News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by hkt on Monday December 10, 2018 @03:55AM (#18646310)
It'd be lovely if the security services acted to make the general population morr secure instead of less.
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by kmlx on Monday December 10, 2018 @04:02AM (#18646341)
"Police foil seven terror attacks in London in just six months"

https://www.standard.co.uk/news/london/police-foil-seven-ter...

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by fromthestart on Monday December 10, 2018 @04:31AM (#18646469)
I'd be extremely wary of such reports coming from the government. I don't know about other sources but that article provides absolutely no additional information beyond the claim. And I imagine this kind of information is nearly impossible to verify, which they may be betting on.

In short, given the current state of media and government, it wouldn't surprise me if this were just propaganda.

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by mike_hearn on Monday December 10, 2018 @04:49AM (#18646558)
Maybe but not necessarily.

The flip side of your view is that there are absolutely cases that are real, which don't even make it to the press at all. I was an expert witness for a terrorism case in the UK - the guy was convicted - and nothing about it ever surfaced in the media.

The reality is that there are a stream of people in the UK who try to carry out terrorist attacks, and who are stopped by the police. Attempting to argue against a bad policy by claiming terrorists are establishment propaganda is likely to be a bad strategy as a result.

A much better approach is to ask how many of these terrorists are really using sophisticated cryptography, and how many successful attacks would have been stopped if not for encryption? And there we find the answer is "not many" and "essentially none".

There is a great article on that very topic, written by a British journalist who also has acted as an expert witness in many terrorism trials:

http://privacy-pc.com/articles/how-terrorists-encrypt-threat...

It looks at many cases of busted terrorist attacks over many years, and examines the involvement of cryptography. The conclusion is that the intersection of terrorists and sophisticated users of encryption is the empty set. The closest you get is a groupie who worked on things like propaganda and funding, but who wasn't involved in any attacks themselves.

Now that article was written quite a few years ago and I suspect the new attitude of companies like Facebook towards encryption has changed the game somewhat, WhatsApp end to end encryption (assuming it's really on for everyone) makes it much easier to protect conversations than before so, it would stand to reason that cryptography does foil terrorism investigations more often than it used to. However, we don't know that, and the IC was yelling about the danger of cryptography for decades already - certainly in the time frame that Duncan Campbell's analysis was written in.

In conclusion, I'd focus more on whether real terrorist plots are happening successfully because GCHQ couldn't hack things fast enough, than on whether terrorists exist at all.

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by TheOtherHobbes on Monday December 10, 2018 @06:24AM (#18647057)
Interesting. This paper takes a different view.

https://ctc.usma.edu/how-terrorists-use-encryption/

I would be very surprised indeed if the intersection of front-line terrorists and users of industrial encryption was an empty set.

I think it's more likely the intersection of caught and prosecuted terrorists and users of industrial encryption is an empty set - or at least a much smaller set than those who use FB Messenger to coordinate attacks.

This is not an argument for backdoors. I suspect the real inefficiencies in monitoring don't come from lack of evidence, but from lack of efficient data processing and flagging.

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by mike_hearn on Monday December 10, 2018 @06:44AM (#18647153)
The two papers discuss some of the same cases.

In particular your paper discusses the "Tadpole" program developed by Rajib Karim to communicate with Al-Awlaki, albeit it doesn't refer to it by that name. It's interesting to see how there are different spins on the same event.

http://privacy-pc.com/articles/how-terrorists-encrypt-7-pecu...

Both papers point out that: Police described his use of encryption as “the most sophisticated they had seen in a British terrorist case.”

In the talk by Campbell, Tadpole is described as amateur hour. It's literally a Caeser cipher implemented using Microsoft Excel, with the results copied into password protected Word documents. Campbell observes that even a very rudimentary intelligence agency would be easily able to break this code without access to any of the underlying materials ... in fact, the technique for breaking such a cipher was first described by an Arabic mathematician over a millenium ago. This was used in preference to the "Asrar" PGP GUI that was circulating amongst jihadis, because it wasn't clear to Karim that Asrar was really trustworthy. Was it an NSA plant? This problem crops up all the time with jihadis trying to use strong encryption: they can't implement it themselves, they don't trust western apps and struggle to verify the origins of programs claiming to be written by fellow jihadis.

Overall Campbell treats Tadpole as a joke: a textbook study in why terrorists+encryption are not anything worth worrying about.

