News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by tzs on Friday November 05, 2010 @03:29PM (#1874506)
She brought this on herself. It's interesting to compare what the outcome would have been with a rational defendant.

She had downloaded and was sharing a couple thousand songs. I don't think we've been told what the RIAA's initial settlement offer was when they contacted her, but I believe those are generally in the $3-5k range.

Now at this point, you probably don't know how many songs they know you have pirated and are sharing, and of those you don't know how many they can actually prove. You can guess that they probably know about a lot, though, as they have generally only gone after big time sharers.

For every song that they can prove you violated copyright on, they will get a MINIMUM of $200 statutory damages if you can prove that you were an "innocent infringer". If not, the MINIMUM is $750 per song. (The maximum is something like $30k/song, raised up to something like $150k/song if they can show you were a willful infringer).

Being extremely optimistic, knowing that you've in fact infringed a couple thousand songs, and so calculating damages as an innocent infringer, all they need to do is get you on more than 25 songs, and your BEST CASE outcome is worse than just accepting the initial settlement.

If the innocent infringer thing doesn't fly, all they have to do is get you on 7 songs and you lose compared to accepting a $5k settlement offer up front.

A rational defendant would simply have jumped at the initial settlement offer, accepting that by pirating a couple thousand songs they were essentially taking a bet that they could get the songs for free, but if they lost they'd end up paying about 2.5 times per song than what they would have paid at iTunes.

She refused to settle. She tried to blame others, such as her kids, for the downloading. She tried to destroy evidence (after the other side knew about the evidence--if you are going to destroy evidence you really need to destroy it BEFORE the other side knows it exists). She lied about her actions under oath in court.

These are the kind of actions that make a jury think you are not an innocent infringer--in fact they make a jury think you are scum, and when told to pick damages from a big range, the jury tends to go high, not low on you.

She had another chance to be rational, as the RIAA again made a settlement offer after the first trial, for considerably less than they had won. I don't believe it was as good as their initial offer, but it was still pretty good--somewhere close to the bottom range of non-innocent infringer statutory damages for the 24 songs they actually ended up litigating over.

Nope, she fought and got another trial. She lost again (which makes since, given nothing had changed), and this new jury went much higher on damages. Oops. Now she's had a third trial, and another loss, and another jury going high.

And she's rejected a $25k settlement offer from the RIAA.

She should accept that offer, apologize for being such an idiot, and ask for donations. There will be enough sympathetic people to cover $25k.

And then someone should see if the lawyers who represented here can be brought up on ethical charges. It seems pretty clear that they used her in order to try out their cockamamie legal theories, and that they were acting in their interests, not in the interests of their client.

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by alexqgb on Friday November 05, 2010 @07:50PM (#1875411)
The fact that she was both wrong and stupid is beside the point. The real issue is the absurdity of the punishment, which is both cruel and unusual in that it's wildly disproportionate, and totally unparalleled by any other form of statutory damage.

Cases like this are exactly why the Framers insisted on jury trials in the first place. Through the principle of Jury Nullification, jurors retain power over the law through sanctioned refusal to convict - even when the law has clearly been violated. This check exists as the last line of defense against lawmakers who are abusive, corrupt, and/or inept. For example, the ones who authorized these monstrous fines.

In 1972, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia said that the jury has an " unreviewable and irreversible power... to acquit in disregard of the instructions on the law given by the trial judge.... (US vs Dougherty, 473 F 2d 1113, 1139 (1972)). However, this ruling went on to note "The fact that there is widespread existence of the jury's prerogative, and approval of its existence as a necessary counter to case-hardened judges and arbitrary prosecutors, does not establish as an imperative that the jury must be informed by the judge of that power".

In other words, the judge is free to 'command' that the jury rule only on the law, not on its justice. And the jury is free to ignore him - but only if they're aware of the option.

