News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by nsx147 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:10PM (#18717799)
This is a good step forward IMO. Life sentence was pretty harsh for 3 strikes on drug charges - 25 years is still a lot, but this sets the bar for the next iteration to keep getting lower
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by maxlybbert on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @05:23PM (#18720401)
I have no idea if this is still the case, but I was surprised to learn about twenty years ago that Brazil’s constitution prevented anyone from getting a prison sentence longer than 35 years. Brazil also doesn’t have capital punishment.

Most violent crimes are committed by young men, say from teenagers to early twenties. I don’t know anything about Brazil’s juvenile justice system, but a twenty year old who gets a 35 year sentence is very unlikely to be a violent person at 55. And if not, another 35 year sentence puts him away until he’s 90. It doesn’t take very many prison sentences like that to completely get rid of the risk of recidivism.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by turc1656 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:35PM (#18718042)
I've always found it fascinating how people are still willing to risk life imprisonment for a third strike after getting caught twice already. It really boggles my mind. I'll never quite understand this mentality. Whether the punishment is life, 25 years, or something else - I just don't understand how the risk/reward ratio plays out in their mind.

I get that one argument is that many have "nothing to lose". And yeah, maybe they are very poor, unemployed, without a proper education or skills so their situation doesn't look great. But to then say "well, doesn't matter if I end up in prison for the rest of my life is truly mind-boggling.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:06PM (#18718327)
> I just don't understand how the risk/reward ratio plays out in their mind.

For the most part, the same as in most people’s minds for most decisions—if it plays out at all, it does so only as a post hoc rationalization for decisions not made based on risk/reward calculus in the first place, which conveniently juggles facts to support the action already undertaken.

Rational choice theory is a nice model that has some use in modelling behavior in some domains in broad aggregates, but has little to do with how individual decisions are actually made.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by scarface74 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:40PM (#18718090)
You’re assuming that the justice system only convicts the guilty and doesn’t target poor and minorities.

What if they had a 3 strikes clause for white collar crime?

Also once you’ve been convicted, it’s harder to find a job with a criminal record.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by _ah on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:39PM (#18718080)
You're confused that people who (by definition) make poor life choices are unable to evaluate consequences and make better life choices?
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by turc1656 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:52PM (#18718197)
Honestly, yes. I realize that response sounds stupid but we're talking about something pretty obvious. Like "hey, if we catch you selling drugs again you go to jail for the rest of your life." Why anyone would ever take that gamble is simply lost on me. I don't care how uneducated or unintelligent a person is - everyone who isn't very mentally handicapped can understand that. And they still do it. I just can't wrap my mind around it.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by diob on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @03:35PM (#18719308)
It's more that 3 strikes can happen all at once. The justice system isn't fair by a long shot. Hardly anyone is charged with a single crime, so usually the 3 strikes happen through a single instance.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by turc1656 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @05:03PM (#18720176)
Is that true? If so, I wasn't aware 3 strikes could happen all at once. I thought a strike was incurred at a given sentencing, which incorporates all the charges from a single crime.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by philwelch on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @04:34PM (#18719910)
> It's more that 3 strikes can happen all at once. The justice system isn't fair by a long shot. Hardly anyone is charged with a single crime, so usually the 3 strikes happen through a single instance.

Yeah, that's actually incredibly possible in our legal system, and it's incentivized by the plea bargaining system, because the more charges the prosecutor can pile on, the stronger her negotiating position.

Suppose you rob a bank with a gun, the old-fashioned way. Clearly, that's at least one crime: armed robbery. Now, usually brandishing a weapon is a crime in itself, and if you're brandishing it at people, that's also assault with a deadly weapon, and if you're threatening people, that might qualify as terroristic threat. Arguably, the single act of "waving a gun around and demanding money from the bank teller" has double jeopardy protection and it should only count as one of these three crimes. But what if you point the gun at more than one bank teller? What if you point it at the customers and demand that they get on the floor? I don't know. I'm not a lawyer.

Suppose things escalate and you, for example, don't even shoot the gun, you just pistol-whip someone. That's definitely an additional crime. It's an additional crime for each person you pistol-whip, let alone shoot. Probably some sort of aggravated assault or assault and battery type thing, depending on the laws in your particular state.

