- Diablo 3's hardcore mode, where you have a single life and your gameplay and saves are on a cloud server
- Far Cry 2 permadeath journals
- Roguelike strategy games like Dwarf Fortress and Rimworld
- One chance, a browser game designed around a single playthrough (although the saves are hidden in a cookie that can be cleared)
The reviews are hysterical.
https://store.steampowered.com/app/595690/One_Hour_One_Life/
I'm a big Rohrer fan and death seems like a recurring theme throughout his games:
-Passage: where you pass through an entire life in 5 minutes
-The Castle Doctrine: a permadeath home defense MMO where you set death traps and try, often impotently, to defend your small family. When you fail to defend them, you'll get to watch the security tapes in detail and come home to their mutilated corpses.
Just focus on Vitality, pick a low difficulty level, and slowly grind the game.
Never died, had 1 close call due to Frozen.
"Games aren't hard if you lower the difficulty" is a strange argument to make.
You can take a level 70 weapon with a gem of ease, jump in at Torment VI and level a new character from 1->20 in sixty seconds even when playing solo.
Let it go.
It also had a great intro with goofy pics of the dev team (who the soldiers were named after) in military attire.
I think a core issue for games is that loss is fundamentally at odds with player agency. In pre-written stories it ends up feeling cheap even if it was influenced by player choice. It is much better suited to games with emergent narrative, such as Dwarf Fortress, Rimworld, Crusader Kings II, or X-COM, but still stings more as an annoyance than something deeply emotional.
I've certainly been in a group that decided to ignore the outcome of a session where we had particularly bad luck on the dice rolls because of the expectation that it would've made subsequent sessions unwinnable/not fun.
There's arguably more incentive to do this in the board games because restarting from a 'ruined' game state in fire emblem requires pressing a few buttons, doing so in the board game requires spending $70 again.
Good emotional impact comes as a result of making choices for some trade off of greed, virtue, practicality, risk, etc.
Ooh. I'd love to see a Fire Emblem style game like this. No main character, so any of them can die and not end the story. If a main character dies, someone else can take up their path, or it can slightly diverge. Ending depends on who's left alive at the end. It'd be a mess to do I think, especially dealing with when characters die and adjusting the storyline, but it'd be super interesting and you could easily get multiple playthroughs. I'd even say that the game allows you to do multiple ones, with each death/recruit being an autosave, so you can't undo it.
Supports would be the harder to thing to find to influence the game at that point I think...But maybe you could even just do that down to NPCs commenting about how so-and-so look so in love, or how they glare at each other. Might flesh out the world a little more. Even maybe make them have rumors about ones who've died who they've heard about.
It's just a matter of bringing everything together I think. That's the annoying bit of it.
I bought the extra skins DLC pack and rewarded each soldier with unique armour when they reached the rank of Major. It was great.
Buy even if they're short, they can be unforgettable. I would urge everyone interested in such a story to play "Brothers: a tale of two sons", which might have been some of my best 2-3 hours of gaming ever. Presenting it on this context might spoil some of it, but go in without any judgment or preconceptions and you'll have an experience that sticks.
The default is assumption, however, is permadeath.
How about balancing a handful of levels so that it's impossible to finish without losing someone? You could replay in hopes of saving a character...at the expense of losing a different character.
Fire emblem is a good example of this. It’s a strategy game where you have about 30 characters who permanently die when killed in any battle. Most players just restart each battle until deathless runs are achieved- either due to emotional or practical concerns. So, when someone dies, it’s not sad, it’s annoying.
You also lose empathy if a character dies due to unforeseeable consequences of choices or shitty AI performance.
Legacy board games address these problems well. Because the state of the game is irreversibly driven forward by physical mutation of the game, it forces you to commit to your fortune and errors. I hope we see more of these games made. I haven’t seen this model used anywhere, but I could imagine a video game where you buy the right to do one irreversible play through of a story mode, cloud saved on their systems so you can’t manage the data yourself.