News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by SkyPuncher on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @10:29AM (#18716233)
> So they lied in the first response (all data is wiped and unrecoverable)

Not defending Mailchimp, but keep in mind the perspective and context. To a customer support agent using some backend interface, it very well could be "completely wiped". To an escalation team, they may be able to pull it from backups in an "unofficial" manner.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by rkeene2 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:42PM (#18717538)
The antecedent of "they" in the previous sentence is the company, not an individual. The individual creating the email, as a person, probably was not lying BUT since they were acting as an agent of the company, in an official capacity all of their actions were that of the company as a whole.

This shields them from individual liability as well as makes the company liable for their actions (as long as they are acting as agents of the company in an official capacity).

The customer has no business relationship with the individual customer support person, so whether they are lying or telling the truth is irrelevant to the customer -- they do have a business relationship with the company (a single actor, with multiple agents) and the company can easily tell lies via these agents.

If the above narrative is correct, the company did very likely tell a lie since the fact that the customer's data was recoverable was probably known by the company and also the company likely actively worked to make the opposite of this known via their agents.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by wahern on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:58PM (#18717699)
> This shields them from individual liability

That's... ambiguous. Agents aren't liable for contractual violations, but agents are typically liable for torts. Liability depends on exactly what the employee did.

AFAIU, theoretically an employee committing a tort could be liable personally as well as the employer; and if service is disrupted the employer could be contractually liable.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by notatcomputer68 on Thursday December 20, 2018 @12:43PM (#18727098)
That way of looking at it - that the company is lying but the individual is not - is fascinating to me.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by tjoff on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @10:34AM (#18716286)
It is still a lie.

Also keep in mind the perspective and context that the end user has no way of knowing.

And even if the data can be recovered in an unofficial manner whether they will actually bother is highly unlikely if they care as little as they most obviously do.

So, as a user it is a pretty safe bet to just assume it is gone (but do keep poking).

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by Spivak on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @10:51AM (#18716438)
It's a lie that organizations have backups?

"Your data has been deleted" pretty much has always meant that it was deleted from the live servers and that the deletion will propagate through backups depending on the orgs retention policy/requirements.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by amingilani on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:23AM (#18716725)
MailChimp, the organization, first stated that all data was completely wiped, and when threatened, promptly produced the previously wiped data. MailChimp, as an organization, lied. It doesn't matter if the support agent didn't have the capabilities or not, that's an internal thing.

The organization knows that they have the data, but they trained their staff to reply that it was destroyed.

That's a lie. Not an untrue statement, but a deliberate lie.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by dhimes on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:16AM (#18716659)
"Your data has been deleted" pretty much has always meant

To whom? My mother? Nope- she thinks it's gone. So yeah- it's a lie, and you only catch it if you know better.

"Yes Dad I did my homework" has pretty much always meant that he hasn't started it yet.

No, it's a lie and the organization knows it. They are responsible for training their CS folks.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by Spivak on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:22AM (#18716721)
If I turn on Windows Backup on my Mom's laptop and she right clicks a file and selects "Delete" is the expected behavior that it be deleted in every backup as well?
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by icebraining on Thursday December 20, 2018 @05:04AM (#18723692)
Windows doesn't tell your Mom that her data has been wiped, just that a particular file has been deleted.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by AsyncAwait on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @05:32PM (#18720485)
If she doesn't know the backup's been set up, in her mind, yes.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by dkonofalski on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @06:43PM (#18721111)
Are you suggesting that the delete command shouldn't be trusted because there might be a backup of the file somewhere?

You people are throwing around the word "lie" very loosely here...

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by AsyncAwait on Thursday December 20, 2018 @09:44AM (#18725277)
> Are you suggesting that the delete command shouldn't be trusted because there might be a backup of the file somewhere?

No, the exact opposite in fact.

Am saying that if you weren't told there's a backup, you'll not think there's one and treat the data as completely deleted, even if they really aren't.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by detaro on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @10:58AM (#18716503)
We don't know the exact messages. If the poster asked for a copy of his data and was told it was deleted, then yes, that was a lie (although possibly the person sending the message genuinely might not have known better, which puts the fault more nebulously at "the company"). If they asked why their account was gone and the response said "all data has been deleted" without offering a copy of it, it's just bad service.