Let's imagine that during this bank robbery, someone dies. They don't even die of being pistol whipped. There's a little old lady at the bank who just wants to deposit her Social Security check, and here you come, screaming and yelling and pointing a gun in people's faces, and she dies of a heart attack. Was the heart attack caused by the stress of being in the middle of a bank robbery? Yes, and the medical examiner would rule the cause of death as "homicide". Which means, merely by virtue of robbing the bank in the first place, you are now guilty of felony murder.

Now, let's suppose you didn't just walk in the front door, like an idiot, and you instead did something more creative like crashing through a window. Breaking the window is probably a type of vandalism or malicious mischief, so let's add that on too. Likewise, if you fire a warning shot into the ceiling, like in the movies: lots of property damage there (and, of course, strict liability for anything or anyone else that stray bullet happens to run into.)

Let's talk about the gun. Is it an unregistered gun in a state that requires gun registration? Did you carry it concealed and loaded on your way into the bank without having a concealed carry permit? Did you buy a stolen gun from a fence instead of having an obvious paper trail at a legitimate gun dealer that has your name and ID on file? Probably a crime or two in there as well.

The getaway is its own unending font of possible crimes. Let's suppose you get your bag of cash, jump in your car, and drive away. If at any point in this process you're being pursued by the police, this constitutes resisting arrest. You're likely committing reckless driving, too. Obviously if you run over a person that's vehicular assault and felony murder again, but depending on what else you run into, you could also be guilty of animal cruelty, mailbox vandalism (actually a federal offense), damaging government property, just plain normal vandalism, and so forth, not to mention all the trespassing and moving violations you're undeniably committing as well.

Also, if you ever discussed this plan with anyone, there might be a case for conspiracy. It might not hold up in court or anything, but a clever prosecutor will pile this on anyway just to turn a witness against you or for cheap bargaining leverage.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by KSteffensen on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:09PM (#18718372)
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by ozzmotik on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:39PM (#18718725)
i agree with the poor impulse control claim but beyond that, for people who feel disenfranchised by the system and as though they have no other qualities they can actually use to survive in society, at least wrt the concept of selling drugs, that is an extremely reliable way to make enough money in order to support your life and the pursuit of your desires. that being said, i do believe that anyone can improve their position in life if they stop allowing themselves to believe that they are completely limited by their societal status. however, as someone who struggles to integrate into society in any meaningful way and ultimately support myself, I do get how easy it is to convince yourself that there is no other choice other than what you currently have. it's a super toxic line of reasoning and antithetical to the pursuit of happiness as it were, but man its really easy to do. and as we all (likely) know, many humans tend to prefer to just do things the easy way and rely on what they know or are comfortable with
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by kodablah on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:49PM (#18718163)
> I'll never quite understand this mentality.

That's ok. The important thing is to recognize it exists. Too often, be it taxes on cigarettes or theft or laws like this, people apply their personal lifestyles instead of others.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by mikeash on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:53PM (#18718200)
You don’t get to the point of having two felonies on your record by being good at thinking through the consequences of your actions.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by dsfyu404ed on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:07PM (#18718346)
It's really easy to rack up multiple crimes when you can't afford a good lawyer because they always throw the book. A lot of times "doing X while committing a felony" is also a felony.

People also forget that tons of petty crimes that are misdemeanors have felony equivalents and which one you're charged with is often up to the discretion of the prosecutor.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by hnbroseph on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:22PM (#18718528)
i'm not sure why it's difficult for you. perhaps you are doing a good job demonstrating how privilege impacts thought.

big scary retaliation can only really gain purchase against those who really perceive other options for themselves. if you don't perceive options, you're likely to just be resigned to what you see as your fate. it's not crazy to see prison as shelter and food, and far better than starving in a ditch.

we also cannot assume that people are in an emotionally and psychologically healthy position when deciding what risks are worth taking, or even that people are considering risks at all, or when they do that the risks are even perceived as optional.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by burfog on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:38PM (#18718716)
Yep. Some people just don't think right. Their minds are broken.

The whole point of the 3-strikes laws is to acknowledge that rehabilitation is simply not possible with some people. Such people will forever be a hazard to society, and thus need to be separated from society.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by jimmy1 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:19PM (#18717893)
Not meaning this in a combative fashion, but why is only what you think right in this case? I think there are plenty of people that were actually OK with the 3 strike penalty, and more that would be OK with 25 years. Why set the bar for the next iteration to keep getting lower? A large segment of the population does not agree with decriminalization of drugs as policy.

