News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Anyone use a treadmill desk daily? by askafriend on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @01:04PM (#18666144)
How about you just go to the gym and build real strength and endurance instead of having a treadmill desk. The treadmill desk will only make yourself feel better about sitting around all day but it won't move the needle significantly on much else besides emotion.

The reason I chose the harsh wording is because there truly is no substitute for getting in the gym to correct posture, build strength, build endurance, and prevent injuries long-term among other things.

You just have to make time for it and do the work, just like with anything else worth having in life.

Re:Ask HN: Anyone use a treadmill desk daily? by greygore on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @01:17PM (#18666253)
Walking rather than sitting or even standing has helped me with my back problems after having had two surgeries for a herniated disc. The constant motion helps prevent me from developing problems that would always develop from those static positions.

Additionally I tend to pace when I think and this means I can stay at my desk while puzzling something out. The fact that I can burn a thousand calories on an extended day of focus is just icing on the cake.

I see my treadmill desk as something that helps me work, not a substitute for the gym. Maybe dial back the judgement and "harsh wording" in the future, or at least talk to people before developing and/or sharing such a strong negative opinion.

Re:Ask HN: Anyone use a treadmill desk daily? by simplify on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @01:21PM (#18666283)
An hour a day at the gym is no substitute for working on your posture throughout your waking hours. It'll help, sure, but it's not even 10% of your day, even less so of your week.
Re:Ask HN: Anyone use a treadmill desk daily? by kojeovo on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @01:56PM (#18666650)
I'd recommended doing both. Ultimately, you need resistance to strengthen upper back / rear delts, but you should for sure be taking breaks to 'reset'.
Re:Ask HN: Anyone use a treadmill desk daily? by ykevinator on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @03:26PM (#18667438)
I'm not interested in strength or endurance, I'm solely interested in burning extra calories and back strengthening. I'll be 50 next year, my first born is off to college next year, I cannot tolerate the mental torture of the gym, it's just too boring, I have tried for 3 decades to try to like, I just don't.
Re:Ask HN: Anyone use a treadmill desk daily? by sethammons on Thursday December 13, 2018 @11:01AM (#18673274)
"I'm not interested in strength ... I'm soley interested in ... back strengthening." :)

Nothing builds strength, especially back strength, like lifting heavy things. If you have any space at home, a squat rack (if needed to save space, free standing on each side) and a bar with some weight. Just do something like 5x5 stronglifts app and some stretching. An hour (total, for warming up, stretching, and lifting) three times a week and your world could change for the better. Mine did. You could even do this watching nor listening to some entertainment. I had back pain. Hurt to downhill on a mountain bike. Sleeping got worse. Sitting got worse. Then I started lifting and stretching (was stretching for the cycling already, but needed some new stretches for the lifting). As long as I stretch my glutes/hip and pick up heavy things, I have no back issues. The stretching is key to keep the new muscle loose.

Re:Ask HN: Anyone use a treadmill desk daily? by paulcole on Wednesday December 12, 2018 @02:54PM (#18667189)
> won't move the needle significantly on much else besides emotion.

To be fair there are worse things than feeling happier.