I don't know if the 1972 ruling has been superseded. Assuming it hasn't, it appears that none of the judges (or the defense lawyers) made the rules clear. So now we get a legal fiasco, ridiculous public expense, and at least one ruined life.

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by tzs on Saturday November 06, 2010 @02:33PM (#1877436)
A jury also has the power to convict in disregard of the law given by the trial judge as many a black defendant in the south from around the end of the civil war through the mid 20th century found out.

The judge or a higher court can reverse a jury guilty verdict, so some such wrongly convicted defendants are spared, but most won't be so lucky. In most cases, there will be enough evidence offered to support conviction if the jury believes that evidence over the defendant's explanations, and so there is no way for the court to tell if the jury convicted because they felt the defendant was guilty, or if they convicted because they don't like the defendant's race, religion, sexual orientation, etc.

The Framers understood this, which is why they didn't require juries to be told of the nullification power. No one has ever managed to come up with a way to tell juries of nullification without taking a great risk that juries will figure out that they can also go the other way and convict when the law doesn't support it. Not telling the jury about the nullification power is essentially the check on the nullification power.

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by darklajid on Friday November 05, 2010 @04:46PM (#1874851)
While you seem to be much better informed that I am: Still, in some parts of the world damages this high are just mind-blowing.

Yes, you might be perfectly right and she should know the legal outcome in her country, but reading this here I somehow have to assume that Proposition 19 was accepted and the jury was stoned.

Again: I _know_ that the legal system is just different and I have no right to judge it. But I can compare it and say that this is completely out of perspective from my position here. Wow.

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by astrofinch on Saturday November 06, 2010 @12:19AM (#1875996)
FWIW, Proposition 19 was a proposition in California. This woman was from Minnesota.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by reader5000 on Friday November 05, 2010 @06:57PM (#1875252)
Regardless of her trial strategy, the absurdity here is the federal law permitting essentially a financial death penalty for an individual sharing a few songs. The statutory copyright penalties were clearly written with commercial-type infringement in mind, not individuals engaging in personal use. The penalty is grossly unfair, the RIAA - regardless of their settlement offers - come off looking like huge pieces of shit, and the whole thing needs to be appealed and the judgment reversed.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by chancho on Saturday November 06, 2010 @02:18AM (#1876311)
"The statutory copyright penalties were clearly written with commercial-type infringement in mind"

The whole "these bits are worth $X each" scenario becomes meta-absurd when you consider commercial infringement. At $60K/song, The Pirate Bay would be on the hook for more money than the Earth could produce before it was consumed by the sun.

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by defen on Friday November 05, 2010 @07:45PM (#1875398)
If you took away all the parts that make her an unsympathetic defendant (blaming it on the kids, destroying evidence, lying about actions under oath), would you still support this outcome? After all, the exact same thing could have happened to her if she hadn't done those things, but still refused to settle. In other words, do you support making an example of a guilty person by punishing him in a way that far exceeds the damage that he caused? If so, in what situations is it justifiable? Would $150,000 be an appropriate fine for single graffiti tag?
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by tzs on Friday November 05, 2010 @08:25PM (#1875486)
Well, if I perpetrated graffiti, got caught, and the building owner said to pay him essentially the cost of painting over the graffiti and he'd consider the matter settled--otherwise he'd take me to court, and then I found out that the anti-graffiti law had been written with major offenders who cause massive damage in mind, and so the minimum I'd be out if it went to court is $150k...guess what?

I'd freaking settle, and write to my legislators suggesting that the law needed to be tweaked to allow for small time graffiti, where a reasonable penalty would be the cost of clean up plus enough to sting enough to discourage repeat offending.

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by defen on Friday November 05, 2010 @08:56PM (#1875544)
Well that I agree with. I don't think nearly as many people would have a problem with this if the statutory penalty were in the $1,000 per song range. But $1.5 million dollars just seems absurd.

One problem with my graffiti analogy is that there's a precise way to measure the actual harm to the victim from graffiti, whereas with file sharing it's very nebulous and almost entirely centered around punishment as opposed to restitution.