Personally I would be a fan of 3 strikes and you are committed to mandatory drug rehabilitation, and aren't let out until you are clean for x number of whatever amount of time seems fair and reasonable.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by danso on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:37PM (#18718056)
The 3-strikes law had an ostensible worthy purpose, which was to prevent incidents in which judges made ill-informed lenient sentencing decisions, which could happen through pure incompetency or ignorance. But like all simplifying algorithms, the downside was a sentencing system that was indifferent and uncompromising to absurdities, such as sentencing someone to life in prison no matter how relatively minor the first- and second- strikes were.

Even the name and implementation of the law -- "3 strikes" -- feels absurd. IIRC from the Congressional debate, the choice of 3 strikes is rooted in the familiarity of the term from America's pastime, not based out of an analysis of penalties and recidivism outcomes.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by burfog on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:32PM (#18718636)
The problem of ill-informed lenient sentencing decisions was already dealt with by mandatory minimum sentences.

The 3-strikes laws serve a different purpose. The trouble is that some people simply won't get the message that crime is unacceptable. It doesn't matter how long we keep them in prison. Letting them out is like being an accomplice, because they are going to commit that crime. The only solution is to separate these criminals from society.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by danso on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @03:42PM (#18719381)
They are the same purpose and the same thing. 3-strikes is by its very definition a mandatory minimum sentencing guideline. Moreover, not every kind of felony has a mandatory minimum statute, whereas a broad range of serious crimes could qualify as part of 3-strikes sentencing.

It's true that some criminals may be irredeemable. The ideal is that only these criminals face the punishment intended by 3-strikes, the reality is that otherwise rehabilitatable criminals might be unduly punished. For example, prosecutors can use the statute to pressure a defendant to plead guilty or testify as state's witness, with no ability for judges to act as a check on sentencing if the defendant goes to trial and loses. And of course, there are the criminals who get life in prison for minor, usually drug-related crimes [0].

[0] https://www.rollingstone.com/politics/politics-news/cruel-an...

https://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/25/opinion/sunday/california...

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by srmatto on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @05:02PM (#18720163)
That's simply not true. Our criminal justice system isn't aimed towards reform, not really. It's aligned with a puritanical sense of punishment.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by burfog on Thursday December 20, 2018 @01:41AM (#18722955)
It can be many things at once.

1. It can reform. This is often officially implied by names that contain the word "corrections".

2. It can satisfy victims who would otherwise enact their own idea of justice.

3. It can be a deterrent for others.

4. It can be a deterrent for that same person, if later released.

5. It can protect society by making the attackers be dead or physically contained in cages, and thus away from society. It's hard to rape kids when you are all alone in a concrete box.

6. It can fulfill a religious duty.

You seem to think that numbers 2 and 6 are all we get out of the deal. This is not the case. We get all of the above. With the possible exception of number 6, all of them are beneficial.

I'm pretty sure that number 5 is what the American system is mainly about. If you can't behave, you can't be with the rest of us.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by cwkoss on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @03:29PM (#18719266)
Creating a legal framework for all recreational substances could be another solution.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by Sir_Cmpwn on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:14PM (#18718429)
The purpose of prison should be to keep dangerous people out of society. It costs society to keep people in prison, so naturally this makes sense - in a way it's our tax for the privilege of not having dangerous people around.

Non-violent offenders should not be in prison. Punishing people with prison doesn't fix the problem, better mental health services and education (real education, not lies about drugs == devil) does much better. If you want to punish drug users, you're right (and in morally questionable standing imo) and you'll have to pay for that, but if you want to reduce the drug problem you're not in the right.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by sthomas1618 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:41PM (#18718743)
> The purpose of prison should be to keep dangerous people out of society

Whatever happened to purpose of prison being rehabilitation? I mean... they are called correctional facilities. Are we so far gone now that we think criminals are beyond redemption and change?

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by philwelch on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @03:55PM (#18719508)
> Whatever happened to purpose of prison being rehabilitation?

You can't change someone's behavioral tendencies against their will. The criminal has to choose for himself to change and to be rehabilitated. The most you can do is to provide the resources and support he needs to carry out that decision once he's made it.

What you can do is (a) provide a disincentive for committing crimes and (b) separate people with a known tendency for committing crimes from the rest of society. Prison and the death penalty both accomplish these goals, but prison is cheaper and more reversible.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by Bjartr on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @04:16PM (#18719720)
> The most you can do is to provide the resources and support he needs to carry out that decision once he's made it.

