News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by SmellyGeekBoy on Friday December 28, 2018 @09:32AM (#18776882)
As a Brit it's interesting to see how the default American response to anything out of the ordinary seems to be "we must be under attack!"

I don't mean this as any kind of criticism - I guess it's just a cultural difference. For example we had someone shut down the second busiest airport in our country last week by flying a drone around and the assumption here (by the man on the street and the media in general) was "idiot with a new toy" rather than "terrorist attack".

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by dhimes on Friday December 28, 2018 @10:56AM (#18777442)
As a Brit it's interesting to see how the default American response to anything out of the ordinary seems to be "we must be under attack!"

I honestly think you are mistaken. It certainly crosses some peoples' minds, and I imagine that any issue will make someone consider it might be terrorism.

But I bet if a bunch of smoke came pouring out of your tube, somebody would wonder if a bombing was attempted. I don't think we're that different that way.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by chimeracoder on Friday December 28, 2018 @09:43AM (#18776938)
> As a Brit it's interesting to see how the default American response to anything out of the ordinary seems to be "we must be under attack!"

As a longtime Hacker News reader, it's interesting to see how strong the urge is for non-American readers to make generalizations about Americans based on cherry-picked data that suits their paradigms.

> For example we had someone shut down the second busiest airport in our country last week by flying a drone around and the assumption here (by the man on the street and the media in general) was "idiot with a new toy" rather than "terrorist attack".

Aside from the fact that (a) there were people speculating about terrorists at LGW, (b) the common response of New Yorkers last night was not to assume it was a terrorist attack, you're also comparing a drone flying over an airport to a massive explosion that lights up the sky for a prolonged period of time - over a minute - with bright pulsating blue light.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by reaperducer on Friday December 28, 2018 @12:25PM (#18778071)
we had someone shut down the second busiest airport in our country last week by flying a drone around and the assumption here (by the man on the street and the media in general) was "idiot with a new toy" rather than "terrorist attack".

I was watching Sky News. It immediately went with terrorism speculation when the drone was first reported.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by mr_overalls on Friday December 28, 2018 @10:34AM (#18777277)
I think the 9/11 attacks really left their mark on the public consciousness.

Add to that the near-daily school shootings, miscellaneous other mass shootings, and general sense of frustration & helplessness about ongoing Russian cyberwarfare and interference with our elections (I mean, for God's sake, it seems reasonable to suspect that our President could actually be a Russian intelligence asset), and the zeitgeist has become one of heightened paranoia.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by zerkten on Friday December 28, 2018 @10:55AM (#18777429)
This predates 9/11. I'm not sure how to best to explain it because it can come off badly because US vs UK discussions aren't very healthy beyond a few jokes.

Americans are just different from other english-speaking countries (the thing people tend to think of as the closest comparison.) It could be a strength or a weakness depending on how you think about it. There are definitely changes that you can attribute to 9/11 such as the Patriot Act, airport security, etc. However, I don't think Americans think much differently that might have done during the Cold War.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by komali2 on Friday December 28, 2018 @11:42AM (#18777781)
Perhaps it would help to frame these discussions as not needing to consider whether aspects of our cultures are strengths or weaknesses, and simply talk about the differences frankly.
Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by dvtrn on Friday December 28, 2018 @12:21PM (#18778051)
Speaking frankly, I can kind of speak to the oddness of the reactions-having once lived within an hour of a couple of air bases and an Army base with an aviation detachment in at least 3 of the four cardinal directions (this was Texas, plenty of military bases) two hours up the road (plus another one on the far side of the state). This was several years ago now, before 9/11.

Now personally, I figured it would be normal seeing military birds flying over head en route to one of the three bases, like I said, we were within two hours drive to one of three installations, by air probably even less.

Evidently the rest of the township at the municipal airport I was working at thought otherwise-and didn't find it so 'normal'. "Jade helm" (speaking of post 9/11 'events') went from a painfully reported news story for three straight weeks to a bit of a joke in our office, but before that nothing could stop people from phoning my desk at general aviation to ask if we were under attack or what business the military has flying over civilian airspace.

