This is a loaded question... Cryptocurrencies are not "censorship resistant". If they were, maybe your complaint about HN's "echo chamber" would be warranted.
Here are some censorship examples:
1. BTC: OFAC has listed Bitcoin addresses that you cannot legally send money to. If you do, expect fines/jail/interrogation/etc.
2. ETH: If you exploit a vulnerability in a contract, your transaction will be invalidated.
3. BTC: If the devs decide to abandon the longest chain like they did in 2013, any transaction on the forgotten chain will be effectively erased from history.
There are more, but admittedly they require a bit of thinking to realize that they are in fact censorship. Everything is obfuscated when it comes to blockchain, which is why it's managed to fool so many smart people into taking its claims as granted.
2) Just as a logical proposition is written in law and exploited by persons (Check how often tax laws are updated), unaudited smart contracts will pose a risk. The state of auditing is improving daily
3) This is a disingenuous comparison; in 2018 One ASIC has a mining power of approximately 12 tera-hashes per second. For comparison, in 2013, the total hash rate of the Bitcoin network on April 29, 2013, was 79.02 Th/s.
Are you saying there is a difference between "censorship" and "technical censorship"? You are demonstrating the obfuscation I called out in my post. Suppressing content is suppressing content. If you believe that Bitcoin will allow you to freely send money to OFAC-sanctioned addresses, please prove it by sending a transaction there and providing us with a verified signature. Until then, my point stands.
If you rely on VISA/Mastercard, you could be "censored" for any number of arbitrary reasons -- go google the number of legitimate businesses that have had issues using those platforms.
With Bitcoin, sure, a government can use its criminal laws to ban certain transactions, but keep in mind that: (1) they need to use valid legal process, (2) the reach of their laws only go so far, etc.
Also, the OFAC banned addresses were easily tracked since they re-used addresses. Today, best practices dictate a new address for each transaction. You also have Monero, Zcash and others working on further privacy enhancements, as well as wallets like Wasabi that mix Bitcoin transactions.
But can they stop you from sending money there? Can they reverse your transaction later? That's what they mean when they say it's censorship resistant.
It's an easy to verify claim, and as far as I'm concerned it's the people making extraordinary claims that have to provide proof. If you want to prove this "censorship resistance" that you claim, please sign a transaction to an OFAC-sanctioned address and let's see how many confirmations it gets.
1) Any sensible HN-reader is not going to want to personally send money to an OFAC-sanctioned address; or
2) That if someone were to send money to it, the network would fail to confirm the transaction?
November 28 press release announcing the two addresses added to the OFAC list: https://home.treasury.gov/news/press-releases/sm556
Blockexplorer for address 1: https://www.blockchain.com/btc/address/1AjZPMsnmpdK2Rv9KQNfM...
Blockexplorer for address 2: https://www.blockchain.com/btc/address/149w62rY42aZBox8fGcmq...
Note that both have confirmed transactions occurring after November 28.
Now, I of course have no interested in sending a transaction myself since that's illegal under U.S. law, but that does not mean the network itself can be censored.
(On a side note: how did you go from working at Coinbase to being such a crypto hater? I understand if you don't want to answer that, I was just genuinely curious.)
I worked on crypto for many years and over time I realized meaningful problems were better solved by building trust, not running away from it. Further, tech can’t replace trust: humans own the network, not the other way around.
And, it's significantly less likely that this would happen again today. Bitcoin has matured a lot and the types of pressures that existed in 2013 to push changes onto the network have largely been eliminated today.
See, now you're trying to censor history. Here's a refresher of what happened:
>>> from https://freedom-to-tinker.com/2015/07/28/analyzing-the-2013-...
Right away, developers start giving out advice to downgrade:
23:49 Luke Dashjr surge_: downgrade to 0.7 if you mine, or just wait
23:50 Pieter Wuille doublec: do you operate a pool?
23:50 doublec yes
23:50 Pieter Wuille doublec: then please downgrade now
BTC Guild gets going immediately… 23:51 BTC Guild BTC Guild is going back to full default block settings and 0.7 soon.
00:01 BTC Guild Almost got one stratum node moved
… even at significant monetary cost. 23:57 BTC Guild I've lost way too much money in the last 24 hours
from 0.8The majority of nodes on the network stuck to following the longest chain rule and noticed nothing out of the ordinary.
Make a Jewish joke and Paypal will not be your friend. Piss of governments and Visa and Mastercard will make it impossible to donate to your cause.