(Although given privacy regulations, it's a bad sign if a support agent can't give a precise answer about data stored or at least know not to make unchecked claims about it)

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by stefan_ on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:48PM (#18717606)
Either the data is deleted or it's not. If I send you a GDPR request, you reply "it's all deleted" then at a later date, data magically appears, that's an obvious per se violation.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by kemiller2002 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:30AM (#18716795)
>>"Your data has been deleted" pretty much has always meant that it was deleted from the live servers and that the deletion will propagate through backups depending on the orgs retention policy/requirements.

No it doesn't. Deleted most places means deleted and gone forever. There are a number of legal requirements (in the U.S.) at least when dealing with certain government organizations, and many non ones as well surrounding this. Think of it this way, a customer comes and says, there is sensitive information on your server, and since we no longer want to do business with you, you are now required to delete it. Normally there is an end date to allow the backups to be purged through propagation etc., but at the end, when they say it's deleted, it means deleted from everywhere. Sometimes this also means completely wiping drives so there is absolutely no trace of it left.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by cmiller1 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @10:52AM (#18716449)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lie

"A lie is a statement used intentionally for the purpose of deception"

I don't think you can prove it was a lie.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by LanceH on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:20AM (#18716697)
The company is set up to deliver a lie, even if the last person telling it is doing so unintentionally.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by ergothus on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:02PM (#18717084)
That's...fascinating. While we have lots of corporate personhood, I normally disregard blaming specific actions on a company because at the end of the day a person makes the call. But here you've pointed out that a company, operating as a collection of people, can "act" in ways that may be unintentional or may be deliberate, but are hard to pin down to a specific person.

Definitely worth considering in more depth, thanks for the perspective.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by ams6110 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:35PM (#18717486)
It's the main reason for corporate structure in the first place. To shield individuals from personal liability. CEO tell VP who tells Senior Manager who tells Department Manager who tells worker bee to do something. Everyone has an out. They either were "misunderstood" or they were "following instructions"
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by nwellnhof on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:41PM (#18717531)
"Corporation: An ingenious device for obtaining profit without individual responsibility." -- The Cynic's Word Book (1906), by Ambrose Bierce
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by pavel_lishin on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:27PM (#18717376)
Charles Stross has posited that we've invented Artificial Intelligence with the advent of corporations.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by lukifer on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:52PM (#18717641)
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by vokep on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:02PM (#18718280)
Yknow the paperclip maximizer? The thing where a paperclip company makes an AI that takes over everything, making it into paperclips? Well, actually you don't need any fancy AI. The paperclip company is already a [Local Currency] maximizer from the start.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by black6 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:57PM (#18717688)
Check out The Myth of the Machine by Lewis Mumford, specifically the second volume The Pentagon of Power, which gets into the idea of the modern "megamachine"
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by politician on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:22PM (#18717319)
Does your tongue know when it's used to lie?
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by pasbesoin on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:43PM (#18717545)
Exactly. Corporate structures, governance, and regulation have been formulated to treat corporations as "persons".

Well, that "person" lied. Regardless of the specific agency it employed in doing so.

(And, this type of banning and cut-off from data is obviously -- just look at the comments here -- not a one-off scenario. I find it difficult to believe that the consequences, including the customer's lost access to their data, were not thought about by MailChimp, as an organization and by people in their official roles within MailChimp.)

P.S. As I've grown older and observed and thought about things, I've come to see this as a primary role of the corporation or other such entity: To "dilute" responsibility and accountability to the extent that no member -- or, no member who has sufficient influence, who "matters" -- is ever held personally accountable for their actions within and on behalf of the corporation. [Addendum: And, in turn, the corporation is never truly held accountable, because the employees involved "lacked knowledge". Nicely circular, eh? By the way, I don't consider paying a dollar amount that is often a fraction of the gains realized by the behavior, to be "being held accountable".]

I've stopped letting people in such corporate or institutional roles off the hook, just because "they didn't know". Or rather, I've stopped letting the corporations and institutions off the hook because employee X didn't know. All too often, it's set up precisely that way and on purpose.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by baldfat on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:43AM (#18716911)
Mailchip seems to be in the wrong, but ignorance isn't the same as a lie.