"Sir", I would say (or ma'am if appropriate), "we're one hour from Lackland AFB in San Antonio, this is normal aviation activity, those boys are probably just finishing some training and heading back to base for some R&R".

Would wager....15 calls a day, more on the weekends if the hornets were practicing for a flyover of DKR up in Austin for a Texas football game.

Edit:

I completely forgot, the calls got to the point where we had a dedicated phone line installed just so people could call in and get ATIS-ish type information from general aviation-and one of the pre-recorded bulletins, I think the very first thing callers hear was "General aviation does not intercept, record, or log the presence of military aircraft in the airspace immediately surrounding New Braunfels Regional Airport"

They ended up disconnecting that line after a few years. People would figure out another number with a human respondent and badger them instead until one of our hangars started getting phone calls wanting to be transferred to the tower.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by atmosx on Friday December 28, 2018 @10:55AM (#18777428)
> I mean, for God's sake, it seems reasonable to suspect that our President could actually be a Russian intelligence asset

I don't think so. That is propaganda from the other party. Strongest I've seen in years, honestly.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by dhimes on Friday December 28, 2018 @10:59AM (#18777462)
I agree. I mean, in some vague sense he's an asset because he's been useful- and I imagine that happens from time to time to people with power when the other side has a strategy or a goal you haven't caught on to yet, but I don't think he's aware of it.
Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by buttcoinslol on Friday December 28, 2018 @11:47AM (#18777823)
A useful idiot is still an asset, perhaps not knowingly.
Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by mr_overalls on Friday December 28, 2018 @11:15AM (#18777584)
He has repeatedly sabotaged our relationship with traditional democratically-governed allies (i.e. NATO) - and avoided criticizing Russia to an extent that is simply bizarre.

For example, despite the repeated statements by American intelligence agencies that Russian interfered in the 2016 election, Trump said in Helsinki that he believed Putin's denials over his own intelligence apparatus. This is just incomprehensible behavior by a President.

https://www.businessinsider.com/trump-putin-press-conference...

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by vxNsr on Friday December 28, 2018 @11:24AM (#18777663)
> He has repeatedly sabotaged our relationship with traditional democratically-governed allies - and avoided criticizing Russia

The same could be said for his predecessor. See Israel, Japan, hot mic with Medvedev.

I think we see what we want to see and forgive "our guy" because we believe his intentions.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by mr_overalls on Friday December 28, 2018 @11:55AM (#18777869)
Can you provide specifics on Obama's actions re: Israel and Japan that you find objectionable?
Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by vxNsr on Friday December 28, 2018 @12:26PM (#18778074)
Here's one article that explains the final "f u" obama gave to israel:

https://www.nytimes.com/2016/12/23/world/middleeast/israel-b...

The constant calls for restraint on Israel's part as Israeli children as young as 6 months were being stabbed to death in their beds by "freedom fighters" lauded by PLO and PA media also comes to mind.

The blind eye towards how PLO officials spoke to their own people (bloodthirsty talk of killing all the jews) vs what they said in English (calls for peace if only Israel was willing to compromise).

But just googling "Obama and Israel" will give you tons more.

Obama's weak stance on NK and china at the expense of Japanese security was seen as failing an ally.

I'm wondering if you could provide concrete examples of Trump sabotage. I'm curious mostly because I'm guessing we're gonna see it very differently.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by justin66 on Friday December 28, 2018 @12:47PM (#18778212)
Just so nobody else wastes their time I thought I should point out that that NY Times link doesn't support any of the crazy stuff you're saying.
Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by vxNsr on Friday December 28, 2018 @01:12PM (#18778375)
Just so we're clear, the NYT article is only about Obama choosing not to veto a resolution condemning Israel.

Not sure what I said that was crazy?

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by mr_overalls on Friday December 28, 2018 @01:05PM (#18778334)
For starters, Trump doesn't seem to even comprehend the mutual defense pact that is the foundation of NATO.

https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/18/world/europe/trump-nato-s...