In the West Point paper you link to, the same program is described in quite different terms. It's described as an "intricate system", an "unorthodox and complex technique based on cipher codes and passwords stored on Excel spreadsheets" that produced "end to end encryption". It says "Western intelligence agencies were not able, as far as is known, to intercept any of his communications in real time". The West Point author appears to be under the impression that the only mistake Karim made was not wiping his laptop in time, which allowed police to access the underlying spreadsheets he was using.

This is a fascinating study in how the capabilities of terrorists are sometimes exaggerated to build the case for all-backdoors-all-the-time. Tadpole wouldn't have stopped a clever teenager with access to some intercepts, let alone an intelligence agency as sophisticated as GCHQ. Yet it is being used as evidence of fundamental shifts that require deep social and policy changes.

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by rishabhsagar on Monday December 10, 2018 @10:14AM (#18648438)
Thanks for such a detailed insight.

Westpoint paper in this case appears to be clearly hiding an agenda. Don't courts have some sort of checks and balance to minimise this type of influence from expert witnesses?

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by wbl on Monday December 10, 2018 @11:49AM (#18649161)
Cross examination.
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by f0ff on Monday December 10, 2018 @12:18PM (#18649418)
Comment of the year. Absolutely wonderful.
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by 1337biz on Monday December 10, 2018 @06:01AM (#18646948)
> I was an expert witness for a terrorism case in the UK - the guy was convicted - and nothing about it ever surfaced in the media.

Can you give us a rough idea why that trial was keept a secret from the public?

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by foldr on Monday December 10, 2018 @06:06AM (#18646973)
I don't believe there have ever been fully secret trials in the UK. In camera sessions with secret evidence have been held in a handful of terror cases. The more likely explanation is just that nothing was being kept secret, and the trial wasn't deemed newsworthy.
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by tialaramex on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:54AM (#18647875)
One of my practices is to periodically use a day or two off work to attend court. I've sat in various sessions of a magistrates' court (low seriousness offences, shoplifting, maybe a drunken fight at most) and the conveniently adjacent crown court (rape, fraud by impersonation, lots of drug dealing). I never saw a reporter even once. The courts are set up to allow a local journalist to cover them, but there's no money in it unless the defendant is famous. Usually I was the only person who wasn't essential to the mechanics of the court, in the fraud trial and some of the magistrates' stuff there were family there to support the defendant but never anybody else. Your friends and indeed family are probably not going to take the day off work to attend your rape trial. So that's worth knowing...
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by 1337biz on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:42AM (#18648193)
I am intrigued. Are the sessions publicly listed or do you attend them more or less randomly?
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by tialaramex on Monday December 10, 2018 @10:56AM (#18648752)
There are listings an adjacent post links but I don't pick and choose. The staff at a court will tell you e.g. that Court #4 is done for the day, or it's doing a bunch of calendar management which you might find tedious. I guess you'd want to plan at least somewhat if you have to travel a long way to attend, for me it's just across the city.
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by foldr on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:59AM (#18648326)
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by mike_hearn on Monday December 10, 2018 @06:33AM (#18647099)
That's right. I don't think there was any gag orders or anything. The trial wasn't secret. I certainly didn't have to sign anything committing me to secrecy, which is why I'm willing to mention it now. My contact at the police just asked me not to blog about the details, as a friendly courtesy. It just didn't make it to the press. My guess is that court case -> media transmission is not 100% reliable as we might imagine.

The police wanted it kept quiet for the usual reasons. There's some amount of luck involved in foiling any crime, especially before it happens, and when the details of a trial are broadcast it necessarily implies teaching future criminals how their predecessors were caught. The police don't like that, it just makes their jobs harder.

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by pjc50 on Monday December 10, 2018 @07:04AM (#18647267)
Well, there were the "Diplock courts". But yes: it does seem that the newspapers have no interest in reporting actual convicted terrorists. Which is very strange given how they sensationalise the threat of terrorism.
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by zentiggr on Monday December 10, 2018 @10:16AM (#18648453)
Not at all strange - convicted terrorists convince people that the threat is being met. The threat of unknown terrorists keeps everyone anxious and biases towards granting more police powers in order to curb those unmet threats.

PsychOps 101.

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by Angostura on Monday December 10, 2018 @11:47AM (#18649141)
Umm, I see quite a lot of reporting of it. Its just on page 7 usually since it comes down to a bloke being arrested and being found guilty of conspiracy to commit acts of terrorism. Not very newsworthy.
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by Shivetya on Monday December 10, 2018 @06:20AM (#18647041)
sometimes I wonder about people, all quite willing to trust government if they will pick up the tab but never willing to trust them with it inconveniences them.

the little microcosm that is HN is just fun to watch with stories replete with people demanding intervention standing side by side with stories claiming over reach. I am not sure you can have your cake and eat it to.

