Realistically letting the kids control their money gives them a bit extra feeling of independence without giving up much control... Most kids can't go anywhere without you being around until they're a teen and at that point it's a very different game. My dad always liked to ask me if my "money was burning a hole in my pocket" when he thought I was about to buy something stupid... He wouldn't stop me, but he did act like an advisor leaving the control and choice ultimately in my hands.
Is it their money or yours? You are welcome to not give them control over money, but they won't learn anything about controlling their spending.
"Each month, they will accrue a little bit of interest which, for the amount children will realistically make, is no big hit to my wallet."
This is also interesting. There's two aspects to saving: saving for big purchases, and saving for a rainy day. Interest is not really relevant to the first, and the latter is hopefully not part of childhood.
It's their money within the boundaries of my responsibility to them as the parent. For instance, I reserve my right to say no to violent video games, too much junk food, etc. They are free to make monetarily bad decisions, but I reserve the responsibility of instilling my values and preventing them from making really bad decisions like becoming overweight or obese. Sure, they can buy candy with their money, but if they are buying too much candy I can't let them continue to go down that path.
The idea of interest is merely to encourage saving. I don't know if that would really work.
this a great way to make them want both even more albeit without ever learning the restraint that comes from finding their own limits, probably as the result of one or more bad decisions. the biggest flaw i see in the planning of most prospective parents is that they fail to acknowledge their children will not be confined to their little garden of eden. the reality is that they'll have have friends with parents that exist outside your perfect moral codex (and some who are frankly just negligent) who will let them play all those games and drink as much soda as they want. i've never seen a parental media embargo actually have it's desired effect, but the kids who never learned to handle their shit where always immediately apparent. when you set such restrictions, all you're really doing is rejecting the responsibility to actually teach your children & hoping they figure it out on their own.
That doesn't mean I don't believe my kids are going out to experience(and develop their own) moral codes. What it means is that as long as they are in my house, they will abide by my rules, as they will have to when they will abide by their landlord's rules. This is coming from a former kid who went over to his friend's houses to play FPS games, downloaded porn then erased the internet history, and visited anarchy websites teaching me how to build bombs and the like. I know what children are liable to do outside my range of vision.
The problem I have with your perspective is that it can be taken to any end and doesn't teach children that different people have their own values, or that parents have a duty to their children's wellbeing. It takes moral relativism to such an extreme that, given the possibility that your premises are true, I'd have to question whether parents are even necessary.
The reason that I would instill my values in my children is so they can enter a world where not everyone sees my moral codex as valid, thus they are given something to think about when they come to an age where they're forced to wonder whether I as a parent am being reasonable. They can choose to rebel, which they almost certainly will, and they can also choose to respect at least some of my values. In my experience, the kids who grew up in households whose parents let their kids do whatever they wanted turned out to be dependent little shitheads. I know of only one exception, and in that case the dad was such a negligent jerk that the kid had to raise himself; he turned out pretty well in the end, but that's not without the psychological drama of having shitty parenting and other mistakes he made because he had no moral guidance.
Sorry, but I'd rather be an actual dad and play some role in how a child gets raised. Allowing children, especially under the age of 12, to do whatever they want, is absurd.
> your perfect moral codex
I never made such a claim.
If you offer a few dollars it feels not worth it, but if you ask them to do it because it’s kind or the right thing to do they realize it’s another sort of worth.
That memory may impact how you are now, but it's probably not how things were.
To memory, my parents didn't start having me do chores until I was at least 10 years old. I was not a fan of doing most of what was asked of me, and in retrospect I think the problem was the system I was working for was very unfair; I usually got paid $5 a week for mowing the lawn, but the other chores I had to do paid me nothing. I don't think my parents thought they were being unfair and I'm sure they were concerned with limiting how much money I would have on hand, as well as saving their own wallet obviously. What ended up happening was I had to wait too long to make another measly $5, and the other chores I had paid nothing so I felt I was getting gypped. At the time I didn't articulate this feeling to them... not sure why, but I guess that's just something children are usually unable to do.
I grew up as a lazy person; my grades were pitiful and I generally didn't try hard at anything until my early 20s when I realized that life was going to pass me by if I didn't do something about it. I don't think this is necessarily due to my parents raising me as a lazy person, but perhaps a more enterprising and less dependent attitude could have been instilled in me early on so I wouldn't have had to learn the hard way after I became an adult.
In response to that experience, I've been thinking about a better system for my hypothetical children:
- Get them doing chores as early as possible so that participating in work is normalized before the age they will have too many mindless distractions like video games. It's hard for me to say how much a 6 year old can do, but I'm sure there's at least a few easy tasks they could be doing on a regular basis.
- Most chores that are result of primarily my actions(e.g. I choose to own a stupid water-thirsty lawn) should pay. I would want to create at least a handful of opportunities for my child to make money throughout each week that they are motivated and regularly rewarded. Adults probably forget that a week seems like a long time to a child.
- Tasks like cleaning their room are unpaid because they have to learn to be responsible for their own mess. There will be a consequence for them not cleaning their room, but they can still choose to forego this task without being scolded(within reason of course).
- I will be their "bank" and they can deposit and withdraw from their account so long as I approve of what they are spending their money on. Each month, they will accrue a little bit of interest which, for the amount children will realistically make, is no big hit to my wallet. This not only allows me to make sure they aren't spending their money on crap, but it gets them used to the idea of working with a bank early on. In the case they decide to fail to clean their room, for example, I can choose to withhold access to their earnings.
- Besides holidays and special occasions, I won't be paying for the things that they want. If they want a toy, they're going to have to work for it and save enough money they they can afford it themselves. Their meals, educational material, and other essential items, are up to me, but they have to learn that they are ultimately responsible for their own desires or else they'd better develop a sense of patience.
I presume such a system would be difficult for families who live in places such as apartments where there are only so many chores to be done. Hopefully I live in such a situation, like having a house with property, where I can find enough things for my children to do.
Is the system I'm thinking of too draconian? What do you think?