Apart from that, he was generally a source of chaos at the 2018 NATO summit, 1) demanding that NATO allies increase per-GDP spending ahead of schedule or the US would "go it alone" (and hijacking a meeting already in progress to make these demands), 2) accusing Germany of being "totally controlled" by Russia, 3) and giving a parallel-reality final press conference touting that NATO partners had agreed to significant increases in spending (which said partners denied).

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2018/jul/12/how-trumps-n...

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by vxNsr on Friday December 28, 2018 @01:20PM (#18778432)
The NYT article is more about him questioning why we should do it, he seemed to understand what mutual defense is, just that he didn't want to commit to it. If you recall the parable of the elephant and the mouse, Trump doesn't see the value of the mouse and thus doesn't wanna commit to helping it without question. at least that's what I gleaned from the article.

There is a difference between being "a source of chaos" and actual sabotage of alliances.

1) Still doesn't seem that unfair of a demand.

2) You gotta admit that he had a point that using Russia as a source for oil kinda undermines independence. We ran into the same thing in the 70's, it sucked.

3) Classic Trump. but not sabotage.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by daodedickinson on Friday December 28, 2018 @12:35PM (#18778129)
The zeitgeist has not recently become one of heightened paranoia, it's the Sword of Damocles that comes with being the biggest target. And you could make a better case that Nixon was an asset of China.
Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by magduf on Friday December 28, 2018 @10:51AM (#18777397)
The only problem with the near-daily school shootings and other mass shootings is that those are a choice that we, as a society, have decided we want to tolerate and have in our lives. It's not an attack from outsiders, it's something that we've decided we want to put up with from our own people because we refuse to change our gun laws. Other developed nations simply do not have this problem, for the very simple reason that they don't have easy access to such weapons.

As for the Pres, there again, that's a choice that we made as a society. We elected him after all, and we've continued to defend him no matter what.

In short, these are problems of our own making.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by iamdave on Friday December 28, 2018 @12:27PM (#18778084)
The only problem with the near-daily school shootings and other mass shootings is that those are a choice that we, as a society, have decided we want to tolerate and have in our lives.

I'm getting a little more than annoyed with the constant insinuation, in the face of challenging, difficult and emotionally painful issues in our society getting thrown into a discussion as something we've factually accepted and tolerated as something that just 'is', as if we've thrown our hands up and said "please keep slaughtering our school children".

Especially in the form of throwaway comments from individuals who aren't actually putting forth a solution themselves.

Please stop waxing post hoc ergo propter hoc like this-just because a solution hasn't made its way through the mechanisms of law and procedural solution making, and please stop projecting YOUR cynicism on the issue on to the rest of us.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by magduf on Wednesday January 02, 2019 @10:41AM (#18806851)
>we've factually accepted and tolerated as something that just 'is', as if we've thrown our hands up and said "please keep slaughtering our school children".

That's exactly what we've done. We're not making any solutions, because too many voters and politicians absolutely refuse to. To them, this slaughter is the price they're willing to pay for their "freedom" to have guns.

>Especially in the form of throwaway comments from individuals who aren't actually putting forth a solution themselves.

Solutions have been put forth, countless times over many years. The pro-gun side refuses to accept any of them, because it means they can't have all the guns they want. It's really quite simple. We're dealing with extremists, except that these extremists have the vote of about 1/2 the population.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by thedaemon on Friday December 28, 2018 @11:09AM (#18777542)
"Idiot with a new toy" is not a very interesting news story in the US. The object is to make sales with headlines. Therefore it's always the worst possible thing. It's not cultural unless you count the media as our culture, which it is part of it.
Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by gcb0 on Friday December 28, 2018 @10:54AM (#18777417)
your theory doesn't hold for most things. more school shootings than days in a year? no problem. politicians selling the country for personal gain? no problem.

Americans are pretty chill, dude.

Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by dhimes on Friday December 28, 2018 @11:00AM (#18777468)
Ouch! (But fair...)
Re:911 call centers down in Washington state by kabdib on Friday December 28, 2018 @12:09PM (#18777962)
It definitely crossed my mind. On the other hand, what I've read about the "security" of the infrastructure for controlling power, water, gas and so on doesn't fill me with confidence, and concern for these systems is not unreasonable.

A state-level actor could make the next election day in the US pretty spectacular.