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by gambiting on Monday December 10, 2018 @04:35AM (#18646487)
We are now finding out that during the cold war, the government has released several reports of "arresting communist spies" when in fact, no one was ever found or arrested - it was just a propaganda piece. I would not be surprised if we were seeing the same thing now to support the "war on terror" narrative.
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by vahji on Monday December 10, 2018 @04:43AM (#18646531)
If they talk evil about something I don't like, that's cool and genuine. If they talk good things about something I don't like, now let me be a cynic here
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by chmod775 on Monday December 10, 2018 @09:13AM (#18647990)
Reminds me of when Obama claimed upwards of 50 attacks have been foiled by bulk data collection programs. However other officials said that the NSA was unable to provide substantial evidence that even single one was foiled[1].

[1] https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/nsa-program-stopped-no-te...

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by deogeo on Monday December 10, 2018 @01:14PM (#18649897)
Using the hacking powers mentioned here?

And I bet they could foil even more crimes if everyone had to wear an ankle monitor. Does that make it a good idea?

If I seem aggressive, it's not intentional - your post only highlighted relevant data, which is always commendable.

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by manicdee on Monday December 10, 2018 @05:59PM (#18651883)
(Out of nine bait-and-sting operations planned)
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by cyphunk on Monday December 10, 2018 @06:57AM (#18647228)
eventually this (e2e encryption everywhere) will happen once governments realize their security and secrecy depends on the security of consumer technology and to protect the public is to protect themselves.
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by ben_w on Monday December 10, 2018 @07:35AM (#18647418)
You’re more optimistic than me. I see it like Brexit: they demand all the advantages and none of the disadvantages and angrily dismiss anyone who tells them it’s an impossible combination.
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by brokenmachine on Monday December 10, 2018 @07:56PM (#18652504)
Just happened in Australia.

In 2017, Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull said, "The laws of mathematics are very commendable, but the only law that applies in Australia is the law of Australia".

The unprecedented and abysmal Assistance and Access Bill was just rushed through, against the advice of all legal and technology experts.

Any individual employee of a company can be compelled to install malware on their systems under threat of 10yrs jail and 50k, and they're not even allowed to inform their employer!

There is no judicial oversight and the one who determines if the spying is proportionate is the agency requesting the data, which is even State Police.

Under five eyes, that will be used to spy on UK, US, etc citizens and the information will be shared back. It enables the US/UK government to spy on their own citizens in ways that are illegal in their own countries.

Every Australian citizen has just become an unpaid black hat hacker/spy for the Australian government.

Have no doubt, this is coming to a nation near you.

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by capdeck on Monday December 10, 2018 @10:34AM (#18648578)
When technical means will stop working they will issue the laws that make e2e devices without backdoors illegal or not easily obtainable. Not completely apples-to-apples comparison, but look at all the iPhones and androids where you can't have root and can't load another OS, can't side load apps in apple's case. In China you already have to have an app on your phone mandated by government at all times. And if you opt to have a "freedom phone" -- your life will become quite inconvenient (with some services impossible to get). TL;DR: even if e2e everywhere happens, it means nothing if you have to have a mandatory app on your phone.
Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by ionised on Monday December 10, 2018 @05:27AM (#18646750)
That's not why they exist.

They exist to protect and maintain the status quo for those that benefit from it.

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by eponeponepon on Monday December 10, 2018 @06:42AM (#18647140)
There are two ends to the true picture here - they do exist to protect and maintain the status quo as you say, but the underpinning (largely unspoken) assumption is that the general public, as the GP hopes, are among the set of 'those that benefit', on the basis that the continued existence and flourishing of the state is beneficial to the public.

That's the theory. In practice, of course, the truth has been weighted more to one side or the other at different times and in different places.

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by Nasrudith on Monday December 10, 2018 @08:51AM (#18647844)
Well they sure are doing a shit job then - if they were smart they would realize they have the most to lose from weak crypto.

But there will always be sociopaths who would rather be dictator or a pathetic state of starving and poor people rather than president of a prosperous.

Re:UK spies: You know how we said bulk device hacking would ... by hkt on Tuesday December 11, 2018 @03:53AM (#18654016)
True.