If you have a pattern of abuse even legitimate behavior may appear as abuse. The solution is to not engage in a pattern of abuse.
If they consistently "lost track of time" or "got caught up doing X" but they one day get a flat, why wouldn't I believe them?
I don't know if or how this affects the analogy.
You can't do much over the behavior of people's whose trust you've lost, so if they don't believe your flat tire story, too bad for you.
How is systematically not meeting your time commitment not straigth up lying?
I am don't think any alleged previous wrongdoing answers those questions, unless you are saying there is no specific evidence of any wrong doing in the latest revelations, but we should assume there to be anyway.
If you want an accurate understanding of what's going on in the world, then you should probably believe that people who are habitually late do sometimes also get flat tires. If they say they had a flat, the logical conclusion isn't blind trust or being sure they're lying, but mild skepticism.
Yes, the goal should be for both parties to reach a correct understanding: not at fault this time, but often is.
Facebook, to some, appears to be only loudly arguing about the specific injustices they feel, without giving up much ground on their habitual mistakes.
The only irrational part is when there's a disproportionate response, and that comes with part of the social contract - outside of existential threat, repetition and duration require an escalation of response until a behavioral correction is observed. It's a feedback system and feedback is also rational (only the form of the feedback might be questionable).
If they’re late 10% of the time and the odds of a flat tire are 1 in 1000 (based on my driving experience I’d say that’s a high estimate, too) then you should start by assigning a probability of around 1% to the flat tire hypothesis. Then modify that based on how honest they typically are.
There were leaked emails in which FB was discussing how to ACTIVELY ensure the updates for their app specifically obfuscated the fact that they were preventing the users from understanding what they were agreeing to, as it was bad PR, and Zuck authorizing with "yup do it"
All from here: https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2018/12/new-documents-show-fac...
If you have a source for him saying "Yup do it" to an attempt at confusing their users on an agreement... that would be a big news story.
https://www.cjr.org/the_media_today/british-parliament-faceb...
https://www.mercurynews.com/2018/12/06/facebook-knew-collect...
Do you honestly think that Facebook was trying to allow users to make the decision in an informed way? I suspect most people instead think Facebook was trying to get some way of SAYING that the users agreed while maximizing the odds that the users would be surprised to discover the implications.
That'd be my answer as to "why". I could be wrong, but I can't think of an occurrence where FB seemed to be acting in their (non-advertising, non-paying) users' interests. Yet FB will claim otherwise.
And that disconnect is what people are finding "wrong".
I mean, that's kind of a tough thing to hang our hats on if the idea is to take Facebook down. From congress the best you could hope for there is for companies to be required to use "more clear" language when writing up consumer agreements in the future. Which would be a nightmare requirement in and of itself, so it would likely never happen.
I'm not taking a position on "taking Facebook down" - I'm arguing that legal isn't the same as moral/ethical, and it's entirely correct to label an activity as "wrong" and to be upset by it without that activity being illegal (In fact, I'd argue there's great value in having such legal-but-not-moral areas as long as they aren't too vast). I'm not well-versed enough in the legalities to SAY if the behavior is legal, but I feel well qualified to say when something feels deceptive and wrong.
Outside of the general issue of legal vs moral: While I agree with you about the legal requirements of agreements, I'm also okay with saying there is such thing as bad faith in entering an agreement, and a reasonableness standard about what people are actually agreeing to seems legit - the alternative grants all the power to people who can afford the time and lawyers for every agreement. Whether such standards would have any impact on this situation is way beyond my knowledge level to be certain (i.e. I'm not saying that's the solution to this particular problem, it's just a related thought)
Anyway I do sometimes think that it might be good to have an actual screen recording of everything I do online, just so that I could look back and see what a permission dialog looked like for instance.
Maybe I will build a Chrome extension for myself.
1) automatically grabbed a screen text (so it snags the text hidden inside a scrollable container, for example) capture (with notification) when you had a page with a button or link with the text "Agree" or "Understand" or "Accept" in it. Capture would be "tagged" with referrer url, current url, and timestamp. Possibly a screenshot of the rendered page as well.
2) Allowed you to manually trigger such a capture.
I'd think that would involve reasonable space, and even if I wasn't trying to gather legal evidence, it'd be interesting to see the results after, say, only a month.
1) It's not "sometimes." It happens many, many times a day. It's basically become the way they do things.
2) "narratives capture the public's attention so the incentives get a little weird" -- So the news is no longer about finding and transmitting the truth. It's about selling narratives? And the more the legacy news industry progresses on its inevitable collapse, the worse it's going to get? Nice.