Would you then agree with "Cryptocurrencies in 2010 censored less than cryptocurrencies in 2018"?
From the Tor FAQ:
> Some advocates of anonymity explain that it's just a tradeoff — accepting the bad uses for the good ones — but there's more to it than that. Criminals and other bad people have the motivation to learn how to get good anonymity, and many have the motivation to pay well to achieve it. Being able to steal and reuse the identities of innocent victims (identity theft) makes it even easier. Normal people, on the other hand, don't have the time or money to spend figuring out how to get privacy online. This is the worst of all possible worlds.
> So yes, criminals can use Tor, but they already have better options, and it seems unlikely that taking Tor away from the world will stop them from doing their bad things. At the same time, Tor and other privacy measures can fight identity theft, physical crimes like stalking, and so on.
BTW: Those examples I gave are for Milo Yiannopoulos and WikiLeaks. I am not sure they fit into any category you mentioned.
> If when you say whiskey you mean the devil's brew, the poison scourge, the bloody monster, that defiles innocence, dethrones reason, destroys the home, creates misery and poverty, yea, literally takes the bread from the mouths of little children; if you mean the evil drink that topples the Christian man and woman from the pinnacle of righteous, gracious living into the bottomless pit of degradation, and despair, and shame and helplessness, and hopelessness, then certainly I am against it.
Holders are positive, partly because they have financial motive to do so.
Nocoiners are negative, partly because they are kicking themselves for not cashing in on one of the biggest opportunities of the last decade. They like to see crypto fail so they can say: See, I told you so! and feel better about missing out.
Then there is the perversion of the cryptopunk community, where it became all about greed and hype, and much less about the technology and vision. I wouldn't mind if the greedy folk dropped crypto and it became more about sticking it to the man (because I already largely cashed out, and kinda feel bad for the environment and taking last year's mom-pops Christmas money).
It pays to revisit the very first post on Bitcoin on HN and maybe realize that what HN thinks about crypto is not so relevant as it may seem:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=599852
> Well this is an exceptionally cute idea, but there is absolutely no way that anyone is going to have any faith in this currency. - May 2009
HN can be wrong at times. The canonical example is "Show HN, Dropbox". Time will tell if HN was wrong about cryptocurrencies as well.
We are still way too early to pass final judgement. The combined market cap of the cryptocurrencies didn't even reach dotcom niveau.
Looking at cryptocurrencies I have a feeling like looking at something from the future out of the corner of my eyes but not completely being able to grasp it. There is a gut feeling about a tremendous potential to change the direction of the future but I don't know what exactly.
I haven't had that feeling in decades. But I do know that if there is a killer app for cryptocurrencies it is not currency.
None of those people are wrong, they just want different things and luckily they have solutions that can all coexist happily.
A lot of people think 10 years is long enough but the road from arpanet to the www was multiple decades. Just because the hype hit faster doesn't mean we won't get as far as the internet did.
While the protocols and algorithms may be trustless, there is a huge amount of trust inherent in performing financial transactions between two parties even when using cryptocurrencies:
1a. At least the sender must trust an exchange to purchase crypto
1b. At least the sender must trust mining software and/or hardware to create crypto
2a. You must trust wallet software to hold and transfer crypto
2b. You must trust an exchange to hold and transfer crypto
3. You must trust nodes to forward transactions in a timely manner
4. You must trust miners to include your transaction in a block in a timely manner
5. You must trust the receiver to acknowledge the receipt of the transaction
#3 has historically been fairly reliable, but there's no intrinsic reason nodes couldn't collaborate to censor addresses.
#4 can at least be accomplished by more or less increasing the fee sent.
#5 may be secured through traditional means (law enforcement) if both addresses are provably tied to external entities (eg humans, corps, orgs, etc) and the transaction follows relevant laws and regulations in both parties' jurisdictions. Obviously this introduces a huge amount of trust.
#5 isn't a concern for donations which is partially why cryptocurrencies have seen some success at funding terrorist organizations (eg altright and isis).
#5 isn't a concern for transactions fully handled by smart contracts, although then you must audit or trust the smart contract code. Also many contracts are mutable by an administrator which may introduce additional trust requirements.
It's not magic God-math free of all human imperfections. It's just another government, and not a terribly good one.
EOS relies on 11 elected validator nodes who have been shown to try to buy votes
ETH is the only platform IMO that truly captures consensus and its move towards proof of stake will improve transaction throughput.
