whole idea of suburbs throughout human history was the luxury of not being in a city, but thanks to that mentality + the Baby Boom, modern cities are now glorified business parks.
That isn't true actually historically it was the reverse where the outskirts of the city were where the poor went, especially when it meant being outside of the protection of city walls! We are just seeing the trend reverse itself.
I think that would be easier to do with self-driving cars as opposed to human driven cars for the reasons I mentioned in the parent post
I get your point and have even gone and stood on paint to protect bike lanes. But I lack any faith in lawmakers to care about any mode other than driving.
I would be angry, too. The prospect of self-driving cars excites me, but I can totally understand not wanting your neighborhood to become the testing grounds for this new tech. Uber and Tesla's mishaps in the self-driving space understandably color the public's perception of Waymo's far more responsible efforts to date.
They own the house, not the right of way in front of it.
People who think they own the road are why we need self driving cars.
I'm very eager to get to the point where we have self driving cars, even though I'd be categorized as an enthusiastic driver (daily driver is a h-pattern 5-speed, racing experience including championship wins, etc.).
That said, if they were beta-testing in my neighborhood and actually hurt my kid or likely even a neighbors, they'd have a hard time keeping their cars running in the area.
"Move fast and break things" is only valid in a few limited contexts, and is particularly invalid in any potentially fatal context. I understand the need for realistic data, but, their industry has already killed someone beta testing (yes Uber. not Google, but...)
Under any circumstances, ever? That seems rather extreme.
Anyway, people aren't arguing against technology here, but on an unwanted externality (extra traffic) with no persons around to provide accountability or mitigate the negative aspects with positive ones (like stopping for lunch to cause money to circulate longer in the longer economy). Centralized automation siphons money away in small quantities from many places and leads to a glut of it elsewhere, driving up prices and rents there.
Please quit with the Luddite arguments, which are a misleading diversion from this well-defined economic issue.
Political and corporate brands know this very well — we are not at all rational beings and any approach based on only “making a logical case for...” is insufficient. We believe we’re rational (the premises of the enlightenment) but are not.
Also, please consider how many people are employed in transportation and see themselves broke and homeless before you compare self driving cars to washing machines. Housewives were never paid to exclusively and only wash clothes. Completely different scenario.
These are people who, like luddites, see the end of their lives as they know it.
From a comment below, on Luddites:
> The group was protesting the use of machinery in a "fraudulent and deceitful manner" to get around standard labour practices.
> These are people who, like luddites, see the end of their lives as they know it.
I agree it's a different scenario but how much of a fraction is that? I doubt it's very large. Literally millions of new employees in this field have been created thanks to companies like Uber, I doubt most were in the transportation business beforehand and had jobs doing something else, and once driverless cars are more common most won't be in transportation afterwards either. Most people can find new jobs, and most people in the industry already are probably there as a consequence of "I need a new job" rather than being born and bred for this one thing they can do that a machine will now take over.
"The needs of the many outweigh the needs of the few" only exists in Star Trek, and Silicon Valley. In the rest of the world, every life has value.
> I don't see how violence or vandalism of property is ever justified
I welcome your commitment to unilateral disarmament, end of gun ownership, disarmament of the police &c. /s
I don't want any of my neighbours to have washing machines. I didn't agree to this. They should ask permission.
Because "cars are taking jobs" isn't what is being protested here.
They deliberately conflate vandalism with general debate, and unfortunately it is then up to us to be smart enough to not lump them together like they did. The formula is usually to take shocking story/reaction, humanize it at a micro level, talk to so-called expert who may have written a book, have expert give general reasoning at a macro level, and then watch readers confuse micro and macro.
> The trouble started, the couple said, when their 10-year-old son was nearly hit by one of the vehicles while he was playing in a nearby cul-de-sac.
> “They said they need real-world examples, but I don’t want to be their real-world mistake,” said Mr. O’Polka, who runs his own company providing information technology to small businesses.
People protest for all sorts of reasons. bko's point is not relevant to every protester.
I don't see how violence or vandalism of property is ever justified. Not to mention the fact that pelting self-driving cars with rocks or trying to run them off the road puts others in danger as well.
What I don't understand about these modern day Luddites is why what's considered today's technology is okay but any technological advances beyond this point is harmful. Why not attack washing machines and dishwashers? Surely forcing people to get their clothes washed by hands would create hundreds of thousands of jobs.