Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab?

Posted by KleinmanB on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @04:06PM
from the ask-hn dept.

Is there some kind of best practice philosophy? I work with many things running at once and it always confused me why sites would push you exclusively to the link you clicked.

Weigh in Gentle Fops and Courtesans.

( 12 comments | 3 points | on HN )

Re:Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab? by michael_dorfman on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @04:11PM (#1866292)

it always confused me why sites would push you exclusively to the link you clicked

They don't. The browser gives you a choice (via mouse-buttons.) The alternative, forcing links to a new tab or window, is what takes away user choice.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab? by KleinmanB on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @04:14PM (#1866299)

Right, but "displaying on the same tab" seems to be the default standard. I was interested to hear how people felt about both sides.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab? by metageek on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @04:07PM (#1866275)

Because forcing me to open a new tab is evil. If I want a new tab, I'll middle-click.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab? by KleinmanB on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @04:57PM (#1866489)

I was using HN as an example. I have noticed that many sites do this (non tech sites as well).

On something like a Macbook, or other one button mouse computers most consumers aren't as quick with their understanding of "right click menus" and other options.

Does anyone have a strong feeling when building a site about this?

In my experience when I am on a site with many things I want to interact with, if I am pushed out of the site to interact I am less likely to come back.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab? by frou_dh on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @04:52PM (#1866465)

Choosing to open in a new tab must be muscle memory territory for geeks. I must have done it thousands of times on my MBP and I can't remember what I do. I think it's holding the Cmd key.

I'm browsing with a Kindle right now which is actually a non-tabbed browser with only one type of click. Hilariously it in fact refuses to open links that try to force a new tab.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab? by evo_9 on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @04:24PM (#1866339)

I don't understand why this isn't just a setting on each of our account preferences; if you want links to open in a new window you'd just 'check' that option. Choice solves the debate (aka each their own...).

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab? by frou_dh on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @05:02PM (#1866508)

Ask every site on the web to implement an account option

vs.

Let the browser handle it

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab? by evo_9 on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @05:21PM (#1866575)

Given the relative ease of adding something like this I don't think it's as absurd a request as you are making it out to be.

Also, if you are on the 'pro new tab' side of this and occasionally forget to hold down whatever extra key you need to for your particular OS, yeah it gets old; not to mention the hassle this adds when browsing on an iphone/ipad/etc.

This change would have zero effect on any anyone; you'd have to go and turn on this option if it were added.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab? by frou_dh on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @06:08PM (#1866736)

Myself I guess I decide whether I want a new tab on a link by link basis, not site by site. Regardless, an account option on every site just seemed like epic logic bloat in aggregate. I do see the problem with touch screen browsers. Maybe a gesture like press and flick could open a link in a new tab.

So my take is: never force a new tab, browser implementers should make it quick & easy to decide for yourself for each link.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab? by evo_9 on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @06:14PM (#1866758)

Ah yeah, see I hadn't even consider that. I suppose for most it's probably not an all or nothing choice. It's an interesting yet deceptively simple usability 'problem' the more I think about this now.

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab? by SanjayUttam on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @04:50PM (#1866451)

Is right-clicking and selecting "open in a new tab" that much more difficult? (FF 3.6.X). You're clicking a mouse button either way...

[ Parent | on HN ]

Re:Ask HN: Why Don't HN stories open up in a new tab? by HackyGeeky on Wednesday November 03, 2010 @05:06PM (#1866524)

Use middle-click. Many users don't like things opening in new windows.

[ Parent | on HN ]