Re:Jury finds Minn. woman owes $1.5 million for sharing 24 s...
by tzs on Saturday November 06, 2010 @02:33PM
(#1877436)
A jury also has the power to convict in disregard of the law given by the trial judge as many a black defendant in the south from around the end of the civil war through the mid 20th century found out.
The judge or a higher court can reverse a jury guilty verdict, so some such wrongly convicted defendants are spared, but most won't be so lucky. In most cases, there will be enough evidence offered to support conviction if the jury believes that evidence over the defendant's explanations, and so there is no way for the court to tell if the jury convicted because they felt the defendant was guilty, or if they convicted because they don't like the defendant's race, religion, sexual orientation, etc.
The Framers understood this, which is why they didn't require juries to be told of the nullification power. No one has ever managed to come up with a way to tell juries of nullification without taking a great risk that juries will figure out that they can also go the other way and convict when the law doesn't support it. Not telling the jury about the nullification power is essentially the check on the nullification power.
The judge or a higher court can reverse a jury guilty verdict, so some such wrongly convicted defendants are spared, but most won't be so lucky. In most cases, there will be enough evidence offered to support conviction if the jury believes that evidence over the defendant's explanations, and so there is no way for the court to tell if the jury convicted because they felt the defendant was guilty, or if they convicted because they don't like the defendant's race, religion, sexual orientation, etc.
The Framers understood this, which is why they didn't require juries to be told of the nullification power. No one has ever managed to come up with a way to tell juries of nullification without taking a great risk that juries will figure out that they can also go the other way and convict when the law doesn't support it. Not telling the jury about the nullification power is essentially the check on the nullification power.