To the best of my knowledge, one of the problems with US prisons today is that the resources and support you describe are not widely available.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by philwelch on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @04:41PM (#18719985)
Yeah, and that sucks, and I'd like it to change. But I don't think turning American prisons into Norwegian-style resort hotel prisons is going to magically convince every American criminal to turn into a productive citizen.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by Bjartr on Friday December 21, 2018 @01:12PM (#18735205)
> But I don't think turning American prisons into Norwegian-style resort hotel prisons is going to magically convince every American criminal to turn into a productive citizen.

I think you're arguing against a strawman here. I don't think most people who support moving from the current system towards a more Norwegian-style approach are arguing that it is the panacea that will reform all criminals, only that it will do a lot better that the current system.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by philwelch on Sunday December 23, 2018 @07:32AM (#18745734)
It’s not an uncommon fallacy to think that people only commit crimes because of poverty, desperation, or oppression, and that solving these problems is sufficient to stop crime. It’s also not an uncommon fallacy to think some sufficiently liberalized, rehabilitative form of incarceration would actually work for 95% of criminals. The fact that some people are just awful and need to be quarantined from society is uncomfortable, taboo, or alien to a lot of people.

Maybe this comes across to you as a straw man argument because you don’t live somewhere completely insane where there is political opposition to building jails and police stations in the first place because of wacky leftist ideology. Sometimes I envy people who assume I’m arguing with a straw man.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by InitialLastName on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @05:48PM (#18720639)
I mean, presumably making it possible for them to be productive citizens would be a pretty good start.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by philwelch on Thursday December 20, 2018 @12:53AM (#18722786)
Yup, I think I covered that in the first sentence of the comment you are replying to.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by Sir_Cmpwn on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:46PM (#18718804)
There are better ways to rehabilitate non-violent offenders. Prisons should focus on rehabilitation, but what sets it apart from other methods of rehabilitation is that they keep dangerous people out of society in the meanwhile.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by scarface74 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:30PM (#18718002)
Because I don’t really care about someone’s moral belief in what’s right or wrong as long as it doesn’t effect anyone else.

We have an existence proof that the “War on Drugs” has been a failure, has not made drugs any harder to get, and penalties are unequally applied on the poor and minorities.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by jimmy1 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @08:40PM (#18721816)
> Because I don’t really care about someone’s moral belief in what’s right or wrong as long as it doesn’t effect anyone else.

Moral beliefs tend to eventually end up externalized in some form or fashion. What then? What if I told you that everything we do affects someone else? This post-modernist idea that you can do whatever you want as long as it doesn't affect someone else is a fallacy. Unless you live in an isolated, self sustaining biodome in Antartica, chances are you are impacting at least one other life in extreme cases, if not more.

The "Desert Fathers" of the ancient Church, of whom left the holy cities with the extent purpose of leaving the world to not impact others (or be bothered by the cares of the world) ironically, impacted millions.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by scarface74 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @08:46PM (#18721853)
Yes and someone else’s moral belief led to miscegenation (interracial marriage) being illegal into the late 60s, Jim Crow laws, laws against homosexuality, and the War on Drugs.

Let’s not forget if those preaching “morality” had their way they would also ban birth control.

You’ll have to excuse me if I don’t pay too much credence to the “moral majority”.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by jimmy1 on Friday December 21, 2018 @10:20AM (#18733791)
This is flawed perspective and your three examples are a very mixed bag of unequal occurrences. All three of those situations are unlike the other. Jim Crow laws were very much not due to a "majority" -- if you remember, the country went into civil war over the issue of slavery, and the North has always been the more populous part of the country. Laws against Homosexuality were part of the fabric of pretty much most of the world (still so in 72 countries, as well as 70% of the commonwealth states), so not sure you can attribute that to any one particular moral majority, it was more of a global majority, so there goes that comparison out the window. And finally, the War on Drugs had nothing to do with morality, but basically one man's smart campaign to manipulate the public so that he could target minorities and anti-war protestors (later -- the CIA learned you could make a nice dime, so they continued it in the name of "national security" -- wonder where we heard that before)

And finally, your argument is very flawed because systems of morality are what have lead to the greatest human progress for thousands of years, and you are invalidating all of that on some unfortunate decade-long (strong emphasis on decade long, not millennium long) effects of fundamentalists and charlatans who, as history has already judged, were on the wrong side of things? You must have a very bleak outlook on humanity.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by scarface74 on Friday December 21, 2018 @01:18PM (#18735269)
As far as US history.

