I've never worked in an environment was happy to see highly paid engineers sit idly in a meeting.
No one has ever said "Yes sure we have the time and money to spend to have you be bored instead of productive".
Obviously, YMMV - I simply want to express how I can in no way relate to the "bad guys" (management) in this scenario.
Being a parent of small kids, not once have my kids complained about "not having the big picture" or "having a say in whatever, etc."
I'm struggling to find the useful, productive substance part of your comment.
Same with open space. Most people agree they suck but somehow it's still the safe choice.
"Nobody ever got fired for holding meetings"
"Nobody ever got fired for creating an open space office"
1. The people who most vigorously argue things like "this meeting could be replaced with an E-mail"... tend to not read their E-mail.
2. The people who complain that they're always out of the loop are the ones that don't go to the meetings or read their E-mail.
3. The least productive/reliable people tend to be the ones that flake out on meetings and/or have 13,591 unread messages in their inbox.
4. I hate to interrupt people while they're "in the zone" but I'll do it after 2-3 un-answered E-mails/IMs over the course of a few days. A lot of times they'll get irritated and say something like "Why can't you just E-mail this to me instead of interrupting me?"
I agree with you with non-remote meetings though, they are highly improductive to me.