I bet you people just assume or their manager doesn't know either.

Why was my account suspended -

https://mailchimp.com/help/why-accounts-get-suspended/

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by brewdad on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:01PM (#18717073)
The first level support person isn't lying if he/she doesn't truly know whether the data is recoverable. A manager higher up, who approved the script and knows better, is lying however. To the end user it makes no difference who the liar is, only the the lie is being told.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by mirimir on Thursday December 20, 2018 @12:16AM (#18722674)
But that end with:

> If we suspended your account, we'll contact you as soon as possible to let you know why, and to give you details on how to fix the situation.

And that's clearly a lie, based on OP's experience, and those of other commenters.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by mirimir on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:43PM (#18718780)
It goes lots deeper than that. It's not uncommon for corporations to be setup to prevent leaking or discovery of sensitive information. Military intelligence agencies are notorious for that.

Top executives maintain ignorance of operational unpleasantness. Technical staff know operational specifics, but little about business design and usage. Intermediate management know pieces of business design and usage, but nothing about technical implementation.

Nobody needs to lie, and still there's often no way to know for sure what happened.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by lozaning on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @02:08PM (#18718356)
I once had a job where I eventually figured out this was implicitly was I was hired to do, be the guy who gets lied to so it's not a lie when you tell the customer. I didnt last long.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by vkou on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @10:59AM (#18716509)
Since we don't have a mind-reading machine, by that logic, we can conclude that no statement can be proven to be a lie.

After all, how can we know what an alleged liar is really thinking?

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by skybrian on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:09AM (#18716600)
You exaggerate, but actually, this is a good reason to avoid accusing people of lying unless you understand the situation pretty well. Honest mistakes do happen a lot.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by vkou on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:27AM (#18716762)
It doesn't matter if the individual people at MailChimp were liars.

What matters is that the institution as a whole - the way their policies and procedures come together - lied.

The institution certainly knows of it's capabilities. It deliberately chose to not tell that to it's CS reps, because of a multitude of reasons, that come down to 'It makes our/their jobs easier.'

My ISP, for example, lies to me every time I make a call to customer service. Is the front-line CS rep lying to me? No. But his employer is, by making him tell me a pile of bullshit about why my Internet is busted - again.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by skybrian on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @04:18PM (#18719745)
Well, but that's anthropomorphizing. Institutions don't really know things, people do. Getting stuff out of one person's head to all the people that could use it actually takes a lot of effort. (Look at how terrible medical record systems are.)
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by diminoten on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:48AM (#18716957)
"The word lie has lost all meaning"

"It doesn't matter if they're liars"

C'mon, man.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by coding123 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:10AM (#18716610)
Lies can be proven by finding evidence someone did know something when they say the opposite.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by vkou on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @12:23PM (#18717329)
And in this case, we have iron-clad evidence that MailChimp, as an organization, with 100% certainty, knew that the customer's data was recoverable.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by mojowo11 on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @10:51AM (#18716432)
As a manager of a customer service team, everyone on my team knows exactly whether something has been "totally wiped" or not, regardless of whether it's something that would require developer intervention to recover. To have your reps not understand this and ultimately mislead the customer (or, in this case, I suppose former customer would be more accurate) is a management/training problem, and what the rep ultimately said on behalf of the company was a lie as a result.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by dkonofalski on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @06:34PM (#18721034)
I have to disagree with this wholeheartedly because sometimes you don't want to set the expectation with a front-line representative that the data is recoverable. In many cases, you don't want reps promising to recover data that's potentially unrecoverable. It's one thing to recover data in the event of a mistake on behalf of the company but that should require a conversation with someone outside of front-line customer service. I've been in situations too many times where our front-line team knew when something had not been "totally wiped" and they turned out to be "totally wrong" because they were aware that we kept backups but not aware that we had a strict retention policy outside of a specific timeframe or, in other cases, where a hardware failure caused a loss of a specific set of data because it was marked for deletion and wasn't scheduled to have a backup anyways. The customer had cancelled their account and agreed to losing their data but didn't actually read the terms of the cancellation they agreed to and then returned over a month later asking for their data and a rep told them that it's not really lost because we keep backups every 30, 60, and 90 days. That part was true for live accounts but not for deleted accounts.