Should I start with the mass slaughter of native Americans, slavery, Japanese internment camps, etc?

All the while the “good Christians” either actively took part or looked the other way?

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by moftz on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:37PM (#18718058)
Certain addictions are pretty much life sentences. Heroin addicts will always want another hit regardless of how good they are at suppressing the addiction. A lot of people OD because they've been clean for so long that their tolerance isn't what it used to be. Maybe rehab should be the first step and not the third. Catch someone as early as possible into their addiction and they might have a fighting chance. Catch them when they've already been through the prison system a couple times and there's little hope. No one wants to hire a recidivist junkie.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by philwelch on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @04:00PM (#18719555)
There's two overlapping issues being conflated here: whether drug possession and use should be a crime, and how criminals should be punished.

I have no problem with the notion that violent criminals, thieves, and con men should be punished, and that those who persist in their crimes should be permanently removed from civil society. I do have a problem with the notion that someone only guilty of carrying two ounces of cannabis or transporting a particular species of fish across state lines should be punished in a similar fashion. That's because I think one category of felonies should continue to be felonious, and the other category should cease to be felonious.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @01:43PM (#18718116)
> Not meaning this in a combative fashion, but why is only what you think right in this case?

The law of noncontradiction: to believe X is necessarily to believe they the belief in not-X is incorrect. One may believe it is right to tolerate or accommodate the incorrect belief, but that's not the same as viewing it as correct.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_noncontradiction

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by KSteffensen on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:04PM (#18718315)
The law of non-contradiction is valid for mathematics and propositional logic, not politics and ethics.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:13PM (#18718428)
> The law of non-contradiction is valid for mathematics and propositional logic, not politics and ethics.

The law of noncontradiction is valid everywhere. One can have a meta-ethical view (which would apply to politics insofar as that depends on ethics) that ethical propositions are neither true nor false but simply subjectively preferred behavior or subjectively opposed behavior, but then one wouldn't actually believe any subordinate ethical proposition to be true; noncontradiction would still hold just fine.

But lots of people believe that ethical propositions can be true or false even if they accept some area of preference, and anyone who believes a particular ethical proposition is true must also believe that any contradictory position (the simplest case of which is simple negation) is false.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by KSteffensen on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @05:26PM (#18720428)
If you accept 'areas of preference' don't you also accept that other positions, even those in direct conflict with your own, are not necessarily wrong or false, but could simply be different?
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @07:06PM (#18721263)
> If you accept 'areas of preference' don't you also accept that other positions, even those in direct conflict with your own, are not necessarily wrong or false, but could simply be different?

If you accept areas of preference, then your beliefs in those areas are not of the form ‘X is right’ or ‘X is wrong’ but ‘X is my preference’ or ‘X is not my preference’. A statement about someone else's preference in that area does not conflict with yours even if the preferences differs (‘A prefers X’ does not contradict ‘B prefers not-X’.) Any statement of universal truth by a third party in the area of preference conflicts with the belief that it is validly an area of preference, OTOH, and cannot simultaneously be viewed as anything but incorrect while believing the area to be validly one of preference.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by scarface74 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:10PM (#18718383)
And as far as the law is concerned. The only “ethics” that the government should legislate are behaviors that infringe on someone else’s liberty/property/rights.

If someone feels that drug abuse is “unethical” shouldn’t matter as long as the drug addict is not breaking into your home or otherwise causing you harm.

Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by KSteffensen on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @03:48PM (#18719448)
I think ethics do (or should) play a part in large areas of politics, e.g. taxation, healthcare, foreign policy, criminal justice sanctions, et.c. Governments should legislate based on more than economics alone.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by scarface74 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @03:53PM (#18719486)
I agree but the war on drugs and deciding that someone should be convicted for using or buying drugs is based solely on someone’s personal belief about what someone else should do with their own body.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by drewmol on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @04:29PM (#18719859)
Yes, and we should wary of anyone who proposes to forcfully enslave others for simply excersizing their liberty to consume drugs w/o a permit from a prescriber.
Re:US Senate Passes Sweeping Criminal Justice Reform Bill by diob on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @03:30PM (#18719269)
3 strikes is a lie as a policy though. You can get in trouble once and use up all three strikes if they do separate charges. Don't fall for it.