News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by tzs on Friday November 05, 2010 @08:25PM (#1875486)
Well, if I perpetrated graffiti, got caught, and the building owner said to pay him essentially the cost of painting over the graffiti and he'd consider the matter settled--otherwise he'd take me to court, and then I found out that the anti-graffiti law had been written with major offenders who cause massive damage in mind, and so the minimum I'd be out if it went to court is $150k...guess what?

I'd freaking settle, and write to my legislators suggesting that the law needed to be tweaked to allow for small time graffiti, where a reasonable penalty would be the cost of clean up plus enough to sting enough to discourage repeat offending.

Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s... by defen on Friday November 05, 2010 @08:56PM (#1875544)
Well that I agree with. I don't think nearly as many people would have a problem with this if the statutory penalty were in the $1,000 per song range. But $1.5 million dollars just seems absurd.

One problem with my graffiti analogy is that there's a precise way to measure the actual harm to the victim from graffiti, whereas with file sharing it's very nebulous and almost entirely centered around punishment as opposed to restitution.