All in all, the fact that I can complete a 1k transfer in 5mins for under 10 cents is unheard of in any banking workflow.
Almost every single positive feature to bitcoin or ethereum has proven to be bunk. It isn't trustless, it isn't censorship resistant, it gobbles massive amounts of electricy, it can't scale, it isn't anonymous, it isn't a good store of value, it isn't instant, it isn't free, it isn't immutable. Its advocates don't understand finance, business, government, politics, computer science, math, sociology, monetary policy, macro or micro economics, or human psychology.
There is nothing left to pick apart. Bitcoin, Ethereum and the all mighty Blockchain are completely useless. The entire space is lead by some of the scummiest scum bags around and from top to bottom the only true motive for the technology is to Get Rich Quick.
It is scams on top of scams on top of scams. The whole space is a joke. Except instead of being funny it is busy pissing away small nations worth of energy to enrich a few scummy people who got lucky and bought into the pyramid early.
There is a growing body of nuanced evidence that it's not the case that "it is scams on top of scams" and "the whole space is a joke".
(This isn't the same thing as saying "the price is going to the moon".)
I'm involved with https://augur.net. In a few years time, Augur will be the backbone of a new generation of entertainment, trading, and forecasting products. These products will have lower capital requirements as they effectively outsource the financial bits to Augur. Users of these products have self-sovereign control of their assets (ie. private keys; the emerging phrase for this is "non-custodial") which is a benefit over centralized alternatives.
Most products built on Augur will constitute a form of gambling, but unlike gambling on a dice roll, this gambling is more akin to trading stocks, with randomness and strategy.
Also, Vitalik Buterin tweeted yesterday on non-financial applications of blockchains https://twitter.com/VitalikButerin/status/107215895799977164...
There are in fact some very reputable persons in the space:Tim Berners Lee, Andreessen Horowitz, Tim Draper to name a few. More so, to get a real feeling of the development community behind eth I say check out https://ethresear.ch/. The devs on the project are very dedicated, transparent and post nearly daily updates on progress.
Weird, I must work with a bunch of dunces who turned millionaire by sheer luck.
The technology itself is perhaps sound.
It's the greed, 'high-horse' thinking that is of primary concern...
Ask crypto devs (myself included) I welcome regulatory oversight. I also believe in working along side the banking industry to develop appropriate interfaces and adopting KYC/AML process where appropriate.
And how long after that did Facebook / Google / Amazon become some of the most valuable companies on earth?
So on year 1, internet provided unique and useful functionality -- one could exchange information with thousands of people all around the world very quickly. This was pretty revolutionary, there really was no similar services.
(fun sample articles: http://www.eightyeightynine.com/culture/80susenet.html )
What are the use cases for a data-structure like the blockchain? I can't name a single one.
P. Krugman 1998, “The growth of the Internet will slow drastically, as the flaw in ‘Metcalfe’s law' becomes apparent: most people have nothing to say to each other! By 2005, it will become clear that the Internet’s impact on the economy has been no greater than the fax machine’s”
I personally say it's too early to tell. And anyone who says yes or not to potential value doesn't actually have a clue.
Its had 10 years. Its had enough time.
"It was obvious that the internet had great potential from the start"
> Actually, many people thought the internet had very limited potential
"PROVE THAT BLOCKCHAIN HAS POTENTIAL."
Seems like your argument is a bit inconsistent. But I can give you a handful of hugely interesting applications for blockchain technology off the top of my head.- Borderless currency that relies on no nation-state.
- Complex financial instruments which require no 3rd party to make them possible (the MakerDAO project is very interesting, for example).
- Storing any type of record where it is important to have an immutable log of those records. Property ownership is a big one, as is any other kind of title (cars, boats, etc). Another good one is transparent supply chains that can be fudged for one reason or another.
- Censorship-resistant web applications (social media, news, forums).
- Provably fair gambling
- Interesting gaming applications, such as in-game merchandise that can be used across different games created by different people / companies without needing to rely on the solvency of a particular provider.
I can't think of good uses for blockchain technology therefore there aren't any.
Yeahhh, pretty sure that's not how it works.
As internet served as a conduit to open and accessible knowledge to the world, crypto has the potential to open value exchange globally without the need for trusted entities.
Granted there are fast and established solutions available today for money transfer, however, they all rely on a trusted entity that under the right political pressure will compromise a user and thus is not censorship resistant.