2) I'm not sure what point you are trying to make here. I didn't say that news isn't about finding the truth. But when describing complex systems and situations there is always going to be judgement applied in the distillation process. So for instance, you could say "Facebook provided private message data to some application partners" or you could say "Facebook's users inadvertently agreed to share private message data with application partners." Both are true.
I have also seen Facebook exec emails about obfuscating permission dialogues in order to get more permissions, though. It seems to have been pretty accepted practice.
You don't. There is no safe way to do this, but more to the point, this is not something that your users want to actually do. If people want to give their data to a "third party" they can just go directly to that party and give it their data. Your permission or participation is not required.
If you'd like to try it, start a social network and then start serving big dialogue boxes that say "Would you like to give all your personal data to a third party? Click here to get started." Note that Facebook worked very hard to do the exact opposite of serving that kind of clear dialogue.
> I want them to be able to use third party chat UIs.
Why? If you are running a chat system, why not just build the UI you want your chat system to have? This doesn't even make sense to me.
I think maybe what you mean is that you want your users to be able to interact with 3rd party services through your chat UI? In which case the answer is to build an API for that which properly handles data and privacy. "Let this 3rd party do everything with a user account that a user can do" is a shitty, lazy and/or deliberately permissive way to deliver that feature. Note that Apple and Whatsapp, among others, provide 3rd party chat integrations without letting the 3rd parties read every message in the user's archive.
People who used the Nylas N1 client, or now, any app that uses the Nylas APIs are sharing all their email messages, contacts and calendars with a third party - this includes your messages and your telephone number.
There have been studies on Facebook's permission dialog and its lack of usability, and it's hard to escape the conclusion that it was deliberately designed to make it hard for users to understand. It has been improved several times over the years.
For example http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.183.... (from 2010) which discusses how permissions dialogs are not designed in a way that allows users to easily understand permissions (using Facebook as one example) https://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=2078843 (from 2011) which found that Facebook users were unaware of the extent of 3rd party apps' data access even after viewing the permissions screen.
https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/blogs/techftc/2015/05/usabil... discusses usability concerns around permissions dialog boxes in general so it's been on peoples' radar for a while as an issue.
> Facebook also regarded these partners as extensions of itself because they committed to abide by its privacy guidelines, according to the Times report, and therefore the company felt it did not need users' permission before sharing their data.
I really like Steve Jobs' comments on how to operate, with regards to questions of user privacy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=39iKLwlUqBo (3 minutes)
While I'm not convinced about the need for devices to be locked down, the rest of his response should be the gold standard in my opinion.
i think we can use a dose of common sense to understand that what FB did was ... let's say not in the interest of users. so really, the problem is not that fb is being unfairly taken to task. the problem here is the NYT reporting isn't a deep investigative enough piece for your taste. it's more of a drive-by "oh boy, what did FB do now" click attractor.
This is precisely why I keep pounding on the idea that "Trusted Execution" technologies need to be turned around 180 degrees. It's intimately tied tot he idea of privacy. It's horrible when governments and big companies have "privacy" but use their power to strip individuals of it. Likewise, it's a public good for individuals to have privacy, and for governments and big companies to be transparent. Likewise, it's horrible when big companies turn "Trusted Execution" against individuals -- this is DRM. However, it would be a tremendous good if the voting public got some laws passed requiring big companies to subject themselves to Trusted Execution technologies when handling customer data.
Doing this would give individuals the keys to control their own personal information.
Maybe a list of entities, and when you click on one, you see what they would see.
If you care, you opt out. If you don't, you do not opt out. Either way, it makes it hard to plead ignorance or vagueness of permission dialog text.
But not on precisely how. I think what we’ve identified, nationally, is a need to legislate standards around digital privacy and information monopolies. Your confusion is reasonable. We, as a nation, never had these conversations. Democracy is, at the end of the day, a reactive system.
Now, how do I do it in a non-evil way? I am presuming here that everyone agrees that should be possible to make that work.
Apparently Facebook did it the wrong way. Why?
If the argument is "Users who agreed to this integration did not know what they were doing because the permission dialog was not clear enough", then I have a couple questions:
- What was the permission dialog like, really? Does anyone have a source for this?
- Why does the New York Times not go into this? I mean, if that is the issue, it seems kind of important?
- Reading the latest Times piece, does anyone feel comfortable arguing that the reader will understand what is apparently the issue - the permission dialog was not clear enough? Or is it more likely that the reader is left with the vague notion that Facebook just dumped all user's private messages over to a bunch of other companies?