In other words, data recovery that can't be handled by the customer service reps and that requires developer intervention should be a "surprise and delight" sort of situation and not a "customer should expect this" type of situation.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by lolc on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @07:05PM (#18721261)
Saying you know when you don't is a lie. Instructing people to say they know when they don't is instructing them to lie on your behalf.

The answer should be: "I can't know." Followed by one of: (1) Let me connect you to someone who can know (2) Let me tell you how much it costs to find out (or 3) Also we don't care.

That would be honest. Not saying it's easy.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by dkonofalski on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @07:17PM (#18721331)
>Saying you know when you don't is a lie. Instructing people to say they know when they don't is instructing them to lie on your behalf.

Because, in that case, the intent of the statement is to deceive. If the intent of the statement is simply to not set an expectation that can't be guaranteed rather than to intentionally deceive, then it's not a lie, in my opinion.

I work in audio editing and recovery/enhancement and there are situations on a regular basis where we tell customers that their audio can't be recovered. I don't think we're lying to customers in saying that despite the fact that, in some cases, we may be able to recover or enhance the audio to the point where it's usable if we invested an exorbitant amount of time on it. In the most literal sense, yes we can recover the audio but in the practical sense and, most importantly, to the customer we can't recover the audio in any meaningful way because they either can't afford the work necessary, we don't have the resources to devote to that work, or we can't guarantee that, even if we can recover it, it's acceptable for whatever purpose they need it for despite being "good enough" for us.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by lolc on Sunday December 23, 2018 @11:38AM (#18746974)
I agree with what you say. I think the trouble starts when the economical burden of recovery is not on the customer, but on the company.

If I tell somebody that something's unrevocerable because I know they wouldn't want to pay the recovery, I'm not lying. But saying nothing can be done when I'm just afraid of the cost of righting my mistake: that is lying.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by craftinator on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @10:28PM (#18722262)
The correct response is to tell the customer that it has been deleted from the main server, and that it MAY be recoverable with escalation to the dev team. Why would you even consider telling them anything else, if that is not the truth?
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by UseStrict on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:00AM (#18716519)
Agreed, regardless of whether the rep can see it or not, they should be trained properly and reply that they no longer have access to the data, and that access would require an escalation of some sort. To simply say the data is gone is a straight up lie.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by dkonofalski on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @06:40PM (#18721092)
A lie is a falsehood that's meant to deceive someone. A rep saying the data is gone because, functionally, it is is not a lie. If the intent is to set proper expectations with a customer then I think telling them it's gone and potentially being able to say "actually, we were able to recover it by escalating it" is better than "we may be able to recover it by escalating the issue" because you're underpromising and overdelivering. The opposite just sets you and the customer for failure.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by drwl on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @10:56AM (#18716484)
It's possible that tools used by Care/Support don't have everything implemented
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by detaro on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @10:57AM (#18716489)
to quote your parent:

> regardless of whether it's something that would require developer intervention to recover.

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by cwkoss on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @05:23PM (#18720406)
A company is liable for its agent's false statements.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by briandear on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:30AM (#18716793)
But it isn’t completely wiped. That is completely inaccurate.
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by patrickg_zill on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @10:54AM (#18716470)
If management sets up a system which intentionally results in untruths being told to customers ...?
Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by SkyPuncher on Wednesday December 19, 2018 @11:23AM (#18716728)
There's nothing nefarious about customer service not having access to every single possible data record on a customer. In fact, I'd be concerned if customer services had access to archived backups or raw server logs.

For most intents and purposes, data existing only on archived backups or raw server logs is "completely wiped".

Re:MailChimp deleted my account with no warning by icebraining on Thursday December 20, 2018 @05:11AM (#18723722)
There's nothing nefarious about customer service not having access to every single possible data record on a customer. In fact, I'd be concerned if customer services had access to archived backups or raw server logs.

Irrelevant, customer service can know if the data record exists without having access to it.

For most intents and purposes, data existing only on archived backups or raw server logs is "completely wiped".

My intent and purpose in asking the question may not be part of "most", yet it's still valid.