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by chc on Friday November 05, 2010 @06:29PM (#1875171)
So, essentially, "Look at that skirt! She was asking for it!"

Horrible actions don't become less horrible just because you can come up with a facile excuse for them. $1.5M does not seem like a reasonable penalty, even if she isn't very likable and clearly was not in the right.

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by darklajid on Friday November 05, 2010 @07:12PM (#1875317)
I'm with you on that "that's an interesting argument" train of thought, but you ruin the argument if you pull it down to this level.

Most people react _very_ emotional (and - for the most part - this is probably a really good thing) if you bring in arguments about sexual abuse (bonus points for minors).

Let's try to stop these comparisons. They are kind of like Godwin's law, killing the discussion in the process.

In fact - did already someone name this fact before? Can I claim? ;)

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by chc on Friday November 05, 2010 @07:48PM (#1875407)
That's a good point. I hadn't intended for the argument to have such a strong emotional overtone. It just occurred to me as a known-to-be-invalid argument that the comment resembled very closely. I'll keep your law in mind from now on.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by GHFigs on Friday November 05, 2010 @07:03PM (#1875283)
So, essentially, "Look at that skirt! She was asking for it!"

That isn't even remotely the argument that was made in the comment you're replying to.

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by chc on Friday November 05, 2010 @07:44PM (#1875397)
I think "She brought this on herself" is pretty close to "She was asking for it." And most of the facts in the comment go not toward the severity of the crime she was convicted of nor necessity of such a severe response, but merely toward showing that her behavior was provocative and that she failed to take many precautions.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by awa on Friday November 05, 2010 @07:10PM (#1875313)
She was actually violating a law and hence your quote doesn't make any sense (Apart from adding sensationalism) in this story.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by chc on Friday November 05, 2010 @07:51PM (#1875416)
My point is that many people violate laws every day without receiving such an absurd punishment. The fact that somebody violated a law does not give society — much less the recording industry — a right to do whatever it wants with them.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by tedunangst on Friday November 05, 2010 @03:41PM (#1874562)
Small point, but I think it's important to distinguish between being sued for downloading vs uploading. This wasn't just a bet about costs of buying from itunes vs downloading, which she could probably have done with impunity.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by nkassis on Friday November 05, 2010 @03:47PM (#1874593)
That's the biggest issue here because I don't think they ever showed that the songs were downloaded from her computer. The RIAA used the make available argument which makes no sense to me.

Frankly, this whole case has nothing to do with Thomas being a good person or an evil person stealing music, rational or irrational. The real question is why 1.5 million was awarded for something that's orders of magnitude less in damages. It's ridiculous.

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by weavejester on Friday November 05, 2010 @08:11PM (#1875464)
Regardless of her poor judgement, the end result is that RIAA is being awarded $1.5 million dollars for an action that caused less than $24 in economic harm.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by tzs on Friday November 05, 2010 @08:36PM (#1875515)
The action was prompted by a couple thousand songs, not just 24 songs, so the economic harm could be up to several thousand dollars (depending on how many people downloaded the songs she was sharing)--a number remarkably close to what the RIAA initially offers to settle for when they first contact people.

BTW, even if the RIAA could actually collect $1.5 million dollars, it would be a net loss for them. They've almost certainly spent more than that on legal fees so far.

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by vl on Friday November 05, 2010 @09:50PM (#1875646)
For 1.5$ mil you can get 5 medium-level lawyers to work for you for entire year full-time. There is no indication that this case required this amount of legal power.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by tedunangst on Friday November 05, 2010 @08:52PM (#1875540)
The RIAA was willing to let her walk by making a donation to a musicians' group, so their motive in this action is not profit.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by nitrogen on Friday November 05, 2010 @09:24PM (#1875591)
If it were me, and I could choose the group, I would accept and donate to Creative Commons.